10 Thoroughly Mistreated Video Game Franchises

Do Sega hate Sonic or something??

Sonic The Hedgehog 2006 Sonic
Sonic Team

There are few things more frustrating than when a beloved game series with thousands of fans just doesn't get treated with the amount of respect it deserves. Sometimes it seems to happen for no reason - the games get fantastic reception and a loyal following, only for the developers to throw that way.

Of course, creating games and managing a franchise is hard and anyone on the outside looking in probably has no idea what all goes into it, but sometimes the mistakes seem so obvious, you have to wonder what they were thinking.

Whether from refusing to make new games, making new entries that completely ignore what people liked, or just disregarding the fans entirely, some titles just don't get treated right.

It seems like the quality of the series doesn't even matter, they can still fall victim to terrible mismanagement.

No franchise is ever really safe from being treated terribly, but these entries are some of the most notable ones that have suffered from poor decisions. Some of them may have recovered from the treatment, but the bad times will always stick in people's memories.

10. Rayman

Rayman Legends
Ubisoft

By all accounts, Rayman should have been the face of Ubisoft. Perfect as a mascot, the series has had some incredibly beloved games starring the limbless wonder, as he platformed his way through several fun adventures.

But then Rayman hit a roadblock he couldn't get past for a long time:

The Rabbids.

Created as the main enemies for a mainline Rayman game, it got cancelled/reworked into a Wii minigame collection, and that started the full-on Rabbids takeover of the series. Rayman was barely seen for years as the Rabbids invaded everything they possibly could, with their own games, cameos, and even their own cartoon series.

Eventually though, Rayman came back in glorious 2D platformers, earning high praise as some of the best of its genre. However, that glory didn't last long, as after two games Rayman was regulated to mobile, with auto-runners and a brand new adventure of the hero being miniaturized.

The mobile games themselves are fine, but with how loved the character is, it's a shame that Ubisoft seemingly refuses to do right by him.


9. Star Wars Battlefront

Star Wars Battlefront 2 Jakku
EA

How do you take a fan-favorite series and almost destroy it?

Give the license to EA, apparently.

The original Star Wars: Battlefront 1 and 2 were beloved, seen by many fans as some of the best Star Wars games ever made, and were some of the most popular games to play during the early days of online console gaming.

Unfortunately, that original series would never see a third game, as it went through a lot of development issues. There were even plans for a fourth game on top of that, but of course, that was never going to happen.

Eventually the game was cancelled, and Disney would give the license to EA, where they created a new Battlefront game that was bare bones at release, but fine enough.

Then they made a second game, and almost killed the series before it released due to their loot box implementation. Basically putting in a pay-to-win mechanic, and making them almost mandatory if you didn't want to spend 40 hours unlocking Darth Vader, the blow back was seething, giving them the most downvoted comment in Reddit history, having the controversy appear in mainstream news, and forcing them to remove loot boxes 24 hours before launch.

Now it seems like there won't be a third game (again), leaving the series in limbo once again.


8. Metroid

Metroid Dread Samus
Nintendo

Metroid is one of Nintendo's biggest franchises, but it doesn't get treated like it.

Sure, we finally got Metroid Dread in 2021, but the series has gone through a lot of ups and downs. While most games are critically acclaimed, so few come out that a lot of people just kind of forget about the series until that next release.

Being a Metroid fan is frustrating beyond belief. You have the fantastic 2D games and the Prime series that reinvented what Metroid could be, and then you have Other M which had some weird design choices and a story that was the definition of character assassination for poor Samus.

Want a new Prime game? Too bad, have a spin-off with Metroid Prime on it that actually has nothing to do with Samus and doesn't have the gameplay of the original. Want a new 2D game? Have some remakes while they spend two decades trying to make Dread. Still want Metroid Prime 4? Well, they restarted development, you'll have to wait even longer.

It's a series that should be bigger than it is, but with some baffling decisions, the series has been held back from its full potential.


7. Sonic The Hedgehog

Sonic Lost World
SEGA

You would think with being the biggest franchise in Sega's library that Sonic Team would know what to do with the series, but as it turns out, they have no clue. And they haven't for a very long time.

Of course we had the original and iconic trilogy back on the Genesis, and the fun Sonic Adventure duology, but afterwards the series started taking a nose dive that it never recovered from. The developers just had no idea how to make Sonic appealing, adding more and more gimmicks.

While Sonic Heroes and even Shadow the Hedgehog were fine if not slightly mediocre, the fact they felt they had to give Sonic's darker twin a gun should speak volumes.

That's not even going into the mess that was Sonic 06, the Werehog, and Sonic Forces.

The only game that got any widespread acclaim for the blue hedgehog in the modern era was Sonic Mania, a game that was created by diehard fans of the series. With how great everything else in the world of Sonic is right now, we hope that the games will match up with that quality eventually.


6. Metal Gear Solid

Metal Gear Survive
Konami

Not too many games are dependent on any one man, but Hideo Kojima wasn't just any man.

Kojima helmed the Metal Gear Solid series, and knocked it out of the park with every entry. With political intrigue and storylines about the horrors of war, predicting the state of the world with eerie accuracy, Metal Gear Solid is rightfully considered one of the best game franchises ever.

However, Kojima and Konami started to clash during the production of Metal Gear Solid 5, and that led to a very ugly and very public divorce of the two before the game was released. While 5 had its issues due to this, it was still critically acclaimed due to its open-world and freeform gameplay.

And then the series immediately tanked so much that it might be dead.

The first game without Kojima behind it, Metal Gear Survive came out, most likely as a way to test the waters with the franchise after the breakup. It was a spin-off game, not having anything to do with any version of Snake, and having the player get transported into a zombie dimension.

The gameplay was tedious, the story completely lacking, the world bleak and boring, and everything just being so terrible that most of the fanbase have written off the franchise entirely. You're more likely to see a pachinko machine for Metal Gear than a new game anytime soon.


5. Conker

Conker's Bad Fur Day
Rare

Arguably the property that has suffered the most from Microsoft buying Rare, Conker has had more than one bad day at this point.

The squirrel made his debut on the Nintendo 64, and while it didn't sell too well, it was praised thanks to its solid platforming and raunchy and adult subject matter being a perfect mismatch with the kid-friendly visuals. A sequel was planned, but was scrapped once they went over to Xbox, and a remake of the first game was made instead. Then they tried to make a multiplayer only game, but that never materialized.

Conker kind of disappeared after that, with no real news about the series coming out. But then in 2014, almost 10 years after the remake was released, it was announced that Conker would make his triumphant return!...in a game-creation game called Project Spark.

Obviously just a shallow marketing tactic, Project Spark shut down very early into its life, cutting any new experiences with Conker short.

Afterwards, something called Young Conker was announced for the Mircosoft Hololens in 2016. Unsurprisingly, fans hated the idea, and Conker hasn't been seen since.


4. Devil May Cry

DmC: Devil May Cry Dante
Ninja Theory

Devil May Cry is an stylish character action game that was built off a prototype for Resident Evil 4. The series quickly found its own identity, and fans loved the exploits of Dante and his family as the tight combat, ridiculous weapons, and fantastic enemies to combo Devil May Cry a top Capcom franchise.

However, Capcom wanted to do Call of Duty sized sales numbers, and figured the best way to do that was to reboot some of their franchises to appeal to western audiences. And Devil May Cry was one of them.

Chaning Dante's iconic look, making his brother Vergil like he'd call you "m'lady," having the story try way too hard to be cool and edgy, and actively mocking things that previous fans of the series liked, the reboot was not looked at favorably. And that's before going into the frustrating gameplay that had it so only specific weapons worked on specific enemies, ruining the flow of combat and making it unsatisfying to play.

Years later, Capcom admitted they made a mistake and made Devil May Cry 5, going off the original series continuity and giving a fitting end to the Sons of Sparda. Hopefully they keep it up.


3. Diablo

diablo 2 dark wanderer
Blizzard

"Is this an out of season April Fools joke?"

Those nine words are the best way to show how hilariously out of touch Blizzard was with what people wanted.

Diablo 3 was released in 2012 to positive reviews, with fans of the series loving pretty much everything about it. But then years passed, and fans were anxious to see a new entry to the series. Rumors of Diablo 4 were swirling, so at their convention in 2018, Blizzard announced the next entry to the Diablo series, Diablo Immortal.

It was a mobile game. And then they announced nothing else.

In their infinite wisdom they decided to have a Q&A session about the game, which led to the immortal (heh) quote above, had the crowd booing the developers when they announced that their would be no PC port, and one particularly terrible retort from a developer that went to the tune of "do you guys not have phones?"

The game is slated to release in June of this year, and a fourth game was officially announced a while later, but man was this a farce.


2. Mega Man

Mega Man Legends
Capcom

Mega Man 11 was released in 2018 to favorable reviews, making fans of the series very happy. But the iconic character wasn't always in such a good place.

For all intents and purposes, Mega Man was DEAD in the 2010s. Several games for the blue bomber were announced in 2010, but every single one of them were cancelled, and Capcom just didn't do anything with the character for a long time. The great Mega Man drought happened, and fans were in despair for something, anything from the franchise.

In the gaming world, the best they got was a wacky DLC guest character spot in Street Fighter x Tekken. And it wasn't even the Mega Man everyone loved, it was Mega Man from the box art of the first game.

Y'know, the one that had him look like an out of shape, middle-aged man.

Things seem to be a bit better for Mega Man now, with 11 and with his spot in Marvel vs Capcom Infinite (quality of that game aside) showing a renewed interest to include him in Capcom's plans. Hopefully the character won't vanish again.


1. Silent Hill

Silent Hill 2 James Maria
Konami

This series just couldn't catch a break.

Silent Hill is one of the most iconic survival horror franchises ever, with the first three games in particular really standing out. Dealing with demons, both literal and personal, these games were artistic and horrifying masterpieces.

But it seemed they lost track of why these games were so good, because they made a lot of follow-up games and not a lot of them were any good. Homecoming and Downpour in particular focusing more on action than horror, ignoring story beats from previous games in order to try and appeal more to audiences, and just being very obviously rushed games of poor quality.

But then the series was unexpectedly given a second breath. A mysterious demo dropped on the PS4 called P.T., a game where you walked down a hallway over and over and over again as you dealt with a terrifying ghost stalking you.

It was horrifying, it was tense, it was everything that fans wanted from a horror game, and it turned out to be a new Silent Hill game, starring Norman Reedus of all people, and being created by Hideo Kojima and Guillermo Del Toro.

You see where this is going.

Kojima leaving the company effectively killed Silent Hills.

Konami snuffed out the second breath almost as quickly as they gave it, and Silent Hill seems to be dead as a franchise. What Silent Hills could have been is an unanswered question that will haunt many gamers for years.


Watch Next


Contributor

I write and nerd out about stuff.