10 Times Video Games Got Science WRONG
A real-life Last of Us isn't happening anytime soon.
Science is the cornerstone of our very existence - despite those who might suggest otherwise - and entertainment as a whole has had a rather curious, casual relationship with scientific fact for as long as media has existed.
We can all name countless movies which shamelessly flouted the laws of physics, biology, and chemistry for the sake of our blockbuster thrills, but the video game industry is hardly a champion of good science itself.
Though the more heightened nature of gaming generally makes it easier to accept ridiculous storytelling, there's no denying that sometimes the junk science is just too distractingly absurd to pass muster.
That's absolutely the case with these 10 games, which threw scientific plausibility out the window in pursuit of glossy AAA entertainment.
In some cases it proved more amusingly ridiculous than anything, but in others, the otherwise firm veil of "realism" was entirely derailed by this careless lack of regard for actual science.
Though these gaffes don't break their respective games for all but the most ardent scientists, they're still sloppy attempts to get away with blatant non-knowledge...
10. That's Not How Viruses Work - Spider-Man
Though most people will cut Insomniac's Spider-Man some slack given the character's fantastical origins and, well, the generally elevated nature of most superhero stories, the game's more "grounded" engagement with science sadly doesn't hold up to scrutiny at all.
One of Harry Osborn's scientific side missions, "Dive and Dash," sees Peter attempting to test a virus which will kill some toxic algae about to wreak havoc in New York's rivers and lakes.
The short mission sees Peter obtaining a sample of the algae, using his acrobatic abilities to apply sufficient G-force to break down the algae's cell walls, and then testing the virus on the algae in the lake.
Except, as some science-minded players have pointed out, none of Peter's methodology or execution makes any scientific or ethical sense whatsoever.
For starters, Peter implies he whipped up the virus in Harry's lab in an afternoon, which is impossible - it'd take at least a few days with major prep time.
Secondly, the premise of the virus itself doesn't make sense: there's zero chance it could eliminate every micro-organism in the lake, and so, the algae would simply regenerate within a short time.
But worst of all, from the pure perspective of scientific protocol, it's extremely ill-advised for Peter to release an untested virus in the wild, and it's one of the major no-nos in the field of virology.
9. Nonsense Chemistry - No Man's Sky
No Man's Sky was certainly a game made to appeal to science buffs, yet many were disappointed to discover its shockingly lax approach to chemistry and the periodic table in particular.
The primary gripe is that many of the recipes for synthesising elements aren't even remotely close to the scientific truth, and one enterprising fan was even miffed enough that they created their own mod, whereby actual chemical equations would generate the required materials.
The irony is that, for well-read scientists, No Man's Sky became a more bewildering challenge because it betrayed the laws of science so recklessly.
With their real-world knowledge more or less useless, they had to trawl fan-created Wiki pages to figure out how the hell to create even basic elements.
And honestly, that's just the tip of the iceberg.
8. Wooden Buildings Standing 200 Years After A Nuclear Apocalypse - Fallout 3
Fallout 3 takes place approximately 200 years after The Great War, a nuclear apocalypse which turned the globe into a heavily irradiated hellscape.
And as neat a setting as the world of Fallout is, that epic time jump does raise a few baffling scientific questions throughout the third game. Primarily, how the hell are any wooden buildings left standing two centuries after withstanding a nuclear blast?
Even the structures which survived the initial blasts would 100% rot away from contamination in 200 years, yet in Fallout 3, many wood-framed buildings look in remarkable shape - relatively speaking, of course.
It's been widely speculated by fans that Fallout 3 was originally supposed to be a prequel set 20 years after The Great War, which would certainly go a way to explain the glaring inaccuracy - to say nothing of all that food which somehow went unspoiled for 200 years.
7. Liquid Snake's "Inferior" Recessive Genes - Metal Gear Solid
Metal Gear Solid is hardly the first place anyone should look for scientific plausibility, but even so, the series' emphasis on genetics does nevertheless provide it with a grounded tether to our own reality.
Except, the end of Metal Gear Solid features a sequence in which the villainous Liquid Snake speaks of his "flawed, recessive genes," while noting that Solid Snake got "all the old man's dominant genes."
Liquid's assumption that he is the inferior clone of Big Boss and Solid is the superior one due to their respective genetic loadouts is totally incorrect, though.
Recessive genes are simply less likely to be passed on during reproduction, while dominant genes are more likely to be - yet this has no bearing whatsoever on the quality of those characteristics.
In a delicious bout of dramatic irony, the game's post-credits scene even compounds Liquid's misunderstanding further, by revealing that he was actually the "superior" clone all along - whatever that actually means in the context of Kojima's muddy grasp of genetics.
Though Kojima later claimed that Liquid was intentionally incorrect, it felt more like an attempt to hand-wave either his own flawed writing or a major mistake in the game's English translation.
6. Simplified Evolution - Spore
Spore was one of the most ambitious and long-awaited video games of all time, and it's fair to say that the end product simply didn't live up to the years of immense hype.
The primary criticism levelled against Spore was its disappointingly simplistic approach to its compelling premise, whereby players could foster a creature from a single-celled organism all the way through its evolution to becoming a member of a space-faring race.
Unfortunately, the game was criticised by scientists for its contradictory approach to the actual "laws" of evolution: for starters, none of the species in the game have common ancestors, and so the player's evolutionary path is linear rather than branching.
Furthermore, the player's creature doesn't evolve in response to their environment but instead a transparent path towards the final space stage, and the player's ability to alter their creature's physicality isn't at all reflective of actual evolution.
Evolutionary biologists from Yale University called the game fun but "severely messed up," while science magazine Seed said, "the snag is that Spore didn't just jettison half its science - it replaced it with systems and ideas that run the risk of being actively misleading," and spoke of "grave concerns about a game which seems to further the idea of intelligent design under the badge of science."
5. Long Fall Boots Would Shatter Your Legs - Portal 2
Though there is a fundamental undercurrent of absurdity in the Portal games, they are nevertheless bolstered by a semi-rigorous focus on taking plausible physics concepts - namely momentum - and stretching them to breaking point.
But perhaps the most patently ridiculous element of Portal 2 - beyond GLaDOS being powered by a potato battery - sees protagonist Chell being kitted out with special "Long Fall Boots" at the start of the game.
These boots allow Chell to avoid injuring herself - or worse still, damaging the Portal Gun - when falling from great heights, except they're a feat of absolute scientific implausibility. Even more so than a Portal Gun, probably.
The issue comes down to deceleration, and the notion that you've never killed by a fall itself, but the sharp stop at the end.
There is no way for the boots to provide sufficient deceleration and spread the surface area of the impact enough to not explode Chell's legs into a gory mess.
Ultimately, it comes down to "because Aperture Science," and for most players, that's probably good enough.
4. Everything Mutates From The T-Virus...Except Rats - Resident Evil 2
Resident Evil is another video game franchise which doesn't exactly beg itself to be taken seriously, but given that the series starts out with the modest(ish) spread of a biological agent known as the T-virus, it's certainly interesting to consider things from the perspective of actual science.
One of the key plot points in the second game is that the T-virus is carried throughout Raccoon City by rats, which are shown licking up the remnants of the virus from the city's sewers and consequently spreading it.
However, rats are also the only infected animals which aren't shown to mutate in some form, seemingly serving only as passive carriers to pass the virus along.
Given the various grotesque animal mutations we've seen across the series, that seems like not only a missed opportunity but also a scientific impossibility. After all, why would rats be spared turning into abominations beyond all other species?
It's been theorised by fans that Capcom may have removed mutated rats from Resident Evil 2 due to Konami's cult classic horror game Parasite Eve, which was in development at the same time and prominently featured mutant rats as a recurring enemy.
3. Everything About Europa - Call Of Duty: Infinite Warfare
The Call of Duty series' increasingly outlandish foray into silly sci-fi territory was already hugely divisive with the core fanbase without pissing off the science-loving crowd, but here we are.
One of Infinite Warfare's major settings is Europa, a moon of Jupiter which is represented with no authenticity whatsoever.
For starters, in reality Europa has an extremely thin atmosphere comprised entirely of oxygen, which would make the cloudy storm depicted in the game quite impossible.
Also, Jupiter appears far larger on the surface of Europa in the game than it actually should. Though in reality Jupiter should look 24 times larger than the Moon does on Earth, it's clearly many factors larger than that.
These are just some of the myriad issues sure to leave scientists raging, though at least there's a huge gun-totting spectacle to distract you from the sloppy, non-factual approach.
2. Cordyceps Can't Actually Infect Humans - The Last Of Us
The Last of Us takes place in a world ravaged by a mutated strain of the Cordyceps fungus, which infects humans' brains and transforms them into aggressive, mushroom-sprouting monsters.
Despite the game's grimly fantastical nature, cordyceps is in fact a very real fungus, albeit one which is (thankfully) confined to insects and unable to leap to humans. For now, anyway.
In nature, cordyceps will infect an insect's brain and control its motor functions in order to position the fungus for maximum reproductive success, at which point the insect will clamp down in place and be devoured by the fungus.
It would reportedly require hundreds of years of evolution for cordyceps to be able to manipulate a human's brain sufficiently to make it worthwhile, and given that insects are far higher in number and more easily controlled, they are clearly the most efficient means for propagation.
Furthermore, cordyceps by its nature doesn't turn the infected aggressive, so even if, centuries or more likely millennia from now, cordyceps somehow fluked its way into a human's brain, they wouldn't suddenly transform into the cannibalistic monsters depicted in the game.
Yet to be fair to The Last of Us, despite its grittiness, it has few pretensions to scientific authenticity, even if renaming the virus to something other than cordyceps might've been a good idea.
1. Impossible Acrobatics - Prince Of Persia
With its focus on time manipulation, the Prince of Persia franchise may cast much of our known physical world to the wind, but arguably even more ridiculous than its time travel hooey is the game's approach to basic physics.
The big lure of the Prince of Persia games, beyond the time gimmick, is the Prince's ludicrously entertaining array of acrobatic abilities, allowing him to run along walls and make absurd leaps in a single bound.
But of course, anyone who's ever tried parkour knows that there's no physical way for a human being to make a far-flung leap onto a teeny tiny ledge without breaking every bone in their hands and more than likely falling to their deaths.
That's to say nothing of the Prince's incredible ability to run along walls at will.
And to be clear, the Ubisoft Prince of Persia games couldn't care any less about presenting plausible physics, but considering that the earlier iterations of the Prince possess no supernatural powers, it's still a flagrant violation of the laws of physics.