10 Times Video Games Totally Broke Your Trust - Commenter Edition

Wait, the boss can resurrect?!

There are certain things we just expect to be true in video games. Things like red barrels explode, if a boss has a glowing eyeball you should really shoot it, and being nice to everybody is the fast track to the good ending.

Of course, there are always exceptions to the rule and the video games on this list delighted in ripping the rug out from under you when you expected things to go one way and they flipped the narrative on its head. We made up a list of our favourite cases of this video game phenomenon earlier this year (see below) but you guys had plenty more suggestions of times games have switched up on you, so we’re digging into those.

Whether the mechanics changed up on you, or a safe place suddenly wasn’t, here are ten cases where you thought you were safe to sit back and expect the expected but the truth was anything but.

--

10. Storage Locker Of The Demon - DOOM 3

doom 3 storage locker
iD Software

Doom 3 has loads of storage lockers filled with sorely needed supplies to help you take on all the things that have crawled out of hell.

In order to get your hands on all the ammo, guns, and gear they have to offer you’ll need to track down the relevant security access codes for each locker. That is except for one particular locker aptly bearing the ID ‘666’. If you didn’t see something coming here, that might be on you. To be fair though, in the entire game the dozens of lockers have held nothing but gear and useful bit and pieces so it’s not entirely on you if the post-it note bearing the code right underneath the keypad and the ‘Open With Caution’ label didn’t set off warning bells.

Open this one, though, and you’ll very likely get the fright of your life as a demon launches out at you from the darkness.

Once your heart rate has returned to acceptable levels you can check out the strewn people bits inside the container and be about your business.


9. Crystalbugs - Final Fantasy XII: The Zodiac Age

final fantasy 12 crystalbugs
Square Enix

Ah the humble crystalbug, the ultimate troll and wild betrayal of your trust in what can be a party-decimating end result if you aren’t prepared.

These enemies can be found in the Stilshrine of Miriam, Sochen Cave Palace, and the Nabreus Deadlands and come in three colours; orange, blue, and green. The trust that’s been broken here is that these particular baddies look just like save crystals, the things you’ve been taught to seek out and breathe a sigh of relief upon finding because you know all your hard work up to that point will be safely stored for your return at any point.

But no, low and behold, get close enough to these little bastards and boom, you’re in combat.

Not just any combat too, it can be legitimately challenging, especially if you’re under-leveled. There are only three in the game so it’s a real shock when you come across them, but you’ll certainly never be able to approach another save crystal again for the rest of the game without at least an ounce of scepticism.

Quite apart from the sheer embarrassment of being killed by a save point. That sucks.


8. The Sign-Loving Subrosian - The Legend Of Zelda: Oracle Of Seasons

the legend of zelda oracle of seasons subrosia
Nintendo

Breaking stuff and The Legend of Zelda games really do go hand-in-hand. Break a pot, break all the pots, chop all the grass, chop the signs, you get the picture, Link is a bit of a bull in a china shop when he’s let loose. So there’s an expectation that since so many things in Zelda games are destructible, there’s really no harm in “hiya”-ing your way through everything in sight, right?

Well, sort of. Everything is just dandy right up until you meet the Sign-Loving Subrosian in Subrosia, the subterranean lava world that sits beneath Holodrum.

This guy loves signs, like really loves them. He keeps track of how many signs you break in the game and asks how you could be so cruel to break signs around town. Once you’ve broken one-hundred or more signs the happy-go-lucky sign man loses it with you and tells you to prepare for what’s to come. At this point the start-up screen will flash up implying you’ve lost your save file and the game has either restarted or your progress has been erased.

Of course, this is only a troll and the Sign-Loving Subrosian gives you the Sign Ring to remind you of your mistake but you’ll have been absolutely terrified for a second there.


7. No Safe Spaces - Dead Space 2

dead space 2 elevator
EA

There are plenty of games that play with the idea and expectation of safe spaces, especially horror games. On our last list we called out the workbench ambush in The Last of Us and Nemesis moseying into your save room in Resident Evil 3 Remake as examples of games totally messing with you.

This is even more rude when you think everything is fine because an earlier game in the series established it that way. For example, the elevators in Dead Space.

Now, we all understand by the second game in the series that the world of Dead Space is relentlessly horrifying, wildly unsafe, and riddled with dark rooms and jumpscare-loving Necromorphs. That said, we’ve been led to believe that at least its elevators are safe. Sure, a Necromorph might try to get in and get sliced up by the door but they can’t actually get you in there. Right? Well, sure, right up until the bit in Dead Space 2 where you run in from the church and a Necromorph drops in on you from the ceiling.

Queue the most frantic session of shooting and stomping of your game so far and you’ll never trust elevators in Dead Space again.


6. Sister Friede’s Last Stand - Dark Souls 3 Ashes Of Ariandel

Sister Friede
FromSoftware

When you play a FromSoftware game you’re always ready for anything. Chests that want to chew your hand off, skull-faced birds of prey dropping from the sky, you name it. But what avid fans had come to understand after a number of entries was that bosses would max out at two phases.

Well, that is until they took on Sister Friede.

You’ll deplete Sister Friede’s health bar, watch her fall to the floor and bleed out which massively pisses off Father Ariandel at which point you’ll need to fight the both of them, now engulfed in flame. Being Dark Souls 3, this is no cakewalk, but with enough careful planning and pitch perfect execution you’ll make it to the end and the game will give you a Titanite Slab, a rare crafting ingredient. Then when you think you’re all done, because you got the loot and everything, the music stops and you can wander around again, Blackflame Friede rises from the dead to mess your s**t up.

This was an incredible shock, as this was the first time in the series a boss battle had progressed to a third stage.

It’s a beautiful and cinematic fight but it sure did break the trust of players who thought they knew the rules of a Souls boss battle.


5. Idle Screen Ghosts - Fatal Frame 2

Fatal Frame 2
Tecmo

Fatal Frame 2 isn’t the first game in the series to feature this nasty little trust-breaking feature but it is as cheeky and trolly in Fatal Frame 2 as ever. Leave your controller alone for too long and this iconic horror title will fade in horrific ghostly visages across your screen. Because god forbid you take a few seconds away from the relentless ghost-riddled terror to grab a snack or take a phone call.

While some games on this list broke your trust in save locations, this one just drops the rules of what you expect any video game to do by essentially loading up a creepy ghost screensaver.

Keep playing? See scary ghosts. Stop playing? See scary ghosts. Either way Fatal Frame ensures it keeps its place as a seminal horror franchise and you stay primed for terror at every moment.


4. Turn Off The Console - Metal Gear Solid 2

Metal Gear Solid 2 Raiden
Konami

Up there with moments in your childhood that fractured your trust for life we have the sequence where the Colonel appears to lose his mind in Metal Gear Solid 2.

Raiden will suddenly receive a transmission telling him to, quote, “turn the game console off right now”, which is absolutely not something you expect a video game character to say and somehow completely terrifying. Terrifying for you, no doubt very funny for iconic developer Hideo Kojima. Of course turning off the console will just throw you back to the last checkpoint and repeat the conversation when you reach the trigger point. He tells you not to worry and it’s only a game, but you need to cut the power. His voice then gets more distorted and he tells you he had a supernatural experience.

It’s all very unsettling but particularly when the game tells you you’ve been playing it for too long chances are it was probably on the money so it felt suitably freaky.


3. You’re On The Clock - Deus Ex: Human Revolution

deus ex human revolution hostages
Eidos-Montreal

Right near the beginning of Deus Ex: Human Revolution, in the very first mission in fact, you’re tasked with saving hostages. What you couldn’t have known is that an invisible timer has kicked off and if you don’t get underway in time, all the hostages will die. If, for example, you spend too much time exploring the first building before getting on the helicopter you won’t get there in time to save them.

Of course, as mentioned, there’s no way for you to know that all of a sudden you need to get a wriggle on so the game has taken your expectations that almost all video game time limits are fake and made it very real.

You’ll never think of all RPG time limits as artificial again after this one. Especially if you managed to get the hostages killed. Oops.


2. Fake Knockout Sign - Cuphead

cuphead fake knockout
Studio MDHR

In a case of it being a positive to be chronically online, you wouldn’t have been fooled by one of brutal platformer Cuphead’s most brutal betrayals of your trust; a fake knockout sign. That blessed knockout sign means all your tense minutes of hard-earned evasion, attacks, and platforming are finally over.

If you do decide to take your hands off the controls and celebrate early, though, you might see your fate sealed in the final moments by a sneaky snail that crawls out from under the baddie’s hat.

There’s nothing quite as painful as being trolled by the sign too late for you to recover and seeing you made it right to the end only to be taken out in the final moments. We trusted you, Knockout sign, for shame.


1. A Totally Real Jedi Holocron - Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic 2

star wars knights of the old republic 2 fake holocron
Obsidian

In any RPG you’re going to want to buy all the important things that any random NPC has to sell you. Especially when you’re on the outskirts of a ruined Jedi enclave that you already know salvagers picked clean and one such salvager offers you a Jedi holocron. Not only that but one of your companions has told you to try and track down holocrons and he’ll help you in deciphering them.

Of course, said salvager won’t part with it for nothing which stands to reason so he tells you to fork over 1,000 credits and it’s yours.

You do so and upon further inspection find out the holocron is fake. What is there to do from this point? Absolutely nothing. The guy tells you it’s your bad for buying it, no take-backsies, and he won’t give you your money back. So you stand there with your lightsaber in your hand and 1,000 credits out of pocket feeling like a dummy. Thanks a lot, video game. We trusted you. Kriea almost definitely laughed at you over it too.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Dark Souls 3
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Jess has been a journalist and content creator in the games industry for over 15 years and has been WhatCulture's resident Australian import and sorry cop since 2020, upping the quotient of swearing and apologising in WhatCulture Gaming's annual blooper videos considerably. She previously worked at GameSpot for 10 years, most notably hosting GameSpot News in addition to E3 live shows, and PAX panels. She regularly livestreams a variety of games on her 'jessmcdonell' YouTube and Twitch channels and hosts the 'Do It On The Day' podcast. She has won awards for her news and feature work in gaming as well as an accolade for her comedic writing (likely an admin error). She can be found on X at @jessmcdonell and Instagram at @jessicamcdonell sharing her current videogame fixations, industry insights, and videos of her cat, Karma.