10 UNACCEPTABLE Video Games

From gore to broken at launch.

Now that video games have well and truly entered the mainstream we find ourselves at a time where there is a game for every conceivable genre and to appeal to every kind of player.

In general, this is a fantastic thing. It means chances are no matter what you’re after, there’s a game out there for you. That said, for all the fantastical mediaeval adventures, engaging hero shooters, and everything in between, there have inevitably been a handful of games that certain people think went too far.

Perhaps this was a government laying down a ban on a game for being too violent, a subsect of gamers declaring the game inappropriate for its themes, or dedicated fans with expectations who were so let down by a title they walked away from it immediately and deemed it unplayable.

Whatever the case may be in each of these cases, somebody wasn’t happy with the following titles.

--

10. Hatred

Hatred game
Destructive Creations

Starting off with one of the earlier games to cause an enormous uproar for its content, we have 2015 isometric shooter, Hatred.

Perhaps because the world was becoming disturbingly aware of the wave of mass-shootings, or just because its content was going to be controversial regardless, this game that put you in the shoes of a mass-murder didn’t go down particularly well with many players or critics. The main character doesn’t have a huge amount of justification for his unaliving rampage except for his declaration that he, quote “just !*$% hate this world and the human worms feasting on its carcass”. In another cringe-inducing move, the game also encourages you to execute unconscious people as a way to recover health.

Unsurprisingly the ESRB slapped Hatred with an Adults Only rating, only the third they’ve ever dolled out, due to its content.

This rating prevented the game from being sold at any traditional retailers. Upon release some dubbed the game unacceptably promoting violence, others claimed it was only shooting for shock value, and a couple claimed even if you overlooked those aspects the game was actually fairly repetitive. In any case, this one certainly caused a stir.


9. My Lovely Daughter

my lovely daughter
GameChanger

Although Hatred is largely played from an isometric perspective, it plays like a traditional action shooter which given its themes is naturally going to disturb some viewers.

My Lovely Daughter, in contrast, sits closer to the strategy and visual novel genres, but is no less disturbing for those that tuck into it.

Like a good amount of the entries on this list, this is another that some claim is a masterpiece while others think it should never have been made. My Lovely Daughter tells the story of an alchemist who wakes up only to discover his daughter has died. Unwilling to accept his circumstances, the grieving father decides to create a series of homunculi who he raises as his own daughters, only to kill them and harvest their souls to try and revive his deceased child.

You’ll also assign them jobs while they’re alive and build relationships with them prior to their inevitable death and, yes, it is as brutal as it sounds. Especially as the daughters you must murder grow to adore you.

Without spoiling anything, as the story progresses you also begin to recover your memories of the fatal event and unravel precisely what happened to lead to your predicament. The cycle of murder is enough to have put plenty off the game, but those who can look past its nasty aspects are in for a treat.


8. E.T. The Extra Terrestrial

E.T. The Extra Terrestrial
Atari

Rebounding off that ball of depression, we have a game that was unacceptable for a totally different reason: E.T. Those in the know probably don’t need any more explanation as to why this one made the list but just in case you aren’t, let me run you through it.

This 1982 adventure game is commonly accepted to be one of the worst video games of all time.

Partially a victim of its own hype, the game was criticised for its gameplay, story, bizarre frequency of holes for our hero to fall down, and general crappiness. This was likely due to the extraordinarily tight turnaround demanded of the developers but it didn’t make the poor final product any more acceptable. In fact, the game was so badly received that a load of cartridges were discarded by Atari and buried at a Texas landfill. Though initial reports suggested the dumped video games were exclusively copies of E.T., this wasn’t actually the case, though there were at least 1000 copies of it in there, so, it wasn’t exactly flying off shelves.

Perhaps the worst thing we can say about this iconic disaster, though, is that it contributed to the crash of the video game industry in 1983. Yikes.


7. Saya No Uta: The Song Of Saya

Saya No Uta: The Song of Saya
NitroPlus

While some of the games on this list are horrific but contain enough substance and intrigue to make them genuinely worthwhile experiences, a lot of people would claim Saya No Uta is not one of those games. It falls into the erotic visual novel genre but it goes quite a bit darker than that.

Essentially, critics argued that this one is aiming for shock value and tragedy porn.

You play as a medical student who wakes up after a car accident to learn he is the only survivor. In a gruesome twist, his head injury has rendered him unable to see his environment and those within it as anything other than gory piles of flesh and organs. In what initially seems like a reprieve, he meets a girl called Saya during a hospital stay but she turns out to be a violent murderous creature so that’s not great.

This game hits the whole kitten caboodle of horribleness running the gamut of sexual assault and flesh eating.

While the game has its fans, inevitably, as evidenced by its Steam reviews, there’s no denying this exercise in repulsion and boundary pushing drew a lot of criticism.


6. Harvester

harvester game
DigiFX Interactive

It’s easy to dismiss Harvester as a goofy horror game peppered with gore and awkward FMV sequences that couldn’t possibly be called unacceptable, but some of the scenes in it are beyond anything that even the gruesome games on this list have to offer.

You awaken in a strange town with no memory and find yourself persuaded by the local cult to execute a series of tasks that often lead to some extremely violent outcomes.

Your unsettling journey devolves into a main narrative that features incest, manslaughter, murder, suicide, and themes of how a regular person can become a brutal killer. There’s also a bit where you see supposedly joyous kids eating their ailing mother so, you know, that’s a whole thing. Harvester has it all; unsettling themes, gore galore, nasty set pieces, and a wildly disturbing narrative. It also has a cult following so if it is your kind of thing then good for you but you’d find yourself in some decent level of company if it isn’t.


5. Manhunt 2

Manhunt 2
Rockstar

Given the uproar it caused, we’d be remiss to make a list of games that were deemed unacceptable without including Manhunt or its sequel.

Whether you agree with the inflammatory response to the game or not, it’s undeniable that this one made waves. To say the least. The initial cut of Manhunt 2 received an Adult’s Only rating, restricting it from sale and essentially banning the game, until it was edited so it could achieve an M rating instead. Rockstar’s series is, at its most basic, a murder-simulation, riddled with violence and gore and there are many ways you can execute and maim those unlucky enough to meet you throughout the game.

Even though the graphics don’t hold up particularly well for gamers who might be revisiting the title to see what all the fuss is about, those who played it at the time will remember how brutal it was.

Manhunt 2 was initially seen as unacceptable because some claimed it was connected to a murder in the UK that happened at the same time, while others were appalled that the original received a sequel at all. Activists campaigned against it and tried to get it classified a “public nuisance”, government officials tried to have its M-rating reinstated as AO and in Australia the game was never ever submitted for reclassification rendering it banned.

Classic Australia on that one, though, honestly.


4. KZ Manager

kz manager
Various

In what is almost certainly the most appalling game on this list that should never have been made, and absolutely deserves its ban, we have KZ Manager. Or moreover, we do not have KZ Manager.

In a bizarre case of “who on earth funded and let this be made??”, the 1990 game essentially has the player run a Nazi Concentration Camp. Yeah, really.

The details of this one are almost too awful to go into. The game is set up as a simulation management-style game where you enlist prisoners to work, execute them for popularity, or make money through some absolutely atrocious treatment of your captives. Unsurprisingly the game is almost universally banned

It’s honestly almost too sick to talk about and pretty universally unacceptable, so let's move onto our next entry.


3. Anthem

anthem game
Bioware

Admittedly, there’s not much to say about Anthem that hasn’t already been said but to make a list about unacceptable video games and not throw this disappointing disaster on there also seemed like a huge oversight so here it is.

The main thing that made Anthem so unacceptable wasn’t it’s dull story, repetitive gameplay, or even its unfinished nature. Instead it’s really the fact that it was made by BioWare and EA.

That is to say, there is no reason Anthem should have been so bad. In the year 2019 after so many fan favourite slam dunks from the developer and publisher it was unthinkable, and in retrospect unacceptable, that a AAA game could arrive this broken, disappointing, and borderline unplayable if we’re going by how many players couldn’t be bothered to persist with it.

We know Anthem is a mess and from any other developer it might have just been a middling action adventure offering soon forgotten but from such prestigious studios it was downright atrocious.


2. The Cat Lady

the cat lady
Harvester Games

The Cat Lady appears to be fairly tame at first glance, especially compared to some of the other games on this list, but dig a little deeper into its themes and protagonist and things are more than a little disturbing. We join our heroine, 40-year-old Susan Ashworth on the brink of her decision to take her own life.

This choice leads her down the rabbit hole as a supernatural entity called the Queen of Maggots tasks her with ridding the world of multiple psychotic people.

What follows is a point-and-click adventure laden with explicit gore, incredibly violent and depressing circumstances, and plenty of characters you would not want to meet in a dark alley. Or any alley, really. While the story revolves very specifically around the themes of death, suicide, and the most unsavoury of people, there is resilience and hope buried in there too. As a result, this is firmly on the list of games that some would deem unacceptable, but one which you should seek out if you’re open to what lies beneath its grisly, macabre, and bleak facade.


1. Thrill Kill

Thrill Kill
Paradox Development

And as these things go we’re rounding out our list with an example that truly exemplifies our topic. It’s not acceptable, its concept was almost universally despised, and it’s so grotesque it never even came out. Ladies and gentleman, Thrill Kill.

So controversial that it was cancelled before it could even come out, Thrill Kill was a fighting game intended for a 1998 release that called upon those who got sent to Hell to fight for the opportunity to be reincarnated by the Goddess of Secrets. So far, not so bad, right? Well despite seemingly like a Mortal Kombat rip-off given you’d be working to fill a kill metre so you could unleash the titular “Thrill Kill” move, published Virgin Interactive were keen to further up the violent ante. That resulted in the game earning the first ever Adult’s Only rating handed out by the ESRB primarily due to violence and not nudity.

The game essentially ended up as a violent gore-fest featuring a series of erotic and almost exclusively BDSM and kink-themed fighters with gorey backstories of why they landed in hell.

In short, mostly these fighters are largely naked and deeply messed up so unsurprisingly potential publishers like EA decided to back out and the title was overcome by the distaste for a title of its nature at the time of its planned release. In the years since bootleg versions have found their way onto the internet and certainly hold an iconic cult status given the game’s infamy. Whether or not the game deserved to be pulled, no one who cares about video games that push the boundary will forget about it any time soon, for better or worse.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Jess has been a journalist and content creator in the games industry for over 15 years and has been WhatCulture's resident Australian import and sorry cop since 2020, upping the quotient of swearing and apologising in WhatCulture Gaming's annual blooper videos considerably. She previously worked at GameSpot for 10 years, most notably hosting GameSpot News in addition to E3 live shows, and PAX panels. She regularly livestreams a variety of games on her 'jessmcdonell' YouTube and Twitch channels and hosts the 'Do It On The Day' podcast. She has won awards for her news and feature work in gaming as well as an accolade for her comedic writing (likely an admin error). She can be found on X at @jessmcdonell and Instagram at @jessicamcdonell sharing her current videogame fixations, industry insights, and videos of her cat, Karma.