10 Unintentionally Terrifying Video Game Moments

Seriously **** this guy.

Tomb Raider 2
Eidos Interactive

There are plenty of horror video games out there that do a great job of putting the fear of God in you. From Resident Evil to Silent Hill, releases both new and old still have that special concoction of fear and anxiety that makes for the creepiest gaming experiences.

However, sometimes the scariest games are the ones that aren't actually billed as horror titles. Maybe it's because you're more prepared to be shocked in those, already on the defensive and looking out for the game's tricks, whereas in these unassuming titles you're caught well and truly off guard by an unintentionally terrifying moment.

In many cases something which should have been innocuous comes across as pant-wettingly absurd because of dated graphics making everything already look a little surreal, but other times you get the feeling that the devs were trying to make something normal, and the Lynchian part of their brain simply took over with the intent of morphing that into something human eyes should never be subjected to.


10. Jaws 2 - Banjo Kazooie

Banzo Kazooie
Nintendo

For the majority of its runtime, Banjo Kazooie is that great Nintendo platformer you fondly remember from your childhood. What you might have repressed, though, is the way it occasionally pitted you against some of the most terrifying sharks of all time.

First up is Snacker, who's essentially just your standard Great White. This guy, with his ridiculously menacing eyebrows, chases you as soon as you jump into the water. It's never played out loud, but this entire level is soundtracked by the Jaws theme song playing in the back of your mind.

In the words of the immortal Qui Gon Jinn though, there's always a bigger fish, and the second shark, Clanker, makes Snacker looks like lunch. This fella is absolutely huge and made of metal. Not only is he ferocious in his pursuit of the player, but he has these wide, emotionless eyes that stare straight through you and into another dimension.

Those eyes and teeth... ugh, I still see them behind my eyelids.


9. All The Bosses - Cuphead

Cuphead root pack
Studio MDHR

In one sense, Cuphead is incredibly lovable. Its cartoon art style, imaginative characters and charming heroes all scream the kind of kid-friendly comfort that you move away from as you grow older.

However, all of that is warped through the distinctly strange aesthetics of the 1930s cartoon style. It's not only this game, but the shows that inspired it; there's just something not quite right about the way these designs, animations and music all mesh together. It's the way the enemies move and their mad eyes especially that are just freaky to see in motion.

As a result, even the silliest of bosses, like the vegetables early on in the game, take on an eerie, unnatural quality that makes them oh so scary. It might seem ridiculous to be terrified by a carrot, but that's what makes it hurt so much.


8. Most Haunted - Rugrats

Rugrats ps1
THQ

Where to even begin with the Rugrats PS1 game? The whole release uncannily looks like a cartoon version of Eraserhead for one, with the choppy characters and sparse environments creating this terrifying hellscape for the player.

The smooth edges of the original show have given way to these choppy, angular representations of once-lovable characters that would absolutely eat a baby if given the chance.

The whole thing already has an eerie vibe to it, so when you're cast as Tommy and told to make your way around an empty house at night while goddamn ghosts roam the hallways, you might as well have been playing a straight up horror game.

It still retains its unnerving atmosphere now, as the dated graphics look even more alien than they did at the time.


7. Crash's Gruesome Deaths - Crash Bandicoot 2

Crash Bandicoot N Sane Trilogy
Activision

Crash Bandicoot is a scamp, isn't he? Across Naughty Dog's original trilogy players controlled the Bandicoot as he jumped, span, and ate wampa fruit across colourful levels all soundtracked to some of the grooviest music on the PS1.

All that made it so jarring, then, when Crash would get brutally murdered by enemies over and over again. While there was nothing special about the deaths in the first title, the following two upped the ante with unique death animations, as Crash's spirit would literally leave his body and fly towards heaven above.

That was pushing the boat out enough, but the real scarring material came when you'd get killed by specific creatures. Take the bees for instance, it wasn't only tense to be chased across a level by these things, because if they caught and stung you, you'd have to watch Crash grotesquely swell up before he died.

If you didn't see this as a kid and then develop a fear of bees for the rest of your life, you're much stronger than I am.


6. The Night Levels - Rayman

Rayman ps1
Ubisoft

Now, the night levels in Rayman are spooky for the same reason Cuphead is. On the surface, the designs of the environment and characters are wholesome and innocent; you've got music notes, clouds, bongos and a whole bunch of other music-related iconography.

Of course, it's how these innocent concepts are twisted, and made slightly off, that makes the whole affair transform into something terrifying. The night already has a mystical quality to it, and combined with the alternate soundtrack that swaps music out for the ominous thumping of thunder and punishing animated musical instruments that can shoot lightning at the player, it makes for a strangely atmospheric time.

Again, it's that creeping unnaturalness that's the most off-putting, and what makes the original Rayman still quite unnerving to play now.


5. The Vampires - Enter The Matrix

Enter the Matrix
Atari

It didn't review well, but Enter the Matrix was goddamn awesome. The movie franchise is perfectly suited to a video game translation, and this canonical continuation perfectly realised the core staples of slow-mo combat, intense gunfights, and kicking the crap out of vampires with wooden stakes.

You might be questioning the last part of that statement, but a whole level in the game had you battling against these supernatural creatures in a gothic mansion. As mentioned this is an official tie-in approved by the Wachowskis, but it's never really explained why there's suddenly these creatures of the night lurking about.

The in-universe explanation (found in the second movie) states that they're leftovers from an older version of The Matrix programme, but their sudden inclusion in Enter the Matrix is startling to say the least.

It's mostly unnerving because the game barely draws attention to them. They're treated as any other enemy, and if you didn't know the explanation beforehand, the spooky questions they raise stay with you for the rest of the game.


4. Dodging The Prefects - Harry Potter And The Chamber Of Secrets

Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets
EA

In a way, literally every single part of both Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone and Chamber of Secrets games could have made it onto this list. Each one is straight up nightmare inducing, as the whimsical magical setting of Hogwarts is warped through the limitations of a PS2 movie tie-in production.

It's the second title that's the spookiest though. The film it's based on is already terrifying, with an unseen giant snake slithering through the halls of the school, petrifying students and whispering into Harry's thoughts. It's none of that mystical stuff which makes Chamber's game tie-in so scary though, but rather regular old high-school prefects.

There's one rather lengthy sequence in the title where you control Harry as he sneaks around Hogwarts at night, avoiding his older classmates who are patrolling the halls.

There's something uniquely tense about being that age, in a school setting no less, and being somewhere you shouldn't.

The nighttime setting exacerbates those paranoid thoughts (and it doesn't help ease the nerves that you could theoretically run into a giant snake if you turn the wrong corner), but it's the sheer act of getting caught being somewhere you're not supposed to be that puts the chills up the spine.


3. Elevator Soldiers - Metal Gear Solid

Even though it's a stealth action game, the horror genre is all over the original Metal Gear Solid. From the hellish brutality of Grey Fox to Psycho Mantis directly addressing the player, there are so many spooky moments in the original game, but they're all intentional.

One which isn't played as straight horror, though, is the elevator ambush. This sequence sees you activate a lift, only to get a call from Otacon. He informs you he built five stealth camouflage prototypes, and that four are missing. He also says the elevator is over the weight limit... despite Snake being the only person in it.

The music gets tense, and Otacon suddenly tells you to look out, because the guys who stole the tech are in there with you. Suddenly, four soldiers appear, and an action scene begins.

It's a short, deadly surprise, and it puts you on edge for a good hour afterwards.


2. Monster Ock - Spider-Man

Spider Man Ps1 Doc Ock
Marvel

For the most part, the PS1 Spider-Man game is a vehicle for a whole load of banter. It's set in a colourful version of New York, and even teams Spidey up with Venom, whose symbiote must be made up primarily by 90s cheese rather than alien goop, because half of the character's dialogue is made up of one-liners and the word "dude".

What I'm saying is that it's a very kid-friendly introduction to the comics universe, with the exception of the final boss. The main antagonists of the story are Doc Ock and Carnage, and the final level sees the two entities merge into Monster Ock, a hulking symbiote with six arms that chases Spidey (and the player) through an exploding lab.

Now, it might not look like much now, but this thing was terrifying at the time, primarily because of how alien a concept it was. Even if you were a fan, you probably weren't expecting to see this abomination brought to life.


1. The Creepy Butler - Tomb Raider 2

Tomb Raider Butler Gif
CORE Design

This guy. This guy can absolutely go f**k himself.

Tomb Raider 2 made the genius move of allowing players to explore Lara's ridiculously glamorous mansion. Away from missions you could get a feel for the controls, engage in some harmless platforming segments around obstacle courses and in the gym, and just generally get a taste for what Lara herself does in her downtime.

It was supposed to be a super fun time, but there was a spectre hanging over all of it. A spectre in the form of a black-robed hunchbacked old man who followed you with a tray of tea everywhere.

This zombie butler constantly appearing behind you was damn terrifying, and there's a reason everyone locked him in the freezer to stop his endless pursuit.

This is on Lara as well though. This dude can barely walk and she still has him employed? What black magic has she spun to entrap this man's soul to a life of servitude?


Watch Next


In this post: 
Tomb Raider 2
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Josh has over 11 years of experience as a published writer, having worked nine of those years as a full-time content producer at WhatCulture. In that period he has created hundreds of articles, videos and podcast episodes for multiple WhatCulture channels, specialising in gaming, horror and film & TV. He now primarily works as a senior content producer and presenter on WhatCulture Gaming where he co-hosts the WhatCulture Gaming Podcast, a top 3 UK most listened to gaming podcast that he co-created in 2018. Over the years he has reviewed several high-profile gaming releases, covered industry events with on-site reporting, opined on breaking news, and even kicked off his interviewing career by chatting to childhood hero, Tommy Wiseau.