10 Video Game Characters Who Got Undeservedly Brutal Deaths

These video game characters definitely deserved much better and far less gruesome deaths.

Max Payne 3
Rockstar

As video games have become more and more technically demanding, they have continued to find new ways to be emotionally affecting. Back in the day, seeing the Asteroids ship collapse into tiny pieces was a little sad, but it wasn’t quite a detailed, visceral experience.

Over the years, titles like Dead Space has shown us the harrowing effects of ship damage in deep space and the lives taken in brutal ways. This isn’t a strictly sci-fi phenomenon, either: characters meet grisly ends in all kinds of ways in contemporary gaming, and with sophisticated narratives and characterization, some of these losses can really sting.

Naturally, a lot of the time, we’re dealing this death ourselves, in gory shooters, Mature-rated fighters like Mortal Kombat and such titles. Here, there’s some justification for this, as enemies and villains are dispensed with glee.

We may flinch at some of the more visceral deaths, but when developers inflict them on innocent characters rather than dastardly foes who ‘deserved’ them, that’s a different matter entirely. Here are some examples of characters who received shocking, vicious death scenes they certainly didn’t deserve.

10. Pious Augustus - Eternal Darkness: Sanity’s Requiem

ETERNAL DARKNESS 2
Silicon Knights

GameCube exclusive cult classic Eternal Darkness: Sanity’s Requiem is a grim tale indeed. The plot centres around Alex Roivas, a young woman who unknowingly picks up the torch her family has carried for generations: saving humanity from the threat of the Ancients.

To do so, she travels between the chapters of the Tome of Eternal Darkness, each time taking the role of a different person from throughout history who has their own role to play. The protagonist of the first chapter is Pious Augustus, a Roman Centurion who happens upon the Forbidden City and the Ancients’ artifacts. As Pious, the player must select one, and Pious is immediately killed by its power as he touches it.

He doesn’t only die, though. As the game demonstrates in awful, protracted detail, he becomes a powerful Lich, doing his chosen Ancients’ bidding and opposing the player (killing several other protagonists in various ghastly circumstances) for the rest of the adventure. It's a terrible, centuries-long un-end for this noble warrior.


9. Baby Metroid - Super Metroid

Super Metroid Final Fight
Nintendo

As franchise fans will know, there’s absolutely no love lost between Samus and the Metroids. She’s Ice Beam-ed and rocket-shattered countless numbers of these angry critters, but there’s one she absolutely couldn’t kill. One that seemed to accept her as its mother.

Ridley steals away with the little critter at the beginning of Super Metroid, and it has developed to vast size by the time Samus encounters it again. However, in a move entirely uncharacteristic of its belligerent species, it withdraws from attacking her and flees.

It would ultimately die in a horrible, heroic and horribly heroic fashion, absorbing the full force of Mother Brain’s attacks (including the beast’s ultimate beam) and disintegrating before Samus’ eyes. The bounty hunter heroine rarely has allies, and the fact that a Metroid took Mother Brain’s full fury for her, combined with the implications the encounter had for her DNA with the X Parasite in mind, made this one of the saddest moment in the series.


8. Aeris Gainsborough - Final Fantasy VII

Aeris Death
Square

This could be gaming's most devastating deaths, and that’s no hyperbole.

Since we first meet Final Fantasy VII’s Aeris(/Aerith), a jostled flower seller in the slums of Midgar, we feel an affection for her - a liking for this good, pure, kind woman. As the hints pile up about her nature as an Ancient and her potential importance to the overarching fate of humanity, these feelings intensify sevenfold.

It all leads, tragically, to that encounter at the Forgotten Capital. Cloud hurries to the goodly Aeris on the altar, only to see Sephiroth (or rather Jenova in his guise) plunge towards her from above, the Masamune in hand, and… everybody knows what happens next, and it ends with Cloud releasing her into the surrounding waters.

This much-discussed death was a shocker for its time, and remains so. It’s rare for the Final Fantasy series (and indeed RPGs in general) to kill off a main party member, and to present her death in such a fashion was a powerful move. Later in the game, the party and Bugenhagen watch a projection of Aries’ Materia falling from the altar, in agonizingly slow fashion, as Aries’ Theme begins to play. It’s profoundly affecting and still painful to watch.


7. Father Gascoigne’s Family - Bloodborne

Bloodborne Father Gascoigne
Sony

In the grim and gothic world of Bloodborne, generally speaking, nothing ends well for anyone. The three different ending options for the player character each have their own sort of tragedy about them, and the few NPCs that can be saved either die, find no peace or, in one memorable case, conceal a secret beasthood within themselves and slowly pick off the other survivors.

The first mandatory boss in the game, Father Gascoigne, is a former Hunter who has succumbed to the scourge himself. He transforms shortly before his death, and piecing things together, the player learns that he appears to have killed his beloved wife, Viola, with no control of his actions.

If you explored the first area thoroughly, you will have found a young girl and the Small Music Box item. This, it’s revealed, calmed Gascoigne and could bring him back to himself somewhat, but the unfortunate Viola did not have it with her. The girl is revealed to be Gascoigne’s daughter, who meets her end when she is consumed by the gigantic pig in the sewers while looking for a safe place to hide.

Later in the game, Gascoigne’s elder daughter learns of these family tragedies, and, all depending on the player’s choices, remarks that she has something to remember her sister by, at least: the Red Messenger Ribbon (red because it’s stained with blood) dropped by the pig that ate her. It’s all a horrible and tragic web to untangle.


6. Sam And Henry - The Last Of Us

Last Of Us Sam And Henry
Naughty Dog

The Last of Us is a harrowing, emotional, often tragic experience, which explores so much of the human experience behind what some may consider a cliched zombie apocalypse backdrop. The awful ends of brothers Sam and Henry are testament to this.

Ellie accompanies the siblings through a protracted siege sequence, while Joel battles to keep the encroaching hordes at bay with a mounted gun. The high-octane action is tempered by touching moments between the four survivors, in which Ellie shares a very special toy with Sam and Henry cooks. Tragically, Sam had been bitten in the previous fracas, and when Ellie goes to wake him for breakfast, she shrieks as he suddenly turns.

A tormented Henry hesitates before shooting his brother, rescuing Ellie from his clutches. Joel desperately tries to take the gun from him, but Henry turns it on himself in horror. It’s a brutal shock in the midst of such a (by The Last of Us’ standards) touching and tranquil domestic moment.


5. Great Grey Wolf Sif - Dark Souls

Dark Souls Sif
Bandai Namco Entertainment

The Soulsborne games have a unique way of creating monstrous boss enemies that players still somehow pity. Bloodborne’s Father Gascoigne is a fantastic example of this, but the iconic Great Grey Wolf Sif is on a similar plane of tragedy.

Sif is found in the Artorias of The Abyss DLC of Dark Souls, which can make the eventual fight against the animal even more heartbreaking in the main game. That's because the great beast, which was protected by Artorias from beyond the grave by his shield, does not want to fight the Chosen Undead. The protagonist, in turn, is surely unwilling to fight Sif, but it proves a formidable opponent once battle is joined.

It’s the small touches that make this such a tragic and heart-wrenching fight. The story of Artorias and Sif, the fact that Sif wields its master’s sword, the cruelty of making this a mandatory boss… it’s all brutal in an entirely different way.


4. Fabiana Branco - Max Payne 3

Max Payne 3
Rockstar

Some characters meet ghastly ends simply because they were in the wrong place at the wrong time. Fabiana Branco, it seems, married the wrong man at the wrong time, and paid the ultimate price for it.

In Max Payne 3’s vicious world, awful incidents wait around every corner, and they seemed to follow the Brancos around. Her high-profile husband, Rodrigo Branco, would himself be killed during an attack on his compound. Fabiana was kidnapped soon afterwards, by the fearsome Comando Sombra.

Even Max Payne failed to save her from their clutches. On discovering their whereabouts, brother-in-law Marcelo Bianco attempts to reason with the group and provide a ransom for her release. Payne, listening outside the building, knew just enough of the language to know that things were going south quickly. He bursts in against far too many armed foes, is quickly neutralized, and seems to goad the kidnappers. In response, the bound Fabiana is shot by Serrano.


3. John Marston - Red Dead Redemption

Red Dead Redemption John Marston Death
Rockstar

John Marston’s end has a bittersweet brutal beauty about it. Marston may not have been the goodliest and most noble of men, but he always had his family’s welfare in mind. The player commits awful deeds as Marston, but the raw, imperfect character develops in a gripping way. Through the course of Red Dead Redemption and its sequel (which is technically a prequel), we come to bond with him.

Players understand the reason why he’s being hunted, and the moral high ground is tough for Marston to claim. Nevertheless, his death is just heartbreaking to watch.

It has all the hallmarks of a movie tragedy, from his son’s entreaty “you’re comin’ with us, Pa,” to the slow opening of the barn door, from the few foes Marston can dispatch in slow-motion to his slow and haunting drop to his knees, it’s protracted, brutal, and genuinely upsetting.


2. Delta - BioShock 2

Bioshock 2 Subject Delta
2K Games

Much like the original BioShock, the player’s choices throughout the game have a big impact on the outcome. Several endings are available, and they’re all very emotional in their own ways.

Delta will, inevitably, perish at the end of the adventure, having been caught in an explosion while leading Eleanor to safety. The Big Daddies of BioShock may be dismissed as great, lumbering bullet sponges, but the new insight the second game gives us into their creation and Delta’s experiences made us truly care for this one.

If the player opted to harvest the Little Sisters throughout the game, there’s much worse to come: Eleanor will drown her mother, viciously extract the ADAM from the dying Delta (who knew what she was about to do and desperately, weakly, tried to stop her) and emerge ready to let loose her wrath on the surface world.


1. The White Wolf - Children Of Morta

Children Of Morta
11 Bit Studios

Children of Morta is an experience quite unlike the typical roguelike. The player takes the role of members of the Bergson family, a brave clan of warriors dedicated to eradicating the evil forces spreading around the mountain of Morta. Expeditions are of a Diablo-esque nature, in which the various members of the family (each with a unique weapon and playstyle) explore a wide, procedurally-generated level and fend off hordes of monsters.

The game is very much narrative-driven, though, and the exchanges between the Bergsons are touching and heartening in equal measure. Events pop up mid-level too, and one concerns a wolf pup. Its mother lies dead, torn apart by a group of foul creatures, and it is wounded in attempting to defend her until the player intervenes.

This is no throwaway encounter, either. The family member who rescues the pup takes it home, and by collecting the right items, you’re able to nurse it back to health. The whole thing is wound into the game’s story in the most touching of ways.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Max Payne 3
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Chris Littlechild hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.