10 Video Game Characters You Unintentionally DOOMED

When helping just makes things worse.

the witcher 3 hearts of stone
CD Projekt RED

Making choices is one of the most crucial aspects of story-driven video games. It’s what lets the player control the course of the narrative and decide what type of story they want to tell.

However, not every choice you make is crystal clear when it comes to its consequences.

Sometimes you might take an action with very specific intentions in mind, only to be surprised by a completely different outcome. Usually in the form of something really tragic happening to the people you were trying to help.

There are plenty of moments in video games where your attempts at giving someone a helping hand result in them suffering a terrible end. This can be especially disheartening when the person in question is an NPC who acts as your friend or a loyal companion.

Nothing hurts more than knowing you have unintentionally doomed someone with your "good deed." For this reason, you might want to be extra careful when dealing with the following NPCs.

Deciding their fate may not be as simple as it seems.

10. Charles Kinnear - Red Dead Redemption

Red Dead Redemption Charles Kinnear
Rockstar

Since the dawn of mankind, one of humanity's greatest aspirations has been to conquer the skies and soar through the air like a majestic eagle.

Red Dead Redemption 1 allows you to connect with this innate dream by helping an aspiring inventor named Charles Kinnear build his first flying machine. It then takes that dream and crushes it right in front of your face when Mr. Kinnear and his contraption plunge headfirst into their impending doom.

Yes, although your intentions for helping Charles may be good, if not downright noble, the world of Red Dead Redemption is apparently not a place for dreams and ambitions. As soon as you deliver the necessary parts for Charles' flying machine, the man takes it for a test flight and then almost immediately finds himself losing control and falling to his death.

It's a really cruel trick on the game's part, as trying to gather all of the ingredients for Charles' project is incredibly time-consuming. The fact that all your efforts ever amount to is the death of an innocent man who just wanted to realize his dreams is just brutal.

But hey, at least Charles got off better than John.


9. Jeff's Wife - Grand Theft Auto IV

gta 4
Rockstar

The world of Grand Theft Auto is filled with wacky strangers that are more terrible than a human being. Despite this, the player can still choose to help them, and although usually strangers get their comeuppance, sometimes it's innocent people that suffer.

This is exactly what happens in the random encounter with Jeff Harlingford.

Jeff is a jealous husband who asks the player to follow his wife and take pictures of her as she goes out for drinks with her friend. It may sound a bit sketchy, but considering the other things you do as Niko in GTA IV, it's actually a fairly innocent request.

The mission makes it clear that the wife isn't actually cheating on Jeff, but once the player sends him the requested pictures, the man grows incredibly paranoid. A few days later, he will call Niko, asking for another favor, and this is where you realize you've helped the wrong guy.

When you meet up with Jeff, the man will show up with the brutally mutilated corpse of his dead wife. It turns out you gave this unstable man a reason to murder an innocent woman, and worst of all, you did it for a mere $500.


8. Olgierd Von Everec - Witcher 3

The Witcher 3 Olgierd
CD Projekt RED

The theme of "lesser evil" is a pretty important part of the Witcher series. Most decisions Geralt needs to make throughout the trilogy have no easy answers, even when it may appear otherwise. Just like the conundrum in the Heart of Stone DLC.

The DLC's main story revolves around helping a demon called Gaunter O'Dimm collect the soul of a man named Olgierd, who made a deal with him a long time ago.

Now, although you start off working with Gaunter, you can choose to help Olgierd break his curse. However, although saving a man's soul from a powerful demon sounds morally right, when you really think about Olgierd's situation, letting Gautner collect his debt sounds like a more humane solution.

You see, because Olgierd's curse turned him into an immortal and emotionally detached monster, by the time you break it, he has nothing to live for. The love of his life is long dead, as is his brother, and the only thing he knows in life is how to raid and pillage.

Given his past temperaments, the freed Olgierd is likely to become a thrill-seeking and suicidal bandit again or just fully succumb to his depression.

Either way, he's screwed.


7. Septimus Signus - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim

elder scrolls Hermaeus Mora
Bethesda

Whenever Deadric Princes appear in the Elder Scrolls series, you know things are about to get really messed up. The same goes for Hermaeus Mora's cameo in Skyrim, although you don't really realize how bad things are until it's too late.

The main questline in the game requires you to find an insane researcher named Septimus Signus to learn how to obtain an Elder Scroll. The man is willing to give you the information, but in exchange, he wants you to bring his lexicon to the Elder Scrolls location in order to help him translate it.

This starts a long quest in which Septimus and you attempt to open a Dwemer Oculory in hopes of finding the legendary Heart of Lorkhan. What you find inside instead is Hermaeus Mora's arifact, the Oghma Infinium, which immediately kills Septimus.

It turns out Mora ticked Septimus into unearthing his artifact because he wanted you, his next champion, to find it. When the old man was no longer needed, Mora simply let him die a terrible death.

So congratulations on your promotion! Let's hope your new boss doesn't trick another soon-to-be champion into getting rid of you next!


6. Conrad Verner - Mass Effect

Mass Effect Conrad Verner
Bioware

Conrad Verner is Commander Shepard's number one fanboy and the only Mass Effect character who can die in each game in the original trilogy. Each and every time, it happens because your character unwittingly pushes him over the edge.

In Mass Effect 1, Verner asks Commander Shepard if he could join their Spectre squad. If the player refuses while simultaneously telling Verner to buzz off, he will become upset and then try to prove his worth by fighting a group of angry Turians... and dying a horrible death in the process.

It's a pretty extreme reaction for simply getting a bit moody with him, right? Well, in Mass Effect 2, rebuffing Verner has a similar effect, except this time around, Verner tries to prove his heroism by stopping a group of hooligans on a bus, only to fall off the said bus, get hit by a bunch of cars, and then finally fall right into a power turbine of a biomatter recycling plant.

Well, at least he does get to die a hero in the third game by saving Shepard from getting shot, but even that interaction makes it seem like meeting Comander Shepard was the worst decision in Conrad Verner's life.


5. Heather Poe - Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines

Heather Poe - Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines
Troika Games

Heather Poe is a gravely injured woman that the player encounters in Vampire: The Masquerade: Bloodlines. The player can feed her some of their character's vampiric blood to instantly heal her wounds; however, like most things in the dark world of vampires, your good deed will inevitably lead to something terrible.

Soon after Heather is healed, she shows up at your place, begging to become your servant. It turns out your blood is incredibly addictive to humans, and Heather cannot think about anything else other than your character.

It's not the end of the world, though, right? Yes, you have a slave, but you can be nice to her. Well, the problem is that eventually your character starts attracting some pretty dangerous attention to themselves, and if you don't tell Heather to leave you alone, the vampires from a rival sect will kidnap her and kill her.

On the other hand, letting her go is not a great option either. After all, she is hopelessly addicted to your blood, and by the time you make your decision, she will have sold all of her belongings and dropped out of college for you.

Yeah, you know what? She's probably better off dead.


4. Sims Who Divided By Zero - Sims 3

The Sims 3
EA Maxis

The Sims series is well-known for its quirks and oddities. Most of them are cartoonish and fun, like the games' obsession with llamas, but sometimes the weirdness takes on a more disturbing form. Disturbing and unpredictable.

There are many ways in which a Sim can die, from things like fire and old age to the classic routine of drowning them in a pool with no ladders. Out of all the games, Sims 3 probably features the largest selection of means of departing from the world of the living, and one of them in particular can completely catch you by surprise.

The expansion pack, University Life, introduced a special interaction in which one Sim can tell another to divide by zero.

It looks like a silly, innocent joke, but in reality, when the other Sim decides to take them up on the challenge, the impossibility of the equation causes them... to explode!

Yes, as soon as the Sim finishes the equation, fire will erupt from their behind, and shortly after, they will be nothing but a smoldering pile of ashes.

What a nerd! Getting so fired up over simple mathematics...


3. Grey Prince - The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion

Elder scrolls oblivion
Bethesda

The Grey Prince is the Grand Champion of the Cyrodiil arena that appears in The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion. He's a formidable and honorable warrior who never lost a single match, but at the same time, he's also incredibly friendly and amicable towards his fellow fighters.

So you just know the game will want you to absolutely ruin his life.

When the player meets the Grey Prince, the orc will tell them about his secret noble heritage. He reveals that he is actually a half-orc and that his father was an Imperial Lord named Lovidicus. The Grey Prince wants to prove he is of noble blood, and so he will ask you to check his father's old fortress for him.

The problem is that when you arrive at the castle, Lord Lovidicus turns out to be a bloodthirsty vampire. When you bring this news back to the Grey Prince, he is horrified by the revelation and can't stand the idea of being the spawn of an evil vampire. He becomes so distraught that he spirals into depression and then eventually lets you kill him in battle.

If only those DNA ancestry websites existed in Cyrodiil. It would've spared you a pretty nasty guilt trip.


2. Boc The Seamster - Elden Ring

elden ring  boc the seamster
FromSoftware

Boc The Seamster is a helpful little demi-human, an Elden Ring's mix between a monkey and a human, who offers the player to tailor their outfits for them after they rescue him from his more savage and murderous cousins.

Boc is an incredibly humble and helpful fellow, but he has one fatal flaw: he thinks he's incredibly ugly. If the player talks to him about this, Boc will explain that he hates his demi-human form and that his only wish is to be reborn. He tells you that according to legend, Rennala (that annoying boss with the one-shot lazer beam) is capable of granting people a second life.

Naturally, most people want to help their buddy Boc, which is why once they defeat Rennala, they immediately tell him to go to her and get his long-awaited moment of rebirth. And this is usually the last they hear from him.

You see, after Boc is sent to Rennala, it turns out he was indeed reborn as a human, but something went wrong. His new form is incredibly pale, and he cannot speak to you. When you visit him the second time, he simply curls into a ball and dies.

So much for helping your tailor...


1. Gascoigne's Daughter - Bloodborne

Bloodborne Father Gascoigne
Sony

The world of Bloodborne is a terrifying and depressing place. Everything is either cursed or turned insane, and whenever you just might start thinking you could make a difference in the world, the game takes your good deed and turns it into a demoralizing atrocity. Just like it does with Father Gascoigne's daughter.

Gascoigne's daughter (yes, that Gascoigne, the one with the axe and the sharp teeth) is a young and innocent girl who hides from the atrocities of Yharnam inside her parent's home. Despite her apparent safety, she's worried about her parents, and she asks the player to find out what happened to them.

Long story short, it turns out Father Gascoigne killed his wife, and then the hunter killed him. When the girl finds out about this, she begins to question the safety of her house, and at this point, the player can direct her to a new hideout.

Aw, good on you! Helping a young girl survive the apocalypse!

Except you aren't.

This is Bloodborne, remember? In reality, the girl never makes it to the new safehouse. She gets eaten by a massive boar halfway there, and it's all your fault!

By FromSoftware standards, that's still a pretty happy ending.


Watch Next


Contributor

Video games enthusiast with a love for bizarre facts about his favorite titles. Really into old-school strategies and RPGs of all shapes and sizes.