10 Video Game Deaths You Were Powerless To Stop

There was nothing you could do.

wolfenstein thumb
Bethesda

Even though the vast majority of video games see players deal hundreds if not thousands of deaths to anonymous enemies, truly great video games know how to make major character deaths count.

These days it's not uncommon for video games to offer players multiple paths, allowing them to rescue characters who they perhaps allowed to die on a first playthrough, a formula best perfected by Quantic Dream's highly variable "interactive drama" games such as Heavy Rain and Detroit: Become Human.

Yet many games also prefer to strip away the player's power entirely and force them to sit through a devastating character death, with no possibility of a better outcome.

These 10 games all served up unforgettable character deaths which, for better or worse, made players feel like human garbage as they debated how a supposed "entertainment" product gave them an existential crisis about the lack of agency in their own lives.

These video game deaths all left players looking on helplessly as a beloved character was brutally sent to meet their maker...


10. Aerith Gainsborough - Final Fantasy VII

final fantasy 7 aerith
Square Enix

Is there any video game death more thoroughly heartbreaking than that of sweet, innocent Aerith Gainsborough mid-way through Square Enix's landmark RPG Final Fantasy VII?

Totally out of nowhere, Aerith is impaled by Sephiroth's Masamune sword, and within a matter of seconds, she's gone. There isn't a sentimental farewell, just a thoroughly enraged Cloud cradling Aerith's corpse while Sephiroth taunts him.

It's one of the most emotional moments in gaming for damn good reason, and bothered players enough that there have been persistent rumours over the years of a secret way to bring Aerith back to life.

At present the only way to do it is with mods or cheats, though it'll be interesting to see whether or not the impending Final Fantasy VII Remake offers players the chance to resurrect her.

In the interest of maintaining that original storytelling integrity, hopefully not, as painful as her loss undeniably is.


9. Eli Vance - Half-Life 2: Episode Two

Half-Life 2 Episode 2 Eli Dead
Valve

Half-Life 2: Episode Two concludes with Alyx and Gordon preparing to visit the Aperture Science research vessel known as the Borealis, and as compelling a cliffhanger as that would've been in of itself, Valve decided to dish up one final jolting surprise for fans.

In the game's closing moments, the hangar is discovered by two Advisors, one of which quickly grabs Alyx's father Eli and impales him through the back of the head in front of her very eyes. Alyx is scarcely saved from the same fate by Dog, and the episode ends with Alyx cradling her father's corpse. Bummer.

Though the player being unable to do anything to help Eli is bad enough, it's even worse when you consider that this game was released over 12 years ago, and Valve still hasn't gotten around to giving fans any sort of narrative follow-up whatsoever. That's what truly makes the player feel powerless.


8. Lee Everett - The Walking Dead

The Walking Dead Lee Death
Telltale Games

Though Telltale's The Walking Dead games present players with a certain degree of freedom, it was a real Sophie's Choice situation in the first season's final episode when infected protagonist Lee is given two options: ask his surrogate daughter Clementine to kill him before he turns into a Walker, or have her flee the area and leave him to turn.

Players are basically tasked with picking the terrible option or the slightly less terrible one, though opinion on which is which might well vary among fans.

Either way, the end result is basically the same: Lee, the person the player grew to know and care for over the course of the game, is no more, and there's no way for players to save him.

Season two of course shifts the player perspective to Clem herself, but in all of the game's subsequent seasons, never once did it achieve quite the same level of expertly-crafted hopelessness as this.


7. John Marston - Red Dead Redemption

Red Dead Redemption John Marston Death
Rockstar

Rockstar Games' Red Dead Redemption boasts arguably the strongest climax to any of their games to date, as protagonist John Marston's past finally catches up with him and he gets, to not be too indelicate about it, lit up like a Christmas tree and peppered with more holes than a wheel of Swiss cheese.

What's truly brilliant about Marston's death is that the player is given a brief opportunity to use the game's slow-mo Dead Eye mechanic to take down as many of Edgar Ross' men as possible before John is blown to hell, implying a certain measure of player agency in how his fate plays out.

And while it would've been the most Rockstar thing ever if skilled players could use Dead Eye to actually avert John's fate, they're ultimately unable to avoid our morally dubious hero from being shot down like a dog.

But as a compromise, players are then able to take control of John's son Jack for the game's epilogue sequence, where you can mete out bloody vengeance against Ross in a mano-y-mano duel.


6. You, Sarah Lyons OR Everyone - Fallout 3

Fallout 3 Fawkes Ending
Bethesda

The original ending of Fallout 3 was such a misguided exercise in ripping away player choice that Bethesda actually ended up "fixing" the ending in the Broken Steel DLC.

However, the pre-update version of the game ended with the player forced to decide who will enter the irradiated control room and input a code, saving the day but subjecting themselves to a lethal dose of radiation in the process.

Despite being surrounded by cohorts, all of your pals give hilariously flimsy excuses for not volunteering themselves, all of which are basically variations on not wanting to interfere with your destiny.

This is especially egregious in the case of the mutant Fawkes, who could do the job without suffering any adverse effects.

Your rather depressing series of choices, then, are to lay down your own life and input the code, send Sarah Lyons into the control room instead, or do nothing and wait for the facility to explode a few minutes later.

It was such a lamely transparent attempt to funnel the player down a set story path, and fans were irate enough that Bethesda eventually changed the ending in Broken Steel, allowing players to send in Fawkes or their other radiation-immune pals to save the day instead. Justice!


5. The Boss - Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater

Metal Gear Solid 3 Boss
Konami

The final boss in Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater is, of course, Naked Snake's steely mentor The Boss, a former American agent who defected to the USSR.

The glorious final boss fight sees a reluctant Snake battling The Boss in a field, and once she's been mortally wounded, Hideo Kojima literally stops the game and forces the player to fire the final bullet into her.

There's no other option here: you can turn your console off to avoid actually pulling the trigger if you really want, but otherwise, there's no choice but to shoot her dead.

The unease that comes with plugging such a nuanced character becomes worse in retrospect, though, when it's revealed moments later that The Boss never actually defected, but simply feigned defection in order to infiltrate Volgin's ranks and track down the Philosopher's Legacy.

And if you don't feel terrible enough yet, The Boss has to die branded a traitor with nobody but yourself, Eva, and a handful of others knowing the real truth.

It's the smartest and most emotionally resonant writing of Kojima's entire career, and as devastating as it is, we wouldn't have it any other way.


4. Edith Finch - What Remains Of Edith Finch

What Remains of Edith Finch
Giant Sparrow

Giant Sparrow's unforgettable "walking simulator" What Remains of Edith Finch is a game entirely obsessed with death, with the whole game focused on the titular protagonist exploring the home of her cursed family, who have all died in a litany of mysterious and often darkly amusing ways.

At the end of the game, it's revealed that Edith is pregnant - though attentive players who keep looking down will see her full belly earlier on - and consequently dies in childbirth.

Further still, the player character is actually revealed not to be Edith herself but her son Christopher, the only surviving Finch, who places some flowers on young Edith's grave just before the credits roll.

Knowing that almost your entire extended family are dead before the game even begins is one thing, but learning that the person you thought you were playing for the entire game died years prior and you're technically the "cause" is the sort of existential crisis nobody needs in their life.

But despite how emotionally traumatic it is, it also provides a poignant and uncommonly insightful perspective on the impermanence of everything.


3. Sarah - The Last Of Us

The Last of Us Sarah Death
Naughty Dog

Naughty Dog's The Last of Us makes the player feel the weight of every character death like few games in history, and none more so than the opening demise of Joel's young daughter Sarah.

What's truly brilliant about the game's chaotic prologue is how efficiently it makes the player empathise with Joel and informs his mission throughout the rest of the game.

In that opening 15 minutes, the player desperately scrambles to get Sarah to safety, but fails when she's accidentally shot by an enemy.

A more traditional game would've had it happen off screen or relegated it to an entirely non-interactive cutscene, but by making the player live through the horror, their own protective instinct for Ellie is immediately activated from the start of the game proper.


2. Fergus OR Wyatt - Wolfenstein: The New Order

Wolfenstein The New Order
Bethesda

Wolfenstein: The New Order's pre-titles prologue concludes in unforgettably grim fashion, when protagonist "B.J." Blazkowicz is captured alongside his pals Fergus and Wyatt while breaking into Deathshead's weapons laboratory.

The sadistic Deathshead then forces B.J. to choose whether he kills Fergus or Wyatt, resulting in a stomach-churningly gruesome cutscene where the victim of the players' choosing has their eyeballs ripped out, before a barbaric surgical instrument is used to cut a hole through the back of the head and suck their brain out while they're still alive. Gross.

In either case there's nothing the player can do to affect this: it's a literal Sophie's Choice and the end result is equally horrifying no matter whose fate you seal.

Worse still, you then have to destroy said brain at the end of the game after Deathshead places it inside a robot which attacks you.

As much as graphic violence shouldn't surprise any Wolfenstein fan, the sheer pleasure that Deathshead took in offing one of your friends made it especially nauseating.


1. Vaas - Far Cry 3

Far Cry 3 Vaas Death
Ubisoft

And finally, we have a slightly different angle for our final entry. After all, you're probably wondering why we're crying foul about the death of Far Cry 3's cartoonishly savage antagonist Vaas, right?

Well, the manner in which he died proved hugely frustrating to fans, because Vaas isn't killed by the player's own inputs, but during a cutscene after they enact a basic takedown prompt - a QTE, effectively.

Given how hatefully Vaas was depicted throughout the game, for players to not even have the satisfaction of ending him themselves was mightily unsatisfying.

We wanted to be the ones who finished him off, but instead the game took control away from us and did it itself. Boo.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.