10 Video Game Decisions You Immediately Regret Making

Kabuto, I choose you! No, wait a minute...

Pokemon Choice
Nintendo

Choice is wonderful, but is too much of it a bad thing?

Ask anyone under the thumb of Soviet oppression and they'd have said, "nyet, absolutely not," or at least they would have had they not feared being whisked away in the middle of the night for expressing such an opinion. When Tetris creator Alexey Pajitnov, himself a citizen of the Eastern bloc, visited a Tokyo supermarket for the first time, he broke down in tears; he couldn't believe real people could choose between more than two different fruits, and that they didn't have to wait in line to buy a potato.

Clearly then, he believed choice was a good thing. Yet he never introduced it to his games; the only way in Tetris is down, and you get whatever block you're given, even if you really want and need one of the big long boys.

So was Pajitnov a hypocrite? Not hardly: he recognised, even before video games generally allowed players to make complex decisions, that choice is often a burden, not a blessing. In many games which have presented ethical dilemmas since, the only good option has been to hit the power switch, and take up a less stressful hobby like base jumping instead.

10. Chopping Your Own Finger Off (Heavy Rain)

Heavy Rain finger
Quantic Dream

What would you be prepared to do to save the ones you love? Pay a hefty ransom, upwards of five figures? Kill a fella or two? Trade your Charizard Pokémon card? Something unimaginably even more extreme than that?

That's the core question driving the narrative of David Cage's 2010 "Jason!"-em-up Heavy Rain. Having rather carelessly lost another of his kids, hapless father Ethan Mars is goaded by a series of increasingly hideous challenges, each offering another part of the cipher supposedly revealing his son's location should he successfully pass them.

It starts off relatively simple; the first trial asks him to drive against traffic for five miles. Things quickly ramp up - he's next asked to traverse a vicious obstacle course of broken glass and live electricity - before it all takes a stomach-churning turn with the third and most brutal task.

Decoding another origami clue, this time in the shape of a lizard, Ethan finds himself in a room with a small table laden with all manner of very sharp objects. A recording soon confirms our worst suspicions: he must cut off part of his finger within five minutes.

No matter how you look at it, there's no easy way to saw/hack/chop off a digit. It's an utterly butt-clenching sequence with no easy option. Surely your son is worth more than your trigger finger? And besides, at least Ethan wasn't asked to chop something else off.


9. Stealing Anything (Legend Of Zelda: Link's Awakening)

Link S Awakening Thief
Nintendo

Just because some reed-bound prophet with an overzealous engraving hand carved an arbitrary law onto a tablet three thousand years ago, doesn't mean that stealing is inherently wrong. Everyone likes a freebie, and if you're sufficiently stealthy, you can get just about owt for nowt. Groceries, games, a garden shed; your loot's only as big as your overcoat.

That's not to say there aren't repercussions if you're caught trying to cash in your five-finger discount. Extant laws range from fines, prison time, and in some countries, amputation. The inhabitants of Koholint Island, the tropical setting of Nintendo's portable dream Link's Awakening, take the law into their own hands. And their vigilantism takes precisely zero prisoners.

It's entirely possible for Link to deceive Mabe Village's otherwise eagle-eyed shopkeeper and slip out unnoticed, with an overpriced bow and arrow in tow (or above his head, as it happens). But only once. Word spreads of our not-so-heroic hero's larceny. Not only will every character now refer to him as 'THIEF', but dare return to the store and he'll get a faceful of an electric zapper. Link can cheat the clerk, but he can't cheat death.


8. Cancer Or World Hunger (Saints Row IV)

Saints Row IV Cancer or World Hunger
Volition

Volition's GTA killer Saints Row: The Third ends on a mighty high for the eponymous gang, as The Boss and co. declare their native Steelport an independent republic under their purple-soaked purview. By the start of Saints Row IV, things have somehow gotten even better for the 3rd Street Saints: the Boss and his associates have thwarted nuclear annihilation, and he now finds himself installed in the Oval Office as President of the United States.

Unfortunately, not everything is quite going to plan. Approval ratings are through the floor for the POTUS with the mostus, whilst conversely unemployment is skyrocketing. Life's tougher than our put-upon Pres. imagined, and as he's sweating down the halls of the White House, an eager congressman comes at him with another impossible choice: cure cancer, or solve world hunger?

The 'playa' can only pick one of the two bills: 'F*ck cancer' or 'Let them eat cake'. No matter which they choose, they'll walk away knowing they just signed several thousand people to a preventable death. At the very least you get to ease the stress by 'punching a d*ckhead' a few steps later.


7. Blowing Up Megaton (Fallout 3)

Megaton Explosion Fallout 3
Bethesda

When Fallout 3's Lone Wanderer wails their silent vagitus upon emerging from the womb that is Vault 101, they do so towards the ears of a world that it's fair to say has seen better days. Stumbling upon the debris, detritus and Brahmin dung of the radioactive wasteland is something of an eye-opener - and that's not just down to being exposed to sunlight for the first time ever.

The first solace within this crapsack capital is the relative refuge of Megaton, a ramshackle but safe shantytown just outside the Vault. What began as the crash site of a plane carrying a nuclear bomb quickly became a shelter for stragglers denied entry to Vault 101, and over time, the site grew into a permanent home and active trading community.

There's just one problem: impending doom lingers over Megaton's citizens constantly. The bomb the plane was carrying never detonated, and it now sits ominously armed in the centre of town. If only some goody two-shoes hero could deactivate it?

Good idea; frankly, the last thing Capital Wasteland needs is more nuclear devastation. But what if, in a world where resources are scarce, one of the land's few rich men offered to make you a prince, if only you wiped the unsightly town of Megaton from the skyline? It wouldn't take much effort, afterall.

That's the agonising decision handed the player in the quest The Power of the Atom. The natural inclination is to save Megaton and its people - but when you're scraping around for caps and a safe place to sleep later on, you might just wish you'd gave good karma the two fingers.


6. A New World Order Or The Status Quo? (Subsurface Circular)

Subsurface Circular Final Chapter
Mike Bithell Games

Mike Bithell's mass transit mystery Subsurface Circular ends with the titular metro's tube-bound sleuth finally confronting the shadowy resistance robot known as Red Tek, despite so many other commuters suggesting he was merely a myth.

Not only is Red Tek real, but turns out to be the very same robot which tasked our unnamed investigator with tracking a case involving other missing mechs. The sneaky bot hoped the metal gumshoe would unravel the mystery and learn the truth it already knew: Teks weren't going missing, but have been purposefully overproduced to fill an infantry just outside the city. They're now awaiting the order to overthrow the human government, under the belief robots would do a more efficient and fair job for everybody.

Here's the kicker: it's up to the player whether they do or not. Having used the detective's high-level circuitry to properly analyse the situation, Red Tek hands them a gun, and provides two choices. Shoot him, and the world carries on as normal; shoot yourself, and allow Red and his New World Order to sweep through the city.

Now this is what's known as a rough commute.


5. Horde Or Alliance (World Of Warcraft)

WoW Horde vs Alliance
Blizzard

If you're going to spend the next 700 hours of your life ensorcelled within a digital realm, you'd best take your time picking your house colours.

That was the dilemma facing World of Warcraft subscribers migrating to Azeroth back in 2004, who were presented with the tricky choice of the Alliance's band of differently shaped humans or the Horde's, um, horde of otherworlders and outsiders.

Warcraft lore dictated it wasn't even as easy as Alliance = Heroes and Horde = Villains. Throughout the series' chronology, the plight of the misunderstood albeit bloodthirsty Orcs is explored in as much detail as the arrogant pomposity of the supposedly virtuous humans. Where your sympathies lie largely depends on your tolerance for green skin.

A simple aesthetic choice was just as tough. The undeniable, fan-art baiting coolness of the druidic Night Elves is matched by the Undead's skeletal shuffling, whilst the steampunk gadgetry of Gnomeregan's exiled crew is comparable to the low-key nobility of peaceful cowmen the Tauren.

And what about lore? The Alliance side has Stormwind and all of Azeroth's key assets, but the Forsaken call the ruins of Lordaeron their home. Ultimately, the only answer is to roll a rogue, and tour the world under a cloak of invisibility.


4. Amputating Your Own Arm (The Walking Dead)

The Walking Dead amputation
Telltale Games

Telltale's The Walking Dead adaptation is a game chockablock with choices tougher than zombie flesh, but few are as agonising - both figuratively and literally - than this dilemma from the first series' final episode, a decision that left many players stumped one way or another.

At the end of the previous chapter, 'Around Every Corner', protagonist Lee is carelessly bitten by a Walker whilst raking through some garbage. Just like that, after spending an entire season vigilantly avoiding their clutches, our hero is now staring down the same fate as so many unfortunates before him.

Really, it was inevitable, as it is for each of the hopeful crew. Yet the player is given a possible albeit grisly lifeline: chop Lee's arm off above the bite, in the medically insecure hope that this'll somehow thwart the plague.

Don't, and you're forced to endure the anguish of wondering, given The Walking Dead's heartbreaking scenes, if you could have saved him. Spoiler: you couldn't. Those who did amputate Lee's limb realise they've put him through considerable additional torment for absolutely diddly-squat, as he perishes anyway, minus an arm for no good reason.


3. Kabuto Or Omanyte (Pokémon Red/Blue)

Pokémon Red Fossils
Nintendo

After spending the better part of their young adult lives and at least half a dozen AA batteries trawling through Mt. Moon's labyrinthine caverns, budding Pokémon trainers were presented with a rock-hard problem. Upon defeating a scientist nerd to clear Team Rocket out of the maze for the good, two odd shaped archaeological artifacts are left behind: the helix and dome fossils.

The player is forced to pick one there and then - they're so big they're blocking the exit - with absolutely no idea as to the benefit lugging a big stone in their backpack will bring. It transpires much, much later that a scientist situated on the remote island of Cinnabar has perfected the technology to bring these fossilised remains back to life, and he does so with zeal, oddly expressing no surprise that one happens to be in the possession of a ten year old kid.

The process is a success, and you get either Kabuto or Omanyte depending on a decision you made at about Level 10. Immediately upon seeing your daft revived shell/helmet, you wish you'd picked the other. The only way to get both is through an external trade; the other fossil is put on display in the Safari Zone. Curses!


2. After School Clubs (Persona 4)

Persona 4 Drama Club
Atlus

The latter entries in the Persona series perfectly capture the high-school life, right down to the tedious extra-curricular clubs your parents force you to attend because "they'll be 'enriching" (and give them a few hours peace). In the stellar fourth outing, the evening activities on offer at sleepy suburban school Yasogami High comprise the usual array of sports nonsense, as well as cultural clubs, not involving Boy George, but drama and band.

From 19 April, our TV-tripping protagonist gets to pick one, but the implications of the choice aren't immediate. Although both the drama and music society open up a Social Link of the Sun arcana, the choice of friendship on offer differs: on the one side, you have talented if overbearing thesp Yumi Ozawa, on the other painfully shy trombonist Ayane Matsunaga.

Ultimately, it makes no difference either way, but one aspect of life Persona absolutely nails is chronic FOMO. It's impossible, once you're stuck performing a terrible high-school production of Twelfth Night, to not look across to the music room and wonder if Thursday nights would be better spent playing the flute badly.


1. Almost Everything In Papers, Please

Papers Please Strip Club
Lucas Pope

Lucas Pope's outstanding Papers, Please is a dystopian document thriller, which makes bureaucracy anything but boring. You wake up one typically grey day in the Eastern Bloc-chic country of Arstotzka, with a letter on your uncarpeted floor congratulating you on winning October's labour lottery: starting immediately, you'll be working as an immigration inspector at the newly opened Grestin Border Checkpoint.

Ostensibly, the aim of Papers, Please is to check passports against an ever-mutating series of rules, granting admission to those who meet the requirements. But it's not as simple as that; you're repeatedly forced to consider your humanity, making excruciating decisions to deny desperate individuals entry on the basis of a technicality or overly officious and often overtly unfair new regulations. It's a constant struggle of sending your conscience to the back of the line behind your family.

Even when the choice seems a no-brainer, Papers, Please has a habit of kicking you in the teeth and the knackers. During your first few days on the job, women hand the inspector a flyer for an East Grestin brothel called The Pink Vice. Some time later, another woman hands you the same flyer - slipped within is a note imploring you to deny entry to a man in line named Dari Ludum, who she fears will force her and her sister to work at the brothel.

When Ludum steps forward, his papers check out. Even if you deny him entry - and accept the citation which follows - a headline in the paper several days later reports that several of the Pink Vice's dancers have been found dead. It's the unrelentless, dehumanising suffocation of oppression in microcosm.


Watch Next


In this post: 
pokemon
 
First Posted On: 
Editorial Team
Editorial Team

Benjamin was born in 1987, and is still not dead. He variously enjoys classical music, old-school adventure games (they're not dead), and walks on the beach (albeit short - asthma, you know). He's currently trying to compile a comprehensive history of video game music, yet denies accusations that he purposefully targets niche audiences. He's often wrong about these things.