10 Video Game Developers Who Made The Right Decision To Ignore Fans
Developers really do know best.
It's often said that a writer's second novel is infinitely harder than their first, and the same seems to hold true for game development.
It's not always clear what makes a series popular, and devs need to find ways to improve upon the original formula while not alienating fans who often have a clear set of expectations of what they want to see in the sequel.
When innovating too much could destroy the brand, and innovating too little risks a slower but equally painful death by stagnation (rest in peace, Telltale Games), it's no surprise that devs often get the balance wrong. Listening to your fans is often necessary to know where to plant your flag; to understand what to keep and what to unceremoniously ditch.
That said, fans can be wrong and sometimes - just sometimes - the companies and people who make a living from creating video games really do have a better idea of what makes a better final product than the adoring public.
Some of the greatest games of all time come from devs listening carefully to their audience - and then ignoring them entirely.
10. Romancing Triss AND Yennefer - CD Projekt Red (The Witcher 3)
The Witcher 3 finally answered the burning question on all fans' minds: will the titular Geralt of Rivia cop off with series stalwart Triss Merigold, or with his star-crossed lover from the books, Yennefer?
In fact, the game allows him to get it on with either lady. You might think some players would try to sneak an awkwardly-rendered lovemaking scene with both women, and you'd be absolutely right. If this happens, Triss and Yen invite Geralt to a steamy ménage à trois... before tying him unclothed to the bed and leaving him there.
Some fans were enraged by this unwelcome injection of reality into their fantasy, and the scene suffered an online backlash against the two witches failing to meekly accept Geralt's philandering.
In truth, however, it's a great narrative moment that fits perfectly with the personalities of these femmes fatale and with the game's themes of decisions and consequences.
For a studio which once exhibited a less than, uh, sophisticated attitude towards women (CDPR would surely love to forget about the nudie trading cards from the first game), it is encouraging that they stayed true to the essences of their female characters without resorting to lazy fan service.
9. Ditching "Gotta Catch 'Em All!" - Game Freak (Pokémon Black & White)
While the upcoming Pokémon Sword & Shield are under fire for removing some of the collectible critters, this is not the first time Game Freak has pulled this particular stunt.
Pokémon Ruby & Sapphire quietly dropped the iconic "Gotta catch 'em all" slogan on the basis that players could not, in fact, catch 'em all, and the fifth generation games went one further in rebooting the entire franchise.
The backlash to this decision was predictable, with players voiced their displeasure at not being able to use their favourite 'mons (at least until after they beat the game) in terms which will be very familiar to anyone following the current furore.
However Game Freak certainly didn't skimp on providing replacements, and at 156 new creatures, Black & White feature a larger roster than other generation before or since. Indeed, the reboot mentality leaked into every pore of Black & White, which feature a particularly dark take on the Pokémon world.
Generation five had arguably the tightest and most original storytelling of the entire franchise, which we might not have been treated to if Game Freak had stuck rigidly to their winning formula.
8. Ignoring The Call For "More Of The Same" - Respawn (Titanfall 2)
The two Titanfall games followed very different trajectories.
The first was hyped as a system-seller for the Xbox 360, and while it offered a competent multiplayer experience, its threadbare game modes and features ended up underwhelming. The sequel Titanfall 2, by comparison, flew under the radar for many but those who actually picked it up found a surprisingly compelling single and multiplayer package.
What changed?
Well, according to a far-ranging (and often rambling) interview with director Steve Fukada, the missing ingredient was a healthy dose of disdain for the wishes of series fans.
Fukada revealed that players were clamouring for more of the same; Titanfall 1, but just a little bit bigger.
Instead his team upended the pace of combat for the sequel and restructured how the game played, getting rid of much of the "verticality" which defined the original. The final product was instantly familiar to players of Call of Duty and similar shooters, but with zippier movement and stompy mechs to boot.
The moral of the story should be clear: Take an already-successful game (like COD), and add big stompy mechs. That may go against the spirit of this article, but big stompy mechs objectively make everything better.
7. Striving For Mass Appeal - Nintendo/Sora Ltd. (Super Smash Bros. Brawl)
When creating the third installment of Nintendo's iconic fighting franchise, series director Masahiro Sakurai famously decided to move away from the fast-paced, tech-heavy gameplay of its predecessor, Super Smash Bros. Melee.
This resulted in a very different feel to gameplay and a greater emphasis on single-player modes.
The large tournament community may have decried the slower, floatier feel of the game, but casual players appreciated greater accessibility and a wider variety of modes. The Subspace Emissary story campaign (a first for the series) is still remembered with affection.
Brawl was a far broader Smash Bros. than Melee, if just that bit shallower, and became a huge critical and commercial success which helped to extend the Wii's dominance. The prospect of resident puffball Kirby being able to kick seven shades out of ultra-hard mercenary Solid Snake was just too charming to resist.
For Melee fans, as well, there's a happy ending. They may not have got the sequel they wanted but the competitive scene eventually recovered (which may not have happened had Brawl been more competitively-focused), and attendance and viewing figures for tournaments continue to rival the most recent entry in the series, Super Smash Bros. Ultimate.
6. Embracing Fantasy - Creative Assembly (Total War: Three Kingdoms)
The two halves of the Total War community have been in a state of all-consuming conflict (if only there were a phrase for that) ever since the 2016 release of Total War: Warhammer.
With half of the fanbase clamouring for additional content and iterations of the fantasy side of the series, and half waiting for a return to the more grounded historical settings of the early Total War games, Creative Assembly seemed guaranteed to disappoint at least half of their fans with their next title.
Still, a Total War based on a heavily-romanticised retelling of history complete with god-like hero units seemed the perfect way to upset everyone, containing neither historical authenticity or zombie dragons. What's more, the setting - third century China - caused consternation by being unfamiliar territory for players, at least in the West.
Creative Assembly somehow managed to pull the opposite trick, however, producing a slick strategy title which gave both history buffs and fantasy fans something to chew on.
Three Kingdoms became the fastest-selling entry in the whole franchise, driven both by Western sales and by the lucrative Chinese market, glad to finally get some representation after decades of Total War kicking about almost exclusively in Europe.
5. Changing Everything - SIE Santa Monica Studio (God Of War)
God of War (2018) is a very different game to God of War (2005), despite Santa Monica Studio not being able to come up with a new name after thirteen years. While now acclaimed as one of the greatest games of the year and the generation, fans were initially distressed by the game's break from tradition.
The introduction of adoptive son Atreus raised eyebrows, as anyone who has ever performed a video game escort quest (or indeed raised an actual human child) will surely understand. Moreover, the tonal shift, from button-mashy Greek tragicomedy to artful Scandi drama, made the 2018 reboot feel like a very different series.
However, gameplay which was great in 2005 is not necessarily still as good now, and the original God of War games really show their age today.
The series's newest entry is updated for the late 2010s; a rich gameplay package held together with a gripping and emotional narrative. It doesn't exactly dispense with the formula that made its forebears so successful, but utilises over a decade's worth of additional expertise to sculpt the best possible sequel yet.
Surely, that's what game development should all be about?
4. Being "Glorified DLC" - Valve (Left 4 Dead 2)
The only game on this list to earn backlash simply by existing, the sequel dropped only a year after the original Left 4 Dead. Fans of the four-player co-op zombie shooter were concerned by the possibility of a Valve money-grab by rushing out a sequel, and soon after its announcement a Left 4 Dead 2 boycott group on Steam had attracted over 37,000 members.
As you can probably guess, these fears turned out to be groundless. Left 4 Dead 2 introduced a wealth of new modes, levels, and zombie types, as well as notable features missing from the first iteration such as melee combat.
Classily, Valve even continued to support the first game with both free and paid content, and soon opposition melted away. The boycott group didn't even survive until release date; incredibly, at least according to Valve supremo Gabe Newell, members of the boycott actually preordered the game at a faster rate than other players.
It's possible that Left 4 Dead 2 could (and should) still have been released as downloadable content for the first game, but it's hard to argue that fans who stumped up for the sequel didn't get their money's worth.
3. Chasing The Mobile Game Crowd - Firaxis (Sid Meier's Civilization VI)
Casual colonialism simulator the Civilization series came in for flak on the unveiling of its sixth entry. Sporting colourful, larger than life visuals, the art style irritated many fans who were used to the more muted and realistic look of Civilization V.
Developer Firaxis's protestations that they weren't attempting to emulate mobile games were somewhat undermined when Civ VI literally became a mobile game, getting ported to iOS as well as to the Switch.
While the mobile game comparison might seem apt however, Civilization VI’s art direction was more reminiscent of its granddaddy Civilization IV, which released during the heady pre-Clash of Clans days of 2005.
The vibrant palette and expressive world leaders helped put the charm back into ruthlessly conquering and pillaging your enemies, and it seems to have finally battered its doubters into submission, with VI recently overtaking V on Steam's listing of most-played games.
As a postscript, a Firaxis developer recently released a semi-official graphics patch giving players the option to dress Civ VI up in V's skin, so now everyone can enjoy this rock-solid strategy title in whichever guise they prefer.
2. Capcom - Resident Evil 4
Resident Evil 4 had a famously drawn-out development schedule, with no fewer than four different versions being created and scrapped before Capcom settled on the final design.
The discarded concepts ranged from a simple continuation of the formula popularised by the first three Resident Evil games (complete with awkward fixed camera angles), to a superpowered, fast-paced combo-heavy action title. The eventual product ended up as something of a halfway house, providing the blend of oppressive horror atmopshere and hectic gameplay which would define the series until the soft reboot of Resident Evil VII.
At the time, Capcom had an EA-like reputation for releasing similar Resident Evil games year-on-year, so the complete shift in tone caught many by surprise.
But fans needn't have worried.
RE4 not only reinvigorated its own franchise, but managed to spawn an entirely new one. Capcom continued to develop the action-heavy prototype mentioned earlier, which ultimately became Devil May Cry.
RE4 went on to become one of the bestselling games on Gamecube and PS4 and has been ported to several platforms including mobile, a feat which not even Skyrim has achieved yet.
1. Nintendo - The Legend Of Zelda: The Wind Waker
It seems incredible now, but prior to release, The Wind Waker's cel-shaded art style was loathed by many players (most of whom presumably have experienced "fun" a maximum of twice in their lives).
Riding high off the graphically-impressive Ocarina of Time and Majora's Mask, Nintendo's embrace of cel-shaded visuals stood in stark contrast to the prevailing wisdom that more realistic graphics were better, turning many fans off.
Despite the naysayers, however, the result was a visually gorgeous game packed with character which also cannily managed to disguise the shortcomings of the underpowered GameCube.
Although not an unqualified success story commercially (slow sales contributed to a more conventional art direction for the follow-up Twilight Princess), The Wind Waker is now rightly considered a critical masterpiece.
Nintendo makes some very, very strange decisions at times, but gems like this - and of course the more recent Breath of the Wild, which eschewed the series' traditional dungeon crawling for an open-world experience - should serve as a reminder that in most cases they have earned the benefit of the doubt.