10 Video Game DLCs That Burned Their Fanbase

Parted with hard-earned money for a game? According to publishers, that's simply not enough.

Fallout 76 DLC
Bethesda

DLC used to stand for Downloadable Content. It now stands for Dastardly Laundering Conspiracy. Granted, gamers are still afforded such wonders as The Witcher 3's epic Blood And Wine expansion and Far Cry 3's hilarious '80s action parody Blood Dragon, but over the years, DLC has begun to evolve into something roundly more sinister.

No longer content with adding exciting new scenarios to their games, publishers love nothing more than to wrest finished titles from their developers, slamming them onto a chopping board and messily hacking away, shipping unfinished products and offering players the rest of the game for an extra tenner out of the goodness of their hearts.

Beyond this, gamers can now pay for the privilege of timesavers, allowing them to bypass levelling systems without putting the time and effort in, or immediately execute finishers without pesky things such as skill getting in the way. An insult to fans who have invested time and money into their favourite franchises, there is no depth these companies won't sink to in order to exploit their player bases even more.

It's enough to make one pine for the days of pre-internet gaming, where a finished game was standard operating procedure rather than a valuable commodity. Let's have ourselves a look at ten of the worst DLC offences that have been inflicted upon loyal fanbases. Upgrade to a WhatCulture Premium account to see the rest of the list! (We're kidding.)

10. Horse Armour - The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion

Oblivion Horse Armour
Bethesda Softworks

An early example of DLC burning its fans, Oblivion's infamous Horse Armour debuted in 2006, when DLC and online content was still very much a new thing - and it may well have opened the floodgates for what was to come. For just $2.50, players could drape their mount in some gaudy golden armour as they rode across the verdant land of Cyrodiil.

In the current gaming climate, $2.50 for a cosmetic item doesn't seem like much at all - in fact, players are known to spend hundreds on such things - but back in 2006 this felt like a massive insult. What didn't help was that Oblivion was a single player experience, so the only people to show your purchase off to were stiff-faced NPCs who couldn't care less rather than obnoxious other players, who also probably couldn't care less.

Acknowledging their error, Bethesda acknowledged their misstep on April Fools' Day 3 years later, where they did a sale on Oblivion content - everything was half price except the Horse Armour, which they doubled. The company had the worst up their sleeve, however, and may well be making another appearance on this list.


9. Battle Of Forlì And Bonfire Of The Vanities - Assassin's Creed II

Assassin's Creed II Battle Of Forli
Ubisoft

For many gamers, Assassin's Creed 2's "extra" story chapters were their first experience of content being cut out of a finished product and sold back to them in the guise of an expansion. It certainly was for me. When playing Assassin's Creed 2, your exciting Renaissance adventures are interrupted frequently by irritating modern-day segments, because Ubisoft at the time were under the impression that Desmond Miles was a good character.

One such moment, however, stuck out more than the rest. Immediately after Ezio Auditore's successful initiation into the Assassin Order, the Animus would encounter a glitch, resulting in one of Desmond's stupid friends declaring that the next 2 memory sequences were corrupted. The game would then invite the player to purchase the sequences as Downloadable Content upon their releases.

The 2 sequences were fully-fledged chapters (one an exciting action epic and the other a tedious forced stealth slog), but the fact that these had clearly been saved to squeeze a bit of extra cash out of players left a sour taste in everyone's mouth. Sadly, this kind of practice is now common in video game publishing, and it's no longer surprising to be met with an incomplete game if you didn't shell out for the gold-plated prestige edition.


8. Ultimate Shortcut Bundle - Battlefield 3

Battlefield 3 Multiplayer
Electronic Arts

Across many genres, grinding is simply a part of gaming - as frustrating as some may find it. Whether it's endlessly repeating World Of Warcraft's fetch-quests or fighting the same wolves over and over in Final Fantasy VII's overworld so you don't get stuck in Wutai at too low a level to continue the sodding game, it's a game mechanic that despite its repetitive nature is deliberate and ultimately rewarding.

The same goes for online first-person shooters, where racking up kills against all the other 12 year olds would yield the best weapons and attachments. The guy who keeps splattering you with Akimbo 1887s in Modern Warfare 2? You may hate him, but he put the work in to earn those shotguns.

From Battlefield 3 onwards, EA began capitalising on player impatience by offering the "Ultimate Shortcut Bundle", where for not much less than the price of the game, players could simply pay to have all weapons and abilities unlocked for them from the outset. This practice enraged many Battlefield fans, as it meant that players with some more cash at their disposal could simply jump the queue, easily winning matches without having earned it. The Ultimate Shortcut Bundle perpetuates a class war between players rather than a good old-fashioned violent one.


7. The Taken King - Destiny

Destiny the taken king
Activision

Bungie's third expansion for their sci-fi looter-shooter Destiny, The Taken King above all else displayed the utter contempt that Bungie and Activision had for its own fanbase. For starters, the expansion was almost the same price as the base game, which soured the experience for a lot of players. The Taken King was admittedly huge, improving the game's story, mechanics and mission structure, but this had one massive drawback.

In restructuring the game in such a way, player who hadn't bought the exorbitantly priced DLC were locked out of already existing content, such as Nightfall missions and Daily and Weekly Heroic Strikes - further limited were bounties and playable match types. The developer had essentially punished loyal players for not forking out another $40 for an expansion to a game they had already sunk time and money into.

Even worse was the fact that some of The Taken King's content was only available to players who bought the $80 Collector's Edition of the expansion, which included the base game which they already had. Bungie's creative director Luke Smith defended the decision to further withhold such content in an absolute trainwreck of an interview with Eurogamer, where he essentially blamed players for being anxious about the price. It's truly toe-curling reading.


6. Street Fighter X Tekken - Additional Characters (That Were Always There)

Street Fighter x Tekken
Capcom/Namco

Unlocking additional characters has been the bread and butter of fighting games for decades. Of course, this was once simply achieved by playing through arcade and story modes of the titles in question and earning a new character and their story upon each completion.

Of course, publishers have since realised they can sell new combatants as DLC and players will lap it up. Later Mortal Kombat titles in particular hinge a huge amount of marketing on new characters that will be available for purchase, with crossovers such as Alien, Predator, Friday The 13th and The Terminator all having been touted.

Street Fighter X Tekken, Capcom and Namco's highly anticipated first half of a fighting game crossover that was disappointingly never completed, caused outrage with a particularly insulting practice. Capcom announced that the 12 previously PS Vita-exclusive fighters would later be sold as DLC on the PS3, Xbox 360 and PC versions of the game, and admitted that they were already on the disc. The work had already been done, no extra budget had needed to be spent on creating or porting the characters. The publishers simply locked the content off in order to net themselves an extra payday down the line.


5. Easy Fatalities - Mortal Kombat X

Mortal Kombat X Fatality
Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment

Speaking of fighting games, and Mortal Kombat in general, NetherRealm Studios spectacularly missed the point of their unique selling point when they released the highly anticipated Mortal Kombat X. Fatalities, a far cry from the moral panic generator they were in the early 1990s, have gradually morphed into an exercise in excess and silliness. Their impact is largely lost, but the complex and difficult button combination required to pull them off still makes them rewarding.

That is until NetherRealm introduced "Easy Fatalities", allowing players to immediately execute the gory finishers for a small price - 99 cents for 5 or $4.99 for 30. That's right, the one thing that still made the tired curtain calls special could now just be bought with real money on top of the game's original price tag. It utterly devalued what was left of fatalities and undermined a game with one of the most dedicated and kompetitive fanbases in gaming history.

It didn't help that Easy Fatalities had reportedly been requested to NetherRealm by a small subset of players who just wanted some casual fun, resulting in NetherRealm turning round and saying "here you go!" while rubbing their thumb and forefingers together.


4. The Ending To The Game - Asura's Wrath

Asuras Wrath 1
Capcom

Many moons ago, games such as Golden Axe, Streets Of Rage 2 and Earthworm Jim would end early or withhold the game's true ending from players for committing the sin of playing on easy mode. In 2012, Capcom took this in an entirely more reprehensible direction with anime-inspired action brawler Asura's Wrath. Here, they withheld the game's true ending from players for committing the sin of... buying the game.

The 18-episode base game ends with the declaration that the player must go back through the game and obtain 5 S-ranks in order to see the "true" ending at the end of a hidden episode. This ending then introduces a cliffhanger which many fans assumed to be a hook for a sequel. However, Capcom then announced a piece of DLC containing episodes 19-22, which included the game's actual true ending. And then proceeded to charge $6.99 for it.

Obviously, players were incensed. Here was another example of a completed game having content removed and sold back for some sleazy extra profit - but unlike Assassin's Creed II, whose missing chapters weren't entirely essential to the game's plot, this was the game's actual ending. That's some serious brass balls that Capcom are brandishing.


3. Burial At Sea - Bioshock Infinite

BioShock Infinite DLC Burial At Sea
2K Games

This is likely to sound like a massively personal gripe, but there is still a point to be made about how Bioshock Infinite's Burial At Sea DLC fatally undermines the incredibly powerful story that Bioshock Infinite presented and neatly wrapped up. While the Rapture-set expansion plays well and looks incredible, it's also a piece of cynical fanservice that downplays the sacrifices of Infinite's characters in order to tie in with the plot of the original Bioshock.

Bioshock Infinite's plotline is a little confusing and, admittedly, not watertight. However, everything is brought together perfectly in its final moments where - spoiler warning - protagonist Booker DeWitt makes the decision to be drowned at a certain point in time in order to prevent all the wrongs he will commit. All timelines and all parallels are erased.

Then Burial At Sea happens and retcons Infinite's ending, revealing that one Elizabeth remained and has been chasing down remaining Bookers - who, according to Infinite's ending, had all been wiped out. The DLC then proceeds to see the characters killed in a plot that leads up to Jack's arrival in Rapture. Booker's sacrifice is meaningless, and it's all ultimately to serve a character with the personality of a piece of driftwood.


2. Stuff Packs And Much, Much More - The Sims

The Sims 4 house
Electronic Arts

The Sims, everyone's favourite utterly decadent Stepford Wives simulator, is a global phenomenon. That's not even hyperbole. Its first instalment, essentially SimCity if it was zoomed in on one single household, was a fairly earnest entry, whose critically acclaimed expansion packs added new game mechanics, careers, items and features amongst others.

The Sims 2 was similar, with each expansion bringing massive new neighbourhoods, fantasy creatures and much more. However, the addition of "stuff packs", essentially more household items that needed to be bought, raised some suspicion. The Sims 3 once again bombarded players with even more expansions and even more Stuff Packs, and while the game was rich with content, it was beginning to feel bloated and more than a little like a cash grab.

Then came The Sims 4. The base game itself had been stripped of content and contained significantly less than its predecessor at launch, and players were expected to buy 16 Stuff Packs, many of which had been key features of the previous games. The entire game is built around its paid DLC, limiting even the most basic content to players as shallow and money-driven as its own characters.


1. Fallout 1st - Fallout 76

Fallout 76 Squad
Bethesda Softworks

How fitting it is to bookend this list with Bethesda Softworks, a company that in recent years has slipped from pioneering lovingly crafted single-player RPGs to botching their launches, betraying their player base and butchering their own IPs with all the elegance of a man falling down a spiral staircase.

Fallout 76 is bad. Really, really, atrociously bad. Many fans were already unhappy at the direction Bethesda were taking the Fallout series, increasingly favouring action over RPG mechanics, but 76's buggy, rushed, threadbare online shooter brought a new level of ire.

After weathering endless (totally legitimate) grievances and suggestions from players who felt ripped off by the cynical mess they had been given, Bethesda proudly announced that they had taken many of these requests into account and would be implementing them. Casting back the curtain, they revealed that private servers, unlimited scrap storage, a placeable fast-travel point and much more was available... with Fallout 1st, a subscription service that cost £99 a year. And of course, in true Bethesda style, it didn't work properly. The private servers weren't properly private and a bug caused the scrap storage to delete players' scrap. That is undoubtedly the height of greedy, underhanded sh*thousery.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Fallout 76
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

A self-taught video editor with nearly 25 years of experience, Joe worked in freelance videography for many years before joining WhatCulture in 2018. During that time, he has expanded his work to include both writing and presenting, and has been at the forefront of several new channel launches including WhatCulture Horror and WhatCulture Star Wars, largely defining their visual identity through the design and curation of their bespoke assets. As a dedicated WhatCulture Gaming staff member, he has spearheaded numerous new content strategies and formats, and has taken the lead on various charitable projects that have raised large sums of money for charities close to his heart. Bluesky and Instagram: @jjpinwheel