10 Video Game Endings That Totally Trolled Players

It's The Stanley Parable's world, we just live in it.

Stanley parable
Coffee Stain Studios

It's fair to say that an ending can make or break just about any piece of media, and though you might feel more compelled to view a 30-hour video game from the perspective of "it's the journey, not the destination," a bummer ending might still forever taint your opinion of it.

But sometimes endings aren't simply underwhelming or disappointing: sometimes it feels like the developers flat-out have it out for the very people paying to play their games.

It's difficult to experience these 10 video game endings without feeling like the developers are straight-up laughing at you for forking over your hard-earned cash in the first place.

From endings which blatantly looked down at players, to those that bored them with incessant drivel, or just committed a cardinal storytelling sin, these endings all left players feeling basically victimised.

In some cases it was entirely the developer's intent, to jolt players with an expectation-defying shocker of an ending, while in others it was simply a result of the creatives not thinking enough about what players actually wanted.

Whatever the result, these games live on in infamy due to their head-scratching troll-job endings...

10. ANOTHER Cliffhanger - Shenmue III

Shenmue 3 Ending
Sega

Shenmue III was finally released in 2019, almost an entire 20 years after Shenmue II hit stores and left fans on an epic cliffhanger, with protagonist Ryo Hazuki's quest to avenge his father's death still incomplete.

Though franchise creator Yu Suzuki was upfront about the fact that he had plans for Shenmue IV and Shenmue V, fans still had the reasonable expectation that, given how much effort it took to will a third game into existence, it would bring some sort of open-ended closure to Ryo's story.

Instead, Shenmue III rewarded patient fans by leaving them hanging yet again. Players briefly fight the killer of Ryo's father, Lan Di, right at the end of the game, after which the villain escapes and a closing title insists, "The story goes on..."

Considering the mixed response to the sequel and the likelihood that a fourth game won't muster the same nostalgia-fuelled interest, it was a bold gamble to put fans back in the same agonising holding pattern they were in 20 years ago.

After waiting so long, fans deserved better than a mediocre game which had the gall to effectively beg them to crowdfund the next game to see how the story ends.


9. The Cheap Killer Reveal - Heavy Rain

Heavy Rain Scott Shelby
Quantic Dream

Heavy Rain marked a major artistic step up for developer Quantic Dream and their unique "interactive drama" video games, though it also wasn't without writer-director David Cage's now-customary storytelling indulgences.

The thriller, centered around a serial killer called the Origami Killer, spectacularly implodes in the final stretch when it's revealed that one of the game's four playable characters, P.I. Scott Shelby, was the killer all along.

The problem with this reveal and everything that follows is that it completely invalidates the player's perspective throughout the game.

Up to this point, the clear implication is that the gameplay is an objective depiction of events, but given that an earlier scene in an antiques shop made it physically impossible for Shelby to be the killer, this late-stage twist felt like a cheap moving of the goalposts for the sake of shock value.

We thought we were playing a matter-of-fact story when, actually, it was an unreliable representation of what happened. Nothing in the game leading up to the reveal hints at the deception, and so many players felt cheated by Cage's lazy writing.

Though players can arrive at several different endings after Shelby is revealed to be the killer, the lousy twist sucks so much air out of the story that you couldn't really be blamed for losing interest entirely.


8. Say What Now? - Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons Of Liberty

Metal Gear Solid 2 Raiden
Konami

Nobody delivers a bats**t ending quite like Hideo Kojima, who has practically made an art out of it throughout the Metal Gear Solid franchise.

And though Metal Gear Solid V left everyone agape with its final bait-and-switch reveal, Metal Gear Solid 2 features his most aggressive act of player trolling.

After Raiden defeats Solidus Snake in the final boss fight, Kojima forces players to sit through a snooze-inducing dialogue exchange between Raiden and Solid Snake, where they discuss the nature of reality, memes, the future, free will, and of course, the shadowy cabal known as the Patriots.

Between all this, the abundance of live-action footage of New York City, a bizarre jazz music soundtrack, and a saccharine reunion between Raiden and Rose, it's a boatload of WTF packed into an overly verbose 20-minute package.

That's without even mentioning the post-credits tag, where it's revealed that the Patriots, the enigmatic figures you've been chasing the entire game, have been dead for 100 years.

It's certainly a high-minded ending that feels ahead of its time in many ways, but it's also not entirely unlike the infamous Architect scene from The Matrix Reloaded: a giant convoluted word salad to say something that's actually pretty simple when you break it down.


7. Another Downer LGBT Ending - Life Is Strange

Life is Strange Ending Max
Dontnod

As much as Life is Strange has been lauded as a breakthrough game for LGBT representation, it also commits the cardinal sin of rehashing perhaps the most tired and infuriating trope in queer media.

The much-maligned "bury your gays" trope refers to the excessive incidence of death and tragedy in LGBT relationships in all forms of media - particularly movies, TV, and now video games.

Though Life is Strange features two distinct endings which allow Max and Chloe's relationship to play out in different ways, neither of them are ultimately particularly happy ones.

At the end, Max is forced to choose between sacrificing the town of Arcadia Bay in order to save Chloe, and sacrificing Chloe in order to save the town. Either Chloe dies or the town is destroyed, presumably killing many people in the process.

Even if Max and Chloe end up together, this "happy" ending is entirely tainted by the blood Max has on her hands as a result.


6. Changing The Timeline - Final Fantasy VII Remake

Final Fantasy 7 Remake Ending
Square Enix

Final Fantasy VII Remake's ending caught just about every fan by surprise, regardless of whether they dug it or not.

Though most understandably assumed it would follow the beats of the original game relatively closely, the ending of the first volume marked a major departure from the previous continuity.

Final Fantasy VII Remake is effectively a meta-remake that incorporates the 1997 original into its own story as an alternate timeline, one which the game deviates from at the end by having Zack Fair survive compared to his famous death in the original FFVII.

This stirred up plenty of discussion about the possibility of Aerith's death being undone in one of the remake's sequels, but considering that most fans realistically know they could be waiting anywhere from 3-10 years for Remake Part II - it is Square Enix after all - it truly is an ending as frustrating as it is fascinating.


5. You're Actually The Bad Guy - Braid

Braid Princess Ending
Number None

Jonathan Blow's indie smash Braid is remembered for its ingenious puzzle design and superbly executed twist ending, which entirely subverted genre expectations while making the player feel incredibly bad about it.

Players control Tim, who spends the game searching for a princess who has been kidnapped by "a horrible and evil monster."

Except, the final level brilliantly flips the script on typical "save the princess!" tropes, as though the princess appears to be fleeing from a "monstrous" knight, the princess is actually running in reverse. Simply, she's not escaping from the knight - she's running to him and away from Tim himself.

Tim, it turns out, is the real monster, and though the precise nature of Tim's relationship with the princess is kept ambiguous, it's clear that he did something horrible to merit her fleeing from him so desperately.

You thought you were the hero, but you were the villain all along.


4. Giant Meaty Blob Outta Nowhere - Inside

inside game
Playdead

With another indie sensation comes another unforgettable troll-job of an ending. Inside is an atmospheric puzzle-platformer in which players control a young boy as he attempts to navigate a dark dystopian world and evade capture.

There's a tremendous amount of subtlety to the game's narrative and aesthetic, though this is hurled totally out of the window in the final 10 minutes of the game, where it takes a sharp left-turn into David Cronenberg-inspired body horror territory.

The boy eventually comes face-to-face with a gigantic fleshy blob known as the Huddle, with its various grabbing limbs eventually pulling the boy into its biomass, where the player is then given control of the Huddle for the game's final sequence.

Here you're tasked with escaping from the Huddle's laboratory confinement by any means necessary, smashing through windows and obliterating anyone who gets in your way, before finally rolling down a hill and coming to a stop at a sun-topped cliff edge. And like that, the game abruptly ends.

Fans have debated the exact meaning of the ending ever since, but it's safe to say that nobody expected the game to go there in its barmy final stretch.


3. All The Endings - The Stanley Parable

The Stanley Parable
Galactic Cafe

The Stanley Parable is a game which toys and tinkers with the very idea of conventional video game narrativity, and that carries through to its endings - all 19 of them.

Though many of them are unsatisfying by nature, all of them are willfully weird and intended to leave players scratching their heads.

In one ending the narrator relishes your impending demise, in another you end up going to heaven, and in another you're forced to play a mini-game where you must stop a baby and a puppy being burned to death for four hours. Yup.

Some of the endings are funny, some of the endings are annoying, but all are the peak of video game absurdism - a cosmic joke about the goal-orientated nature of the medium.


2. Pick A Colour, Any Colour - Mass Effect 3

Mass Effect 3
BioWare

BioWare clearly weren't intending to troll players with Mass Effect 3's ending, but that's exactly what they did by over-promising.

After claiming pre-release that the game's climax would factor in an entire trilogy's worth of choices in order to give players their own fluid, distinct ending, fans were infuriated to discover that the ending actually boiled down to a simple "pick a colour" trio of choices.

The expected granularity was nowhere to be seen, with players instead getting one of three pre-baked, depressingly similar endings - control the Reapers, destroy the Reapers, or merge organic and synthetic life - defined in the most on-the-nose terms by three separate colours.

The fan outcry was unprecedented at the time, with calls for BioWare to "fix" the endings proving vocal enough that they released an Extended Cut DLC which added context to each of the endings.

However, it wasn't until the release of the Citadel DLC an entire year later that many fans felt like they'd been given a truly worthy resolution to the trilogy - and even then, perhaps not.


1. Peter Molyneux Strikes Again - Curiosity: What's Inside The Cube?

Curiosity What S Inside The Cube
22cans

The curious case of Curiosity: What's Inside The Cube? is unique because it involved an ending which effectively trolled just a single player.

Curiosity was an experimental video game from the industry's most famous snake oil salesman, Peter Molyneux, a collaborative online experience where players had to tap a gigantic floating cube in order to dig through its various layers and discover what was inside the cube.

Except, the catch was that only the single player who tapped the last tile would find out what the "life-changingly amazing" contents were, and it would be up to them whether they shared it with the world or not.

In the end, Edinburgh resident Bryan Henderson was the "winner" of the game, and also decided to reveal his prize to the world. Henderson was given the ability to be the single God character in Molyneux's upcoming god game Godus, and would also receive a small portion of the game's revenue.

But in a predictable anti-climax from the famous under-deliverer Molyneux, Godus never moved beyond its Early Access release in 2013, and Henderson never received either his Godly powers or the aforementioned payout.

Henderson may have been the unfortunate victim of another over-ambitious, undercooked Molyneux game, but everyone desperate to see what Curiosity's box contained was left feeling short-changed by the outcome.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.