10 Video Game Endings Where Nothing You Did Matters
What was it all for in the end?
One of the best ways that video games can well and truly invest players in their ultimate outcome is by promising that their actions and decisions throughout the story will have an effect on the ending, ensuring they feel like an active participant rather than a mere passenger.
But sometimes video games bungle this enough that players are only left with a strange feeling of emptiness, that nothing they did throughout the game actually had much impact on the overall narrative, or really made any difference whatsoever.
It's frustrating to sit and roll credits on a game while feeling that you did little to truly cause the outcome, and perhaps even that the central characters haven't really changed at all.
Sure, this can certainly be an intentional creative choice done for dramatic effect and isn't always a flat-out mistake, but it's always going to be something that ends up heavily dividing players en masse.
While not all games absolutely need to make the player feel like they're having a direct impact on the story, these games well and truly made you feel like your presence in the world was a pure afterthought...
10. Shenmue III
Shenmue III, man, it still hurts.
Though franchise creator Yu Suzuki made it clear that the belated sequel was never intended to be the end of the story, fans nevertheless expected the ongoing narrative to gain some forward momentum.
Instead, the action-adventure threequel ended with Ryo Hazuki more-or-less in the same place he was at the end of the Shenmue II - once again chasing the coattails of his father's killer, Lan Di.
Shenmue III concludes with a "boss fight" - and we're using that term very liberally here - against Lan Di, where the player spends 30 seconds punching air as Di blocks all of their attacks, before a cutscene shows him escaping once again. The End.
For fans who'd waited almost 20 years to see some sort of story progression, this felt like a slap in the face - an almost hilariously perverse refusal to give fans what they wanted.
And given that Shenmue IV is rather unlikely to ever get made, that nothingburger of an ending stings all the more.
9. Far Cry 5
Far Cry 5's two proper endings are both so utterly defeating it's tough not to feel short-changed by the whole experience.
At the end of the game, players are given two choices - to walk away from Joseph Seed and his doomsday cult, or take them out.
If you walk away, the game ends with the player character succumbing to Seed's brainwashing, but if you decide to resist, a nuclear bomb detonates, before you end up handcuffed in Seed's bunker and forced to become his companion.
Basically, Seed comes out on top regardless - the game ends with the feeling that no matter what you did leading up to that final choice, it didn't really matter.
That doesn't invalidate all the fun you had prior to the final stretch, but it's such an arbitrary downer, and feels contradictory for a game with so much moment-to-moment freedom to end in such aggressively futile fashion.
8. Red Dead Redemption
Red Dead Redemption unforgettably climaxes with outlaw protagonist John Marston being betrayed by Bureau of Investigation agent Edgar Ross, resulting in John being shot to death by a gang of U.S. Army officers.
The game's epilogue then leaps forward three years and shifts perspective to John's son Jack, as players are tasked with tracking down and killing Ross in revenge for his father's murder.
Though it's certainly satisfying to see Ross get what was coming to him, it's also a slyly bleak outcome for Jack, who rather than see his father's fate as a warning to do literally anything else with his life, has become an outlaw not unlike his late pa.
As a commentary on how cycles of violence are perpetuated it's fantastic, but make no mistake, it seems incredibly unlikely that anything but an untimely, brutal end awaits Jack sometime in the near-future - just like his dad.
At this point as a player, you just have to ask yourself, "What was it all for?"
7. The Dark Pictures Anthology: Little Hope
It's the 2020s and we're apparently still doing the "everyone else wasn't real!" twist in horror media.
Until Dawn spin-off The Dark Pictures Anthology: Little Hope sees players take control of four college students and their professor after their bus crashes in the titular ghost town, but any suspense or intrigue the game musters over its brief play-time is immediately wiped out by that ending.
Little Hope's big twist is that one of the four students, Andrew (Will Poulter), is actually Anthony, the bus driver. Anthony hallucinated the entire story after inadvertently detouring into Little Hope - the very town where, as a youngster, he survived a traumatic house fire which killed the rest of his family.
It's one of those "Really?" endings which completely undermines any sense of player agency or control, because if most of the characters we're playing as aren't even real, why should we care if they live or die?
6. Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain
Metal Gear Solid fans remain staunchly divided on whether the fifth game's final twist is a genuine subversion of expectations of a massive kick in the digital knackers.
No, it's definitely the latter.
After spending dozens of hours playing through the story and toiling away to unlock the true ending, you'll learn that while you believed yourself to be playing as Big Boss for the entire game, that's actually not true.
The ending reveals that we've actually been playing as a Big Boss doppelganger the whole time - a combat medic injured in the helicopter explosion at the end of prologue game Metal Gear Solid V: Ground Zeroes.
While comatose, the medic was transformed into a Big Boss decoy through plastic surgery and hypnotherapy in order to divert attention away from the real Big Boss.
Given that Metal Gear Solid V was marketed as the game which would depict Big Boss' descent into villainy, for Hideo Kojima to pull the rug out with a "gotcha!" that made most of the game feel largely irrelevant to the series' lore was massively infuriating.
5. Mass Effect 3
There's arguably been no video game ending more vitriolically received than that of Mass Effect 3, for while the bulk of the game is a damn fun time, BioWare well and truly fumbled the ball at the finish line.
Despite promising fans pre-release that the game's ending would take their collective decisions made throughout the trilogy into account, it ultimately boiled down to three colour-coded choices - A, B, or C.
After spending dozens, even hundreds of hours in the Mass Effect world and being promised a climax which would feel personal to each player's specific journey, limiting it to three fixed, frustratingly similar choices unsurprisingly left fans feeling hugely short-changed.
It felt like nothing - or at least, very little - that players did throughout the three games really had that much bearing on the outcome, and so, what was it all really for?
The backlash was ferocious enough that BioWare later expanded upon the endings with a DLC update, yet this did little to remedy the fact that, structurally speaking, the game's endings weren't sufficiently informed by the player's specific experience.
4. Prey (2017)
While it'd be slightly unfair to say that Prey's ending is nothing more than "It was all a dream!," it's certainly close enough to that worn-out trope to leave many players feeling a tad underwhelmed.
In the game's post-credits scene, protagonist Morgan wakes up to learn that the events of the entire game were a simulation and we haven't even been playing as Morgan, but rather a captured Typhon implanted with the real Morgan's memories, in an attempt to teach the alien creature human empathy.
As Morgan's brother Alex informs you, the Typhon have invaded Earth, after which Alex and his colleagues judge your performance throughout the game.
If you failed to demonstrate empathy, you'll be killed, but if you're deemed empathetic, you'll be given a choice - kill everyone, or forge an alliance between the humans and the Typhon.
It's definitely a bold and provocative idea, yet it's tough to blame players for feeling miffed that the entirety of the game wasn't actually happening while they were playing through it.
Plus, with Prey flopping commercially, we never got to see the payoff in a sequel. What a waste.
3. Telltale's Game Of Thrones
While Telltale Games' interactive episodic stories are concerned with player choice, it's fair to say that the choices are for the most part relatively inconsequential in the scope of the overall story.
And that's perhaps no true than in Telltale's Game of Thrones, because while you can certainly take a different route to the ending, the ultimate outcome is basically the same no matter what - there's no way to win the final battle, House Forrester gets overthrown, and the majority of the same characters will end up dead.
While it's arguably a fittingly bleak result for a video game based on an IP known for laughing at the very concept of plot armour, in a game supposedly sold on the notion of player choice, it can't help but sting that players are unable to affect a more fortuitous fate for the Forresters.
By the end only a feeling of emptiness remains, firm in the knowledge that nothing could be done to stop the inevitable.
2. Suicide Squad: Kill The Justice League
It's rather appropriate that a game as crushingly disappointing as Suicide Squad: Kill The Justice League arrives at an ending that makes it all feel bloody pointless.
Though the final boss is iconic alien interloper Brainiac, we learn near the end of the game that Brainiac has been working with a dozen other Brainiacs from different dimensions who are combining their might to take over the entire multiverse.
Basically, you're gonna have to do this nonsense another dozen times to actually save the world - a rather transparent attempt to justify the game's live service gameplay loop, with the other Brainiacs being introduced to players through future seasonal DLC drops.
The second Brainiac was featured in the recent Season of the Joker DLC, but given the game's poor critical and commercial reception so far, it'd be a massive surprise if Rocksteady actually supports it long enough to give players all 13 Brainiacs as planned.
1. Life Is Strange
Life Is Strange is a wonderful game with a polarising-ass ending, as after spending basically the entire game rewinding time at will, the ending sees protagonist Max forced to make a binary, inescapable choice - either rewind time and allow her best pal Chloe to be killed, in turn preventing a storm from annihilating Arcadia Bay (because reasons), or do nothing and let the storm roll through town.
For many, it felt like a frustratingly contrived attempt to rustle up an agonising moral dilemma, and though the overarching message was that Max ultimately couldn't fight fate, suddenly snatching the player's reality-warping abilities away and shoving them down a two-choice corridor left many hugely disappointed.
No matter how you play the game up to that point, it always comes down to "Chloe or Arcadia Bay?," ensuring that for a game seemingly about the notion of player choice, it's really about the illusion of player choice, for better or worse.