10 Video Game Franchises That Keep Making The Same Mistake

Every Resident Evil goes off the rails at the end.

Resident evil ending
Capcom

The definition of insanity is said to be doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result, in which case these video game franchises are categorically nutso.

As a fan of any video game series, it's frustrating to see it repeat mistakes the fanbase has been calling out for years.

From a simple lack of quality-testing to infuriating storytelling, tonal issues, and everything in-between, these franchises fall at the same hurdle every. damn. time.

While most of these games remain critical and commercial successes no matter their nagging issues, it's safe to say that many fans are crying out for an overhaul, for these long-nagging issues to finally be rectified.

In some cases a fix may apparently be in the works, while in others it's clear the developers just don't really have any idea how to solve it, in which case an injection of fresh creative blood is most certainly needed.

No video game series is perfect, but when you screw something up this many times in a row, it's maddening for those players who continue to support the IP no matter what...

10. Not Enough Bug-Testing - WWE 2K

WWE 2K20
2K Games

Wrestling fans craving a genuinely good WWE game sure have been put through the wringer over the years, with the quality of the WWE 2K franchise ranging from good-but-flawed to, in the case of the recent WWE 2K20, genuinely terrible.

Whether good or bad, though, every single game in the WWE 2K series shares one glaring issue: those damn, dirty glitches.

Like clockwork every single year, fans complain about the baffling over-abundance of bugs in the latest WWE 2K release, to such an extent that it seems as though the games have received scarcely any quality-testing whatsoever.

Things have gotten bad enough that many have resolved to basically hate-playing the games each year and actively trying to discover as many glitches as possible, treating them like perverse gotta-catch-'em-all collectibles.

Within hours of any WWE 2K game releasing, social media is rife with hilariously embarrassing, physics-defying bugs, the majority of which aren't ever ironed out by patches.

This reached a painful apex with WWE 2K20, which proved so bug-laden that #FixWWE2K20 began trending, and the planned follow-up WWE 2K21 was cancelled.

Though 2K are set to return with WWE 2K22 by year's end, you'd be foolish to assume that the extra year of development, in the middle of a pandemic no less, will see the series rejuvenated.

Expect nothing and wait for reviews.


9. The Painfully Convoluted Storytelling - Kingdom Hearts

Kingdom Hearts 3 Sora
Square Enix

As fun as Kingdom Hearts is, you won't find a video game franchise with more convoluted storytelling or wilfully obtuse lore.

The hit Disney-themed RPG series boasts charming characters, gorgeous worlds, addictive combat, and... a dense, anime-aping hodgepodge of overwrought, expository plotting that's practically impenetrable for all but the most committed fans.

The battle between light and dark may be the spine of Kingdom Hearts' story, but the series as a whole is so bogged down in overly verbose proper noun nonsense that, for casual players it's actually pretty damn dull to drink in.

It's enough of a mess to somehow make Metal Gear Solid's story seem positively easy-to-follow, and while the die-hards will insist it's really not that much of a chore to understand, it's a classic case of a creator mistaking convolution for complexity.

There are certainly times where Kingdom Hearts achieves a charm offensive of absurdity, but too often the story feels like it's a time-wasting encroachment upon the first-rate gameplay.

Jim Sterling made a rather persuasive video detailing just how utterly incoherent Kingdom Hearts' narrative is:


8. The Wildly Inconsistent Tone - Watch Dogs

Watch Dogs Legion
Ubisoft

On paper, the premise of Watch Dogs should make for a spectacular video game: hack the tech-saturated world around you for your own gain, to make the world a better place, and to bring down authoritarian forces seeking to control the populace.

Yet across its three games to date, Watch Dogs has demonstrated a flabbergasting lack of tonal assurance, such that it's tough to know who these games are really made for.

The first game was a gritty, self-serious tech-thriller, but because neither the melodramatic story nor the dull characters connected with players, Ubisoft felt that a lighter touch was needed for the sequel.

And so, Watch Dogs 2 was a more colourful, free-wheeling affair, which is all well and good save for the fact that the player is free to kill and horribly maim people, which is more-or-less shrugged off without a second thought.

Last year's Watch Dogs: Legion then attempted to forge a compromise of the two games, by tackling weighty political themes - despite Ubisoft still claiming they don't make political games - but also allowing you to play as a super-spy pensioner.

The two moods clashed pretty harshly and Legion ended up the worst-reviewed game of the trilogy. It speaks to the series' wider identity crisis, that it needs to just settle on a vibe and stick to it - serious and dark is fine if the writing is even remotely interesting.


7. Failing To Successfully Innovate - Sonic The Hedgehog

Sonic Mania
Sega

There's perhaps no single video game franchise more infuriating than Sonic the Hedgehog.

Despite its immense popularity and status as one of the most iconic platformers of all time, the series has categorically failed to substantially innovate itself for new generations of gamers.

While Mario impressively maintained relevance during the potentially awkward switchover to 3D, Sonic has stumbled through mistake after mistake, with only the occasional success in-between.

It's incredibly telling that Sonic Mania, the best-reviewed Sonic game in a quarter-century, was effectively an homage sequel remixing Sonic's greatest hits, because Sega knows just how catastrophically their attempts to genuinely reinvent the franchise have failed.

Massively high-profile embarrassments like 2006's Sonic the Hedgehog and Sonic Boom: Rise Of Lyric prove the lack of a compelling creative vision for the series, and so it's far more likely we'll simply get more nostalgia-laced retro homages in the future.


6. Too Much Busywork - Assassin's Creed

Assassin's Creed valhalla
Ubisoft

It's impossible to argue with the success of the Assassin's Creed franchise, which over the last 14 years has released a dozen mainline games and near-countless additional spin-offs.

The stealth-based action-adventure gameplay clearly works, though the series' transformation into an out-and-out RPG in recent years has only ramped up the array of tedious busy-work on offer.

To varying degrees, the last few Creed games have relished flooding the map with icons that are, frankly, exhausting to look at, let alone follow-up.

It is open-world fatigue in a nutshell, and though the recent Assassin's Creed Valhalla offered up a more streamlined map system, the game itself was still jam-packed with repetitive missions in a stamina-sappingly overlong campaign.

Everything in these games is designed to keep you playing for longer and be forever jacked in to the Assassin's Creed ecosystem, even if so much of it is a bloat-filled chore.

But the reliable predictability of the game's Content may well explain why the series continues to sell so well - when games cost up to £70 nowadays, people want to know what they're getting and that it'll last them a damn long time.

Quality and diversity, though, often seem to be secondary concerns.


5. "Bethesda Jank" - Fallout & The Elder Scrolls

Fallout 76
Bethesda

The Fallout and Elder Scrolls franchises are phenomenally successful despite the fact they both share one glaring flaw: that damn Bethesda jank.

Since the release of Skyrim in 2011, Bethesda has been using the Creation Engine for their games, which is based on their prior Gamebryo engine, the jank-infused DNA of which still haunts the publisher's AAA RPGs.

Random physics-based glitches are commonplace in Skyrim and Fallout 4 in particular, yet because the game worlds are so mind-bogglingly large and well-realised, many fans seem content to put up with it.

It's no excuse, though, that one of the most decorated gaming publishers in the world can't deliver more stable and polished experiences, no matter the complexity.

Though Bethesda's Todd Howard has stated that the Creation Engine has undergone a massive overhaul for both the upcoming Starfield and The Elder Scrolls VI, you'd be daft to expect a smooth, glitch-free experience from either.

When the money keeps pouring in regardless of the egregious bugs - some of which fans have ultimately endeavoured to fix themselves - there's probably not much incentive to devote many resources to ironing everything out.


4. The Bloated, Padded Gameplay - Final Fantasy

Final Fantasy 7 Remake
Square Enix

Nobody goes into a Final Fantasy game expecting a brisk 8-10-hour romp you can get through over a relaxing weekend - even sticking to the critical path, most of these games will clock in at at least 25-30 hours.

Even so, as of late Square Enix has dropped any pretence of trying to hide the blatant, egregious padding that runs rife throughout the series.

Final Fantasy XV had the infamous late-game Chapter 13 debacle, where players were largely stripped of their weapons and forced through a dull, labyrinthine, stealth-centric slog.

Though Square Enix released a patch to lighten the load after vocal fan outcry, that didn't deter them from repeating their crime in Final Fantasy VII Remake, distending Hojo's Lab out into an exhaustingly boring mess of repetitive combat and switch-throwing. Yawn.

These games are long enough already, they really don't need added "value" piled on top. There is nothing wrong with a 20-hour critical path while saving all the bloated nonsense for optional side content.


3. Low-Effort, On-Rails Campaigns - Call Of Duty

Call of Duty Ghosts
Activision

Since the release of Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare back in 2007, multiplayer has been the bread and butter of the hit FPS franchise, while the single-player offerings have taken a bit of a backseat.

Though Modern Warfare's short-but-sweet campaign was a revelation for its time, over the last near-15 years the series has done precious little to innovate.

Sure, the franchise has introduced branching narratives and increasingly surreal - and some might say, ill-advised - divergences into sci-fi territory over the years, but the core "follow the objective" gameplay has largely remained untouched since inception.

While the campaigns are more-or-less treated as half-hearted extra features these days - hell, 2018's Black Ops 4 didn't even have one at all - it sure would be nice to see an upcoming CoD game actually try and deliver a unique, envelope-pushing single-player experience.


2. A Terrible Final Act - Resident Evil

Resident Evil 7 Eveline
Capcom

With the release of every new Resident Evil game, fans brace to find out whether or not it craps all over itself in the final hour or two, and lo and behold, it almost certainly does.

Since the series' early days, the overwhelming majority of the Resident Evil games have saved the worst for last, most notably Resident Evil 4's island, Resident Evil 5's ridiculous volcano, and Resident Evil 7's tanker-mines combo.

Without going into spoilers, it's safe to say that Resident Evil Village doesn't much buck the trend, holding back the most boring locale and silliest boss fight for its final area.

Part of the problem might be that, by the end of any Resident Evil game, the fear has begun to wear off and the player is more often than not capably kitted-up to take on whatever is thrown at them.

Even so, there are very few games in the series which manage to sustain a skin-crawling atmosphere all the way to the finish line. Too often, they give in to absurd action schlock.


1. The Dated Save System - Yakuza

Yakuza: Like A Dragon
Sega

The Yakuza franchise is at peak popularity right now, with Like a Dragon's shift to turned-based RPG gameplay going over gangbusters with fans and newbies alike.

Despite this agreeable innovation, there's one aspect of the Yakuza series that still feels painfully stuck in the past: the save system.

Many fans have decried the lack of autosave in prior games in the series, requiring them to manually save their progress, a bizarrely archaic process which in Yakuza 0 and Yakuza Kiwami sees the game save twice in a row (once for save data, once for system data).

Though the more recent games have streamlined saving somewhat, Like a Dragon still features a number of lengthy sections without autosave being offered to players.

This is most egregious in the game's dungeons, which depending on your build and play-style can easily result in you having no means to save for up to an hour and between numerous tough battles.

Getting KO'd and having to slog through it all again sure isn't fun, even with skipped cutscenes cutting down on the repetition. All in all it just encourages players to over-level and make sure they breeze their way through every fight.

The series needs to allow saving anywhere, anytime.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.