10 Video Game Heroes That Accidentally Doomed Everyone

Way to go and break it, 'hero.'

lollipop chainsaw
Grasshopper Manufacture

Everybody wants to be a hero. You need only look at the success of the Marvel Cinematic Universe to see that a world where noble, selfless, and morally upright individuals hand the forces of evil the ultimate beat-down is one we all wished we lived in.

However, there’s a bit of a rose-tinted glasses thing going on here, because heroes don’t always makes things better.

Sometimes the hero is misinformed, find themselves matched against a villain just a smidge smarter, or is burdened by heart just a little too big, and what seemed to be right the decision suddenly turns out to be wrong, with disastrous consequences. It’s a rude dose of reality and proof that no one is perfect.

As players, being in control of the ‘hero,’ this can leave you feeling a proper fool...or volcanically angry that the numbskull you’re playing as didn’t see the blindingly obvious warning signs blazing at them for the past three hours.

Either way, you won’t quickly forget it. As for the poor saps responsible? Well, they’ve got ‘Nice job breaking it’ permanently inked into their CV, especially these ten, who took the heroic faux pas to a level no one ever wanted it to be at.

Warning: Major spoilers ahead!

10. The Saints - Saints Row IV

Saints Row 4 Zinyak
Deep Silver

Few science fiction stories would have the guts to blow up the Earth. But this is Saints Row IV, a game that opens with a man riding a nuclear missile half way to orbit, only to literally crash land into the Oval Office and become president of the United States. Suffice to say, nothing is sacred.

When the evil Zin empire, lead by suave connoisseur of literature, Zinyak, invades Earth he traps the Saints in a simulation with the stern warning that any attempt at escape will result in the Earth’s destruction. As any self-respecting hero – and player – would do, they call the obvious bluff and get to escaping anyway.

Except... Zinyak wasn’t bluffing, leaving the shocked Saints staring at the horrifying spectre of Earth blown to smithereens, along with every single person not yet abducted by the Zin. Worse, while a loophole does allow the Saints to go back in time and see Earth again, their Earth is permanently fried.

On the plus side, with Zinyak defeated they become rulers of the most advanced intergalactic empire in existence. So, it could be worse? Maybe? Possibly? Probably not.


9. Juliet Starling - Lollipop Chainsaw

Lollipop Chainsaw
Grasshopper Manufacture

Juliet Starling is not the sharpest tool in the shed, but when you’re a badass teenage zombie-slaying superhero rocking a chainsaw and magic, smarts might not seem all that important.

So when a deranged Goth takes revenge for the years of bullying and neglect by initiating an extra-dimensional zombie invasion, thus and dooming the entire world to zombie apocalypse, Juliet does what she does best, slaughter zombies in style.

Players, however, would have noticed something ominous.

Juliet must kill five Dark Purveyors in order to prevent the apocalypse. Thing is, the summoning of said Purveyors only happens when the ‘pawn’ arrives, and Juliet just happens to be freshly arrived on the scene. Our hero, bless her heart, never apparently realizes that she is the pawn.

It’s only when all five purveyors are dead and the goth proceeds to blow his own head off to complete the ritual that the penny drops.

Cue a skycraper-sized zombie of all zombies rampaging through town.

In all fairness her quick thinking saves her boyfriend, which turns out to be crucial. But overall? Less lollipops there Juliet, more hitting the books.


8. Guybrush Threepwood - The Secret Of Monkey Island

Secret Of Monkey Island Special Edition
LucasArts

Saving the damsel in distress is a well-established literary trope, one that The Secret of Monkey Island hilariously subverts by having the damsel save herself, only for the heroic manly man to completely mess things up.

When hero Guybrush Threepwood learns that his love interest, governor Elaine Marley, has been captured by the villainous undead pirate LeChuck, and that LeChuck – also smitten with Marley – intends to forcibly marry her, he naturally rushes to the rescue.

Arriving in the nick of time to object he is surprised to find that Elaine has already freed herself, and not only that, she has laid a trap for LeChuck in the form of a doppelgänger composed of two monkeys in a wedding dress, ready to spray LeChuck in the face with deadly root beer.

But Threepwood’s arrival foils the plan, leading to a lecture from Marley and a furious LeChuck beating him all across the island, a beat-down that only ends when the hopelessly incompetent ‘hero’ remembers that he has root beer of his own.

Threepwood gets the girl in the end. An ideal conclusion because any future heroics are best left in her far more capable hands.


7. The Hero Of Tristram - Diablo

Diablo II
Blizzard

As far as villains go they don’t come much bigger than the devil himself, and big damn villains need big damn heroes to take them down. Ideally, though, you need big damn smart heroes, and when it comes to the hero of Diablo, smart they are not.

When Diablo’s plot to gain dominion over the mortal realm was foiled, he was imprisoned within a soulstone and buried (by another band of dumb as doorknob heroes) deep beneath the village of Tristram. Naturally, death, demonic possession and bloody mayhem ensued.

Equally naturally, heroes answered to the call to sort out the mess, duly carving their way through the evil throng, dungeon by dungeon and monster by monster, eventually entering Hell, throwing down with Diablo face-to-face and destroying his mortal form.

So far, so good.

Then, in one of the most monumentally stupid decisions in the history of gaming, the hero, in a fit of righteous, ‘self-sacrificial’ heroism, jams the prison of a Prime Evil into their own forehead, in the vain belief they can contain this evil.

The fact that we have a Diablo II and III shows how well that decision turned out...


6. Chell - Portal 2

Portal 2 Chell
Valve

Portal’s villain GLADOS and protagonist Chell have quite the history: the murderous cake-loving, hilariously snarky AI used Chell as a human lab rat before trying to incinerate her alive, a trap Chell barely escaped before returning the favour and dismantling GLADOS piece by piece.

Come Portal 2 Chell finds herself once more imprisoned in the Aperture Science facility, where she is awoken from stasis by lovable moron Wheatley. Accidentally awakening a furious GLADOS, Chell is summarily forced back into being a test subject.

Wheatley responds with a plan to defeat GLADOS by replacing her – with himself.

The problem is, as GLADOS herself puts it: ‘He's not just a regular moron, he's the product of the greatest minds of a generation working together with the express purpose of building the dumbest moron who ever lived.’ And when that moron promptly goes insane with power, his infinite incompetence threatens to destroy the facility and kill all three of them.

Ironically, GLADOS is the key to fixing Chell’s mess and the two of them end up an unlikely heroic duo. Not that GLADOS deigns to keep Chell around, expelling her from the facility before the ‘hero’ can break anything else.


5. The Lone Wanderer - Fallout 3

Dogmeat Lone Wanderer
Bethesda Softworks

The Fallout series has always been known for its murky morality, so it should come as no surprise that when a quest gives you the option of doing something unambiguously good, there’s good reason to be suspicious.

Arriving at the luxurious Tenpenny Tower, the protagonist the Lone Wanderer finds ghoul Roy Phillips insisting that he and his gang be allowed to move in. Money isn’t the problem, as has Roy plenty of it. No, instead the racist human residents are less than thrilled at the idea of ghoul neighbours, leaving the door firmly shut in Roy’s face.

The player has a number of options, from simply killing the residents, to dealing with the residents’ pest problem by exterminating the ghouls. But you can also take the long, arduous high road by negotiating a truce between the two sides, allowing the ghouls to move in and live peacefully alongside the humans.

But this is Fallout, not Care Bears. The peace holds, for a while. Then the Wanderer returns only to find the humans slaughtered, victims of a disagreement that led Roy to, as he put it, ‘take out the trash.’

No good deed, it seems, goes unpunished.


4. Captain Titus - Warhammer 40,000: Space Marine

Warhmammer Space Marine
THQ

In Warhammer 40K Space Marines are the best of the best, the Emperor of Mankind’s elite, so when Forge World Graia comes under Ork attack only those able to do the impossible are up to the task.

Fighting through the hordes of Orks, the unconventional, and unusually compassionate (for a Space Marine), Captain Titus encounters the shady Inquisitor Drogan, who tells him of a weapon that could destroy all of the invading Orks.

Or blow up the planet should the less-than-intelligent Orks tamper with it.

Ever the loyal soldier of the Emperor Titus fights his way through legions of Orks and escorts Drogan to his secret facility.

But that is about all that goes right, because as it turns out Dragon that was a sorcerous puppet already days dead, and instead of wiping out the Orks the weapon tears open a portal to the demonic Warp, ushering in an invasion of Chaos Daemons and corrupted Space Marines led by a Chaos sorceror hell bent on ascending to become a Daemon Prince.

Luckily for Titus he’s a beast, and luckily for players fighting the forces of Chaos is brilliant fun. So we’ll forgive him this time.


3. Edge Maverick - Star Ocean: The Last Hope

Star Ocean Till The End Of Time
Tri-Ace

If there’s one thing that is every hero’s Kryptonite it’s the soppy story: all the villain need do is turn on the tears, spin a pitiful yarn, and even the most cynical do-gooder is honour bound to believe them.

And we all know what happens next.

Such is precisely what befalls Star Ocean hero, Edge Maverick. Finding himself stranded on Earth circa 1957 he and his party are captured by scientists guilty of imprisoning – and experimenting on – alien refugees. Busting out of jail they are stopped by head scientist Milla Bachtein, who then proceeds to spin an absolute master class of a soppy story.

See, Edge comes from a future where the Earth was devastated by nuclear war. Milla correctly deduces that his civilization overcame their dependence on nuclear energy by developing a clean energy source, one that should Edge help her she could replicate, preventing the need for nuclear weapons and thus the apocalypse.

Edge falls for it hook, line and sinker, and promptly finds himself stuck in a cell, watching as the deranged lunatic integrates the new source into a nuclear reactor with predictably catastrophic results. Edge and party escape, but not before the Earth is destroyed.

Suffice to say, Edge’s conscience is a long time recovering.


2. Gordon Freeman - Half-Life Series

Gordon Freeman Half Life 2
Valve

Gordon Freeman. Hero of the Black Mesa incident. The opener of the way. The one free man. With titles like that how can you not be a hero? But for all his heroic deeds Gordon does seem to have a terrible habit of making things worse.

In Half-Life Gordon successfully defeats the Nihilanth, the creature directing the alien invasion of Black Mesa. But in slaying so powerful a foe he also attracts the attention of the Combine, an intergalactic empire that proceeds to conquer Earth in only seven hours.

In Half-Life 2 he successfully foils the escape of the pretentious, self-serving sell-out of humanity, Wallace Breen. But doing so leads to the destruction of the Citadel – the Combine’s seat of power on Earth. With it comes the creation of yet another Combine super portal and the threat of a second even more devastating invasion.

Gordon eventually seals the portal, but with humanity’s forces still pitifully weak and a key resistance leader dead it was a pyrrhic victory at best.

To be fair, Gordon is doing his best, but perhaps it would be better if someone else took up the hero’s mantle?

Barney, old mate, it’s your time to shine.


1. The Nerevarine - The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind

ES3: Morrowind Dagoth Ur
Bethesda Softworks

Over the course of The Elder Scrolls: Morrowind the protagonist, the Nerevarine, completes a series of tasks to prove themselves the prophesied hero who would bring down the evil Dagoth Ur. And being a prophesied hero they naturally succeed, destroying the Heart or Lorkhan, the source of Dagoth Ur’s power, and ending his plot to take over the world.

There’s just one teeny, tiny, sticking point here: the Heart of Lorkhan was also what gave the gods of Morrowind, the Tribunal, their power, power that was the only means of preventing a rogue moon from slamming into the planet’s surface.

The result? The destruction of Morrowind’s capital city and a massive volcanic eruption that covers the entire region in choking ash, killing thousands and displacing thousands more.

As if that weren't enough, the destruction of the Heart of Lorkhan may also have triggered the demonic invasion that formed the basis for The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion, which in turn became the basis of the Skyrim civil war in The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim.

So yes, if you’ve played all three, you’ve been cleaning up your own mess for two whole games.

No wonder the Nerevarine has not been seen since.


Watch Next


Contributor

Marcellus Huisamen hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.