10 Video Game Heroes That Got Everyone Killed

Lara Croft's plundering had disastrous consequences in Shadow of the Tomb Raider.

God of War 3
Sony

Heroism can be defined many ways, but typically it involves bravely saving the day with little concern for one's own wellbeing, and above all else just straight-up not killing the good guys, right?

In which case, these celebrated video game heroes all stretched the definition of "hero" to breaking point given that their actions ultimately led to a basically genocidal level of death.

Though these heroes all had good intentions one way or another, their acts largely ended up condemning thousands or even millions of regular, harmless folk to brutal deaths - a fact some of these games would perhaps prefer you didn't think about too much.

Even with some of these protagonists having more ambiguous, nebulous takes on heroism than others, it's still shocking just how much blood they ultimately have on their hands, whether in the name of the greater good or simply because they screwed everything up.

One thing's for sure, if you call yourself a hero you should absolutely avoid killing off the population of a large city while going about manoeuvres. In some cases the heroes paid the price for their carelessness, while in others they basically got away with it scot-free...

10. Joel - The Last Of Us

The Last Of Us Joel Ending
Naughty Dog

The ending to The Last of Us is one of the most brilliantly polarising in video game history, as protagonist Joel decides to shoot his way through a Firefly hospital in order to rescue Ellie, who was being prepped for experimental surgery.

With Ellie being immune, the Fireflies' hope was that removing her infected brain would allow them to synthesise a cure, but with there being no guarantee of success, Joel instead decided to retrieve Ellie and slay anyone who got in his way.

To make matters worse, he then lied to Ellie about what happened, insisting that the Fireflies found other immune people to experiment upon, and that their attempts to create a cure failed. Ouch.

While there's indeed no guarantee that the Fireflies' experiment would've created a cure, it was certainly possible, and so by saving Ellie - effectively his surrogate daughter at this point - Joel may well have selfishly doomed humanity.

What we know for sure, though, is that Joel's climactic rampage teed up his own demise, as in The Last of Us Part II he gets brutally murdered by Abby, the daughter of the doctor he shot at the end of the first game while escaping.

Joel's actions are absolutely understandable on a human level, but that doesn't mean they weren't overpoweringly self-serving in obliterating a potential cure.


9. Kratos - God Of War

God Of War 2005 Kratos
SCE Santa Monica

With God of War's Kratos, we're clearly using the term "hero" pretty loosely here, because in his original iteration he's really a tragically doomed anti-hero at best, if not a straight-up mass murderer.

In the original game, Kratos made a deal with the God of War, Ares, to serve under him in exchange for sparing his life during battle and granting him god-like powers.

Kratos was then tricked into killing his own wife and daughter, and it's also made clear that he killed a lot of people while serving Ares prior to this. He even tellingly says, "I killed many who were deserving, and many who were not."

From here, Kratos ends up slaughtering over two-dozen gods - including Ares - throughout the series.

In many cases this caused an untold amount of indirect death, such as when he killed Poseidon and flooded the Mediterranean, murdered Helios and plunged Greece into darkness, and unleashed a plague by slaughtering Hermes.

Had Kratos stopped after killing Ares, perhaps we'd be more willing to go easy on him as the pawn of a god, but the guy just didn't know when to quit.


8. Venom Snake - Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain

Metal Gear Solid V Venom Snake
Konami

Metal Gear Solid V's first Africa-set mission sees Venom Snake sabotaging Mfinda Oilfield, which has been polluting the local water supply with oil and preventing the nearby villagers from drinking it.

Yet later in the game, we learn that oil was being intentionally leaked into the local water, because said water was contaminated with XOF's vocal cord parasites, which would ultimately kill anyone who drank the water and became infected.

Skull Face used the area as a test for the Kikongo variant of the parasite, and so when Snake stopped the oil leak, the locals were again able to consume the water.

This caused the Kikongo infection to spread throughout the area and eventually reach Snake's HQ Mother Base, where he was forced to execute any of his own soldiers infected with the parasite in order to prevent it from spreading to the wider world.

Snake clearly had the best of intentions when he went to shut down the oilfield, but in turn he inadvertently got a lot of people killed, and almost caused a global catastrophe.


7. Alex Mercer - Prototype

prototype game
Radical

Prototype pits the player as Alex Mercer, an amnesiac who wakes up in a lab and soon discovers that he has an array of awesome mutant powers, such as super-strength, super-speed, and the ability to consume anyone to obtain their memories and appearance. Neato.

The game primarily revolves around Alex's quest to figure out his past and stop an outbreak of the Blacklight virus, which transforms the infected into grotesque monsters.

We eventually learn that the outbreak was actually caused by Alex himself, who due to his research getting shuttered and a hit being ordered on his life, smashed a vial of Blacklight at Penn Station, spreading it throughout the borough and infecting himself with it also, causing his "superhero" transformation.

The huge loss of life that Alex's act causes speaks for itself, transforming a massive number of Manhattan's 1.5 million residents into hideous creatures.

Intriguingly, Prototype 2 actually leans fully into the impact of Alex's actions, recasting him as the villain pursued by a new hero, James Heller, whose family was killed by the Blacklight outbreak.


6. Private Joseph Allen - Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2

Call of Duty Modern Warfare 2 No Russian
Activision

Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2's controversial "No Russian" mission sees Private First Class Joseph Allen going undercover with terrorist Vladimir Makarov, as they prepare to carry out a mass shooting at a Moscow airport.

Though players don't have to shoot any civilians themselves - and, in fact, the entire mission is skippable - you do have to walk through the airport while your "comrades" slaughter dozens and dozens of innocent people.

But the rub comes at the end of the mission, when Makarov reveals that he knows Allen is working undercover and promptly shoots him dead.

More to the point, Makarov leaves Allen's corpse at the airport, thereby implicating the U.S. in the airport attack and effectively kickstarting World War III.

Now, Allen can't be entirely blamed for this admittedly - it was of course Makarov's plan to execute a false flag operation which framed him, but even so, by being in the wrong place at the wrong time, his death and the discovery of his body set in motion a global conflict which killed tens of millions.


5. Nathan Drake - Uncharted

Uncharted 4 A Thief's End
Naughty Dog

How many lives do you think could've been saved if Nathan Drake just... stayed home throughout the Uncharted franchise? In the first three games alone, IGN suggested his body count totalled at least 1,829.

Basically if you're not a close personal friend or family member of Nate's, you're fair game to be shot or blown up by the intrepid treasure hunter should you prove to be the faintest obstacle to his precious loot.

The over-the-odds bloodthirstiness of Uncharted's protagonist is especially odd given Nate's charming, roguish persona, enough that the series is often cited as a textbook example of "ludonarrative dissonance" - a disconnect between gameplay and story - in video games.

Hilariously, Uncharted 4: A Thief's End even includes a trophy entitled "Ludonarrative Dissonance," which is unlocked by killing 1,000 enemies.

You have to respect Naughty Dog's willingness to poke fun at themselves, even if Nate's penchant for ultra-violence remains a puzzling aspect of the franchise for many.


4. Commander Shepard - Mass Effect 3

Mass Effect 3 Shepard
BioWare

Mass Effect 3's "Destroy" ending - typically the one accepted to be canon - involves Commander Shepard destroying the mass relays, the ancient machines which facilitate faster-than-light travel.

And by destroying the relays, Shepard ensures that the alien races fighting the Reapers in Sol - that's Earth's solar system - are now effectively stranded there.

It goes without saying that the many alien species stuck on Earth wouldn't be much happy about that, especially those which require specific nutrients in order to survive.

Beyond that, most species wouldn't live long enough to make the arduous journey home using their own faster-than-light drives, nor have the fuel to get there in the first place.

Combine all this with the relative scarcity of resources on Earth and Shepard's destruction of the mass relays would almost certainly result in massive conflicts and death on and around Earth. Well done, Shep.


3. Cole McGrath - Infamous 2

Infamous 2 Cole Ending
Sony

Whichever ending you choose in Infamous 2, protagonist Cole McGarth ends up getting an insane number of people killed.

The game's "good" ending sees Cole deciding to activate the Ray Field Inhibitor, which kills the overwhelming majority of the living superhumans aka Conduits, including Cole himself. Though no precise body count has ever been given, this could theoretically number in the tens of millions.

The "evil" ending is on a whole other level, though, with Cole betraying humanity and preparing to build a Conduit haven on Earth. Cole activates dormant Conduits while a plague spreads that will kill off most non-Conduits, likely causing billions of deaths in the long run.

Sequel Infamous: Second Son later confirmed the good ending to be canon - yet sneakily retconned the survival of some of the Conduits in the process - but even this sunnier finale still results in our hero meting out a ton of death and dying himself (albeit reluctantly and arguably for the greater good).


2. Lara Croft - Shadow Of The Tomb Raider

Shadow of the Tomb Raider
Crystal Dynamics

The Tomb Raider reboot trilogy certainly attempted to reckon with Lara Croft's ultra-violent, mass-murdering ways, while Shadow of the Tomb Raider trained its focus on Lara's problematic stature as a globe-trotting "treasure hunter" who, let's be honest, steals shiny s**t from ancient civilisations.

This is broached early in the game when Lara locates the Dagger of Chak Chel, and despite nearby murals warning of apocalyptic events, she takes the dagger anyway, under the flimsy justification of stopping paramilitary outfit Trinity from grabbing it first.

However, this act of pilfering ends up triggering an event called the Cleansing, whereby a gigantic tsunami floods the Mexican island of Cozumel, causing an innumerable amount of damage and lost life, including a young boy who perishes before Lara's very eyes.

The game is very much concerned with Lara's journey to atone for her actions, which predictably descends into a typical white saviour narrative in which she kills many, many more people in the quest for "redemption."

As Wired's review so brilliantly put it, "Hundreds of people die in this game to teach Lara Croft a lesson in humility."

We know that Crystal Dynamics is currently working on a fourth entry into their reboot franchise, and so it'll be interesting to see how they reconcile Lara's troubling past - both her rampant theft and the massive pile of bodies she left in her wake at the end of the last game.


1. Captain Martin Walker - Spec-Ops: The Line

Spec ops the line
2K Games

Spec-Ops: The Line's protagonist Captain Martin Walker is the living embodiment of the phrase "the road to hell is paved with good intentions."

Walker heads to a storm-wrecked, war-torn Dubai as part of a covert three-man team intending to help rescue stranded refugees and eliminate a rogue, PTSD-riddled U.S. Army Colonel, John Konrad, causing chaos in the region.

But things quickly go from bad to worse, when Walker authorises a white phosphorus attack on an apparent enemy position, which ends up melting 47 civilians instead.

Walker is also manipulated into destroying Dubai's remaining water supply by the CIA - as surely sealed the fate of anyone left in the city - gets his teammates Adams and Lugo killed, and depending on the ending you get, a now-insane Walker might mow down the Army patrol sent to retrieve him.

But the real kicker? If the rest of the world ever finds out about Walker's actions in Dubai, there's the very real possibility it would spark a major conflict between the Middle East and the U.S., incurring mass casualties in the process.

In the very least, Walker's efforts to improve the situation in the city backfired spectacularly.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.