10 Video Game Heroes Who Made Everything Worse

We said they were heroes, we never said they were intelligent.

Resident Evil village chris redfield
Capcom

Typically speaking, a hero is supposed to make things a wee bit better. In most cases, the hero of a story is intended to leave a story's world and people better than how they left it.

Well, I suspect the following characters were busy when that little memo was sent out. Busy doing what, you ask? Why making everything worse for everyone, of course!

Yes, whether on purpose or by accident, the character you the player control will likely end up making things even worse than how they were when you found them. Sometimes the hero is tricked by the villain, sometimes their internal prejudices or baggage lead them to make bad choices, and sometimes the hero is just a prick.

Whatever the reason may be, some video game heroes may not want to set the world on fire, but they're more than happy to strike a match or two to get what they want.

So to honor those screw-ups, failsons, and all around dumbasses that you for whatever reason have been put in charge of controlling into their terrible life choices, here are the 10 worst cases of video game heroes ruining it for everyone.

10. Chris Redfield - Resident Evil: Village 

Resident Evil 8 Village Chris Redfield
Capcom

Resident Evil Village opens with the shocking murder of Ethan Winters' wife Mia and the kidnapping of his daughter Rose. That's shocking in and of itself, but here's the twist - the one that done the deed is seemingly shown to be series veteran Chris Redfield. However, things are a bit more complicated than that. Needlessly so.

See, later on it turns out that WASN'T actually Mia. That was main villain Mother Miranda, who had kidnapped Mia shortly after Rose was born and used her ability to shapeshift at will to take her place. The second Chris figured that out, he and his men filled her with lead.

So what's the problem here? Well there's the teensy weensy, itty bitty, nigh insignificant detail that he DID NOT TELL ETHAN ANY OF THIS. Despite knowing that Ethan would likely be much more helpful if he knew someone had nicked his wife again while he wasn't looking, Chris chose to leave him in the dark for reasons the game never gets around to explaining.

Hell one of his own men outright tells him that he should have explained to Ethan sooner. There is literally zero reason for Chris to not have told him earlier. Or when he showed up to the Village. Or when he was taken in the convey. Or...


9. Gordon Freeman - Half Life

Gordon Freeman Half Life 2
Valve

The right man in the wrong place can make all the difference, says the G-Man at the opening of Half-Life 2. And in the case of Gordon Freeman, he could not have been more right.

Through all the fights with the Combine, as well as the many alien hordes that came through that original portal in the first game, let's never forget that, technically speaking, this is all Freeman's fault.

A freak accident, a long game by the G Man, or perhaps simply cosmic punishment for man's hubris, caused Black Mesa's experiment at the start of Half-Life to go horribly awry. The Resonance Cascade, as it was dubbed, released a horde of alien monsters onto Earth. This was then followed by the invasion of The Combine, who decimated and conquered Earth in a matter of hours.

Whether that has anything to do with the original experiment, I'll leave for you to discover one way or another by actually playing this unfinished masterpiece of a series. But in terms of that humble original title, it's hard to deny that Freeman spends the entire game cleaning up his own mess.


8. Nier - Nier

nier 1
Square Enix

At the start of Nier, all the eponymous Nier wanted was to find a cure for the disease known as the black scrawl. Every decision he makes throughout the game, from forming a pact with a snarky magic book to teaming up with the most foul-mouthed anime girl on the face of the Earth, Kaine, is informed by this larger goal.

This goal, for multiple reasons, is believed to be achievable by slaying the main villain, the evil Shadowlord. Just one problem, though, and unfortunately, this problem isn't revealed until the bastard is dead.

See, the game starts off on Nier and his daughter living in the post-apocalypse. Now, how did this happen? Well, for reasons I am not getting into because this game is long as hell and we'd be here all day if I did, killing the Shadowlord sets in motion a domino effect that culminates in the end of the world.

And it's all on Nier. The tragic thing is that he didn't know going in that this would happen, the dude was just trying to get a cure for a horrible illness. And, well, he got it. Just a shame that humanity being wiped out low-key makes the cure useless. Whoops.


7. Wander - Shadow Of The Colossus

Shadow of the colossus
Team ICO

Never underestimate the tunnel vision that grief gives you. Never doubt the lengths your mind will go to freeze out every dissenting voice when it has itself set on a solution to your pain.

For a lesson in this, look no further than Wander from Shadow Of The Colossus.

We don't know much about our hero Wander, all we concretely know is that he loved a woman named Mano. But when Mano dies, Wander is tempted by a demon into a desperate bargain to bring her back to life. If Wander wishes to see Mano again, he must destroy the Colossi, 16 gigantic, ancient, powerful beasts.

The demon's bargain is so transparently untrustworthy that it's a testament to Wander's grief and desperation that he doesn't immediately see right through it. But sure enough, Wander does what the demon asks, killing these majestic, unique creatures throughout the game. A task that ends up costing him everything in the end.

Even though the demon is ultimately defeated in the end, it doesn't change the damage Wander inflicted. 16 unique creatures have been taken out of the world, and the world is all the lesser for it.


6. Link - Legend Of Zelda: Ocarina Of Time

Ocarina of Time Gannondorf
Nintendo

The last one on our list who was unaware of the damage that would come about by his actions, the entire latter half of Ocarina of Time is lowkey Link's fault.

Ganondorf knew he wouldn't be able to breach the Sacred Realm on his own, so he let this little kid who was running around solving folk's problems do it for him. Once Link did, however, Ganondorf swooped in and took the Sacred Realm for himself, leaving Link magically comatose for the next seven years.

While not really his fault, at least not to the extent of our final five entries, Link's single-minded determination to get the Master Sword and enter the Sacred Realm left him utterly unprepared for Ganondorf's trickery, leading to the demon king subjugating all of Hyrule (or judging by the graphics of the game, just Castle Town and a bit of the surrounding countryside cause, like, everything else looks just fine).

Few other versions of Ganondorf would display such guile, which is probably why we still remember Ocarina's otherwise bland version to this day.


5. Kratos - God Of War 3

God of War 3 Poseidon
SCE Santa Monica

Other games on this list END with the hero making everything worse, but then you got Kratos screwing things up for everybody from minute one of his third installment.

Kratos, on his way to finally bringing about the end of Olympus itself, with an army of titans right behind him, gets one of the coolest boss fights/tutorials in gaming history to start us off with Poseidon. The fight is a massive one, teasing at the epic scale of the game to come. And at the end of the fight, Kratos subjects Poseidon to one of the most brutal QTEs in the history of the mechanic by having the player gouge out his eyes by pressing down on the analog sticks.

And then all of Greece floods. Because that's what happens when you murder the god of the ocean. Whoops.

Yeah Kratos casually and nonchalantly ends all of Greek civilization in the first 20 minutes of God Of War 3. Nice going buddy.


4. Daniil Dankovsky - Pathologic

pathologic hd
Gambitious Digital Entertainment

Pathologic has multiple characters to play through in order to get the best ending possible. Naturally, for a game this unendingly bleak, they start you off on the worst of the three. And mind you, one of the other guys is a serial killer.

Daniil Dankovsky or The Bachelor as the game titles him, is described in the game as, quote, "a prickly prick that will bury us all." And boy howdy is his storyline dedicated to proving that sentiment correct.

Dankovsky doesn't think very highly of the plague-stricken Russian Steppe village the game takes place in. Being a city boy with a bachelor's in medicine, naturally, he sees himself as god's gift to man, all the way down to his goal in the game being to "overcome death itself" like some kind of pulp mad scientist.

Going throughout Daniil's story will see you rubbing elbows with the elite of the city, who want to weather the inevitable shelling of the city by the Russian military in a giant architecturally disobedient structure on the edge of town, leaving the rest of the village to die. And even before this, Daniil's actions cause the burning of a strange giant cow that, in the Haruspex's storyline, you learn can actually help cure the plague.

The summation of this idiot at the beginning of this entry is definitely accurate. If the Bachelor has his way at the end of Pathologic, that prickly prick really does bury them all.


3. Tim - Braid

Braid Screenshot
Number None Inc.

Jonathan Blow's Braid is a story of obsession, and how it blinds us. "Us" in this case being represented by the protagonist, Tim.

The story of Braid is vague as hell, mostly left up to interpretation, but one thing is clear if you're paying attention to the visuals and the few bits of story that the game DOES give you: Tim does not think highly of anyone other than himself. And he doesn't really like himself all that much either.

If you know this game, then you know the twist at the end of the final level where it's revealed that the Princess that Tim spends the entire story obsessively chasing was in fact running AWAY from Tim instead of toward him. But even beyond his own narrow-minded projections onto this woman he's decided to chase after, the entire game is filled with Tim killing every creature he comes across.

The game literally keeps score and doesn't let you progress until every "enemy" is dead. This is at its most callous in the level where progressing means literally sacrificing a bunch of adorable little bunny rabbits to cannon fire.

No wonder the princess was so desperate to get away from this psycho at the end.


2. Anders - Dragon Age 2

Dragon Age 2 Anders
BioWare

When we met Anders in Dragon Age Awakening, we're left with little reason to believe he had any profound thoughts on the plight of the mages one way or another. The flippant, snarky young man was mostly following The Warden around for a laugh, only really growing close with Justice, the noble spirit The Warden picks up along the way.

When Hawke meets Anders in Dragon Age 2, however, things are...different. The body Justice was using in Awakening had long since broken down, causing Anders to offer his own. However, when Justice possessed Anders, it opened up every trauma inflicted on Anders throughout his life by the Templars. This not only awakened Anders' revolutionary spirit, but tragically mutated the noble spirit of Justice into a violent demon of Vengeance, prone to taking over Anders and going on a rampage.

What was intended as a symbiotic relationship turns, over the course of DA 2, into a case of mutually assured destruction, with Anders and Vengeance's worst natures tearing them both apart, to the point where, in Act 3, it's constantly up in the air which one is talking at any given time.

This, of course, culminated in the tragic ending of Dragon Age 2 where Anders triggers the Mage/Templar war by blowing up the largest Chantry in Kirkwall. Hawke has to leave the life they fought so hard for, the entire world is thrown into a violent war, and it's all Anders' fault.


1. Captain Walker - Spec Ops: The Line

Spec Ops The Line Walker
2K Games

One of the most infamous protagonists in gaming history, there was really no question who was going to top this list.

Spec Ops: The Line intentionally lures you into a false sense of security as it opens with the usual trappings of the AAA titles of its era: soldiers, helicopters, Middle Eastern settings etc.

It then uses all of that to metaphorically and very literally beat Walker, and thus the player, over the head with the morally murky nature of the military and the war on terror. Throughout his mission, Walker rips apart whatever little is left of the destroyed Dubai, in a series of increasingly ghoulish war crimes. Culminating in the game's infamous white phosphorous set piece.

No matter which ending you end up with at the end, the game's nihilistic approach to the military shines bleakly through. All perfectly symbolized in a soldier who came to this place to be something he isn't: a hero.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

John Tibbetts is a novelist in theory, a Whatculture contributor in practice, and a nerd all around who loves talking about movies, TV, anime, and video games more than he loves breathing. Which might be a problem in the long term, but eh, who can think that far ahead?