10 Video Game Mechanics That Make No Sense
Crouching isn't inherently quieter than just... walking slowly.
More often than not, video games are a uniquely immersive brand of escapism in which players can travel to fantastical worlds and do things they never could in real life.
Games by their nature aren't supposed to be strictly "realistic," though that doesn't mean they can't adhere to the basic rules of our own existence. And yet, so many games feature mechanics that categorically betray the building blocks of reality.
This is most often done by game developers in order to give the player a more seamless, hassle-free experience.
Real life can be a troubling bore, after all, and so players are typically willing to overlook some nonsense mechanics if they result in greater overall enjoyment.
And yet, if you step back and consider these mechanics, they really don't make any sense at all in the most basic terms.
The offending games certainly hope that you don't think too hard about these gameplay features, as if you do your sense of immersion just might be shattered.
The majority of these mechanics are commonplace enough that players basically just accept them, whether they grant a time-saving advantage or just create a ton of busy-work...
10. Detective Vision
One of the most pervasive gaming trends of the last decade-or-so is "detective vision," whereby the player character is able to scan the surrounding environment for points of interest, and even tag enemies and trace their movements through objects.
While some games at least try to explain this mechanic away within the context of its world, like Batman being rich enough to create environment-scanning tech, or Geralt of Rivia having supernatural Witcher Senses, even many realistic(ish) action games will allow you to freely track enemy combatants in a way that isn't even remotely realistic.
Granted, games would probably be a lot less fun if you had no idea whatsoever where the enemy was going, but often it feels like developers use Detective Vision as a crutch to compensate for overly cluttered, busy level design where enemies can't easily be distinguished by the player.
Though The Last of Us' Listen Mode is intended to be a translation of what Joel and Ellie can hear, it still feels somewhat at odds with the game's grittier survival thriller tone. Without it, though, the gameplay would simply be offputtingly difficult for many players.
Such is the tension inherent in Detective Mode - it's useful, but doesn't really make much sense within the internal logic of many games that use it.
And yet, it's so commonplace and accepted nowadays that it probably isn't going away anytime soon - if ever.
9. Weapon Durability
Time for a not-so-hot take: weapon durability friggin' stinks.
No game in recent years has more divisively featured degrading weaponry than The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild, where most all of Link's weapons and shields would break after a set number of uses.
Defenders of the mechanic argue that it incentivises players to change up their play-style throughout the game rather than simply sticking to the same trusty weapon, but critics retort that it transforms even basic combat into tedious busy-work.
But on a more general level, weapon durability rarely makes much sense for the simple fact that weapons and shields just don't break that often in reality.
Even accepting that games generally operate on an accelerated sense of time, weapons and armour break far more frequently than they ever would in real life, where they're typically designed to stand up to enormous levels of punishment for months or even years.
If you had to replace a sword after mere days or weeks in real life, you'd be asking the vendor for a damn refund and take your business elsewhere.
8. Regenerating Health
Traditionally, action-centric video games would litter health packs, potions, and other beneficial pickups around the map to allow players to conveniently restore their health.
But over the last few generations, regenerating health has become increasingly popular, whereby all a wounded player needs to do is take cover and avoid injury for, say, 5 or 10 seconds. Their vitality will then begin restoring itself.
The Call of Duty franchise is perhaps best-known for using this mechanic, whereby the player's screen will begin to flash blood-red if they're close to death, but if they can sit tight for a few beats, their health will return to full.
Not all games are quite so generous, but regenerating health as a whole is a totally cartoonish affectation, given that bloody injuries don't just miraculously repair themselves by taking a breather for a bit. Quite the opposite, in fact.
More often than not it speaks to the challenges involved with game balancing, that providing just enough health packs throughout a level to assist players is tricky.
We've all played older games where we've ended up stuck at a checkpoint with low health and no nearby health packs - it's supremely annoying as you either need to save-scum your way through the level or just start it again.
Conversely, regenerating health ensures that players always have a healing facility at hand, even if like Detective Vision it does feel like a crutch for designers who can't be bothered to balance their games properly.
7. Double Jumping
The ability to double jump is so widespread throughout platforming and action-adventure games that you probably haven't even thought about how ridiculous and "unrealistic" it is.
The basic physics of our world dictate that jumping is achieved by pushing off from a surface with sufficient force to propel yourself, but what exactly are you leaping from to perform a second jump? Thin air isn't a pliable, scalable surface, and so gravity dictates that a double jump is scientifically impossible.
But as Mario, Crash Bandicoot, and hundreds of other platformers have cemented over the years, double jumping just feels right in video games, and when a platformer doesn't offer the ability to stack a jump on top of another, it feels really damn weird.
A few games have at least attempted to offer plausible explanations, perhaps most memorably Devil May Cry, where Dante's double jump (aka Air Hike) ability creates a temporary platform for him to leap off.
It may be unrealistic, but this is one of those mechanics that's so satisfying and feels so intuitively "correct" that taking it away would just piss a lot of people off.
Most realistic video games at least tend to avoid using double jump, and so it's generally only reserved for more heightened experiences that play fast and loose with the laws of physics anyway.
6. Locked Doors As Major Obstacles
There's perhaps no more basic or elemental video game puzzle than trying to open a door after finding that it's locked.
Typically this means you're off to find the key or, in the case of the Resident Evil franchise, complete a series of convoluted puzzles that maybe, just maybe, will eventually net you a key.
It's a long-held video game staple - a brick wall intended to slow the player's progress towards the next narrative beat or boss fight, even if it really doesn't make that much sense.
There's nothing more ridiculous than a pathetic, flimsy wooden door preventing you from continuing on your adventure, especially if you're touting a massive arsenal of weaponry which should conceivably be able to just blow a huge hole through the damn thing.
This is especially irritating when dealing with padlocked gates, where the game won't simply let you shoot the padlock and pass through.
Gamers are so acquainted with this silliness at this point that they're basically conditioned to just accept it, even though it's fundamentally absurd.
At least make the doors look like they're made out of triple-reinforced steel or something, right?
5. Eating Food Heals Horrible Wounds
This mechanic at least has the good sense to be kinda funny and charming, even though it's no less nonsensical than anything else on this list.
If you find yourself gravely wounded in a game, logic dictates that you need to find a health pack and patch yourself up. But for decades video games have offered a magic alternative - just eat something.
Now, it is admittedly important to keep yourself fed: you need energy to do a day's fighting, and in reality a malnourished person isn't going to recover from their injuries very quickly.
But so, so many video games - especially RPGs and action-adventure games - take this to parodic levels by allowing you to restore your health simply by chowing down or taking a drink.
Hilariously, gobbling up a hot dog or chugging a bottle of Staminan (looking at you, Yakuza) can make your grim battle wounds go away completely and miraculously nurse you back to full health.
You can be seconds away from death and have your life saved by even the most basic, terrible food item in your inventory.
Obviously crappy, rudimentary foods tend to heal the player less, but it's an amusing video game cliche that's stuck around for a long, long time. Just imagine if eating a McRib could cure your broken leg in real life.
It makes no sense but people kinda like it, so it's probably not going anywhere.
4. Reloading Your Gun Magically Refills Half-Empty Magazines
In the overwhelming majority of shooters if you reload your gun mid-way through a magazine, that half-empty magazine won't remain in your inventory somewhere but instead be magically refilled the moment you hit reload.
In reality of course a half-empty mag will remain half-empty unless you go to the effort of redistributing the bullets yourself, which just isn't practical in the middle of a tense gunfight.
Though there are a few video games which actively track the bullet count in each individual magazine, such as some of the Rainbow Six games, the overwhelming majority of shooters opt instead for magic reloading, where any half-empty mag will just be fully refilled the moment you hit the reload button.
Ultimately developers understandably assume that most players wouldn't want to deal with the busy-work of juggling a bunch of half-full magazines during a firefight, as would make shooting a lot less fun.
It works for shooters focused on intense, meticulous realism, but otherwise it'd just be a boring impediment. It may not make much sense, but in the interest of fun it's totally worth it.
3. Rubber-Banding
Rubber-banding is a technique used by game developers to ensure that you're never doing too well against the AI opponents. If you demonstrate you're really, really good at a game, the AI will react by suddenly playing insanely well.
It's most typically deployed in racing games - perhaps most famously Mario Kart - where no matter how skilled a human player might be and how much of a lead they should be able to create, the AI rivals will eventually drive supernaturally fast in order to close the gap.
In theory it's designed to maintain a tense experience for the player, rather than allowing them to tediously rinse the competition without even the vaguest fear of losing.
Conversely rubber-banding can also be used to extend a hand to a struggling player, by ensuring a winning AI opponent doesn't surge totally out of reach.
This of course betrays the real-life nature of competition and physics: reality doesn't have a rubber-band, and if you let them, people will leave you in the dust with reckless abandon.
It's more a trick on the developers' part to dupe players into having a more competitive, reactive experience, even if so many gamers are totally savvy to it these days and regularly call it out.
2. Crouching Makes You Move More Quietly
One of the most common gameplay elements of stealth-action games is a crouching mechanic which will make you move more quietly while approaching enemies.
While it makes sense that crouching makes you less visible and more compact to enemies, the sound argument doesn't really hold much water.
For starters, why would you really be any quieter just crouching down but putting the same weight on your feet? Test it out for yourself - there's no difference.
Secondly, crouch-walking for miles on end would absolutely destroy your knees and probably set you up for a later life defined by debilitating osteoporosis. It isn't a combat strategy viable for long-term use.
In reality it makes more sense to just walk at the same slow speed as the crouch - you'd make the same amount of noise but without subjecting yourself to enormous bodily strain.
If Solid Snake, Sam Fisher, Aloy, and the various Assassin's Creed protagonists were real people, they'd need a physiotherapist on speed dial.
1. Monsters Carrying Loot
There are three sure things in life - death, taxes, and loot in video games.
Loot isn't exactly something new - video games have rewarded players with useful pickups for defeating enemies in RPGs for decades, but there's definitely been a trend towards engineering games around the loot grind in recent years.
Whether you enjoy hoovering up loot or not, does it really make sense to kill a giant gelatinous monster and for it to drop items that only a humanoid could conceivably use? More to the point, where would an unclothed monster even keep all that stuff?
Ultimately it's just another part of a game's attempt to carrot-and-stick players, giving them a material reward for killing an enemy and so in turn making that action feel more "meaningful."
There's no more reason for a creature to drop a shield or some currency upon death than there is a spider you kill in your bathroom to cough up some coins.
It's silly, but we all love the dopamine hit that comes with scooping up that sweet, sweet, sometimes-glowing loot.