10 Video Game Moments You Were SUPPOSED To Hate

Mafia 2 knew exactly what it was doing.

mafia 2 vito
2K

Whether you’re playing with friends or getting lost for hours at a time within a sprawling RPG, video games are a fantastic source of entertainment that have created countless genre-defining moments over the decades.

As exhilarating as slaying your first dragon in Skyrim is, though, not all gaming moments are supposed to be fun. More so in recent years, games have become more refined at weaving emotionally complex stories with themes and plot points intended to resonate deeply.

Developers have likewise got better at using the interactivity of games to convey the rawness of these gut-punch moments to players. Unlike in films or television where we simply watch characters go through the motions, players have a tangible part in the action as it unfolds.

These moments are the most effective when developers hold absolutely nothing back, whether through devastating plot twists or ingenious feats of game design.

These moments aren’t supposed to be enjoyable. In fact, the entire point is that we’re supposed to hate them. That’s what makes them work so brilliantly.

--

Beware of massive spoilers ahead.

10. Papers, Please (2013) - Choosing Between Food And Heat

Papers Please
3909 LLC

In Papers, Please, players take on the role of a checkpoint worker in the fictional totalitarian country of Arstotzka. It’s the player’s job to decide which of the people who appear in front of their meagre desk are allowed to enter, and who get turned away.

However, this isn’t as straightforward as it seems.

The rules for entry become more convoluted each day, which consequently makes the required checks more time consuming with mistakes becoming easier. The more mistakes are made, the less money players are awarded at the end of each shift.

Over time you can come away with less money than you started with, and things get worse when players must also decide whether to use earnings to pay for essentials like food and heat, or life-saving medicine for their family. Given how difficult the job becomes, though, this soon feels like an un-winnable task.

As well as serving as a commentary on authoritarian regimes, Papers, Please likewise highlights the soul crushing realities of working a thankless, low paying job.


9. Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 (2009) - "No Russian"

Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 (2011) - No Russia
Activision

Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 made huge waves when it released in 2009 for a multitude of reasons: the campaign was a fast-paced action spectacle, there were genuinely jaw-dropping revelations, and the multiplayer was better than ever.

However, there was another reason this game got plenty of attention, and that was thanks to a controversial mission titled "No Russian".

In it, players took on the role of an undercover CIA agent who accompanies antagonist Makarov to a Moscow airport to participate in a mass shooting. When the elevator doors open, the terrorists open fire on the civilians, with you following suit.

It's easy to see why this part of the game stirred up anger from the media at the time, despite Activision including an option to skip it entirely.

The point is, though, that this level isn't supposed to be "enjoyable".

Whether players chose to fire their weapon or not, they're still forced to walk through the airport watching innocent people killed in cold blood. In stark contrast to the belief that this section encourages gun violence, the effect is the opposite.

This is a truly harrowing level which reinforces the grim reality of attacks such as these.


8. Mafia II (2010) - Going To Prison

Mafia 2 Prison
2K Games

After returning home from World War II, Vito Scaletta reunites with a lifelong friend who's since made inroads in the Clemente crime family. Through his friend's contacts, Vito begins to get some work for the organisation, eventually gaining a foothold within the criminal underworld.

As Vito continues to get more work, he'll begin to earn some money that can be used to buy guns, cars, and even a snazzy outfit.

It's at this point, however, that Mafia II decides players aren't allowed to have nice things.

Everything Vito has earned is taken away when he's sent to prison for stealing gas stamps. And this isn't the first time this happens either. Later, a house fire causes Vito to become penniless too.

After working your way through the story to earn Vito's hard-earned wealth, having the game take it all away and force you to start over again on two separate occasions is understandably frustrating. However, these plot beats are nevertheless necessary in telling Vito's story.

Vito's tale is a tragic one which underscores the risks of his chosen lifestyle. Despite being promised that the mafia would be the solution to his problems, all it does is cause him more suffering.


7. Red Dead Redemption (2010) - John's Last Stand

Red Dead Redemption John Death
Rockstar

Throughout the dozens of hours spent in the weathered cowboy boots of John Marston in Red Dead Redemption, players become well acquainted with the grizzled cowboy as he seeks his titular redemption.

Formerly part of the notorious Van der Linde gang, Marston is no stranger to shady business and nefarious actions. But he wants to put that life behind him so that he can forge a new one with his wife and son on his own ranch.

To get the life Marston wants, however, the Pinkerton Detective Agency need him to kill his former accomplices.

Despite his past, John is a genuinely good-hearted person who's willing to do whatever he can for his loved ones. With the last of his former gang gone, John has finally earned the quiet life he's been dreaming of.

Unfortunately, the Pinkertons arrive to finish all traces the job. An epic shootout at John's ranch leads to a last stand where players have a chance to take out as many agents as they can, but it'll never be enough.

Marston is killed in a hail of bullets, creating a landmark tragic death in gaming history.


6. Dark Souls (2011) - Being Ambushed By The Asylum Demon

dark souls asylum demon
FromSoftware

The first introduction to FromSofware's masterpiece is a handful of very weak enemies whose job is to teach newcomers the fundamentals of how to play.

With only a broken weapon at this point to learn the basics, players will soon arrive in front of giant doors which signal the way forward. Upon entering, players are unceremoniously greeted by the Asylum Demon, Dark Souls' first boss, who'll easily pummel inexperienced players into the ground with a ludicrously oversized hammer.

To those not expecting this ambush, trying to fight this boss with the absence of a working weapon proves to be a gigantic obstacle that's near impossible to overcome.

Yet, everything in Dark Souls exists to teach players something, with this encounter being a trial by fire into what playing this game is all about.

Whether you discover the small door to escape the fight for now, persevere until achieving victory or get flattened and forced into a re-think, this unfair fight is designed to make you strategise.


5. Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns Of The Patriots (2008) - The Microwave Tunnel

Metal Gear Solid 4 Microwave
Konami

Iconic game developer and certified madman Hideo Kojima is no stranger to pushing the boundaries of what video games can be. Especially when it comes to his Metal Gear Solid series, Kojima has experimented with some strange mechanics to create some unforgettably bizarre moments.

But not all these quirky moments were fun to play as the boss fight with Psycho Mantis, with Metal Gear 4's microwave tunnel sequence being one such example.

For Solid Snake to stop Liquid Ocelot from launching a nuke, he must inject a computer virus into Ocelot's warship. To get to the core, however, he must traverse a corridor protected by strong microwave radiation.

As soon as Snake enters the corridor, he's immediately overwhelmed by the radiation's intensity. Walking through this tunnel is a grueling physical process for him, and Kojima underscores the arduousness of his exertion through the gameplay.

Not only does Snake's strained pace give players a sense of his agony, but players also struggle alongside him by frantically mashing button prompts to keep him moving.

Meanwhile, a split screen depicts Snake's allies battling for their own survival. It's an effectively intense scene, and you feel every second of it.


4. Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice (2017) - Giving Up

hellblade senuas sacrifice
Ninja Theory

Everything about the design of Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice is meticulously crafted to immerse players within the headspace of the titular protagonist as she makes her way into Helheim to save her lover's soul.

The journey into hell isn't going to be an easy one. Alongside the disembodied voices whirling inside her head casting doubt upon her actions, Senua likewise comes up against other horrors and obstacles in her path.

Her travels leads to an epic battle that stands between the protagonist and her goal in which she'll face wave after wave of tough enemies. No matter how much she fights, though, the enemies will just keep coming.

The voices in Senua's head will begin to tell her to give up, but our determination to succeed will keep us fighting alongside Senua. We've come as far as her and have no intentions of stopping now.

However, this is a fight that Senua just can't win. To progress past this section, we must stop trying and put the controller down.

Giving in to defeat is the exact opposite of what we're supposed to do in games. Senua's struggle, though, is a tangible lesson that sometimes failure cannot be avoided, no matter how hard we try.


3. Psychonauts 2 (2021) - Compton's Cook Off

Psychonauts 2 - Compton's Cook Off
Xbox Game Studios

There is nothing that makes completing an objective in any video game more stressful than when developers include a time limit. This is exactly what happens in Psychonauts 2 when protagonist Raz enters the mind of Psychonaut founder Compton Boole to find himself participate in a colourful cooking-based gameshow named Ram It Down.

The goal is simple: collect, prepare, and plate the necessary ingredients needed to make the required dish before the timer runs out. If you manage to present the meal to the sock puppet judges while the clock’s still ticking, you’ll be awarded with an alluring mystery prize.

As the dishes become increasingly complex to create, meeting the deadline to claim the prize becomes a frustrating undertaking. But there was a good reason for this.

Each of the minds Raz enters in this series highlights a specific area of mental health, with Compton’s being used to represent the character’s severe anxiety.

While running around an obstacle course to appease overly critical judges is a creative and fitting metaphor for anxiety, the developers likewise offer some advice on how to deal with being overwhelmed by having you take breaks between rounds.

You can even go back to collect the prizes you missed.


2. A Plague Tale: Requiem (2022) - Hugo

A Plague Tale: Requiem - Ending
Focus Entertainment

After narrowly escaping the devastating rat plague at the end of the previous game, it’s not long before siblings Amicia and Hugo de Rune are thrown headfirst into the chaos when the man-eating rats re-emerge to upend their lives once more.

Surrounded by death and devastation, the pair set out on a mission to find a cure for the sickness that’s slowly killing Hugo and finally put an end to the plague before it’s too late.

Much like the first game, Amicia and Hugo endure a harrowing ordeal which puts their survival and bond to the test. After going on this journey with them, it’s impossible not to become emotionally invested in their plight.

Being A Plague Tale, though, things don’t get any better for Amicia at the end. With the sickness now having taken over her brother, she realises that the only way to stop the plague is to kill him.

Struggling to hold back tears, Amicia takes out her sling and players must take aim at the youngster’s head before delivering the fatal blow.

Killing Hugo is one of the toughest things a game has asked us to do, but this action crystallises the losses they've faced along the way into one last scene.


1. The Last Of Us Part II (2019) - The Final Showdown

last of us 2 ending
Sony Interactive Entertainment

Much like its predecessor, The Last Of Us Part II held absolutely nothing back as it wove its gritty tale of revenge. With its visceral combat and subject matter that didn't shy away from difficult themes, there are parts of this title that were simply unpleasant.

After Ellie witnesses the death of her adoptive father Joel at the start of the game, she embarks on a deeply personal quest for revenge against those who killed him.

Ellie is single-minded in her goal throughout her journey, with each person she kills bringing her closer to ringleader Abby (who had her own reasons for doing what she did). Even when Abby spares Ellie's life, Ellie still can't rid herself of her desire for revenge.

At the pair's next meeting, the stage is set for the fight that players have been waiting for. However, things play out differently than expected.

Moments away from getting her revenge, Ellie understands the meaninglessness of the violence and allows Abby to leave. She returns home to find her family is gone and that she's now unable to play her guitar.

Though the finale is purposefully anticlimactic, the bittersweet gut punch it delivers is more powerful than any final boss fight.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Mafia 2
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Glasgow-based cinephile who earned a Masters degree in film studies to spend their time writing about cinema, video games, and horror.