10 Video Game Reveals That Stopped You DEAD

Those video game moments that made you go "Wait, WHAT JUST HAPPENED?!"

Binary domain big bo
Sega

Pulling off an amazing reveal is challenging for virtually all storytellers, no matter if they write books, TV shows, movies, plays, or of course, video games.

We're not talking about the bad video game twists, either, such as 2009’s Bionic Commando reboot connecting Nathan Spencer’s mechanical arm to his dead wife (Emily) or the incestuous and illusory truths that conclude 2021’s Twelve Minutes. Those were jaw-dropping for the wrong reasons.

Instead, we're delving into the narrative surprises that left players frozen in place in brilliant and fitting ways.

Perhaps they add new depth to the experience by recontextualizing entire plots and characters. Maybe they’re deeply emotional beats that stay with gamers long after the credits roll. Or, they could simply be strange and shocking discoveries that no one could’ve predicted.

No matter their purpose, the 10 reveals on this list are among the biggest and most affecting in the medium, and more than likely resulted in everyone needing a few minutes to take them in before carrying on.

SPOILERS AHEAD!

10. Elizabeth Is Anna DeWitt - BioShock Infinite

Bioshock Infinite Elizabeth
2K Games

Regardless of whether it’s superior to the first entry in the series, 2013’s time-bending BioShock Infinite concludes with similarly mind-blowing disclosures regarding the real identities of two major characters.

Learning that protagonist Booker DeWitt is actually an alternate universe version of main antagonist Comstock is certainly startling and significant. Yet, it’s the other confession – Comstock’s rebellious adopted descendant, Elizabeth, is Booker’s long-lost daughter, Anna – that hits like a punch in the gut.

After all, Booker’s entire cause for going to floating city Columbia is to find Elizabeth, as the mysterious Lutece twins tell him that if he “brings [them] the girl,” he’ll “wipe away the debt.”

On the surface, it seems like a simple way for him to erase his gambling responsibilities, but by the end, it takes on a deeper meaning since said liabilities led to Comstock taking infant Anna (and unintentionally severing her finger) in the first place.

Thus, Booker and Anna’s relationship becomes increasingly complicated and touching as BioShock Infinite progresses, leading to a bittersweet finale in which multiple Elizabeths (from multiple timelines) watch Booker drown in order to prevent any version of him from becoming Comstock.


9. Abby’s Motivation – The Last Of Us Part II

The Last Of Us Part II Abby
Sony Interactive Entertainment

The Last of Us Part II has a number of astonishing moments whose impact – even with the controversial leaks – couldn’t be fully anticipated due to their graphic nature and/or shifts to the storyline and characterizations.

Obviously, the brutal slaying of Joel by Abby and her crew during the initial hours are heartbreaking and visceral. Not only is it unforgivingly explicit and ruthless, but it also places Ellie on her tragic, vengeful path.

However, it’s the subsequent revelation of why Abby did what she did that was mind-blowing.

As shown in a flashback that illustrates what Abby was thinking when she committed the murder, the Firefly surgeon that Joel executed at the end of the first game was Abby’s father, Jerry, who had mixed feelings about what he was doing and seemed to be an all-around good person.

Suddenly, we must reevaluate all of the violence and hate that’s defined Ellie (since she’s essentially trying to kill Abby for the same reason Abby killed Joel). That moral ambiguity makes both characters simultaneously heroic and villainous while giving Joel’s inciting choice more tear-jerking complexity.


8. The Boss CAN Be Trusted? - Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater

The Boss metal gear
Konami

Chronologically, Metal Gear Solid 3 – which takes place in 1964 – kickstarts the whole delightfully convoluted saga. That’s probably why it’s getting the full remake treatment (hopefully in the near future) instead of the original and/or MGS2: Sons of Liberty.

A major reason behind why it’s so adored is its moving tale, particularly the implication early on that star Big Boss’ former mentor, The Boss, is working alongside central bad guy Colonel Volgin. Accordingly, it’s assumed that she’s betrayed Big Boss – and the United States of America – by defecting to the USSR.

Once they engage in their last battle (at the end of the game), however, players are treated to arguably the most emotional scene in any MGS adventure.

Rather than become a traitor to her country, fellow spy/romantic interest EVA eventually divulges that The Boss was ordered to bring back the Philosopher’s Legacy by infiltrating Volgin’s camp to gain his trust and any intel she could. She allowed herself to be perceived as a conspirator (and consequently be killed) to protect America.


7. Odin's Ultimate Trick - God Of War Ragnarok

God Of War Ragnarok Odin
Sony Interactive Entertainment

Although he’s not as visually monstrous or physically imposing as, well, any of the preceding God of War enemies, Norse All-Father Odin is captivatingly wicked due to his disarming charm and manipulative genius.

Aside from trying to fool Atreus into being disloyal to Kratos – as well as abusing his family and the citizens of Asgard – one of the worst things Odin’s ever done is imprison sympathetic Aesir deity Týr for adopting a peaceful mindset and no longer wanting to wreak havoc on people.

That’s why it’s so rewarding and endearing to finally rescue Týr and then spend dozens of hours with him in God of War Ragnarok. In addition to offering invaluable advice, he bonds with Kratos, Atreus, and the rest of the team.

Yet, it was all a trick.

Upon accidentally calling Atreus “Loki” (and sparking the suspicion of dwarven blacksmith Brok), Týr transforms into Odin, stabs Brok, and holds Atreus hostage until he’s given the Mask of Creation. It's an exceptionally clever and disconcerting ploy that demonstrates how Odin’s always been one (or two or three) steps ahead of Kratos and company.

Fortunately, the real Týr can still be saved during the post-game, too.


6. Hollow Children - Binary Domain

Although it garnered mostly positive reviews, sci-fi third-person shooter Binary Domain sold poorly, so it’s among the most overlooked games of the seventh generation.

Featuring the sort of body horror that fans of the Tetsuo movies (as well as David Cronenberg’s filmography) should love, its tale of man fusing with machine in a post-apocalyptic Japan is a grotesquely dismaying yet relevant warning for modern times.

Speaking of horrifying moments, there’s a scene in which players see the full scope of what it’s like to learn that you’re a Hollow Child (an android who looks, thinks, and feels like a person).

After all, the man in question thought he was 100% human – why wouldn’t he? – so witnessing him discover his mutilated and semi-robotic face in the reflection of someone’s sunglasses is disturbing. From there, he endures abject terror, cruelty, and hopelessness until he fights back before taking his own life.

You can’t help but be frozen in place until it’s over.


5. Treacherous Tim - Braid

Braid Screenshot
Number None Inc.

As already alluded to on this list, morality is sometimes subjective and multifaceted. Thus, a character can be the hero and the villain of the story at the same time if there are numerous perspectives through which to view them.

Few titles examine that duality better than beloved indie puzzle-platformer Braid.

For most of the playthrough, central figure Tim thinks he’s overcoming dozens of trials and tribulations to rescue a princess from a nefarious knight (or “monster”).

It’s not clear what Tim’s relationship is to her, but judging by how panicked she looks – as well as how frantically she runs through the stages – it appears that she’s scared to death of the knight (and that Tim is on the right track).

That is, until the last level, where the inversion of time also inverts the storyline to show that the princess has been fighting to escape Tim – and be saved by the knight – the whole time.

Based on clues and other information strewn throughout the journey, it’s easy to assume that Tim is the princess’ scorned yet regretful ex-lover who’s mistreated her in the past and refuses to accept that she’s moved on with the knight.


4. Not Entirely A Remake – Final Fantasy 7 Remake

Final Fantasy VII remake
Square Enix

Remaking any acclaimed property (let alone one of the most treasured RPGs of all time) is inherently risky because fans are often skeptical, if not outraged, about even the smallest changes to what they hold near and dear.

It’s no wonder, then, why Final Fantasy 7 Remake was met with a wide range of reactions when it was announced in 2015. Above all else, devotees wondered if it would be a faithful recreation of the 1997 classic or if it would deviate drastically from what its predecessor did.

The answer would be a bit of both.

By expanding the Midgar section into its own full-length quest, Square Enix included much more backstory alongside various revisions. Even so, the superlative shock comes at the end, when it’s revealed that the entire narrative is taking place in a different timeline.

For instance, two major characters who die in the original continuity – Zack and Aerith – are now alive, and Sephiroth’s actively trying to challenge fate. Plus, the Whispers pop up at specific times to ensure that new paths open up and history doesn’t completely repeat itself.

Let’s hope 2024’s Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth maintains that inventiveness.


3. The Cake Is A Lie - Portal

portal cake is a lie
Valve

Similar to how Atlas/Frank Fontaine is initially assumed to be helping the protagonist of BioShock, GLaDOS (Genetic Lifeform and Disk Operating System) seems to be a friendly aid to Chell in Portal.

Particularly, GLaDOS is quite useful in figuring out how to solve all of the puzzles in the Aperture Science Enrichment Center, all the while winning over Chell with witty meta-humor and other comical comments. If that weren’t enough, she even promises Chell cake if she completes all of her objectives.

Who would say "no" to that?!

Well, as it turns out (and as countless memes have reminded up over the last 15 years), the cake (and everything we thought we knew about their bond) is a lie.

Why?

Because the program becomes malevolent as Portal reaches its conclusion and the challenges get increasingly difficult and malicious. Eventually, the player discovers a wall with various bits of graffiti – including that famous phrase – that suggest the A.I.’s ongoing deceitfulness and ultimate goal of luring Chell into her fiery trap.

That’s not to say that the dessert doesn’t exist, as Chell defeats GLaDOS and subsequently discovers a Black Forest cake within the facility.


2. Shady Shepherd - Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2

Modern Warfare 2 Ghost death
Activision

There’s no denying that 2009’s Modern Warfare 2 has one of the best campaigns in the series, with lots of varied locations, intriguing plot points, and trademark over-the-top set pieces keeping you enthralled across its short but sweet duration.

Of course, it also houses perhaps the most stunning – if not generation-defining – reveal in any of the titles.

It turns out that your boss in Task Force 141, General Shepherd, helped Russian terrorist Vladimir Makarov fulfill his mission of attacking the U.S. and Europe to instigate World War III.

Upon arriving at the Georgia-Russian border, your character (Sergeant Gary “Roach” Sanderson) and Simon “Ghost” Riley, hand Shepherd the DSM. Rather than congratulate them, Shepherd shoots both men and leaves them for dead. Backed by a sorrowful orchestral soundtrack, it’s a harrowing and infuriating scene.

At the same time, Captains John Price and John “Soap” MacTavish are betrayed by Shepherd’s men in Afghanistan. Understandably, they hunt him down, with Soap ultimately killing Shepherd by throwing a knife at him while he fights Price.

Rarely has revenge felt so good.


1. Jefferson's Horrifying Hobby - Life Is Strange

Life is strange mark jefferson
Don't Nod

The original Life is Strange was a surprisingly engaging, authentic, and heartfelt entry into the episodic coming-of-age adventure subgenre. From its relatable depictions of adolescence and high school life to its examinations of love, friendship, parent-child bonds and destiny, it’s a profound journey that’s lighthearted, yet also devastatingly grim.

No aspect embodies that latter quality better than the truth about who’s been kidnapping, abusing, photographing and killing young girls – including Chloe Price’s missing buddy/romantic interest, Rachel Amber – in the seemingly idyllic Arcadia Bay.

At the end of Episode 4, Chloe and heroine Max are investigating a scrapyard after finding pictures of said crimes (and Rachel’s remains). They think they’ll be meeting up with their condescending classmate, Nathan Prescott, but it’s photography instructor Mark Jefferson who guns down Chloe and injects Max with an anaesthetic.

As he explains at the start of Episode 5, he’s been doing those nefarious deeds because he’s “obsessed with the idea of capturing that moment innocence evolves into corruption.”

It’s a sickening twist – especially since it leads to some unsettling scenes involving Jefferson holding Max and the adversarial Victoria Chase hostage.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Hey there! Outside of 'WhatCulture,' I'm a former editor at 'PopMatters' and a past or present contributor to 'Kerrang!,' 'Consequence,' 'PROG,' 'Metal Injection,' 'Loudwire,' and more. I've written books about Jethro Tull, Opeth, and Dream Theater, too, and I run a creative arts journal called 'The Bookends Review.' You can also find me talking about horror on YouTube (as Hairless Horror / @hairlesshorror)! Oh, and I live in Philadelphia and teach academic/creative writing courses at a few colleges/universities.