10 Video Game Villains Hiding In Plain Sight

Never, EVER trust the creepy old lady.

Resident Evil 8
Capcom

While the majority of video games present their villains in totally upfront fashion, sometimes developers love to pull a classic bait-and-switch by revealing that the baddie has been hiding in front of the player's face the whole damn time.

If poorly executed it can certainly land with an obvious thud, but if it's pulled off with sufficient ingenuity it can cause players to rethink the entirety of the game's events.

It's a difficult trick to pull off, especially as modern audiences are so thoroughly conditioned to expect such "they were the villain all along!" reveals, but when it works it really works.

While not all of these hidden-in-plain-sight reveals left all fans happy, they were nevertheless completely shocking and unexpected, such that few players could've ever seen them coming.

From villains disguised as other villains, to supposedly friendly characters who turned heel at a pivotal moment, antagonists who took the form of a friendly NPC, and everything in-between, these Big Bads were all concealed mere inches from your face.

In some cases it evoked brilliantly stunned surprise from players, while in others they felt undeniably cheated by a reveal that just wasn't well thought-out enough...

10. Scott Shelby - Heavy Rain

Heavy Rain Scott Shelby
Quantic Dream

The identity of the Origami Killer in Heavy Rain is an especially egregious example because the game doesn't even play fair about concealing its antagonist right in front of the player's face.

At the end of the game it's revealed that the killer is in fact one of Heavy Rain's playable characters, private investigator Scott Shelby.

The notion that you've been secretly playing the murderer yourself is an interesting one, albeit one the game absolutely fumbles by not being straight about it.

The player controls Shelby during a scene earlier in the game where the owner of an antiques store, Manfred, is murdered by the Origami Killer, seemingly making it impossible for Scott to be the culprit.

But as we later learn when the twist is revealed, Scott's perspective has actually been an unreliable one, and the version of the antiques store scene we played through earlier was one constructed in his own mind.

Given that Heavy Rain's gameplay is implied to be objective, it felt like a cheat to many players, who never had a chance of figuring out the twist because director David Cage effectively moved the dramatic goal posts without telling them. Terrible.


9. Clayface - Batman: Arkham City

Batman Arkham City Clayface
Rocksteady

In one of the most ingenious gaming bait-and-switches of the last decade, Batman: Arkham City reveals near its climax that the healthier Joker we've been interacting with for most of the game isn't actually the Clown Prince of Crime at all.

Rather, a very, very sick Joker - who is suffering from blood poisoning due to ingesting the Titan formula in the previous game, Arkham Asylum - has enlisted shapeshifting villain Clayface to assume his identity and pose as a less-sick version of himself.

It comes as quite the surprise to even the Dark Knight, and when the real Joker finally emerges he even gloats about the fact that he hid Clayface right in front of Batman, telling him, "So, how do you keep a secret from the world's greatest detective? Well, do you know? You stick it right in front of him, right under his long, pointy nose... and wait!"

Inquisitive players are able to figure out the twist early, however, by scanning the imposter in Detective Mode, where they'll see that he doesn't have a skeleton and therefore cannot be the real Joker.


8. Maya Brooks - Mass Effect 3: Citadel DLC

Mass Effect 3 Citadel Maya
BioWare

Mass Effect 3's Citadel DLC introducers players to Maya Brooks, a Staff Analyst in Systems Alliance intelligence, who warns Commander Shepard of an impending threat against their life while being presented as a klutzy and frantic but ultimately well-meaning person.

The story makes pains to build a fast bond between Brooks and Shepard after she's taken hostage and rescued by them, but as is revealed roughly half-way through Citadel's story, Brooks' noble persona and even her plummy British accent are actually a front.

Brooks is actually an ex-Cerberus operative who has been working with Shepard's clone to steal his identity, was responsible for setting up the ambush to try and kill Shepard, and also murdered Khan to cover her tracks. Oh, and when the chips are down she even ends up turning on the Shepard clone.

Finally, Brooks attempts to kill the Normandy's crew by sealing them in the iridium vaults without oxygen, and once she's subsequently captured, it's up to the player to decide whether to kill her or cut her loose.

Brooks had us all fooled with her appealingly perky personality and cute accent - who could've predicted she was actually an historically self-serving douchebag?


7. General Shepherd - Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2

Call Of Duty Modern Warfare 2 Shepherd
Activision

In what surely remains the most shocking and defeating plot twist in the entire Call of Duty franchise, Modern Warfare 2 dropped the late-game bombshell that mustachioed badass General Shepherd is actually the primary villain.

Despite being presented as nothing less than a great man hell-bent on prevent World War III between Russia and the U.S., it's eventually revealed that Shepherd has been secretly working to prolong the conflict, having organised the game's controversial airport massacre that first prompted Russia to declare war against America.

Shepherd wanted to take Makarov down less to avenge his fallen men from the first game than to cement himself as a national war hero, a psychotic goal to the extent that in one of the game's later levels, "Loose Ends," he shoots Roach and Ghost dead and sets their bodies on fire. Grim.

Players then take control of Soap for the rest of the game, and in one of the franchise's most satisfying moments to date, get to kill him by throwing a knife right in his eye.

Shepherd's betrayal was so traumatic for fans that it's been tough to fully trust even the most heroic ally ever since.


6. Mitch Conner - South Park: The Fractured But Whole

South Park: The Fractured But Whole Mitch Conner
Ubisoft

The brilliant South Park: The Fractured but Whole takes the notion of the hidden villain to hilariously self-parodying extremes by quite literally placing them in plain sight.

The game's ultimate antagonist is Mitch Conner, a hand puppet created by Eric Cartman by... literally just drawing a face on his hand.

Despite the protests of his friends, Cartman insists that he has no control over Mitch, who "possesses" him in order to his evil bidding.

Though it's made abundantly clear from early on that Mitch is nothing more than Cartman's crudely drawn hand puppet, this basically lures players into a false sense of security, assuming that this joke will eventually be disposed of and the real villain will eventually show themselves.

But no, Mitch really is The Fractured But Whole's ultimate baddie, plotting to cause enough chaos in South Park that he can unseat the current Mayor and take the job for himself. Yup.

The wacky final boss fight sees players battling not one but two Mitch Conners - one from an alternate universe - after which Mitch is killed by his "mother," another crude hand puppet that appears on Cartman's other hand.

Never change, South Park.


5. Liquid Snake - Metal Gear Solid

Metal Gear Solid Master Miller
Konami

Villain reveals don't get much more deliciously satisfying - or surprising! - than this.

In Metal Gear Solid one of Solid Snake's codec contacts is his long-time ally Master Miller, who provides advice and moral support throughout the adventure.

However, close to the end of the game Miller reveals that he's not actually Miller at all but in fact the game's primary antagonist, Snake's "brother" Liquid Snake.

Liquid has effectively been posing as Miller in an attempt to trick Snake into helping activate bipedal nuke launcher Metal Gear REX, which he consequently relays to Snake with gloriously hammy relish over the codec.

As for the real Miller? Colonel Campbell informs Snake that his body has just been discovered at his home, having been killed at least three days earlier as part of Liquid's plan to assume his identity.

Talk about a plot twist nobody saw coming - it's not even like Miller looked that much different to Liquid, but the act was so convincing that he was able to play Snake, and us, like a damn fiddle.


4. Phin - Spider-Man: Miles Morales

Spider-Man: Miles Morales Phin Tinkerer
Insomniac

Spider-Man: Miles Morales' Tinkerer is an interesting example because the supervillain's identity was hidden in plain sight through the sheer virtue of obviousness.

In the comics, the Tinkerer is the villainous alter-ego of Phineas Mason, and so when it was revealed that one of this game's supporting characters was Miles' friend Phin Mason, it seemed like players were being set up for a bait-and-switch twist.

Many fans understandably assumed that Phin was inserted into the game as a misdirect, and that the Tinkerer's identity would be swapped out for somebody else, but alas, at the end of the game's first act we learn that Phin is indeed the Tinkerer.

The game is sensible to get the reveal out of the way just a few hours into its story, because if this had been a late-game twist it would've gone down like a lead balloon.

And yet, Phin being the Tinkerer was still somewhat surprising in its own way simply because so many players had convinced themselves it was just too damn obvious to be true. Fans basically played themselves here.


3. Mark Jefferson - Life Is Strange

Life Is Strange
Square Enix

If a character seems a little too nice, it's usually too good to be true, as was confirmed by the first season of Life is Strange.

At the end of the game, it's revealed that, rather than any of the obvious suspects, it's Blackwell Academy's hip photography teacher Mark Jefferson that is actually responsible for Rachel Amber's death.

Despite presenting himself as a cool-yet-caring individual, we later learn that Jefferson has been drugging and kidnapping young girls and photograping them in order to capture their "innocence."

Though Jefferson claims it was actually his young ally Nathan Prescott who accidentally killed Rachel with a drug overdose, it was Jefferson's plan to kidnap her.

Jefferson subsequently killed Nathan for his mistake, and then attempts to kill both Chloe and Max - but not before taking some creepy-ass photos, of course.

Ultimately Jefferson is brought to justice at game's end, but let's face it, none of us predicted that the hot, supportive photography teacher introduced at the start of the game was going to be the Big Bad.


2. Mother Miranda - Resident Evil Village

Mother Miranda Resident Evil Village
Capcom

The Resident Evil franchise just loves its sneaky villain reveals, and Resident Evil Village served up quite the amusing one.

Throughout the game you'll come across an extremely old woman who speaks cryptically to Ethan about both his own predicament and the role of villainous cult leader Mother Miranda.

However, it's revealed following the battle with Heisenberg that this old woman isn't so much a follower of Miranda as Miranda herself, using her mold infection to change her appearance into an elderly woman who can spy on the local villagers without attracting suspicion.

Given that the old woman has been tacitly guiding the player along throughout the game, it made for quite the surprise that this eccentric yet seemingly harmless individual was the main antagonist all along.

While it was reasonable to expect some sort of payoff with the old lady, few could've anticipated that she would literally be the game's Big Bad hanging out in front of your face the whole time.


1. Darth Revan - Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic

Revan Reveal
BioWare

There's concealing the villain under the guise of a support character, and then there's concealing the villain as the freakin' player character themselves.

Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic's ending delivers an all-timer plot twist by revealing that Darth Revan, the legendary Sith Lord, is none other than the very person you've been controlling for the entire game.

Knights of the Old Republic is glaring proof that amnesia is a plot point that should always make you suspicious.

The player character is an amnesiac who wakes up onboard a Republic ship, but the truth is that as Revan they were actually betrayed by their Sith apprentice Malak and left for dead prior to the events of the game.

The Jedi Council then took custody of Revan and wiped his mind, dovetailing into the start of the game where the player assumes control of him as a blank slate.

Ultimately it's up to players whether they decide to revert Revan to his prior Dark Side ways or gravitate towards the Light, but never before or since has a video game so ingeniously dangled the overarching antagonist right in front of the player's face.

It is, inevitably, one of those brilliant plot twists you can really only get away with once.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.