10 Video Games So Good They Ruined Genres

GTA 5 makes everything else look rubbish.

There's nothing quite like playing a video game and having a moment of reflective clarity, where you appreciate you're not only playing something truly special, you might be playing one of the greatest games of all time.

It's a rare occurrence, of course, and may ultimately lead to a bizarre feeling of melancholy when you finally finish the game and move onto something else, well aware that it hasn't got a hope in hell of matching the 10/10 brilliance you just played.

That's certainly the case with these 10 spectacular titles, which dominated, reinvented and deconstructed their genres with such thorough creativity that they made every subsequent effort feel a bit underwhelming.

That's not to ignore the achievements of the many great games that followed these titles, but when a genre reaches a peak this absurdly high, there's only one way to go, and it sure ain't up.

These games all represent the mechanical epitome of their respective genres, holding onto first place no matter the glut of glossy AAA outings that might try to dethrone them...


10. Uncharted 2: Among Thieves

Uncharted 2 Among Thieves
Naughty Dog

The very first Uncharted may have been a solid PS3 launch title, but it was actually a relatively modest and unrefined start for what is now Naughty Dog's flagship AAA franchise.

Everything changed with the release of 2009's Uncharted 2: Among Thieves, then, which tightened up the movement and combat, ditched the painfully bad jet-ski sequences and basically gave the action-adventure blockbuster video game its defining "Jaws" moment.

Right from its perilous, unforgettable opening sequence, where Nathan Drake is hanging desperately from a train carriage, Uncharted 2 served up unprecedented cinematic thrills and never let up over the course of the entire game.

It murdered its genre brethren and left them for dead, such that the Tomb Raider franchise was left with no choice but to shamelessly imitate it (with relatively good results, in fairness).

Even as the budgets ramped up in later Uncharted entries, the franchise was always at its purest the second time around, as both the third and fourth games over-indulged a little in flashbacks and, er, all that damn crate platforming.

Uncharted 2 is a game so brilliantly genre-defining that most other devs aiming for the flighty, Indiana Jones-inspired tentpole thrills haven't even tried to match it. Even a decade later, it's still the presiding king.


9. Resident Evil 4

Resident Evil 4
Capcom

Resident Evil 4 represented a major creative risk for Capcom, reinventing the classic survival horror franchise to be more action-centric while ditching many of the series' established staples, namely tank controls, fixed camera angles and a limited number of saves.

Furthermore, RE4 massively ramped up the narrative scope, introduced a deep upgrade system, switched up the traditional zombie foes for the smarter and more imposing Ganados and featured several of the greatest boss fights in the history of the genre.

That the game moved away from the series' pure horror roots but was still focused so intently on tripwire tension and making the player feel uneasy at all times is a major achievement.

RE4 could've felt like a disastrous betrayal, but instead it not only rewrote the rule book on the survival horror genre, it had more than a few things to say about third-person shooters, too.

No matter how Earth-shatteringly brilliant Resident Evil 7 was (for the most part), RE4's expert fusion of high-octane action, overwhelming hordes of enemies and absurdly atmospheric locations make it the genre all-timer.


8. Burnout Paradise

Burnout paradise
Criterion

Burnout Paradise is a racing game so purely focused on fun above all else that it has pretty much said the last word on online racers...despite releasing back in 2008.

Paradise was the last mainline entry into the Burnout series before developer Criterion Games began to exit the racing game market, and the franchise went out on an absolute banger.

You see, Paradise introduced open-world, online racing to the series for the very first time, and did such a spectacular job with it that no other game, not even the Forza Horizon series, has quite been able to top it.

A million miles away from the glut of self-serious online racers out there, Paradise was only about racing as much as it was crashing, smashing through billboards and basically causing utter chaos in an online lobby with other players.

Enduring love for the game caused it to be remastered last year, ensuring that no matter how many terrible Need for Speed games might get released, and no matter the impressive steps Forza has taken, Burnout Paradise set a bar for online racers that has yet to be cleared.

Given that Burnout Paradise Remastered topped the sales charts last year - proof perfect of the continued hunger for its refined multiplayer sandbox - maybe one day Paradise will get the follow-up it truly deserves. EA does love money after all, right?

But until then, Paradise is the only online racer you really need to play.


7. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

The witcher 3 geralt
CDPR

The Witcher 3 is often cited as one of the greatest games of all time, and for damn good reason.

It is a game so committed to its astonishing storytelling and world-building that there are literally side quests with more nuance and detail than you'll find in the critical quest-line of other mainstream RPGs.

Released in May 2015, the game took the open-world RPG to new heights, filling its world with truly meaningful content rather than the expected fetch quest filler nonsense, not to mention a huge cast of endearing and memorable characters.

Going back to Bethesda's Skyrim or delving into Fallout 4 after playing The Witcher 3 illustrates just how shallow and barren those games are by comparison.

CD Projekt Red's RPG masterpiece nails the perfect balance of player freedom, with peripheral content that doesn't just feel like soulless busy-work.

You're doing yourself a disservice if you haven't poured dozens of hours into the game beyond the main story, and even for those who like to cut through the critical path and move on, there's a stupid amount of stupid-good content to check out.

Put the nostalgia for games like Final Fantasy VII aside and the truth becomes clear, that there's never been a AAA RPG as deep, mechanically sound or richly absorbing as The Witcher 3.


6. Call Of Duty 4: Modern Warfare

call of duty 4 modern warfare
Activision

Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare is unquestionably one of the most influential video games of all time, an unfathomably ground-breaking first-person shooter which changed both narrative and multiplayer shooters forever more.

For starters, its ultra-immersive, cinematic campaign kick-started a trend of me-too imitators, not least in its own series, which in a quest to recapture the glorious glory of Modern Warfare's blockbuster campaign, progressively ramped up both the shock value and the absurdity to cartoonish levels.

But more historic was Modern Warfare's re-shaping of online gunplay, introducing levelling and progression mechanics to a genre that had previously given players little incentive to keep playing beyond, you know, the fun of it.

The dopamine hit that came with every level up no doubt contributed to Modern Warfare's unprecedented commercial success (for both the franchise and the genre), and every subsequent AAA FPS trying to cash-in on its innovation.

And yet, how many other online FPS franchises can you even name, let alone profess to have played or even actively enjoy today?

Call of Duty may be a very different beast over a decade later, but as the 2016 release of Modern Warfare Remastered proved, the original has an enduring power that makes it as absurdly addictive today as it was in 2007.

No subsequent multiplayer FPS has managed to outdo it because, let's be honest, no other multiplayer FPS has that bloody brilliant Shipment map, right?


5. Rocket League

Rocket League
Psyonix

A slightly controversial opinion perhaps, but why the hell would you want to play actual football - or hell, actual sports - games when you can play car football instead?

Rocket League is the football game for people who don't like football games, or perhaps find FIFA too intimidating or too...football-y.

Melding rocket-powered vehicles with a simple yet effective sci-fi aesthetic, deceptively challenging physics-based mechanics and the fist-pumping emotion of the Beautiful Game, Rocket League is a rare game that's practically perfect, and still outrageously popular four years on.

FIFA and other like-minded sports titles may crank out new editions every year for your hard-earned dosh, but Rocket League launched for a budget price, and in addition to releasing tons of free updates to players - including brilliant ice hockey and basketball modes - developer Psyonix has deemed a cash-grab sequel "not likely."

There have of course been literally dozens of games attempting to cash-in on Rocket League's charm and success, but almost without exception, their initially enthusiastic player-base dwindles after the early excitement dies down.

Rocket League, on the other hand, now has over 50 million players, and is sure to endure with gamers for as long as nudging a giant football around with a motorised car sounds like something fun to do.


4. Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain

Metal Gear Solid V The Phantom Pain
Konami

Though its narrative was actually relatively disappointing, Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain nevertheless raised the bar for not only open-world third-person shooters, but the stealth genre.

More than any stealth game ever, MGSV gave players a mind-boggling level of choice when it came to approaching an individual sortie.

Thanks to the utterly ridiculous array of toys made available to the player, from Fulton balloons to air strikes, decoys, vehicles and all the typical guns, experimentation is a pure joy no matter the repetitious nature of the missions, making MGSV in many ways the definitive sandbox title.

Between the gorgeously realised open world and the sheer insane depth of the combat, stealth and traversal mechanics, it is a game that caters to all play-styles equally well, proving a rare democratic offering that doesn't feel like a compromise in any way (gameplay-wise, at least).

That the game still rules the stealth genre despite so blatantly fumbling its incomplete story is really the ultimate testament to how mechanically perfect it truly is.


3. Half-Life 2

Half Life 2
Valve

Half-Life 2 just might have been the most highly anticipated video game sequel ever, and that's really saying something.

Valve's 1998 original innovated the FPS genre in so many ways, and the weight of expectation on its follow-up was practically impossible to meet - and yet, they actually bloody did it.

To call Half-Life 2 a mere masterpiece is to understate the case quite a bit. In a landscape that has increasingly devalued FPS games with lengthy, substantial campaigns, HL2 remains one of the last true full-fat, blockbuster single-player shooters of its kind.

Ramping up the expertly-crafted set-pieces, outfitting the player with some outstanding weaponry (and vehicles!) and introducing a killer cast of new characters while soaked in pure atmosphere from first level to last, Half-Life 2 remains the best single-player FPS ever some 15 years (!) later.

Do you feel old yet?

With the dubious commercial success of narrative-driven FPS games in the years that followed - largely due to the success of Call of Duty's multiplayer - 12-hour FPS campaigns are virtually unheard of these days, Doom being the major exception.

Gamers generally have to just make do with bite-sized mini-campaigns that accompany the multiplayer suite - Titanfall's 4-hour campaign was fantastic, though.

But if you've played Half-Life 2 recently, you'll likely appreciate just how well it's withstood the test of time, and how it's unlikely to be toppled as the genre king any time soon.


2. Grand Theft Auto V

Michael GTA V
Rockstar

The Grand Theft Auto franchise has basically made a sport out of one-upping itself and redefining its genre with each new entry, especially since the series went the open-world route from GTA III onwards.

And truly, the most recent entry, GTA V, feels like Rockstar Games' most refined effort yet, striking an expert balance where the player has enormous amounts of freedom and very little of it invites tedium.

If San Andreas was a little too into its stat-management to the point of irritation, while GTA IV end up feeling a little bare, GTA V finds the sweet spot in-between.

But what really took GTA V to the next level for open-world shooters was the introduction of GTA Online and also the incredible character-switching gimmick, where players could swap between the game's three protagonists at the press of a button.

Throw in a deliciously entertaining cinematic story and arguably the greatest GTA protagonist of all time (Trevor, of course!), and you have a game that continues to smash sales milestones for damn fine reason.

Seriously, can there even be anyone left who doesn't own this game now?

And before you bring up Red Dead Redemption 2, it's fair to say that the game's lack of a character-switcher and its slower-paced, more pared-down approach to action means it doesn't quite have the definitive word on the genre.


1. Astro Bot: Rescue Mission

Astro Bot Rescue Mission
SIE Studio Japan

And now for something a little different - a VR genre! If you've spent much time in virtual reality, you'll likely have played your share of third-person platformers, and let's be honest, most of them tend to blur together a little too eagerly.

But not Astro Bot: Rescue Mission. No way.

It's not an exaggeration to say, as many have, that PSVR exclusive Astro Bot is the VR medium's Mario 64 moment - it represents a rubicon being crossed, a game literally being changed, with the added dimension and interactivity creating a more tactile platforming experience than ever before.

Astro Bot is separated from other VR platformers for several reasons. First and foremost, it places a huge emphasis on the interactivity between yourself and the adorable titular hero, while the VR tracking is out of this world, and the level design isn't just "good for a VR game" - it'd be downright terrific for an actual Mario game.

Astro Bot may not be a particularly challenging title, but given that you'll probably spend a ton of time staring slack-jawed as you move your head around the gorgeous levels, that's probably for the best. If you haven't played it yet, find someone, anyone willing to let you give it a whirl.

Befriend a stranger if you really have to - it's that good.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.