10 Video Games That Alienated Their OWN Fanbase

Maybe don't call your customers "freeloaders"?

Apex legends
Respawn

The gaming industry is currently in a good place. Riding the wave of a multiplayer boom, able to draw in a paying audience of millions, modern titles frequently have dedicated development teams that can elongate a games lifespan for years.

However, in order to achieve that long lasting success, an active and enthusiastic fan base is critical. With so many public platforms to vocalise how they feel, public backing can be the difference between success or failure.

The following titles have - a couple of exceptions aside - been a financial success, well reviewed by critics, or in some cases both. However, the one thing they all have in common is instances of upsetting their fan base, then paying the price in one way or another. Sometimes the mere existence of a game is enough to set fans on edge, setting that title up for failure.

Fan backlash can be far-reaching and devastating for a game's development. This ranges from being a minor blip, with fans quick to forgive and forget, to actively ruining the reputation of a major title and the studios behind it.

10. For Honor

For Honor
Ubisoft

When it first came on the scene, For Honor seemed like a unique look at one-on- one sword fighting. It was one of 2017s most anticipated games, and this was reflected in the huge sales it made in the first few months of release.

However, problems snowballed quickly. The matchmaking system was a huge issue, which had players spending minutes at a time looking at a blank screen, before being told they had been kicked out of the server.

The game itself was also marred by technical glitches and balancing issues. A For Honour tournament was won by a player who exploited a well known glitch which made his attacks faster and unblockable.

It was also revealed the developers were aware of this particular bug, and had received frequent complaints about it. Not only did the tournament showcase everything that was wrong with the game, it was also conducted on the biggest stage possible.

Add to all this the snafu with the game's economy (requiring 2.5 years of game time to unlock everything... or pay $752), and fans struggled to find any positives.

Although For Honor still boasts a reasonably active and loyal player base, its connectivity issues and glitchy design turned players away. With a little more love and care from the developers, this game could have been so much more.


9. Fallout 76

Fallout 76 13 toxic valley
Bethesda

Whilst not necessarily being the disaster it's been made out to be, Fallout 76 was still a blip in the timeline of a company fabled for making quality triple A titles.

Although Fallout games have never been famed for their visual qualities, Fallout 76 seemed to take a marked step down in the series. The colour palette was drab and unimaginative, and the graphics seemed to have regressed since Fallout 4.

The hallmark of the series, the V.A.T.S system, just wasn't suited to a multiplayer game. Worst of all, NPC's were virtually non-existent, making the world feel barren and uninteresting.

Long-time Bethesda fans weren't necessarily expecting a masterpiece here, particularly as this was the first attempt Bethesda made to bring the Fallout series into the multiplayer realm. Expectations were also tempered by the fact that previous attempts at online multiplayer games had a lukewarm reception.

However, nobody expected Fallout 76 to end up as rushed and unpolished as it was. This led fans to accuse Bethesda of rushing out a lacklustre game to make a quick buck. Although fans will no doubt look forward to their next release, their reputation as a purveyor of flawless games is now somewhat tarnished.


8. Star Wars Battlefront 2

Star Wars Battlefront 2
EA

Although roasting Battlefront 2 is commonplace in gaming circles, it can't be overstated how much of a good thing EA had with the property. Fixing fatal flaws from the first game? Check. Promising early footage of Rey kicking battle droids arses? Absolutely.

Loot boxes were implemented as the games main currency: the player could unlock in game rewards by grinding for hours to unlock in-game content or purchase loot boxes. Using the latter method, players could buy their way to victory, putting minimal effort into the game.

This caused a huge backlash at launch, with many gamers stating they would never buy the game, regardless of any improvements made further down the line. The feedback was so bad that Dice released a statement saying their intent was to "provide players with a sense of pride and accomplishment by unlocking different heroes". It remains the most downvoted comment in Reddit ever.

Although the loot box system was quickly removed, the damage had already been done. Despite being critically acclaimed, the backlash resulted in relatively poor sales, losing EA millions of dollars.

Although continuous support from the developers meant the game has eventually reached its potential, the damage had already been done.


7. Apex Legends

Apex Legends
EA

Once seen as a contender to Fortnite, Apex Legends leapt onto our consoles in February 2019. It boasted excellent shooting mechanics and an innovative ping system which allows you to communicate with other players without actually talking to them, and seemed like it had everything going for it.

Then, in season 2, the dreaded loot box system was introduced, making players pay for cosmetic items at massively inflated prices. This led to a stand off between fans and the developers at Respawn Entertainment.

Fan displeasure was met with the developers calling fans "freeloaders" and "asshats", among other stronger terms unsuitable for print. You don't need to be an industry expert to know that you can't build a loyal fan base if you start slagging them off when they disagree with one of your updates.

This disconnect between fans and developers, coupled with Respawn's reluctance to make major and frequent updates to the game, and some uninspiring battle passes, has led to a steady decline in users and streamers over time.

Recent updates have ensured it still packs a punch in the gaming market, but it is nowhere near the level we thought it would reach when it first burst onto the scene.


6. Resident Evil 6

Resident Evil 6
Capcom

The success of Resident Evil games eventually proved to be the downfall of the franchise. Resident Evil 4 introduced features seldom seen in a horror title: an over-the-shoulder viewpoint, quick time events and a move towards more visceral action. This was carried over to Resident Evil 6, and delivered on a much grander scale than its predecessors.

Resident Evil 6 was an ambitious yet underwhelming product.

While Leon's' campaign replicated the 'classic' survival horror feel of the originals, Chris' campaign was no more than a Gears of War rip off, using cover-and-shoot tactics alongside a grey and drab landscape.

Considering the high watermark of previous entries, Resident Evil 6 felt so far removed from what made the series so fun to play in the first place. This was reflected in overall sales of the game, the poor showing forcing Capcom to lower the company's financial projections for the year.

The negative feedback actually elevated Capcom's future efforts. They reverted back to the old school survival horror, which culminated in the release of Resident Evil revelations, and was the platform needed to create Resident Evil Biohazard, widely considered one of the best entries in the series.


5. Fortnite

Fortnite Battle Royale
Epic Games

Although Fortnite wasn't the first Battle Royale game to hit our consoles, it remains by far the most popular. Say what you like about the gameplay and annoying dances, it has become a cultural phenomenon, boasting a fan base of a staggering 250 million players.

In season 10, Epic introduced B.R.U.T.E.s, which were effectively walking mechs of death. For a game built around building mechanics, this took away a vital sense of balance.

These massively overpowered units of destruction had a rocket attack which could destroy players and buildings alike in one shot.

Epic Games explained that their inclusion was designed to "bring players of all skill levels together...where anyone can win". As admirable as this sounds, longtime fans saw their inclusion as a complete imbalance to the game. Fans immediately took to Twitter in their droves to voice their displeasure.

As a result, Epic Games finally backed down, removing the B.R.U.T.E.S from all competitive and casual matches.

Although Fortnite hardly suffered as a result, it does prove that in certain cases, enough of a fan backlash can make even the most seemingly untouchable developers back down.


4. DmC: Devil May Cry

DMC Devil May Cry
Capcom

In many ways this game was doomed from the start. The main bone of contention was the redesign of series protagonist Dante, who now looked younger and more brooding. This was part of a drive by developers Ninja Theory to appeal to a new generation of gamer, and to make a distinct mark on the series.

Ninja Theory's creative director was determined to stick with the new design, explaining that "If Dante, dressed as he was, walked into any bar outside of Tokyo, he'd get laughed out".

However, the controversy surrounding DmC was not singularly about Dante's new look. It was a tug of war between fans who wanted more of the same, and the developers, who saw this as their chance to reboot the series and start afresh.

Upon release, the game was met with critical acclaim, receiving praise particularly for its engaging story and excellent level design. However, the sales figures tell a different story. Initial targets of 2 million copies were sharply revised to 1.2 million copies actually sold.

The differing visions of fans and creators of such a beloved franchise only served to create uncertainty on the direction of the series, ultimately harming the games legacy.


3. Aliens: Colonial Marines

Aliens Colonial Marines Xenomorph
SEGA

The Alien universe has one of the most readily available player bases in gaming, boasting titles spanning almost the entire history of video games. One of the most anticipated of these titles was Aliens: Colonial Marines.

From the trailer at least, fans were promised great things. It was a love letter to James Cameron's Aliens, keeping the same grimy aesthetic, as well as keeping the iconic setting from the film. The game was also considered canon, and promised to resolve some major plot holes from the films.

Upon release, the final product seemed half finished and rushed, the graphics looking worse than they did in the trailers. It was extremely buggy, and the AI was virtually broken. A particular highlight involved xenomorphs strutting past the player, oblivious to their presence as if on their lunch break.

This culminated in fans taking Sega to court, arguing that the gameplay and visuals from early footage was far removed from the final game. Sega finally settled out of court for a cool $1.25 million, causing them major financial and reputational damage.

Although fans eventually got the Alien game they deserved with Alien: Isolation, there was major regret at what game Aliens: Colonial Marines could have been.


2. Metal Gear Survive

Metal Gear Survive
Konami

Metal Gear Solid with zombies. Although it's an intriguing premise, in reality it didn't live up to expectations. The game had you alternating between killing zombies, base management and resource grinding in a repetitive cycle.

Series creator Hideo Kojima was always a big part of the appeal of the Metal Gear series, and his absence on Metal Gear Survive was notable, after a spectacular public fallout with Konami. The originality and humour that was such a trademark of Kojima was not evident in any way here.

Any resemblance to its predecessor The Phantom Pain was unflattering, reusing many of the same mechanics and visuals. It felt to fans like the developers did not have enough consideration as to how this would fit into the franchise as a standalone story.

The overall package was so far removed from what constitutes a Metal Gear Solid game that there was little to no appeal to fans of the series. While this game was by no means terrible, it was so far removed from what constituted a Metal Gear game, that the most fans could do was greet it with indifference.


1. Sonic Boom: Rise Of Lyric

Sonic Boom
Sega

Although there have been below par Sonic games in the past, none have been so spectacularly misjudged as Sonic Boom: Rise of Lyric.

Classic Sonic games had the player flying through levels at break-neck speed, jumping on enemies heads and collecting rings. With Rise of Lyric, entire sections of game would grind to a halt.

Combat was slow and monotonous, and the 'puzzle' sections were usually nothing more than pressing switches. The game was severely laggy, the frame rate dropping alarmingly during the 'running' sections of the game, making it borderline unplayable.

It also contains one of modern gaming's most infamous glitches. By manipulating Knuckles' double jump ability, players could skip entire levels and 'complete' the game in less than an hour. This astonished players as to how a flaw so fundamental could be overlooked before release.

Furthermore, it was clear to fans of the franchise even before release that this was one to stay away from. Early footage of the game was poorly received, and the developers did little to improve the game. As a result, Rise of Lyric has now been labelled as the most critically panned and worst selling Sonic game of all time.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Apex Legends
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

James Brigginshaw hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.