10 Video Games That Blatantly Ripped Off Iconic Franchises
"Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery."
Video games are constantly being compared to one another. Sonic's a faster Mario, Battlefield is a more realistic Call of Duty. The comparisons never end. Sometimes they foster rivalries that help both sides thrive. Other times a game is actually just a shameless clone of the other and lawyers get involved...
The more successful that something is, the more likely it is that it'll get copied. Think about how many first-person shooters showed up after Call of Duty took off. A certain genre that involves 100 players is reenacting that same situation now.
If you want to see what an undebatable rip-off looks like, just search up the Chinese version of practically any game out there. Final Combat is just Team Fortress 2 with different names, Overwatch has multiple Chinese rip-offs (and just rip-offs in general) like Hero Mission and League of Titans.
What we're about to go over are some of gaming's most infamous (and successful) rip-offs. The ones that are famous enough to have reputations beyond just being copycats. Some of them will be good, some will be bad, but all of them will be unoriginal.
10. PlayStation All-Stars Battle Royale
The Game: Once upon a time, Sony decided they wanted all of their most iconic characters to do battle. In 2009, they began development on a game that would pit Kratos, Nathan Drake, Fat Princess and more all against each other in one epic brawl.
PlayStation All-Stars Battle Royale was released on 20 November 2012 for the PlayStation 3 and PlayStation Vita. It was a crossover fighting game that revolved around beating blue orbs out of your opponents and then collecting them. Doing so would build up a super meter. Each character's super move got three levels, with each level being more useful than the last. They were the only moves that could kill opponents, so they were pretty important.
The Game It Ripped Off: Super Smash Bros.
PlayStation All-Stars was essentially Sony's version of Nintendo's Super Smash Bros. The series' massive success was no doubt why Sony wanted a title like it for themselves. Development even began one year after Nintendo released Super Smash Bros. Brawl for the Nintendo Wii.
PS All-Stars suffered from many issues. Its single-player campaign was low-budget and lackluster in comparison to Brawl's Adventure Mode. Its reliance on using super moves to kill opponents wasn't popular either. The game received mixed to positive reviews and relatively low sales. At least four DLC characters were planned, but only two were released. The other two were canceled due to the first two not selling well.
PlayStation All-Stars' servers were shut down on 31 January 2019. The game never had a sequel. It wasn't an awful game, but it failed the second that it tried to replicate such a successful and beloved title.
9. Crash Team Racing
The Game: Crash Bandicoot is traditionally a platformer about an anthropomorphic bandicoot who spins to defeat his foes. That all changed when Naughty Dog decided that they wanted to make a kart racer.
Crash Team Racing was released on 30 September 1999 for the original PlayStation. It put Crash and all his colorful friends in karts and had them race each other on at least 16 courses. Driving through one of the series' signature crates would reward the racer with a powerup.
The Game It Ripped Off: Mario Kart/Diddy Kong Racing.
By the time CTR released in 1999, Super Mario Kart had already released in 1992, and Diddy Kong Racing had released in 1997. Kart racing games had existed before either of them, but those two were the most popular in their genre at the time. During development, Naughty Dog even rebuilt a track from Diddy Kong Racing called "Crescent Island" to see if the PlayStation could handle something like it.
While CTR is based on the other two kart racers, it's actually far from a cheap knockoff. CTR did a good job of being different enough to set itself apart from the other two. It's amassed its own following of fans that believe it to be better than the other two kart racers. The fact that it's getting an HD remake in the form of Crash Team Racing Nitro-Fueled is proof of its popularity.
8. Bubsy
The Game: Bubsy in: Claws Encounters of the Furred Kind was the very first game in a franchise, named after its protagonist. The game was released for the Sega Genesis and Super Nintendo in 1993. It was one of many platforming games that were released around that time. As such, it revolved around collecting yarn balls and gliding around the environment.
What set Bubsy apart from the other platforming mascots was how often he made quips. Bubsy made a comment every time you started a new level. It was as if Iron Man took the form of a bobcat and went around collecting yarn.
The Game It Ripped Off: Sonic the Hedgehog.
Bubsy wasn't alone in copying Sonic. As previously mentioned, a lot of mascot-focused side-scrolling platformers were released around that time period. The problem was how poor a job Bubsy did at being a literal copycat.
Bubsy was a platformer that incorporated fall damage into its gameplay. If you fell from a high platform and you didn't glide before hitting the ground, you'd die. That was just one of the many flaws that befell the Bubsy series.
Bubsy is a franchise that's somehow still going today, but no one's happy about it. Bubsy only sells copies ironically now. People buy his games because they're bad. Not that the reason for buying them really matters to the developers' bank accounts.
7. Dante's Inferno
The Game: Dante's Inferno is based on an Italian poem known as the Divine Comedy, in particular the first part of the same name. The game is about a Templar knight named Dante who has to fight through the nine Circles of Hell to rescue his lover, Beatrice Portinari.
Dante's Inferno is an action-adventure title with platforming and just a dash of puzzle-solving. It's pretty ambitious, and even had DLC and an animated film titled Dante's Inferno: An Animated Epic.
The Game It Ripped Off: God of War.
Dante's Inferno's biggest challenge was being compared to Sony's God of War, which was one of their most popular franchises, and remains so to this day. Like Dante's Inferno, God of War is also an action-adventure title with platforming and puzzle-solving. The two games even have extremely similar combat systems.
Despite taking so much inspiration from another game, Dante's Inferno isn't awful. It received average reviews with the main complaint being that the game lost creativity and got more repetitive toward its end. It was rumored to receive a sequel, but that never happened.
6. Fortnite Battle Royale
The Game: It's important to stress that the game being discussed here is Fortnite Battle Royale, not Fortnite: Save the World, which is its companion game. Interestingly enough, both titles are still technically in early access. That doesn't stop them from ruling the gaming world. Especially Battle Royale, which gets much more attention than Save the World, even though the latter is the original product.
If you've somehow never heard of Fortnite Battle Royale, it's exactly what it sounds like: a battle royale game. 100 players drop into an area, and only one person (or group of people) survives the massive skirmish that ensures. The genre exploded in popularity when Fortnite BR came out, even though it was far from the first Battle Royale game ever made.
The Game It Ripped Off: Player Unknown's Battleground (PUBG)
PUBG was the most popular BR of its time until Fortnite came along many months later. Fortnite Battle Royale wouldn't even exist if PUBG hadn't exploded onto the scene first. That's why it's safe to say that Fornite "ripped-off" PUBG specifically, even though that game was also far from being the first BR.
Battle Royale owes its roots to mods, add-ons, and a movie. The Hunger Games was a 2012 film that inspired Minecraft Hunger Games, which were a series of servers modded to feature multiplayer matches that echoed the movie's experience.
Then there was DayZ, which was a mod for Arma II. Then there was the PUBG mod for Arma III, which predates the official game by about 3 years. While the BR mods aren't as popular as the BR standalones, they're still the building blocks of a genre that has dominated the gaming market for the past few years.
5. Mighty No. 9
The Game: Actually, it's pretty hard to talk about this one without mentioning what it's ripping off.
The Game It Ripped Off: Mega Man.
Mighty No. 9 exists solely to be a spiritual successor to the Mega Man franchise - back when it actually needed one. In 2013, Keiji Inafune (former producer of the Mega Man series) decided to start a Kickstarter campaign for Mighty No. 9 in an effort to develop a new Mega Man-type game all on his own. The Kickstarter met its $900,000 goal in just two days.
If the game's development went as smoothly as it should have, then this wouldn't be considered a rip-off. Unfortunately, the Kickstarter was marred by mismanagement, poor communication, and constant delays. By the time that the game finally came out, the fans had already lost any hope that it'd resemble the concept they paid to fund. Many fans didn't get to play the game at all due to receiving broken game codes.
Upon release, Mighty No. 9 received negative reviews due to numerous issues. It featured bland levels and frustrating gameplay. Despite having a budget of $4 million, it failed to have the quality to match. Many reviewers dismissed it as a cheap imitation of the series that it was trying to replace. Those reviewers were pretty spot-on.
4. The Simpsons: Road Rage
The Game: The Simpsons: Road Rage is a 2001 game that's based on the hit TV show that literally everyone has heard of. It tasks the player with driving around, picking up citizens, and taking them wherever they need to go. It's like you're a taxi driver or something.
The Game It Ripped Off: Crazy Taxi.
Sega's Crazy Taxi featured the exact same premise but was released two years earlier. It was also much better than its clone, which was criticized for being a lackluster version of Sega's title.
The similarities were so apparent that Sega filed a lawsuit against Fox, EA, and Radical Entertainment (Road Rage's developers) in 2003. Sega claimed that Road Rage was a patent infringement of Crazy Taxi. Seeing as most of Road Rage's reviewers even commented on the similarities, Fox didn't have much of a defense. The case was settled privately for an undisclosed amount.
3. Dangerous Driving
The Game: Dangerous Driving is a racing game that involves a lot more crashing than the likes of Forza. This is a game where you're allowed to ram into your opponents. Doing so will make them crash and explode in a fiery burst of satisfaction. Here, being aggressive may get you first place rather than a penalty.
The Game It Ripped Off: Burnout.
Dangerous Driving was developed by Three Fields Entertainment, which is an indie game studio composed of former Criterion Games employees. Criterion were the geniuses behind Burnout, which was the original aggressive-racing game. This makes Dangerous Driving a spiritual sequel rather than a total rip-off.
The only problem is that Dangerous Driving failed to make that sort of impact (pun somewhat intended). Seeing as the game is essentially Burnout without its budget, DD is merely a shadow of its spiritual self.
EA also tried to revive the aggressive-racing genre when they released Burnout Paradise Remastered in 2018. Even though that game soared to the top of the sales charts during its first week, it also failed to make an impact. Burnout is an amazing franchise that deserves to return, but hopefully, its next attempt is better than Dangerous Driving.
2. Yooka-Laylee
The Game: Yooka-Laylee is a platforming game about a chameleon and a bat that are tasked with exploring colorful worlds. They do so in search of items known as "Pagies." Along the way, they learn new abilities that make it easier to traverse and explore their surroundings. It's a fun formula - one that's rarely done nowadays.
The Game It Ripped Off: Banjo-Kazooie
Once again, this is a spiritual-successor-gone-somewhat-wrong situation. Banjo-Kazooie is an extremely popular video game that got a sequel, and a weird racing spin-off, but never a true third game. Rare (the game studio that made Banjo) decided to focus on titles that weren't Banjo-Kazooie for a while. This left fans desperate for something that would bring them the same sense of joy.
Enter Playtonic Games, a studio made up of former Rare employees. Using the power of Kickstarter (a very popular power back then), they developed Yooka-Laylee in an attempt to satisfy their fans' thirst.
When Yooka-Laylee was released, it only received lukewarm reviews. It was criticized for feeling outdated and bland. The frustrating camera and controls earned complaints as well.
Yooka-Laylee went on to receive patches that fixed some issues, such as the camera. Just recently, Playtonic Games announced a sequel titled Yooka-Laylee and the Impossible Lair. It's in 2.5D rather than the original title's 3D. It seems to feature gameplay that's inspired by Donkey Kong Country - and hopefully won't ape the past too much like its predecessor.
1. Saints Row
The Game: Saints Row is an open world action-adventure franchise. It centers around the Third Street Saints, a gang that does criminal stuff like shoot guns and steal cars.
As the franchise progressed, it grew more absurd. Saints Row The Third even featured a parody of horde mode called Whored Mode. The series' absurdity reached its peak with its (possibly) final main entry, Saints Row 4. That title introduced aliens and bestowed the Third Street Saints with superpowers.
The Game It Ripped Off: Grand Theft Auto
Saints Row vs. Grand Theft Auto has been a debate ever since Saints Row launched. The very first Saints Row game was released in 2006, which was almost ten years after the first Grand Theft Auto in 1997. Saints Row has come under constant fire for being a "Grand Theft Auto clone," but being a clone was never its intention. One of the development team's main goals while creating Saints Row 2 was to establish a unique identity for the franchise. A goal that they managed accomplish.
Saints Row has come to be known as the funnier, more ridiculous version of Grand Theft Auto. The Whored Mode and the superpowers mentioned earlier were established to further that identity. Unfortunately, the quality of the games couldn't keep up with GTA. The latter series is still going strong today while Saints Row seems to be on hiatus. If the Third Street Saints ever return, it'll probably be in the form of yet another ridiculous adventure.