10 Video Games That Didn’t Know When To End

"You could face the final boss, but first you must gather EIGHT more items..."

bad video game endings
Nintendo/Konami/2K

How long should a video game be? It€™s an interesting question, and while many fall on different sides of the debate, there are plenty of examples of games that are objectively too short when their proposed asking price enters the equation, or those that drag on for far too long for seemingly no reason.

It happens more often than you think: Perhaps a story-heavy game gets derailed or overstretched by too many areas or character introductions, or repetition sets in (hello, Far Cry Primal) leading swiftly to boredom and the need to play something else. Or maybe a game is just so outright bad thanks to a lack of overall polish, that it feels way longer than it actually is.

The following are only a handful of such titles; experiences that, for one reason of another, feel like their logical closure points passed them by on the way to some far-off credits...

10. Bioshock

2K Games

There are actually two endings to Bioshock, the first of which is the confrontation and resolution with Andrew Ryan. It is a showstopper moment and a perfect way to end the game... until that stops being the case, and Irrational's baby goes on for a little while longer.

Once Andrew Ryan dies, Frank Fontaine becomes the final villain, and unlike the former, the latter is not nearly as interesting, which makes the final stretch to find him and finish him off kind of a slog. It feels like it should be over, but instead pushes you towards a traditional final boss fight just for the sake of it. Fontaine's final form isn€™t particularly inspired, and honestly, this showdown felt beneath a game as artistically innovative as Bioshock overall.

You could argue that this time is used to wrap up the lose ends of the plot, but it could have been done in a more economical way, allowing for the high of the Andrew Ryan confrontation to remain as the credits roll. Bioshock draws its plot out and ends in a way that almost all agree, simply doesn€™t live up to the standards of everything that preceded it.


9. L.A. Noire

l.a. noire
Rockstar

L.A. Noire starts out with an engagingly simple premise, placing you in the role of Cole Phelps at the beginning of his career in law enforcement. As Cole successfully solves more crimes, he continually gets promoted until he becomes a full fledged homicide investigator, where he is forced to face the darker aspects of humanity. It€™s classic noire storytelling, and this is where L.A. Noire excels the most.

At some point though the story takes a significant turn into a grand conspiracy involving real estate for veterans, which dips further into Cole€™s past during World War II. Gone are the dark alleyways and shadowy murders, replaced with something much bigger but less compelling. The game keeps going in this direction, and the longer it goes on, the more repetitive the investigation gameplay becomes.

L.A. Noire even resorts to changing character perspectives partway through in order to add more hours to the story, which ruins the pacing and detaches you from what you care about. Had L.A. Noire kept its feet firmly planted in the more straightforward and evocative story beats of its early sections while focusing more on the personal life of Cole, it would have made the ending more efficient and satisfactory. Instead, the game starts out strong but drags out until it ends with a whimper.


8. Mario & Luigi: Partners In Time

mario and luigi partners in time
Nintendo

Mario and Luigi€™s second adventure on the DS has them adventuring through time to save Princess Peach (again) from the nefarious Princess Shroob. In the end the Mario Bros. finally confront her for a final battle, upon which she is defeated. But that€™s not the end. In fact, it€™s just the beginning of a protracted battle with multiple stages and false endings.

First Baby Bowser completes the Cobalt Star, which releases Elder Princess Shroob. You fight her not once but twice, her second form taking even longer to defeat. And just when you think it€™s finally over and everything is returning back to normal, she appears again to possess Bowser in the present time line for one last fight.

The Elder Princess Shroob is a great example of a villain that just won€™t stay down, and her persistence stretches the ending out to absurd lengths. After each fight you think the game will be over but she pops up again in a different form, making you wish that she€™d just die already so you can beat the game and see the Mario Bros. save the Mushroom Kingdom once again.


7. Yggdra Union: We'll Never Fight Alone

Yggdra union
Sting Entertainment

Yggdra Union is the second episode in the Dept. Heaven series, and tells the story of Yggdra, the Princess of Fantasinia, as she attempts to reclaim her kingdom from the invading Bronquian Empire . The story concludes with the defeat of Gulcasa, the leader of the Bronquian Empire, or at least it should have.

Suddenly Nessiah, a character that was thought to be dead, appears and reveals that he is the mastermind behind everything. Nessiah becomes the new big bad and you are forced to face him in a battle that extends way past what would have been a logical closing point. It€™s not that Nessiah isn€™t an interesting character; in fact he very much is, and that€™s why forcing him into the end doesn€™t work. He could have been the antagonist in whole other episode in the series.

It€™s yet another case of a video game throwing in another final boss just for its own sake, rather than knowing when to resolve the plot.


6. Chrono Cross

Chrono Cross
Square

The amount of dramatic expansion that goes on in Chrono Cross, the sequel to Chrono Trigger, is down right amazing. Almost the entire second disc is one long drawn out extended conclusion that piles one major antagonist after another.

For much of the game a powerful super computer named FATE is established as the main antagonist. However, he is merely the beginning, and his defeat only makes way for an even greater threat, the Dragon God, a merging of six elemental dragons that threatens the entire world. Finally, just after you defeat Dragon God, yet another massive threat sprouts up in the form of the Time Devourer, and at this stage you wonder just when all this insanity will end.

The lengths to which Chrono Cross goes to keeps things moving forward is admirable, but regardless of how much you enjoy it (and there is much to enjoy), it cannot be denied that there is a narrative hierarchy that inflates the plot to absurd heights. It€™s all entertaining, but not the least bit elegant in the way it tells its story, especially with regards to its multiple false endings.


5. Doom 3

doom 3
iD Software

At some point in Doom 3 you are forced to make your way into Hell itself and retrieve the Soul Cube, which is protected by a monster called The Guardian. This whole section feels like the natural ending point of the story; after all, it's only right that a game that pits you against hordes of demons should conclude in the depths of Hell. From a basic story structure, it just.makes.sense.

And yet... Doom 3 doesn€™t do this. While you might be thinking that things are starting to wrap up, in actuality the trip to Hell is only about two-thirds of the way through. Upon retrieving the Soul Cube you still have tons of shooting to do back on Mars, and while this final stretch is arguably the most thrilling and action-packed part of the game, it does feel like the story continues past its logical closing point.

There should have been more build up, and by relegating Hell to being a minor pit stop instead of the final destination that it should have been, it was robbed of its full emotional impact.


4. Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 3

persona 3 ending
Atlus

In many ways a simulation game as much as it is an RPG, Persona 3 takes place over a year as you attend high school while also using your Persona to combat beings called Shadows, who feed on the minds of conscious humans. You spend the majority of the game alternating between developing relationships with your classmates and journeying into the Tartarus to fight Shadows.

Everything progresses nicely until at a certain point it all grinds to a halt. Suddenly the story lacks the momentum that had advanced the plot prior. For two in-game months there is a distinct lack of things to do other than maintain your relationships with the other characters while the story meanders in superfluous directions. It feels like the game is stalling for time before reaching its climax.

While it€™s true that this down time is used to further develop the relationships between the characters, it comes at the expense of the ending. The timeline should have been spaced out more to accommodate these narrative demands, but instead you get a whole lot of filler that only delays the inevitable.


3. .Hack//G.U. Vol. 3: Redemption

hack redemption
CyberConnect2

There€™s a moment in Redemption, the third and final chapter of the .hack//G.U. series, where everything feels like its coming to a close. Ovan uses his Avatar to reset The World, waking up the comatose players while sacrificing himself in the process. It€™s character driven, bittersweet, and would have made for a satisfying ending.

But then Yata reveals that Cubia, a major antagonist from the previous series of .hack games, is back and threatening to destroy The World. This leads to hours of more gameplay that feels tacked on and detached from the main plot that preceded it. It€™s superfluous, uninteresting, and feels like a misguided attempt to both extend the length of the game and call back to the prior series.

Redemption is one of the clearest cases you can find of a game that doesn€™t know when to stop. Its final hours come at the expense of the narrative; damaging it and detracting from a moment that would have served as a fine ending. By the time it actually finishes, you€™ll only remember its uninspired final hours.


2. The Legend Of Zelda: The Wind Waker

wind waker sad
Nintendo

The Legend of Zelda series is certainly no stranger to fetch quests, but The Wind Waker contains what just might be one of the most poorly placed and tedious in the franchise€™s history. Just as the story feels like its coming to a head, the King of Hyrule sends Link on a quest to find the scattered shards of the Triforce of Courage, of which there are eight. It€™s not until you find all of these that you can fight Ganon.

The problem with this quest is that it comes at the tail end of the game, and the sheer length of time it takes to complete it drags the ending momentum to a screeching halt. Not only do you have to find the shards, but before you can locate them you have to find the Triforce Charts. That€™s a lot of fetching to be doing at a time when the story should be escalating to its conclusion.

Had the Triforce Shards quest been integrated into the narrative earlier and spaced out more, this wouldn€™t have been a problem. The game would have been just as long but without the pacing issues that come in at the end. Instead, the entire quest is dumped on you just as The Wind Waker draws to a close, and the negative effect it has on the plot can easily be felt as a result.


1. Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns Of The Patriots

metal gear solid 4 ending
Konami

When it comes to never ending-endings, the Metal Gear franchise is an embarrassment of riches. The series has built a reputation on its record-breakingly long cutscenes; sporting complicated and convoluted plots that take hours to wrap up. While many entries in the franchise fall pray to this habit, it€™s Metal Gear Solid 4 that is perhaps the most extreme example, especially in its final moments.

'Succinct' is the last world you would ever use to describe Metal Gear Solid 4€™s ending. From the moment the final battle with Revolver Ocelot begins, this conclusion runs over an hour long. That€™s nearing the length of a feature length film. Characters drone on and on explaining various plot points and waxing poetic about this and that. It just keeps going and going, and it€™s all told through cutscenes, which can be an endurance test, especially when it feels like there is no end to the ending in sight.

Metal Gear Solid 4 does have a lot of story to tell however, and so its inability to conclude in a timely fashion is understandable. Still, video games have the most diverse set of tools with which to tell a story, and so you have to wonder if this game could have done so in a way that doesn€™t wear on your patience.

What other video games went on for too long? Let us know in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Film and video game obsessed philosophy major raised by Godzilla, Goku, and Doomguy.