10 Video Games That Forced You To Answer Impossible Questions

The video game equivalent of would-you-rather.

A lot of people like to play the hero in games. If a game throws them a moral dilemma, a blatant choice between a right and a wrong, rather than judge the potential merits of each option and decide what would be most beneficial, they'll most likely just make the most ethical decision available to them. If the choice is between killing a person and not killing them, they don'€™t kill them; equally, a lot of people will take the time to laboriously save a character from certain demise if that option is presented to them. It's nice to be nice after all.

Luckily for them, this philosophy tends to work to their advantage most of the time. Though the negative and positive options in a game are usually presented equally, most games tend to reward the player in the long run for playing it straight. Murdering someone in an Elder Scrolls game for example might get you some nifty loot, but you'€™ll regret that decision once everyone openly hates you, refusing you information and declining your offers to barter.

Part of the problem is that the morality systems in video games can be a little weak: the options and their consequences are blatantly obvious, and playing the good guy is nearly always more worthwhile that playing the baddy. But that€™'s not always the case. Sometimes, a game will come along and pose a question so difficult that it may as well be impossible to answer.

In these cases, there'€™s no right and wrong answer, no winning or losing; it'€™s just about making the best of a bad situation. These decisions will have you choosing between equal dismal choices, trying to ascertain the the lesser of two evils, deciding the fate of friends or even determining the fate of entire civilisations.

As a player, these decisions create an overhanging worry that you'€™ll miss out on parts of the game, or that your decisions will cause irreversible damage that will affect the ending, or that you'€™ll get your favourite characters unnecessarily maimed or killed.

Watch the video version of this article here or read article below...


10. The Walking Dead: Season One

Season 1, Episode 2. After suffering through the most nightmarish day imaginable and witnessing some fairly horrendous sights, the survivors are left directionless and without shelter, their rations now entirely depleted and their morale quickly plummeting.

Just as things seem at their absolute worst, the gang find an abandoned car in the middle of the road, loaded with boxes upon boxes of supplies.

The Decision: Should you take the food and possibly condemn another group of survivors to death, or risk starvation yourself? Granted, even in the most desperate of situations, stealing from someone in the exact same situation as you is fairly unambiguously wrong, but keep in mind, the car is completely abandoned.

There are signs that someone was here quite recently, but who knows if they'€™ll ever be back to collect their stuff. You could just be leaving it to go completely to waste. If you've finished every episode, you'€™ll know that the decision may have lasting consequences, but at such an early stage in the game, there'€™s just no way to know.


9. Spec Ops: The Line

Deep in enemy territory, the 33rd have rounded up a group of innocent civilians, as well as Agent Gould. Gould, a leader of the refugees has already saved your team on one occasion; he€™'s also responsible for saving the lives of countless civilians from the merciless 33rd. Now that he€™ has been captured, his interrogators are slowly killing their other prisoners in order to extract information, information that could prove vital.

The Decision: Do you attempt to save Agent Gould from his captors, thereby putting the civilians in the line of fire, or prioritise the lives of the civilians over Gould? In both cases, action must be taken; one option is a direct assault and the other is a more tactful offensive that minimises the risk of innocent causalities.

I suppose the decision really comes down to boldness or subtlety; in war, either could prove correct depending on the situation. Like many of the decisions throughout Spec Ops: The Line, neither choice will result in the desired outcome. It€™'s not about trying to mediate a peaceful solution, but rather minimise the destructive consequences of whatever you do decide to do.


8. Fallout 3: The Pitt

Formerly Pittsburgh, The Pitt has become a haven for slavers to exploit the work of the countless slaves who occupy the city. Under the rule of Lord Ashur, order is maintained using intimidation and deadly force, the slaves essentially beaten and murdered if they refuse to work tirelessly in the steel mill producing weapons and equipment for their masters.

Though Ashur may sound irredeemably evil, he attempts to justify his actions using the Troglodyte Degeneration Contagion, a nasty disease that prevents childbirth and eventually turns those infected into mindless beasts who attack on sight.

Under such conditions, Ashur argues that The Pitt would not be able to sustain itself without the use of slave labour. However, Ashur€™s daughter, Marie, may embody a possible cure to the contagion. She also represents a bargaining chip for the people of The Pitt to finally end their perpetual slavery.

The Decision: Do you kidnap Marie in order to end slavery in The Pitt, or allow her mother and father to continue their research and possible, one day, cure the Troglodyte Degeneration Contagion?

It€™'s a case of immediate verse eventual result, and there€™s certainly no right or wrong answer with this one.


7. Mass Effect 2

The Geth have been a plague on the galaxy since they were created by the Quarians to act as a source of slave labour. Gaining sentience, the Geth quickly turned on their masters and decimated their numbers to mere thousands. However, despite their destructive capabilities and threat to the galaxy, the Geth€™s artificial intelligence does still represent a valid form of sentient awareness.

The Decision: Boarding the Heretic station with the goal of releasing a virus to incapacitate the Geth, do you rewrite their behavioural programs or destroy them? The former signifies a major violation of their rights as an intelligent species, reducing them to slaves with no power over their own actions, and the latter eradicates them.

A life of slavery or a quick demise: not an easy decision.


6. Deus Ex

Having finally put a stop to insane, billionaire Bob Page and his plans to conquer the world, you€™re left with the very important question of what to do with it. The first option is to side with the illuminati and rule the world in secret, preventing anyone like Page from ever rising to power again; the second choice is merging with the HELIOS AI and becoming an omnipotent, benevolent ruler who answers to no one; the third option is destroying the facility and restoring power to the people.

The Decision: Do you merge with the HELIOS AI, join with the illuminati or just blow the whole thing to kingdom come? Destroying the facility gives power to the people, but it also sends the world back into the dark ages. On the other hand, merging with HELIOS grants you complete power to make the change you want to see in the world, but there's something about an individual having all that power that just does not sit right.

Finally, you can join the illuminati, putting non-elected groups in major positions of power throughout the world, positions that could be easily abused. Unfortunately, regardless of what you decide, the sequel somewhat merges all endings together, meaning they're all canon.


5. Skyrim

Skyrim is a good example of a game that oversimplifies moral choices, usually forcing the player to choose between a blatantly good and bad option. However, there is one question that stands out from the rest, a question that forces the player to judge the merits of cultural tolerance versus religious freedom.

Having signed the White-Gold Concordat, the Imperials have banned the worship of Talos, a figure revered by the Nords above all other deities. In response, the Stormcloaks have instigated a civil war against the totalitarian Imperial Legion, rejecting their authority and heralding Ulfric Stormcloak as the true king of Skyrim.

The Decision: Do you side with the Imperials or the Stormcloaks? Though the denial of religious freedom is fairly awful, keep in mind that the Imperials have only imposed the ban on Talos to keep the peace with the Aldmeri Dominion, preventing a second great war and the loss of further life. The Stormcloaks also have a tendency to exclude or outright abuse other races, and it€™s suggested that Ulfric only cares about the freedoms of his fellow Nords.


4. GTA IV

Niko Bellic€\™s past is about as dark as his present, filled to the brim with death, violence and betrayal. Honestly, it€™'s surprising that he'€™s as mentally stable as he is, given the degree of suffering and misery that has plagued each and every moment of his life thus far.

One such moment came during the Bosnian War in which Niko and his army unit were betrayed by a member of their own team, Darko Brevic. The sole survivor, Niko vowed revenge on Darko; unfortunately, lacking the means or influence to track him down, it was unlikely that his desire for blood would ever be satisfied. That is, until Darko is delivered, bound and gagged right to Niko€™s feet.

The Decision: Should you murder Darko or allow him to live? Though Darko€™s actions got several people killed in the war, it€™'s also suggested that his death won€™t bring Niko the kind of closure that he€™s been looking for. It also appears that Darko would welcome death, tormented by regret and plagued by the consequences of his actions.

If you decide to kill Darko, Niko regrets the decision almost instantly; proving that in the end that vengeance isn't always the answer.


3. Mass Effect

Having defeated Saren, you€™re left to make some pretty important decisions, decisions that will affect the entire galaxy. One of those decisions involves the galactic council who have fled to the Destiny Ascension, the flagship of the entire galactic fleet. Joker informs you that the ship can be saved from an onslaught of enemy vessels, but only if actions is taken immediately. The trouble is: saving the council will result in the deaths of countless human lives.

The Decision: Do you sacrifice human lives in order to save the council, or allow the council to perish? Thus far, humanity has been regularly excluded from important decision making, and repeatedly lied to by the council. Allowing them to die would secure a place for humanity at the forefront of the galactic senate; it would also prevent further unnecessary death.

In the end, the decision is really about whether or not to selfishly place human interest over the needs of the rest of the galaxy. Though your decision doesn't affect the sequel too much, it does have some lasting effects that are tied directly to your decision.


2. Heavy Rain

The Lizard trial. In order to save his son and collect another chip for his phone, Ethan is told to amputate his finger on camera. If the player chooses to proceed, Ethan will collect the necessary tools and place them on a nearby table. You can drink whisky to ease the pain, place a piece of wood between your teeth and apply disinfectant. After that, a tool must be selected and an amputation carried out.

The Decision: Are you prepared to make a sacrifice to save your son? You'€™re well within your power to simply turn around and head back the way you came, failing the trial in the process and possible condemning your son to death.

There€™'s no way to know whether your sacrifice won€™t be in vain, but it might be your only choice. If you do decide to go through with the amputation, it does prove ultimately worthwhile as Ethan gains another clue in the search for his son, but there's no way you could've known beforehand.


1. Fable 2

Defeating Lucien at the very end of the game, the player is given a difficult choice between three very tantalising propositions; wealth, love or sacrifice. Wealth rewards the player with 1,000,000 gold, a hefty sum that has some serious advantages, allowing you to buy up loads of property, or buy some shiny new weapons. Love brings your family back to life, including your sister, spouse(s), children and (most importantly) your trusty dog. Sacrifice brings back everyone who has died building Lucien€™s spire, countless innocent strangers that you€™ve never met.

The Decision: How selfish should you be? Together, the three choices allow you to be incredibly selfish, quite selfish or entirely selfless. Personally, I don'€™t think you can put a price on your dog'€™s life, but then 1,000,000 might just be enough to sway me.

Regardless of what you decide, you'€™re going to feel like you€™'ve been robbed of something; either your best friend, a lot of money or the lives of the people of Albion. It's certainly not a win win situation. In fact, it€™s hardly even a win.

Watch this article in video form below...

Which other complex moral questions have you overcome in video games? Share your favourites below in the comments thread.


In this post: 
Heavy Rain
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Formerly an assistant editor, Richard's interests include detective fiction and Japanese horror movies.