10 Video Games That Got EVERYTHING Wrong

These games whiffed in every way that a game can whiff.

Saints Row 2022
Deep Silver

There's no denying it - game development is really damn hard. Making even a halfway-decent AAA game requires a Herculean heft of collaboration between hundreds of talented artists and programmers, while a great game takes something else altogether.

So it's little surprise that most games are uneven and tout their fair share of flaws - no piece of art is perfect, and most players are fine with some wrinkles if the core gameplay loop is fun enough.

But sometimes developers end up making so many off-base decisions that they basically get every major thing about their game totally wrong.

From the graphics to the story, gameplay, sound, tone, and even more basic things like marketing and messaging - these games tripped and fell at practically every possible hurdle.

It'd be almost impressive were it not so fundamentally sad, that these games - many of them promising on paper - were simply a parade of errors that resulted in critical scorn and a legion of disappointed players.

It takes a major commitment of energy in the completely wrong direction to screw things up quite this much...

10. Babylon's Fall

Babylon's Fall
Square Enix

How bad could an action-RPG from PlatinumGames really be? The answer: pretty bad.

Babylon's Fall was released back in March with a suspicious lack of fanfare, after a marketing campaign which failed to suggest the game would be anything more than a generic, soulless, visually unappealing entry into the genre.

And that's precisely what Babylon's Fall is - an always-online live-service game that feels like a parody of it, so lacking in personality it is.

It doesn't look good, the combat isn't fun or intuitive, and even as a co-op experience it doesn't really work, given that the Steam player count fell to just one player within two months of its release.

It feels less like a typical full-effort PlatinumGames title than something rushed to market at the behest of publisher Square Enix, in a ham-handed attempt to cash-in on the live-service boom.

Needless to say, Babylon's Fall fails in every way that a game of this type can, and far from the enduring project that was intended, it's already evaporated from the minds of most.


9. Fast & Furious Crossroads

fast and furious crossroads
Slightly Mad Studios

Though video games adapted from movies don't have a great track record, you have to wonder how difficult it really must be to make a halfway-decent game based on a film franchise that has itself become increasingly video game-y over the years.

The problem, as ever, is that acquiring the license to adapt a hit movie IP is costly enough that it doesn't leave all that much moolah for active development, as is so painfully the case with 2020's Fast & Furious Crossroads.

You'd never, ever guess that something so unpolished came from Slightly Mad Studios, the dev team behind the great Project CARS franchise, and yet Crossroads falls flat as even dumb, undemanding fun.

Even if you can forgive the utterly lackluster excuse for a story, unenthusiastic performances from Vin Diesel, Michelle Rodriguez, and Tyrese Gibson, and dated visuals, Crossroads' driving just doesn't feel good.

Combine the unresponsive controls with a single fixed camera and four-hour campaign you won't remember within days of finishing, and it's an absolute disgrace that this wasn't a budget title.


8. The Quiet Man

The Quiet Man
Square Enix

Square Enix strikes again with one of the most baffling video games of the last decade - The Quiet Man.

This low-key beat 'em up certainly had a lot of potential with its intriguing hook, that the protagonist is a deaf man and the game lacks sound or subtitles in an attempt to put the player in his shoes.

Ultimately The Quiet Man was quietly shoveled onto storefronts in 2018 and met with near-universal scorn for its failure to get basically anything right.

For starters, the combat was clunky and awkward - unaided by a wretched camera - and the lack of sound ultimately made the story's presentation feel more frustratingly nonsensical than intriguingly mysterious.

A post-launch update allowed players to re-play the game with sound, yet considering you had to beat the game once to do that, who really had the motivation to play through such a miserable experience twice?

There's such a huge gulf between the developers' intent and the end product that the comparisons to Tommy Wiseau's The Room aren't in any way exaggerated.

As both a meaningful work of deaf representation and a basic, meat-and-potatoes action game, The Quiet Man stinks.


7. Umbrella Corps

Umbrella Corps
Capcom

And you thought Resident Evil: Operation Raccoon City was bad.

2016's competitive multiplayer shooter Umbrella Corps is a thoroughly tossed-off entry into the Resident Evil franchise, enough that its title bizarrely doesn't even contain the series' moniker.

In every fiber of its being, this nothingburger of a tactical shooter feels low budget and low effort, as though Capcom tasked a small team with slapping it together during some downtime in the later stages of Resident Evil 7's development.

The graphics look cheap, gunplay doesn't feel good, the camera is terrible, and the maps are too damn cramped.

After a point you have to wonder who Capcom made this for, because it's tough to imagine any type of Resident Evil fan - either those who prefer survival horror or those who embrace gonzo action - prizing much enjoyment from this.

Unsurprisingly, the player count on Steam fell off a cliff within weeks of release and never recovered.


6. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 5

tony hawk's pro skater 5
Activision

Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 5 wasn't merely a terrible game - it was a legitimately sad, pathetic thing to behold. The legendary skating franchise had been on the skids for quite some time leading up to Pro Skater 5's release, which Activision touted as a return to form.

Fans were skeptical going by the pre-release gameplay footage, yet nobody could've anticipated just how much of a broken, janky mess the final release would actually be.

First and foremost, Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 5 is a shockingly ugly game for a 2015 release - the graphics could easily pass for an early PS3 title, yet that's far from the worst of the game's sins.

On a pure gameplay level, skating doesn't feel slick and fluid like it does in even the lesser Tony Hawk's games. Combined with a plethora of bugs, uninspired levels, and a weird lack of NPCs, the once-great series now felt like an emaciated, hollowed-out shell of its former self.

It was clear that Activision had lead developer Robomodo curl this thing out on a small budget with limited time, and the studio ultimately ended up paying for it, going out of business less than a year after Pro Skater 5's release.

The franchise at least enjoyed quite the turnaround in 2020, with remaster project Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 1 + 2 receiving rave reviews and largely restoring fans' faith in the flagging IP.


5. EFootball 2022

eFootball 2022 Paul Pogba
Konami

In 2020, Konami's Pro Evolution Soccer series was re-branded to eFootball, and last September its inaugural free-to-play entry, eFootball 2022, was released.

The game was immediately panned into the ground by critics and players alike for its underwhelming visuals, hilarious abundance of bugs, eyesore-inducing user interface, and worst of all, that it didn't even function as a basically enjoyable football game.

This is without getting into the fact that the initial release was extremely bare bones all while Konami continued to push "premium" paid content, much to fans' chagrin.

It was painful to see the successor to PES - often held up as superior to FIFA in the gameplay stakes - suffer such an embarrassing tumble from grace.

Even with the release of the 1.0 update this past April, major AI and matchmaking problems persist, ensuring that the player-base has largely rejected eFootball as a worthy inheritor of PES' crown.

When a game can't even get the basic thrill of football on lock - something the genre has been doing well for literally decades - you know it's a bust. Expectations couldn't be lower for the imminent 2023 update.


4. Mighty No. 9

Mighty No 9
Deep Silver

Mighty No. 9 is perhaps the cautionary tale for crowdfunded games, because while the prospect of a spiritual successor to Mega Man created with the help of legendary Mega Man artist Keiji Inafune seemed like a can't-lose prospect, the outcome was so tragically different.

Excitement was high when Mighty No. 9 scored over $4 million in Kickstarter funding, with concept art convincing most everyone that it would indeed be a worthy follow-up to Mega Man.

But after numerous delays it was finally released in June 2016, where fans learned the ugly truth of where their hard-earned cash actually went.

Not far, apparently. The detailed promised art style was replaced with something more cartoonish and less robust, performance on consoles was unacceptably rough, and even the core game design felt like a lackluster cast-off from the franchise that inspired it.

All in all, it was a shell of a game that proved what can happen when even slam-dunk projects are mismanaged.

It didn't help that the game's marketing ill-advisedly mocked anime fans - as in, probably a lot of the people interested in the game - and many Kickstarter backers received broken codes or incomplete rewards.

Even on the most basic, infrastructural level, Mighty No. 9 was a mess - failing to get working game codes out to people who threw down their money years in advance is a biblical screw-up.


3. Left Alive

Left Alive
Square Enix

Square Enix's stealth-action game Left Alive was hyped primarily on the involvement of Metal Gear Solid concept artist Yoji Shinkawa, who would be contributing his designs to a game that, focused on stealth and large mechs, didn't seem a million miles away from Hideo Kojima's franchise.

But Left Alive was rightly pilloried by the games press for the fact that it fundamentally wasn't enjoyable as a stealth game, or really anything at all.

The overpowering issue was the savagely unforgiving stealth mechanics, whereby even the lowest difficulty offered a hellacious level of challenge, made worse by a terribly infrequent checkpointing system.

Combined with stiff controls and a nothing story, Left Alive was an absolute chore to play, enough that even Shinkawa's solid artwork couldn't save it on a most basic, superficial level.

Though developer Ilinx did release a patch shortly after release that introduced a new Casual difficulty setting, by this point the damage was basically done. Yet even with this more forgiving mode of play, Left Alive was still a soulless waste of time.

And even though the Metacritic user score is considerably higher than that of critics, it's been suggested by some that Square Enix may have deployed bots to artificially inflate it, as they've been accused of doing with several other games.


2. Saints Row (2022)

Saint Row 2022
Volition

Oh Saints Row, how we all wanted you to be good.

Though it was clear to anyone paying attention that Volition's reboot of the hit sandbox action franchise was basically being sent out to die with a minimal marketing push, everyone still hoped against hope it might be a pleasant surprise.

Yet critics awarded Saints Row 2022 extremely tepid reviews, suggesting it didn't even really cut the mustard as a generic open-world action game.

Many noted Saints Row's lackluster combat, which feels markedly worse than in previous games in the series, and a presentation which awkwardly attempted to split the difference between the more serious earlier games and cartoonish recent ones.

Throw in a bevy of cringe-worthy dialogue, some shockingly dated visuals, and a general feeling of listlessness, and you have an experience that feels like it was churned out for cynical reasons rather than because anyone actually had an inspired idea for a new take on Saints Row.

Amid the scathing reviews, Embracer Group's stock took a hit, indicating just how little confidence there is in both the game and the future of the brand moving forward.

Don't be surprised if Saints Row takes an "extended hiatus" for the rest of the gaming generation.


1. Battlefield 2042

Battlefield 2042
EA

Battlefield simply wouldn't be Battlefield without a rough launch, and though most of the games have suffered through netcode hiccups during their release windows, the gunplay still felt fundamentally good for the most part.

Except with the most recent entry into the series, Battlefield 2042, which in addition to its bevy of other problems didn't actually work as a basically functional FPS.

Angered by the excessive number of bugs, baffling lack of content, wonky progression system, lack of a single-player campaign, and lousy cosmetics, fans soon enough started a petition demanding a refund from EA - which to date has over 230,000 signatures.

Between all this and excessive weapon bloom making gunplay frustrating and unsatisfying, a mass exodus of players quickly began. Barely a month after the game's release, its concurrent player count on Steam was overtaken by 2018's Battlefield V.

EA's response to the matter didn't help, either: they called players' expectations "brutal," and things got heated enough that the game's subreddit was almost shut down.

Though Battlefield 2042 is in somewhat better shape as of the 4.00 patch this past April, there's still the consensus among most that the game is largely a lost cause - too much damage has been done, and disgruntled players have moved on to other things.

Amid disappointing sales, EA blamed both the impact of the pandemic and, hilariously, the smooth surprise launch of Halo Infinite's multiplayer mode just four days before Battlefield 2042.

All in all, it's a festival of mistakes, from the game's overall design philosophy to their PR strategy for interacting with understandably upset customers. Do better next time, EA.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Saints Row
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.