10 Video Games That Had No Right Being This Good - Commenter's Edition

Nobody expected these games to be so much fun, but they are!

Maneater Game
Tripwire Interactive

Gamers can sometimes be harsh on the medium they love. When a new entry in an established, beloved IP is announced, it's often exciting simply for the big name attached to it. Should the title ultimately fail to live up to expectations, the disappointment and anger is palpable. On the opposite end of the spectrum, other new game reveals get no real limelight at all, at least at first.

Trying something new is a dangerous business, and it's easy to pass on a new game seconds into watching a first trailer. It takes an adventurous gamer to take a chance on a seemingly-silly title. The rewards for not passing over an under-celebrated experience at first glance can be great, though. The most unlikely-looking concepts can make for very good games.

Our previous list of Video Games That Had No Right Being This Good celebrated the likes of 2005's King Kong and Minority Report: Everybody Runs, and you had your own ideas for titles that should've been included. Your suggestions were so good, in fact, that you left us no recourse but to craft an entirely new list from them. From a breakfast cereal-centric Doom clone to an RPG starring a shark, here are some unlikely games that were much, much more fun than their premises suggested.

10. Plants Vs. Zombies

Plants Vs Zombies
Popcap Games

The first time players unleashed a jalapeño pepper and burned through an entire row of zombies in one swift strike, they saw what a fun and absurd experience Plants vs Zombies could really be. How, though, did the premise of defending your lawn against zombies using plants work as well as it did?

Zombies, for some years, were an overused, shambling trope that appeared in every other game, and Plants vs. Zombies seemed like a shark-jumping silly moment too far. As it was, though, there was method to PopCap’s weirdness: The finely-tuned and surprisingly tactical gameplay, not to mention the array of modes on offer, made it a fun distraction for tower defense newcomers and a challenge for genre veterans alike.

Attempting to reach higher waves in survival mode was a task that humbled many, and demonstrated the deviousness of the title’s design. Plants vs Zombies went on to be ported to a wide array of different devices, and spawned TPS spin-offs in Plants vs Zombies: Battle For Neighborville and the Garden Warfare series. They, too, are a riot of fun, and with their wide variety of character classes, offer more depth than their silly aesthetic would suggest.


9. The Mummy Demastered

the mummy demastered
WayForward Technologies

The Mummy movies may not be cinematic masterpieces, but they certainly are relentlessly entertaining. Dating all the way back to the iconic Boris Karloff’s star turn in the 1930s, the movies tap into that innate fascination with Ancient Egyptian mummies that so many horror fans have.

The video game world’s takes on the series have hit systems from the Game Boy Color to the Xbox One, with The Mummy Demastered being a surprising success story.

The demastering process is often more of a fan endeavour displaying exactly what can be done with pixel art, but The Mummy Demastered proved its worth as a solid and enjoyable Metroidvania adventure. A varied challenge and quite the looker for fans of 2D art, it’s an underrated gem, and players don’t need to be familiar with the movie to appreciate it.

With a simple mini-map reminiscent of classic Metroid and a spooky vibe that's oh-so Castlevania, WayForward's effort seems to have paid close attention to exactly what makes the genre tick. At the same time, its quick-paced gunplay and movement ensure that it doesn't feel too much like either series.


8. Def Jam: Fight For New York

def jam fight for new york
EA

2003’s Def Jam Vendetta brought something truly intriguing to the wrestling genre. Well, several things. Ludacris, DMX and Redman were just three of them. Hip hop legends breaking each others’ bones in the ring (yes, that was a mechanic) was a thrilling sight to behold indeed, though it has come to be remembered more as a unique novelty than for its virtues as a wrestling title outright.

Its sequel, Def Jam: Fight For New York, might never have happened. It did, though, and it expanded the fighter roster, vastly improved the depth of the gameplay by allowing players to select from custom styles, and even introduced a long and gripping narrative to proceedings (something unfortunately lacking in most fighters to this day).

As the title suggests, the story revolves around battles for popularity and control of New York’s clubs. The story is unrelenting, well implemented in the bouts, and all around surprisingly good, as is the package itself. Few games take the player on a ride like this one, which was quite the pleasant surprise: This was probably the last place players expected to find a engrossing plot.


7. Stray

Stray Zurks
BlueTwelve Studio

Dark and dystopian open worlds are nothing new to hardened gamers. Piecing together exactly what happened to such a dark realm as you pick your way through it is an intriguing exercise.

Stray offers exactly that. Games played as our feline friends are often cutesy, virtual pet affairs, and this may have been what some expected from BlueTwelve’s 2022 title when it first arrived on the scene. As it was, though, it proved to be a gripping and enigmatic journey of real substance.

Murtaugh may act like a real cat (down to cheekily knocking certain items off ledges) and have a designated MEOW button, but his journey is tense, gripping, and perilous. Those Zurks are as menacing as any foes seen in gaming recently, and Stray has an atmosphere and frightening vibe all its own. The enigmatic machines who also reside here have a personality and melancholy feel that only enhances this further.

Stray is the kind of experience that sticks with you, regardless of your love (or possible lack thereof) for our feline friends. There's never really been a cyberpunk experience like it.


6. Stardew Valley

Stardew Valley Npc Map
ConcernedApe

Farming sims have become huge deals in recent years. They’ve also become increasingly elaborate, with the likes of Sakuna: Of Rise and Ruin and Harvestella introducing combat mechanics, other resource-gathering and an awful lot more besides.

At the time of its launch, Stardew Valley was something quite extraordinary. A life sim of sorts, complete with dungeon crawling, social relationships to maintain, fishing, and other pursuits, it’s like a more involved, pixel-art Animal Crossing, and it’s quite extraordinary that it was designed by one person.

Faithfully and painstakingly updated for so long after its release, Stardew Valley is a true labor of love and a beloved classic. It has managed to hook the most hardened of gamers, many of whom may have scoffed at it prior to taking the plunge. No title has quite mastered the formula of time management and filling days with activities as Stardew Valley has.

With its town events, interior decoration elements, and the increasing depths of its dungeons, there's a ludicrous amount of content on offer here, whichever facet of life in the valley appeals to you the most.


5. Chex Quest

Chex Quest
Digital Cafe

The concept of licensed games certainly doesn’t fill gamers with confidence. The concept of a game based on a breakfast cereal, you’d think, would be even less auspicious. Nonetheless, it happened, and it was pulled off with aplomb.

In the wake of the (continuing to this day) controversy regarding the rip-and-tear gore of Doom, there was only one logical course for Digital Café to take: spin the beloved Ultimate Doom, famous for being even more delightfully horrific than the original release, into something entirely different.

How different? Well, Chex Quest is a blood-free romp starring the Chex Warrior, whose weapons are teleportation devices of sorts rather than implements of mass bloody death. The whole thing still revolves around an incursion by lots of creatures, but the snotty Flemoids are far less threatening than Cacodemons, Barons of Hell and other such ghastly Doom-dwellers.

Chex Quest is a relic from a bygone age when fantastic things were provided as gifts in cereal boxes, and perhaps one of the greatest marketing endeavors gaming has ever seen. It's fun in its own right, against all odds.


4. X-Men Origins: Wolverine

Xmen Origins Wolverine
Activision

James Howlett certainly isn’t alone in having a grim and harrowing Marvel backstory. Many other comic book legends, however, haven’t had it as thoroughly explored in other media as Logan’s has been.

2009 movie X-Men Origins: Wolverine, as the title suggests, follows some of the personal tragic and blood-soaked past that made Wolverine who he is. He tends to fight on the side of good, yes, but he’s no conventional hero. Those claws are a perfect fit for a vicious, gory, face-to-face combat style, and he engages in just that during the movie and the video game of the same name.

The game may play it fast and loose with the plot at times, but ultimately, this isn’t so important. A stylish brawler through and through, X-Men Origins: Wolverine may not be the longest experience, but it can be a joyful hack-and-slack stress reliever. There are even RPG elements that allow players to develop their character as he gains experience.

A style-over-substance approach could easily have been taken here, but the developers went the extra mile to craft a game that both looked and played well.


3. Mad Max

Mad Max Game
Avalanche Studios

In a similar fashion to X-Men Origins, Mad Max took the most thrilling, visceral action from the movie of the same name and ran with it.

There are parallels to be drawn between the setting of Mad Max and the original Borderlands, in that the player must traverse a vast and unfriendly expanse that has been claimed by violet bandits. Vehicle combat is quite a challenge for developers, and few games have managed to make it feel as brutal, satisfying, and purely destructive as the concept promises. Mad Max, for some, delivers that.

It's not the most narrative-driven and complex of experiences, but nor is it supposed to be. If you can overlook the storytelling shortcomings, the action delivered here is a blast. Often literally.

The franchise is known for its bombastic, over-the-top action, and this has always been a very difficult thing for developers to do justice to in video game adaptations. As with X-Men Origins: Wolverine, though, it's a grim and visceral experience that is far from perfect, but battles to do right by the source material.


2. Maneater

Maneater Game
Tripwire Interactive

All of that Sharknado business put a bit of a dent in the fearsome image that sharks have developed in the media. Real-life sharks are far from the ravenous, human-devouring monsters they’re often portrayed as.

Nonetheless, the chance to play as one of these formidable creatures offers ample opportunity for mayhem. Maneater could easily have been a throwaway, silly, button-mashing, bloody adventure, and while there are elements of these things, it’s also a surprisingly in-depth action RPG.

There’s a significant amount of content to get your huge bull shark’s teeth into, without everything seeming to drag as open-world titles sometimes can. The narrative is also engaging enough (and has been elaborated on through DLC) to keep the player progressing, and evolution element ensures that the player certainly isn’t any normal shark.

The evolution mechanic ensures that there's always something to progress toward, a world that steadily opens up as the vicious protagonist becomes larger and more capable. As a concept, Maneater could have easily gone a little stale quite quickly as the initial novelty wore off, but this shark tale is one worth sticking around for in full.


1. White Knight Chronicles

White Knight Chronicles
Level-5, Japan Studio

The RPG genre is, perhaps, the biggest and most varied of all.

For many gamers, it’s dominated by the heavy-hitters; the Final Fantasy, Dragon Quest, Xeno series to name just a few. A lot of genre fans have their favorite series and become entirely immersed in it, but there are also so many RPG franchises that fly under the radar of even aficionados and don’t get the appreciation they deserve.

White Knight Chronicles is certainly one of these. The original game launched in 2008 in Japan, a Level-5 creation that boasts all the familiar RPG tropes. From its fantasy setting to its princess-rescuing plot, the adventure of Leonard, his White Knight persona and his friends doesn’t break any particularly new ground.

What it does offer, though, is a substantial, engrossing adventure, and a creative battle system revolving around giving a series of commands to party members to ensure everyone works in tandem with the one player-controlled character. The series saw two further releases and is very worth the attention of any RPG fan, though it may be regarded as a bit of a B-list entry to the world of RPGs.


Watch Next


Contributor

Chris Littlechild hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.