10 Video Games That Knew You Lied
These games saw right through your BS.
Video games are escapist wish fulfilment above all else, allowing players to do things they either can't or perhaps won't in real life, be it conquering alien worlds, saving the day, or even just lying their asses off.
Lying may not rank highly on the list of dastardly things you can do in video games, but many games nevertheless allow players to become veritable bulls**t artists, either through branching dialogue options or simply taking control of a deeply duplicitous character.
Whatever the means, these games all allowed players to fill the shoes of a sure-fire liar, only to flip that untruthfulness around on them in an unexpected and often hilarious way.
These 10 video games all made it abundantly clear that they knew you were lying, in turn guilting you for your dishonesty and even finding a way to punish you for your underhanded approach to the "truth."
The consequences range from trivial to fatal, admittedly, but in each case showed that the game and its central characters knew more than you surely expected, and weren't soon going to let you forget it either...
10. Promising Clementine You'll Look For Her Parents - Telltale's The Walking Dead
Telltale's The Walking Dead series tried to make your choices matter as much as feasibly possible, but far away from its many life-or-death decisions, the first season's fourth episode, "Around Every Corner," set players up to get caught in a lie. And worse still, a lie to a child.
At the very end of the episode, eight-year-old Clementine asks protagonist Lee if they'll have time to search for her missing parents.
At this point, players have three options - they can either flat-out refuse, say they're not sure if there will be time, or lie and promise Clem they will.
If you lie to Clem, she'll reiterate her question, at which point Lee looks sheepishly around the room and Clem devastatingly replies, "I knew you didn't mean it," before breaking down in tears.
And to rub salt in the wound, the game even displays the text, "You lied to Clementine," to remind you of your misdeed.
Granted, Clem basically gets upset no matter how you reply to her, but after being so casually dishonest, the game sure as hell made you feel guilty about it.
9. Elizabeth Knows You're Not Going To Paris - BioShock Infinite
BioShock Infinite revolves around protagonist Booker DeWitt, who retrieves the imprisoned Elizabeth from captivity at the start of the game with the promise of taking her to Paris, even though he's actually taking her to New York City, planning to trade her in order to settle his debts.
Mid-way through the game as you depart on your journey, Elizabeth hilariously manages to see completely through your deception.
As you start charting the course, Elizabeth notices that the co-ordinates you've entered are for New York rather than Paris and immediately calls you out on it.
To make it even better, Booker seems totally dumbfounded that Elizabeth, who he evidently underestimated, would know anything about co-ordinates, before she reminds him that she had a lot of free time to study various subjects while locked away.
Elizabeth then starts crying, but as Booker attempts to comfort her, her feelings turn to anger and she clobbers him over the head with a wrench. Totally deserved.
8. Sleeping With The "Enemy" - Papers, Please
The brilliant Papers, Please is a game centered entirely around deception, where as a border-crossing officer in a fictional dystopian state, you get to decide whether or not immigrants are allowed into the country.
Eventually you'll come to learn that a resistance organisation called EZIC is plotting to stage a coup d'état against the government, and it's entirely up to you whether to co-operate with them or not.
The game has a possible 20 endings, and those who complete a few tasks to help EZIC - but not all of them - may end up having their duplicity unveiled at game's end.
With the right conditions throughout the game, your ending will see you dragged before the terrifying government investigator M. Vonel, who will note that your traitorous behaviour has been discovered, with at least one EZIC member throwing you under the bus during a confession.
You're then carted off to prison to await execution later that night, and that's all she wrote.
7. Valeria's Interrogation - Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare II
In Call of Duty: Modern Warfare II's chapter "El Sin Nombre," you're captured and brought before one of the game's primary antagonists, cartel leader Valeria Garza aka El Sin Nombre herself.
What follows is an interrogation sequence in which Valeria asks the player a series of questions which basically serves as a pop quiz on their experiences throughout the game so far.
At the start of the scene, Valeria loudly demands that you tell the truth, implying severe consequences for failing to do so, and as the player you're given four options, representing truth, lying, antagonising, and simply making no choice at all.
If you pick the lie or even genuinely get a question wrong, Valeria will respond by asking one more follow-up question to gauge precisely what you're up to. Tell a second lie, however, and she'll promptly respond by shooting you dead on the spot.
The game makes it pretty clear upfront that the only way out of this situation is to tell the truth, so you've really only got yourself to blame if you start telling fibs.
6. Cartman Knows How You Got The Basement Code - South Park: The Fractured But Whole
South Park: The Fractured But Whole takes a lot of pleasure in poking fun at the very nature of video games themselves, and specifically the requirement for players to go about objectives in a certain order.
This pays off quite hilariously in the game when you need to figure out the keypad code for Cartman's basement, which can be found in his journal.
But players who simply look the answer up in a guide will get quite the unexpected response. Upon entering the code, "307," Cartman will pop up in the top-right corner of the screen in the guise of New England Patriots coach Bill Belichick and ream the player out. He'll say:
"Hey, Tom Brady, you wanna play the game or do you just wanna be known as a smug cheating b*tch the rest of your life?"
Try to enter the basement again without looking in the journal first and you'll get additional snide comments from "Bill," assuring players that their dishonest approach to playing the game has been duly noted.
5. You're Not Russian - Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2
Another Call of Duty example now - and another from Modern Warfare 2 even, albeit the original 2009 iteration of the sequel.
Modern Warfare 2 features an infamous mission called "No Russian," in which players control undercover CIA operative Joseph Allen as he takes part in a terrorist attack in an attempt to gain the trust of Russian terrorist Vladimir Makarov.
The missions involves joining Makarov and his men during a grim massacre at a Russian airport, where players can either choose to participate in gunning down hundreds of civilians or leave it to the real terrorists.
Either way, the chapter ends the same, with Makarov revealing that he knew Allen was undercover all along, before shooting him dead and escaping the scene.
Leaving an American corpse at the sight of the airport massacre then suggests American involvement in the attack and prompts Russia to declare war on the United States, as Makarov planned all along.
Allen's undercover gambit was always going to be a supremely risky one, and while you've got no option but to get caught at the end of No Russian, it still makes for a hugely shocking punchline to one of gaming's all-time most infamous levels.
4. Two-Timing Yennefer & Triss - The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
The Witcher 3 gives players a ton of freedom, but it's a mistake to assume that your actions also come with immunity from consequences.
Case in point, players may find themselves unable to resist the temptation to romance the gorgeous Yennefer and Triss at the same time, albeit while conducting each romance under false pretenses - that is, not telling them you're not-exclusive.
Take this far enough and you'll actually manage to wrangle a threesome with the duo, but the gut-busting payoff will see the lingerie-wearing pair tie Geralt to the bed, drink some wine, and then take their vengeful leave.
To make it even funnier, Geralt has to suffer the indignity of being rescued the next morning by his bud Dandelion, who admonishes him, "Oh Geralt, how little you know about women. Did you really think you could have them both?".
Yes, evidently, but as it turns out Yen and Triss were a little more savvy than expected - they knew what horny players were up to and were having absolutely none of it. Bravo.
3. Not-So-Dead Ringer - Team Fortress 2
A rare multiplayer example now, with the great Team Fortress 2.
Those who take the support role of The Spy will get a number of nifty abilities, such as Dead Ringer, allowing the player to cloak for seven seconds upon receiving damage, while leaving behind a fake corpse intended to fool players on the opposite team into thinking they're dead.
But there's one easy tell which will give the ruse away: the fake corpse will also leave behind a fake box of ammo, which while looking identical from a distance, won't give an opposing player any ammo when they walk over it, nor cause the customary pick-up chime to ring out.
As a result, Team Fortress 2 players nowadays are savvy enough to give Spy corpses a massively wide berth, and only trust that they're really dead if their ammo drop is indeed legit.
2. The Riddler Knows You Used A Guide - Batman: Arkham Asylum
Perhaps the ultimate test of your mettle in Batman: Arkham Asylum involves hoovering up all 240 of The Riddler's trophies fiendishly scattered around Arkham Island.
Doing it the hard way - that is, without any outside assistance - is incredibly difficult and time-consuming, enough that the vast majority of players surely used YouTube video guides to streamline the process.
But developers Rocksteady were clearly well aware that players would be inclined to find a shortcut, and so once you've collected the vast majority of the trophies, you'll get a hilariously frustrated message from the Riddler himself.
The Riddler will straight-up accuse you of cheating, saying, "What? You're nearly done? Are you cheating? Looking them up on the internet? Tell me!" and later, "I'm losing patience. You are cheating. You must be."
Clearly The Riddler knew that his challenges were just too fiendishly difficult for even the World's Greatest Detective to conquer without somebody else lending a helping hand, even though most players evidently wanted the glory of finding them all regardless.
1. Darth Malak Knows Who You Really Are - Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic
Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic gamely asks the player - is something really a lie if you absolutely believe it with all the conviction in your body?
After all, the player wakes up at the start of the game as an amnesiac and then trains to become a Jedi - a lie that doesn't fool the game's primary antagonist, Darth Malak, much at all.
At the very end of KOTOR, Malak reveals that he's acutely aware of the player's self-deception, that they're actually the rogue Jedi Knight Darth Revan, who after being left for dead by Malak had their mind wiped by the Jedi Council.
It's admittedly a reveal more shocking to the audience and Revan themselves than anyone else, but even so, it's galling to know that the entire time you've spent playing the game, Malak has known your true nature, even better than you did yourself.