10 Video Games That Made Critics And Fans Hate Each Other

Can't we all just get along?

Deadly premonition
Access Games

It'll be a fine day when two mass bodies can agree on something. No no, this isn't about politics or that ninjas are better than pirates. I am of course referring to the age old debate of critic versus fan. Professional reviewer with opinion against fanatical devotee with a different opinion of a game.

But what stings the most is when a reviewer or publication shower a game with praise and hype... only for it to not quite deliver on either. Do those that set these scores have rose tinted glasses on, or is there that stagnant whiff of paid reviews lingering around...?

Hyping a game about a story that wasn't really there, or convincing you that Evolve is actually a good game, for example.

Conversely, there are some games that are thrown to the wolves, yet the fans absolutely love them. Take Swery's weird detective/paranormal romp: didn't review well, but is now getting a sequel. Or lambasting what started the "walking simulator" trend, only to be proven very, very wrong.

We'll never hit a perfect point of agreement, but here's something we can reach consensus on: these games definitely caused some contention when they came out.

10. Terminator: Resistance

Terminator Resistance Opening
Reef Entertainment

It's been a tough time for the Terminator franchise. What should have been left at two brilliant films and a string of arcade games has been strenuously dragged out in the mess it is today. Retcons, timeline alterations, fates not being left to make themselves, it's been a trip.

But one weird positive to come out of it was not the reviews for Terminator: Resistance, but the reception to it from fans. It's not hit "cult classic" status like say, Beyond Good and Evil, but it's doing a fine job holding its own.

Average review scores, hanging in the middle territories, are overshadowed by the two thousand positive reviews on Steam alone.

But by no means is it a hidden gem of a game, breaking new ground in the FPS genre. It is, and I say this lightly, quite bland. Yet considering we haven't had a Terminator game in a while, this seems to be doing the job.

It may that it's only well received because it's all we've got, but people seem to really enjoy it.

Personally, I'm still holding out hope for a Robocop vs. Terminator sequel.


9. The Legend Of Zelda: The Wind Waker

Wind Waker
Nintendo

Stakes were high when it came to anticipating what the follow up to Ocarina of Time and Majora's Mask would be. We had a new, more powerful console in the GameCube, so it had to be spectacular.

Instead, it was Wind Waker.

With the benefit of hindsight, it's a bloody good game. It's better than Skyward Sword, at least.

But ho boy, it was a different scene in 2003. Metaphorical pitchforks were raised and torches were lit in droves to decry how terrible it looked, how it's a radical change for the wrong reasons, etc etc.

Granted, this is before anyone had actually played the damn game. Upon release, it's integrity as a Zelda game held up well against the backlash.

Yes, it had changes. Yes, it did look more childish than the serious tones of 'Mask and Ocarina. But it's still a corker of a game, one that people were very reticent to admit prior to getting their mitts on it.

Kudos to Nintendo for sticking to the their guns, though. It went to show that mass complaining can fall on deaf ears.


8. Dragon Age 2

Dragon Age 2
BioWare

To be fair, this entry could have been about Mass Effect 2 and would have still followed the same beats.

They both follow the same pattern: large, immersive story and world(s) in the first games, somehow shrunk into hub-based gameplay and less narrative depth for the sequels.

Yet for Mass Effect, it went better than expected, going on to be considered the best of the trilogy (no, Andromeda doesn't ever count). The same can't be said for Dragon Age's second offering though.

Critical reception was well received, with stronger visuals and more refined combat being praised. The same couldn't be said for fans though, with criticism aimed at the aforementioned hub gameplay being set largely in Kirkwall for almost all of it.

Bioware assured they weren't "dumbing down" the franchise, but it was hard for fans to agree when you put the first two games in a comparison test. Whilst combat was less turn-based and more real time, the dialogue wheel in place of the multiple text choice answers weren't appreciated.

The team did eventually bring some semblance back with Inquisition, but for a while, the future of the series was in peril.


7. Final Fantasy VIII

Final Fantasy VIII Selphie
Final Fantasy VIII Selphie

You don't sell as many millions of units as Final Fantasy has without suffering a few detractors along the way. Yet this isn't about the travesty of FFX-2, or the linear spectacle of XIII, but one that caused a divide some years prior.

You see, prior to the eighth main offering, Final Fantasy had always predominantly been in the realm of older, mythical fantasy. The sixth one flirted with the technological/industrial revolution alongside magics, whilst FFVII was a lot more modern than its previous iterations.

But when VIII dropped, with its more contemporary sc-fi setting, fans went nuts. Derision was aimed at the story, with its mopey teenagers, time travel and trips into space, despite universal acclaim across the board from reviews.

No one will ever agree on what the "best" Final Fantasy is, but VIII was (for a time) considered a black sheep by fans, regardless of the commercial success.

Opinion has shifted in recent years, even if it won't see the same treatment that VII is currently receiving. But at the time, people weren't ready for the adventures of Squall and his teen-mates.


6. Deadly Premonition

deadly premonition
SWERY

Normally, these lists are meant to be impartial. For the most part, they are. Personal opinion should be left aside in delivering to you these nuggets of wisdom. However...

I cannot stand Deadly Premonition.

I have tried on no less than three occasions to sit and play it, and I can't. I don't get it. The clunk doesn't do it for me, much like the Shenmue series.

That doesn't stop me from appreciating the game though. I can see why people love it, the endearing quality in a game that's so bad it's good. I'm assuming that wasn't Swery's intention, but it's the game equivalent of a Troma movie: that self-aware, B movie romp that knows it's not a blockbuster.

It didn't endear itself to critics though, at least not the "mainstream" ones. Indie review sites loved it because it wasn't a AAA blockbuster, but because it was an odd game. Which, of course, piques peoples' interests more than a run-of-the-mill military shooter sequel. Well, except in the sales.

Besides, how many other games have Guinness World Record for "Most Critically Polarizing Survival Horror Game"...?


5. Demon's Souls

demons souls
Sony Computer Entertainment

It's weird to think, now, of the massive prestige that the Dark Souls franchise carries with it. If it's not a Dark Souls clone, it's a Soulsborne-like game (read: something with an element of challenge to it). Speedruns, no levelled challenges, completion with musical instruments and fruit: you name it, people have done it.

But it wasn't always that way, especially when precursor Demon's Souls came out in 2009. Critical praise was showered on it: it was new, it was fresh, it was bloody hard but that was the point. It holds an aggregate on Metacritic at 89, so why is it on this list?

Well, because it was new and hard. We tend to fear change, the unknown scares us and we'd grown accustomed to handheld, checkpoint gaming. It was a game for the "hardcore", not the casuals. As a result, it didn't exactly fly off the shelves.

Fast-forward eleven years, to three Dark Soul's, a Bloodborne and a Sekiro later, people can't get enough. But for the little game that could before it, it wasn't the warmest reception.


4. Gone Home

Sam Gone Home
The Fullbright Company

"Walking simulators" is the term used to describe story driven experiences that don't fall back on certain genres of gameplay to convey that story. Hence, they became their own genre, with games like What Remains of Edith Finch, Firewatch and Everybody's Gone to the Rapture being beautiful examples of that.

That wasn't the case though, back when the walking simulator was treading water. People were unwilling to accept that a game could be a game without... well, any real gameplay. The whole "games are art" debate came back out, with Gone Home being at the forefront of a lot of the brunt.

Critically, it was hitting unanimously high scores across the board. Subjectively, though, fans were quick to deride it as even being a game at all. The term "walking simulator" became a pejorative term for this newly invented genre, yet now one we use as a staple of praise for one of these adventures.

But as per usual, people were quick to object to something before even playing it.

It really does go to show how progressive we've become, doesn't it?


3. Spider-man: Web Of Shadows

Spider-Man venom Web of Shadows
Activision

Before Insomniac blew our minds with the wall-crawler's PS4 outing, Spider-man games were in a perpetual state of not being well received. At least, by critical review.

Web of Shadows is a curious beast of a game though. Instead of being a straight port across many consoles, each generation/style of console had a different iteration. The then-current console versions, namely PS3 and Xbox 360, continued the 3D, open world that we were used to. The PS2 and PSP were different, as was the Nintendo 3DS version.

So it was difficult for any one publication to nail a competent review, given it spread across several different playstyles. As it stands, it's Metacritic score is sat around the middle for each version.

Fans, by comparison, love it. Playing similar to modern contemporaries like Infamous and Prototype, WoS offered a competent multi-pathed choice system to compliment the story.

Do you want to be the upstanding hero and save the day, or turn the dark side, as it were, and become the leader of the Symbiotes? It was a good a Spidey story as we could get for the time, as well as the closest we've come to playing as Venom... so far.


2. Shenmue III

Shenmue 3
Ys Net

Duke Nukem Forever takes a lot of flack for being an average, borderline terrible game, but more importantly: taking fourteen years to come to fruition.

But did it cost people six million of their own combined dollars? No, nor did it take eighteen years to come out.

Shenmue III did, though, and it's being thrown to the wolves so hard it actually makes DNF look like the better game. Sitting in the middle ground on Metacritic, it's really not hard to see why.

You could argue that Yu Suzuki has stayed true his vision of the series from its earliest iteration in 1999, and fans do. As far as retaining that same clunky, core gameplay and style, it really plays how you'd think a sequel to Shenmue would play.

However, the fact that it does play like a Shenmue game from twenty years ago has led many a critic to call this a lazy cash-grab of a sequel... and you can see their point, too.

Staunch defenders will call it a love letter to the true fans, whilst cynics will call it long past its time. It's not hard to see both cases.


1. Death Stranding

Death stranding higgs
Kojima Productions

C'mon, you had to see this coming. You can't make a list about polarizing opinions between fans and critics without Death Stranding. This game threw out the rulebook when it came to review scores, causing some reviewers to even question their own understanding of what it takes to be a gamer.

...it was quite funny.

Personally, I'm in the fan camp. I was invested since day one, and delved straight in on launch. However, I will not gatekeep it, as the ending of the game is so up its own butt it could probably see the other end of the BB inside us (don't ask).

The ruckus it caused on release though was insane. It didn't just become fan against critic, but even critic against critic at some points, calling out review bias or just "not getting it".

Make no mistake, it is a bananas game. To try and explain it to someone on the fence is a hard task, usually resulting in, "You'll have to just try it" instead.

Three months on, the verdict is still out on whether DS is worthy of its accolades or pretentious trash...


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Player of games, watcher of films. Has a bad habit of buying remastered titles. Reviews games and delivers sub-par content in his spare time. Found at @GregatonBomb on Twitter/Instagram.