10 Video Games That Made Expensive Comebacks (And Still Failed)
All that money, and they still couldn't fly.
Reaching the big leagues in gaming isn't easy. Staying on top is much harder. Even though Jax & Daxter, Dino Crisis, and The Legacy of Kain were once considered top contenders, they've all fallen on hard times.
In situations like this, the creators must choose whether they try again... or curl up and die.
But in order to make a comeback, developers can't just toss out a decent game - they have to go big or go home. They need to invest all their time and effort into making the best darn video game possible.
Now, there are plenty of franchises that have stumbled, only to come back ten times stronger: Resident Evil, Mortal Kombat, Metroid, and so forth.
However, going all out doesn't always breed success. Some companies spent a fortune revitalising once-beloved gaming properties, only for them to flop spectacularly. These games didn't just "do badly". They were loathed by critics, failed to make a dime, and bankrupted development teams.
Though a staggering amount of money was put into these projects, none of them received the welcome they were expecting.
10. Shaq Fu: A Legend Reborn
Serious question: Did ANYONE enjoy Shaq Fu? The 2D fighting title is now renowned for its unpolished and tedious gameplay. Also, who thought it was marketable to have NBA superstar, Shaquille O' Neal, star in a game where he fights monsters instead of, y'know, plays basketball?
Shaq Fu isn't just bad, it's proof that slapping a celeb's name on a crappy product doesn't improve its quality.
But when a crowdfunding campaign for Shaq Fu: A Legend Reborn was set up in 2014, the gaming community seemed to suffer collective amnesia, since thousands of backers were okay with financing a follow-up to this infamous dud.
Even though this reboot reached its funding goal, trouble started brewing immediately. Due to licensing fees, A Legend Reborn suffered massive delays. When multiple ports were cancelled, it was obvious how this needless beat 'em up was going to turn out.
Sure enough, every version of A Legend Reborn received scathing reviews, ranging from 30-54% on MetaCritic. Due to its offensive stereotypes, simplistic combat, and shameful brevity, Shaq Fu: A Legend Reborn is arguably worse than its predecessor.
9. Turok
In the late 1990s, GoldenEye was the top-dog when it came to first-person shooters on the N64.
However, the Turok games weren't far behind. The dino-battling sci-fi saga received consistent praise for its elaborate level design, focus on atmosphere, and the fact the weapons could suck the brains out of enemies.
But when the franchise had a slew of duds, it felt like a reboot was needed. 2016's Turok was developed by Propaganda Games, best-known for... well... nothing at the time. But hey, everybody has to start somewhere.
But apart from the graphics, this incarnation of Turok doesn't have much going for it. The aim-assist is inconsistent, to the point where it's borderline useless. The glitches are so rampant, it's difficult for the Native America hero to perform basic tasks.
Most importantly, the whole game comes across as bland. Compared to other shooters released at the same time like BioShock and Halo 3, Turok feels prehistoric (and not in a good way).
Even though Turok sold marginally well, it wasn't enough to revitalise the brand, causing the proposed sequel to be cancelled. And when Propaganda Games closed shop, Turok fittingly went the way of the dinosaurs.
8. Mighty No. 9
After Capcom cancelled multiple Mega Man projects, the brains behind the super fighting robot, Keiji Inafune, took matters into his own hands.
Leaving the company, Inafune set up a Kickstarter to fund a spiritual successor of Mega Man called Mighty No. 9. Thanks to the Blue Bomber's loyal fanbase, Inafune reached his goal in two days. When the campaign quadrupled its initial target, things were looking up for Mighty No. 9.
Sadly, all hype dried up before release, thanks to the embarrassing Masterclass trailer. Not only was the teaser poorly written and narrated, the line "make the bad guys cry like an anime fan on prom night" single-handedly obliterated any interest in the project.
Then there's the game itself. Honestly, it's hard to understand where the funding went, due to Mighty No. 9's unimaginative mechanics, tiresome gameplay, and by-the-numbers level design.
But Mighty No. 9 wasn't just awful; it was also terribly mismanaged. Kickstarter rewards didn't work, the project was heavily delayed, and several ports were canned (which ended up being a blessing).
Looking back, it's hard to believe the man behind such a beloved franchise screwed up this project so epically.
7. Bomberman: Act Zero
During the 1990s, Bomberman fever was everywhere, with Hudson Soft pumping out up to five games a year revolving around the adorable bomb fanatic.
But when it became painfully obvious Hudson Soft was just repacking and re-releasing the same game over and over, the developers knew something drastic had to be done. With that in mind, the creators forged a reboot in 2006 called Bomberman: Act Zero, which replaced the cutesy style with a dark and gritty aesthetic.
Was it a ballsy move? Absolutely. Was it a good idea? Not at all. Due to the third-person perspective and realistic design, players couldn't tell Act Zero was a Bomberman game, if not for the title.
However, Act Zero's edgy look is not its worst feature.
This reboot suffers from appalling collision detection, unbalanced AI, unbearable loading screens, and grimy art. The main campaign is a borefest from beginning to end, since every level is identical. For some inexplicable reason, the game doesn't have a save option, meaning players are expected to drudge through a hundred levels in one go.
Although Bomberman hasn't had a massive hit since, none of the later entries have been as dreadful as this atrocity.
6. Tomb Raider: Angel Of Darkness
Despite the fact Lara Croft seemingly met her end in Tomb Raider: The Last Revelation, Core Design weren't ready to call it quits on their most lucrative property.
Several years later, the badass archeologist returned in Tomb Raider: Angel of Darkness, which in itself was three years after the forced anthology approach of Tomb Raider: Chronicles. Since this was Lara's debut on the PS2, fans were excited to see how the treasure-hunting, jungle-exploring series would play on Sony's new system.
Although Angel of Darkness was meant to mark Lara Croft's glorious return, it ended up soiling the franchise's reputation. Performing the simplest tasks was a chore due to dated controls, an inconsistent camera, poor combat, and incessant bugs. Also, the frame-rate dipped with such regularity, it felt like a deliberate feature.
Now, this isn't to suggest AoD isn't without merit. When it comes to atmosphere, voice-acting, graphics, and the score, this entry gets top-marks. But considering Angel of Darkness fails in basic departments like moving or climbing platforms, the bad far outweighs the good.
Luckily, Tomb Raider found its footing when it was rebooted again in 2013. If it wasn't for this successful revival, Lara Croft could've stayed buried, figuratively and literally.
5. Yooka-Laylee
Gamers were worried when key players from Rare went their separate ways, believing it would spell the end of certain Rare franchises, especially Banjo-Kazooie. It was all the more disappointing since the last Banjo-Kazooie game, Nuts & Bolts, ended the bear-and-bird's adventures on a downer.
So, when former Rare employees set up a new company called Playtonic Games, things started looking hopeful again. After the developers announced a spiritual successor to Banjo-Kazooie called Yooka-Laylee, it felt like all prayers were about to be answered.
With limited resources, Playtonic had to set up a Kickstarter, with an initial goal of £175,000. The company was overwhelmed with support, receiving over ten times their proposed budget. With over £2 million in the bank, it looked like Yooka-Laylee had more than enough to be a hit.
And the final result was... okay.
By no means terrible, Yooka-Laylee didn't come close to matching its predecessors. Even though the puzzles and platforming sections were fun, Yooka-Laylee felt like it relied on nostalgia, rather than forging its own path.
Sure, it sold decently and spawned a spin-off, but Yooka-Laylee failed to reignite interest in Rare's work the way it should have.
4. Bionic Commando
Nearing the end of the 2000s, Capcom thought it was time to have another crack at one of their most cherished franchises, Bionic Commando. Unlike the 2008 copy-and-paste remake, 2009's Bionic Commando was a major revamp, tailored to resurrect the series.
Rather than churning out another run-and-gun platformer, Capcom and Grin went all out, forging a beautifully rendered world, an in-depth story, a neat combat system and complex grapple hook mechanics. The protagonist, Nathan Spencer, who had previously been depicted as a macho cheeseball, was fleshed out with an intricate and tragic backstory.
As ambitious as the project was, it failed to come together.
Bionic Commando is so generically forgettable, the main takeaway is the ridiculous revelation that Spencer's mechanical arm harbours the soul of his wife. Yeah, it still does't make sense after all this time.
After receiving lukewarm reviews and flopping hard, all plans to continue with turning Bionic Commando into a dark, gritty saga were abandoned. With the series staying dormant for over a decade, it's very possible Bionic Commando is dead for good this time.
3. Sonic The Hedgehog (2006)
Despite the fact Sonic Adventure 1 and 2 were met with a fair amount of praise, their exclusivity on the Dreamcast hurt sales. And when Sonic Heroes received mixed reviews, Sega realised their wisecracking mascot didn't have the same grip on the gaming industry he once did.
To get back on track, Sonic the Hedgehog 2006 was intended to reinvigorate the franchise, allowing the furry speedster to get back on top. Based on epic trailers and a solid demo, this reboot looked like the chilli dog-loving hero had a chance of becoming Mario's rival once more.
But Sega's hopes and dreams didn't pan out, since Sonic '06 turned out worse than anyone could've imagined. Due to buggy gameplay, painful loading times, abysmal controls and boring levels, Sonic '06 is considered the worst entry in the franchise. It still sold decently, but this entry is directly responsible for tainting Sonic the Hedgehog's name.
Even though Sonic '06 was intended to be the sneaker-wearing rodent's comeback, the woeful reboot ended up being his downfall.
2. Shenmue III
Considering Shenmue pioneered quick-time events, open worlds, and other mechanics, it's apparent the Japanese-oriented brawler was ahead of its time.
But since the project cost an outrageous amount and was a Dreamcast exclusive, making a profit was unfeasible. When Shenmue II also bombed, Yu Suzuki's potential franchise seemingly fizzled away.
Both instalments may have failed, but the admiration for Shenmue grew with time, causing them to develop a cult-following. Realising there was still a deep love for his creation, Suzuki organised a Kickstarter campaign for a third Shenmue in 2015.
Amazingly, Shenmue III became the fastest crowdfunded project to reach $1 million and the first Kickstarter game to raise over $6 million. It ended up raising $20 million in the end, surpassing its original goal ten-fold. It looked like the fanbase would be lining up in the streets to get their hands on this long-awaited sequel.
That's why it's depressing to learn Shenmue III was a major bomb. In fact, it failed to outsell 2018's remaster of the original.
Worst of all, this highly anticipated instalment wasn't very good. Although its predecessors pushed the boundaries, Shenmue III was more of the same, making it coming across as dated and unimaginative.
1. Duke Nukem Forever
Although the first two Duke Nukem games sold adequately, its third outing was a monster hit, selling 3.5 million units. After the alien-busting outlaw reached a new level of popularity, fans eagerly awaited a follow-up.
And wow, did they wait. Duke Nukem Forever was originally set for release in 1998. After countless delays, the long-awaited sequel came out in 2011, earning the Guinness World Record for longest time a video game spent in development.
But Forever's development didn't just take forever, it was also unnecessarily expensive. Due to licensing fees, discarded content, having the project restarted repeatedly, running out of cash, and being bought out by another company, Duke Nukem's fourth outing ended up costing at least $30 million.
Though it was impossible for Forever to meet expectations, fans were still excited to witnessed Duke Nukem's return, especially after he took an unintentional hiatus for 14 years.
But when the cigar-chomping hero finally burst onto the scene, it was obvious the game wasn't worth the wait. Despite spending an eternity to develop, Duke Nukem Forever felt rushed, due to the shoddy graphics, excessive platforming, primitive AI, dated pop-culture references, and buggy gameplay.
With all that money and time at its disposal, it's impressive how badly Duke Nukem eviscerated its own legacy in one fell swoop.