10 Video Games That Made You Pay For Essential Features

We shouldn't have to pay for save slots, but Metal Gear Survive had different ideas.

Metro last light
4A

Ever since its conception, DLC has had a contentious place within the video game industry. Though players initially laughed at the sheer ridiculousness of charging money for horse armour in Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion, the practice of purchasing additional content is something that hasn't gone away and is unlikely to go anywhere soon.

If anything, DLC has become more prevalent in games today, with expansions, cosmetics, and battle passes now being expected in most new release.

Although paying for extra content seemed like an alien concept when it first appeared, developers have since shown that DLC can be a useful means of extending a game's lifecycle alongside giving players more of the games that they love. Sometimes the expansion can even be just as incredible as the base game, with The Witcher 3's Blood And Wine and BioShock 2's Minerva's Den standing out as some of the best expansions of all time.

Other times, though, publishers can be downright exploitative when it comes to DLC. Whereas horse armour was a harmless extra, there have been other times where games have required players to pay more for essential features that should have been part of the main game.

10. Starting A New Run - Mighty Doom (2023)

Mighty Doom
Bethesda Softworks

Being a free-to-play mobile game, players can expect a tonne of grinding in top-down roguelite MIghty Doom to upgrade the Doom Slayer's arsenal enough to progress in later levels. Getting the materials for said upgrades therefore takes numerous runs to acquire.

However, starting a new run in this game isn't as straight forward as it should have been. Instead of simply opting to try again after dying (which will happen a lot), beginning a new attempt is tied to an in-game currency known as Energy, which players will need to have five of if they'd like to play the game.

When Energy is depleted, the choice is to either wait for hours until the resource replenishes itself or to spend real money to get the Energy required to play.

More annoying is that this cutesy version of the gory run-and-gun shooter only allows players to hold a maximum of 20 Energy at a time. This means that players can only play a measly four games before they're forced to either wait or throw money at the game for the privilege of trying again.

Even for free-to-play games, being encouraged to pay to play the game is absurd.


9. Save Slots - Metal Gear Survive (2018)

Metal Gear Survive Extra Save Slot Dlc
Konami

Metal Gear Survive was a game that had everything going against it before it even launched. Not only was the game’s zombie survival premise the furthest thing from what fans wanted from a Metal Gear title, but this was infamously the spin-off title that came in the wake of Hideo Kojima’s unamicable departure from Konami.

The game looked like a soulless cash grab on a popular IP, and that’s exactly what it was. The plot was uninteresting, and the gameplay loop of scavenging resources was dull and uninspired. Survive was simply an unenjoyable experience to play, but somehow these weren’t the worst parts of the game.

In an unpleasant shock to everyone, Konami had the audacity to charge players for additional save slots, a feature that's so commonplace in modern games that the thought of being asked to pay for them was unthinkable.

If players wanted to have more than the solitary slot, they start with they’d need to exchange around $10 of their own money for Survive’s SV coins which could then be used to acquire extra saves.

Even if this game was worth playing more than once, this piece of paid-for content as nothing less than pure greed from Konami.


8. Storage Boxes - Fallout 76 (2018)

Fallout 76 - Fallout 1st
Bethesda Softworks

Despite undergoing a handful of game-changing updates which added heaps of exciting content, Fallout 76 nevertheless remains notorious for its catastrophic launch. From pre-order blunders, a handful of game-breaking bugs, and a massive data leak, the beginning of this game’s life was a complete disaster.

Even when Bethesda had corrected some of the biggest concerns surrounding their game (namely a lack of NPCs in the world), fans were still displeased with a sizeable list of grievances which spoiled their time in post-apocalyptic West Virginia.

One such gripe was the stingy limit placed on how much scrap players could store. Although the quantity has since been increased to 1200lbs since launch, the cap remains a thorn in the community’s side.

However, there was a way to increase storage space, and that was to pay for the Fallout 1st subscription service, which will set players back £11.99 a month (or £99 per year).

Alongside unlocking private servers and unique cosmetic items, this subscription fee would likewise grant players unlimited space for all their base-building materials.

Being such a heavily requested feature, it’s understandable why the community voiced their outrage at Bethesda for charging them for a quality of life feature they’d asked for since launch.


7. The True Ending - Asura's Wrath (2012)

asuras wrath ending
Capcom

It's not unusual for games to drop massive plot points as part of DLCs. Assassin's Creed Origins, for example, waited for The Hidden Ones expansion to show how the order of assassins came to be, and Alan Wake expanded upon the titular writer's fate with the release of two bonus chapters that picked up after the events of the main game.

As important as these DLCs were in understanding the overarching narrative, however, they weren't essential when it came to finishing the game.

The same cannot be said for Asura's Wrath, however.

When the dust settles at what looks to be the climactic finale of the eponymous hero's high-octane quest to rescue his kidnapped daughter, players were led to believe that he succeeded in his mission.

But Asura's story wasn't over yet, and the only way of seeing the true ending was to purchase the final four episodes. Here, the demi-god's story continued as an unexpected revelation took the real finale in an exciting new direction for more outlandishly fantastic action spectacle.

As excellent as this game is, charging customers more experience the real ending of Asura's epic tale was a sneaky move from Capcom.


6. The Rest Of The Game - Evolve (2015)

Evolve Game
2K

There was a lot of excitement surrounding Evolve back in 2015. Helmed by Left 4 Dead developers Turtle Rock Studio, this asymmetric multiplayer game saw a team of four players work together to hunt a player-controlled monster before they had time to evolve the creature into a near-unstoppable killing machine.

Evolve's initial reception proved promising, with many praising game's taut gameplay and unique atmospheric setting. And while the title was a success at launch, it didn't take long for the cracks to show.

Alongside a sluggish progression system turning the title into a prolonged grind, it was the ludicrous DLC plans which sparked controversy surrounding the game.

While Take-Two was generous enough to offer new maps for free, everything else from cosmetics to new monsters and heroes were locked behind a paywall. There were 44 pieces of DLC available on launch day alone worth over $130 in total.

Whereas it's normal for games to include some extra content as paid DLC, Evolve took things too far by charging players too much to access the rest of the game in a fatal move that would lead to the plug being pulled on this once highly anticipated release.


5. Story Missions - Overwatch 2 (2022)

Overwatch 2
Blizzard

Since Overwatch 2 launched in October 2022, Blizard have made some questionable decisions that have caused fans to raise an eyebrow on more than one occasion. Alongside having the sequel replace the first game, the cancellation of the highly anticipated Hero PvE mode has been points of contention for veterans of the multiplayer shooter.

Despite these disappointing missteps, fans have been patiently waiting for the arrival of story missions which were noticeably absent at launch. Taking place in expansive new areas, these missions are set to build upon the series’ overarching lore, something that players have been eagerly awaiting.

However, in another disheartening blow to the Overwatch community, Blizzard announced that the first three missions launching as part of the upcoming sixth season would only be available to those willing to pay $15 for them.

While this bundle does include some extra goodies like credits and legendary skins, slapping a sizeable price tag on the major feature fans have been excited for comes across as a manipulative move from Blizzard, especially when this extra content is substantially less than what was initially promised.

Though Overwatch 2 is free-to-play, being strongarmed into paying for the game’s main selling point hasn’t gone down well.


4. Elvish Dialogue - The Lord Of The Rings: Gollum (2023)

The Lord Of The Rings Gollum
Daedalic Entertainment/Nacon

After facing multiple delays since its announcement, The Lord Of The Rings: Gollum finally released in May 2023 to critical scathing. The stealth-action game starring the titular character was set to bring players into the fantastical world of Tolkien's Middle-earth to tell an original story from a unique perspective. However, a selection of mediocre missions, bland narrative, and downright broken gameplay mechanics drastically soured the experience.

Even though playing as Gollum wasn’t much fun, the game nevertheless managed to immerse players in one of the greatest fantasy worlds ever created thanks to some genuinely impressive sound design and music. A large part of this game’s appeal was experiencing Tolkien’s world, but this title fumbled this too by charging players extra money to hear elvish characters speaking in Elvish.

It’s only by purchasing the Sindarin VO pack (either as part of the Precious Edition or separately) that players will be able to hear elvish characters consistently conversing in their native tongue.

Despite developers Daedalic claiming that the dialogue was created by “lore experts”, placing such a basic part of Middle-earth behind a paywall was another baffling misfire for what’s considered to be one of the worst games of the year so far.


3. The Intended Difficulty Setting - Metro: Last Light (2013)

Metro Last Light
4A Games

Adding extra difficulty modes is an effective way of generating extra levels of challenge for players after rolling credits on the main game. After completing Resident Evil 4 Remake, for example, Resi fans can test their skill on Professional difficulty where limited saves and tougher enemies will test the skills of even the most accomplished players.

While difficulty modes are typically already included in the base game, there are times when extra modes are added post-launch, with Amnesia: The Bunker expected to include a Shell-Shocked mode soon.

What's not expected, though, is for publishers to charge an additional price for difficulty modes.

This was what happened in Metro: Last Light when it included its Ranger difficulty setting as a pre-order bonus before releasing it as a DLC pack.

By making the gameplay more realistic by removing HUD crosshairs and limiting how much Artyom could carry, this mode was for hardcore survivors. But it was the fact that this setting was advertised as the "intended" way the game should be played that caused backlash.

If fans wanted to play this game the way the developers envisioned, they'd now need to pay an extra $4.99 to do so. Artistic vision shouldn't come at an extra cost.


2. Javik - Mass Effect 3 (2012)

Mass Effect 3 - Javik
Electronic Arts

In critically acclaimed Mass Effect series, players spend much of their time as Commander Shepherd fighting back against the impending Reaper invasion whenever they're not romancing crewmates.

Not much is divulged about what exactly the Reapers are during the first two games other than their arrival would spell the end of the entire universe, with the extinction of an ancient alien race known as the Protheans underscoring how dangerous the Reapers were. However, there was just as little revealed about what this mysterious civilisation was.

It wasn't until Mass Effect 3 until players finally learned more about this precursor race when a skirmish for an artefact would lead the Normandy crew to discovering Javik, the last remaining Prothean. However, this was only possible if fans picked up the From Ashes DLC.

Alongside adding a new squad mate to the game, From Ashes was essential in filling in the gaps in lore surrounding this race and the crucial role they played within the Mass Effect universe.

Even more irritating was this DLC was released alongside the game's launch, a move that sparked allegations that the content was included on the disc but locked behind a paywall to wring extra funds from fans.


1. Locking Players Out The Game - Destiny: The Taken King (2015)

Destiny The Taken King
Bungie

Live service models can be a tricky balancing act in which developers must find a way to bring exciting and engaging content to their game to increase revenue without punishing those who choose not to purchase any extras on top of the base game.

For most live service titles, this is achieved by implementing a paid-for season pass to reward customers with premium content alongside the free update that everyone has access to.

Destiny didn't seem to get this memo, however, when Bungie dropped The Taken King expansion.

While this expansive updated added a tonne of new and improved features alongside a taut campaign to reinvigorate the looter-shooter, not everyone got to experience the new-and-improved Destiny.

Those who didn't upgrade to the new expansion weren't just unable to take part in the new campaign or game modes, but they unfortunately found themselves severely restricted on what they had access to, with hero strikes and new Vanguard playlists now being off the table.

Thanks to the sheer amount of gameplay tweaks offered in the update, those who didn't purchase the expansion were locked out of playing the game that they'd already paid for.

Forcing players to buy DLC just to continue playing a game was incredibly unfair.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Glasgow-based cinephile who earned a Masters degree in film studies to spend their time writing about cinema, video games, and horror.