10 Video Games That Punish You For Playing Perfectly

It's not always the time to get good.

Saw II game thumb
Konami

Unsurprisingly, the aim of most games is to get as good as you possibly can at them. Be it levelling to an insane amount of power in an RPG, learning a shooter's mechanics so well you can kill someone with your eyes closed, or having such a mastery of a puzzle game you know immediately how to solve it, every genre and type of game rewards you for develop skill.

Most of the time, anyways. Just to pull a fast one of you, some games like to actively punish you for being too good at them - either to dissuade you from grinding levels or similar tactics, or just because they didn't expect you to do so well the first time around.

This can often be seemingly by accident, as often this is because the game isn't actively made with players who are exceptional at it in mind. But sometimes it feels as though it's actively out of spite, because very often you don't realise you've been playing a game too well until either a boss fight sabotages itself, or you realise you've gotten the wrong ending to the game.

10. The White Chamber

the white chamber
Studio Trophis

Arguably, getting everything "right" in a game shouldn't be the main way you get its best ending. Because, at the end of the day, it's generally hard to get everything right first time, and being locked out of a game's best ending because of a small mistake or two can feel kind of bitter.

The white chamber takes this into account - especially because you're playing as a character who is revealed to be pretty massively flawed, with the purpose of the plot being her learning to be a little less awful. As such, doing everything perfectly doesn't net you the best ending in the game - indeed, it nets you the joke ending, where it turns out the whole thing was kind of a prank.


9. Pokémon Mystery Dungeon: Explorers Of Darkness/Time

Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Explorers Of Sky
Game Freak

For the most part, the Pokémon series - including its spin-offs - reward hard work. If you grind your team up to a high enough level, chances are it'll make everything significantly easier.

There is a part of the Mystery Dungeon sequels that does punish ardent fans of the franchise, however. It comes in the sentry minigame, where you have to guess the Pokémon by their footprint.

If you're enough of a Pokénerd that you get them all right immediately straight away, you actually kind of end up shooting yourself in the foot in a sense. Because the minigame rewards you far more lucratively if you beat your previous score, meaning the better you do at it first time around, the less you end up getting from this game overall.

And given some of these rewards are super helpful, you can easily feel a little punished for knowing the difference between a Rattata and a Kangaskhan here.


8. Kirby's Dream Land 2

Kirby's Dream Land 2
Nintendo

One of the funniest things in the world is to hear the different names players have developed for enemies in games where you aren't immediately told them.

This is especially true when the game is the likes of Mario or Kirby, because you tend to play them first when you're a little younger - meaning both that the name you came up with is more ridiculous, and that you simply can't get it out of your head.

Kirby Dream Land 2 only encourages this behaviour, as you don't actually get the official heads up as to what the enemies real names are until you finish the game. Even then, you are only shown all their names if you get the regular ending by defeating King Dedede without getting all the extra Rainbow drops.


7. Banjo-Tooie

Canary Mary Banjo-Tooie
Rare

For the most part, Banjo-Tooie manages to balance out its difficulty fair well. You can't compete everything perfectly first try unless you're a dyed in the wool platforming expert, but if you're a decent hand at video games, there also aren't too many areas that'll give you grief.

Aside from your last race against Canary Mary, of course, which is almost infamously painful if you don't know about it already. The gist is that Mary is coded with the rubberband catch up system that most racing games or minigames use, in order to ensure you can some kind of competition by having the other players remain (relatively) close to you.

Issue is, if you speed away too early in the race, Mary will speed up and not slow down, meaning that your chances of beating her become suddenly much lower. For your best shot, you need to gently stay a little ahead of your opponent until basically the last lap, unless you want her to suddenly gain superspeed when its most inconvenient.


6. Final Fantasy II

Final Fantasy Ii 2
Square Enix

One of the interesting things about Final Fantasy II is the stat growth system. Instead of merely boosting your skills when you level up, it runs by a method similar to the likes of Skyrim - where every time you use a weapon or spell, it increases their skill. Use whatever ability enough times, and you'll level it up.

While this is usually an effective system, it does come with some crucial issues: namely, that in order to effectively level up your skills, you don't want to win too quickly. Kill an enemy in a single hit, and the fight has been significantly less useful than if you'd had to duke it out for a long time.

It's an effective way to prevent too much grinding, but it seems weird that Final Fantasy of all games worried about people grinding. It's even weirder when you think that knowing about this system would make you play the game purposefully "bad" at points, just so you can maximise your skills.


5. Shin Megami Tensei IV

Shin Megami Tensei Iv
Atlus

The Shin Megami Tensei series is essentially the eccentric older brother of the Persona series, and this alone should clue you in to how wild it is at many points in time.

This is especially true for the morality system in the game. As you might imagine from an RPG, Shin Megami Tensei IV has the conventional ending set up, with a good ending, a bad ending, and two neutral endings.

One of these two neutral endings - the most difficult one to get, coincidentally - requires you to not get a neutral moral meter score by the end of the game.

Now, you might be asking a very reasonable question: why? Well, in order to get an actual neutral ending in the game, you need to finish the game with either a negative eight in morality, or a positive eight.

Sounds easy, right? Well, the issue is that the final choice you make in the game gives you either a negative or positive ten. So, if you managed to play the game so well that you got the most neutral moral score you could - negative or positive one - the final choice will take you out of the neutral ending, in a cruel cruel twist of maths.

So, in order to get the neutral ending, you need to be less neutral in your playthrough. Makes perfect sense.


4. World Of Warcraft

World of Warcraft
Blizzard

You'd think the raid section of World of Warcraft would be the one time you'd be encouraged to be as perfect as is humanly possible at the class you chose. And indeed, if you see (or play) a top tier raid, you'll see people turning what was a hobby into a very serious career for however long it lasts, using their skills to the best of their abilities.

However, it turns out there is such a thing as being too good in this scenario, as some boss fights actively penalise you for basically being too good.

Now, this doesn't seem entirely on purpose, but rather down to the ways some fights are constructed - for example, take Maloriak's first phrase down too quickly, and all the summons he would have used in that phrase will appear in the second, on top of the enemies that appear in that phase, leading to a very bad time.

This can also happen with achievements, as you can beat a boss too quickly and miss the sweet trophy - leading to hilarious circumstances of DPS players having to hold off in order to not kill their enemy quite yet.


3. Mabinogi

Mabinogi Mobile
Nexon

If you thought Skyrim's "use the thing until it levels up" system could be wild, wait until you hear about Mabinogi.

The game works on a system similar to this, but with one crucial difference: you also have to fail at using a skill a certain amount of times for it to work. Though it's certainly an innovative method, it comes with a really weird side effect - the better you get at the skill, the harder it can be to level it up, because you still need to fail.

This means, if you get good enough, you'll have to purposefully fail at whatever ability you're trying to develop in order to actually improve it, which is the most backwards concept imaginable.


2. Red Faction II

Red Faction II
THQ

Red Faction II has four endings, with which you get being dependant on how well you play the game - for example, the worst ending comes when you get the lower score, which is exactly as cruel as you might imagine.

Interestingly, though, the ending you get for the highest score is actually the game's joke ending, where Alias becomes a bestselling author and has his life made into a video game, Tangier goes to live on Mars, and Shrike marries into a circus and becomes the premium attraction of a popular theme park.

Although this makes practical sense - because getting the higher score requires you to be good at the game to a level most only reach on a replay of it - it does accidentally punish you if you turn out to be a natural dab hand. If this happens to be the case, you're going to have to run through the game purposefully playing worse - but not too much worse - in order to see the more "legitimate" ending to the game.


1. Saw II: Flesh And Blood

Saw II game
Konami

The clever thing about Saw II is that it really emulates the difficult decisions that individuals in the film series and its awful traps have to make.

This is best shown in your playthrough as Campbell, as - after overcoming countless traps and maiming yourself repeatedly in the process - you are given the option between saving yourself, or saving someone your son's age but condemning yourself to death.

While dying counts as "failing" this trial (because you're dead), saving yourself will come to bite you in the ass far harder, as it's revealed that the game's main character, Michael Tapp, is the person Campbell kills if he chooses to save his own hide.

As such, if you want the best ending of the game, you're gonna have to kill off Campbell in order to do so. To be fair, given Michael has done nothing wrong - but is instead in the Saw traps because of his dad - it does seem like the fair choice to make, just one you don't really realise you're making the first time around.


Watch Next


Final Fantasy ALL GAMES Quiz: How Well Do You Know The Franchise?

Square Enix

1. I - Which Of The Following Is Not A Bonus Dungeon In Remakes Of The Game?

Contributor
Contributor

I like my comics like I like my coffee - in huge, unquestionably unhealthy doses.