10 Video Games That RUINED Amazing Villains
Nobody needed Shelob to be sexy.
Making a truly iconic and memorable video game villain sure is hard, but once you've pulled it off, fans will relish seeing the baddie return time and time again in an inevitable glut of sequels.
However, sometimes developers don't quite seem to appreciate the brilliance they're sitting on, and so, whether in a sequel or a remake of the original game, they throw out everything fans actually liked about the antagonist.
Perhaps the villain is downgraded from a badass into a total wimp, maybe they're unceremoniously killed off or given a bizarre personality transplant, or they've simply strayed too far from what fans fell in love with in the first place.
These iterations of once-classic villains left fans totally and utterly baffled, wondering what the developers were thinking with these narrative and design choices, which were most often done for cynical reasons or, sometimes, no discernible reason at all.
Fans were forced to watch some of entertainment's most beloved and iconic baddies get turned into laughing stocks before their very eyes, ensuring they would never view them the same way ever again...
10. Black Mask - Batman: Arkham Knight
Black Mask is one of the most beloved foes in Batman's rogues gallery, and Rocksteady's Arkham games seemed like a fitting venue to give him his fair due.
Yet perhaps no other Batman villain can claim to have been so thoroughly wasted and eventually ruined throughout the franchise.
His mask makes an Easter egg-y appearance in Arkham Asylum as the answer to one of The Riddler's challenges, before he has a cameo in Arkham City where he's attempting to fend off Hugo Strange's guards.
Black Mask seemingly has a more substantial role in prequel Arkham Origins, yet it's soon enough revealed that it's The Joker in fact posing as him, effectively providing a segue for yet another Joker-centric Batman game.
And finally we have Arkham Knight's Red Hood DLC, where the Red Hood fights his way to Black Mask, only for the villain to beg for his life before Red Hood throws him out of a window to his death.
That's not only literal assassination but character assassination - in the comics Black Mask was a savagely intimidating and calculating mob boss, but throughout the Arkham series and especially in Arkham Knight's DLC, he's reduced to a pathetic triviality who dies a coward's death.
Black Mask had the potential to be a more grounded villain compared to the more campy, theatrical Joker, and yet Rocksteady threw it all away.
9. Skull Face - Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain
Skull Face was first introduced in Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain's bite-sized prologue Ground Zeroes, which quickly established him as an imposing antagonist who fans naturally couldn't wait to take down in The Phantom Pain itself.
And yet, despite Skull Face's excellent character design, James Horan's terrific vocal performance, and his enticingly mysterious past, he ends up being a total damp squib of a villain.
For starters, per the game's scaled-back cinematic approach compared to its predecessors, we don't actually get to see a whole lot of Skull Face throughout The Phantom Pain, which massively dings his impact compared to prior Metal Gear Solid villains.
On top of this, his primary confrontation with Venom Snake isn't a boss fight but an infamous, unintentionally comical exposition dump in the back of a jeep near the end of the game, before Skull Face gets unceremoniously crushed to death by Metal Gear Sahelanthropus as piloted by Psycho Mantis.
Skull Face had all the makings of an all-timer Metal Gear villain, but as is a rarity for Hideo Kojima, he skimps on both the backstory and the creative boss fight fans understandably expected, before having him die a highly underwhelming death.
8. Tiny Tiger - Crash Of The Titans
Though Tiny Tiger isn't one of Crash Bandicoot's top-tier villains alongside, say, Neo Cortex or N. Gin, he has appeared in a number of the mainline and spin-off games alike since making his debut in Crash Bandicoot 2: Cortex Strikes Back.
In the second and third games, Tiny puts Crash through two of the more memorable boss fights in the main series, and though he's not nearly as smart as his superiors, his brawny persona provides a welcome riposte to their poindextering.
He was a blunt object who simply wanted to smash Crash into dust, but he was amusingly stupid and clumsy, as sometimes proved to be his downfall.
2007's Crash of the Titans saw the series undergo a major aesthetic overhaul, however, as the main cast all received significant makeovers, such as Crash receiving punky tribal tattoos.
If Crash was disgraced, then Tiny was outright massacred, as the hyper-masculine brute was reimagined to basically resemble Mike Tyson painted with tiger stripes and put into a pair of combat fatigues.
Tiny was markedly less-buff than in prior appearances, his voice wasn't as menacing, and he'd changed so much that he may as well have been a totally different character.
Crash of the Titans is admittedly jam-packed with head-scratching design decisions, but it's really tough to parse the mindset here.
At least Tiny ended up looking a little more like himself in the subsequent remakes of the original trilogy and Crash Team Racing, as well as his brief cameo in Crash 4.
7. Shao Kahn - Mortal Kombat 11
Shao Kahn is historically the overarching antagonist of the Mortal Kombat franchise - the all-powerful ruler of Outworld who serves as the end-boss in many of the series' games.
Shao Kahn is a takes-no-prisoners ass-kicker who presents a major brick wall of difficulty, and though skilled players will eventually be able to defeat him, he's mostly managed to maintain a fearsome reputation.
That was, at least, until the most recent entry into the series, Mortal Kombat 11, where he played second fiddle to new antagonist Kronika in the hope of once again becoming the ruler of Outworld.
Kahn is then defeated and blinded by Kitana before, in the game's Aftermath expansion, being betrayed by Shang Tsung and drained of his soul alongside Sindel.
Given that Kahn is typically presented as an ultra-wise and powerful enemy, seeing him get ganked so effortlessly by both Kitana and Shang Tsung felt like a major disservice to both the character and to fans.
6. Nemesis - Resident Evil 3
The original 1999 release of Resident Evil 3: Nemesis is still fondly remembered today for the utterly terrifying presentation of its titular antagonist.
Counter to the series' lumbering zombies, Nemesis moved extremely fast, packed a mighty punch, and would even chase the player between multiple rooms as proved particularly stressful.
Above all else, it was vital that the 2020 remake got Nemesis right, though sadly the generally rushed, thrown-together feel of the remake also transpired through to its deeply underwhelming treatment of its primary antagonist.
For starters, this new version of Nemesis has been re-designed - or rather, over-designed. His face looks markedly different, complete with a strangely crooked nose, while he's wearing what's probably supposed to be a body-bag but just looks like a couple of binbags stuck together.
His voice isn't as a creepy either nor are his mutations as impressive, but the deal-breaker is that the player's encounters with "Nemmy" just aren't nearly as scary.
The original game truly makes Nemesis feel like a Terminator-esque killing machine, whereas in the remake he's far less of a threat.
It doesn't help that the game generally appears to regard Nemesis as more of a joke, as when Jill infamously says, "B*tch can't even swim":
5. Thanos - Guardians Of The Galaxy: The Telltale Series
Telltale's Guardians of the Galaxy series made its debut in April 2017, all while movie audiences were still waiting to see the MCU's Thanos (Josh Brolin) take on the Avengers in Avengers: Infinity War the next year.
But even the most casual Marvel fan already knew that Thanos was one of the most powerful Big Bads in the history of comic books, and so there was a reasonable expectation that he'd wreak absolute havoc in Telltale's series.
And so, when the game's very first episode saw the Guardians facing off against him, it was fair to assume that the confrontation would end with Thanos prevailing or at least escaping with his life in tow.
But in a move that shocked just about everyone, the Mad Titan was actually genuinely killed off in the first half-hour of episode one, when Star-Lord fatally blasts him in the chest. And though players surely expected him to return later in the series, he never does.
Thanos' battle with the Guardians confirmed that this version of the character was a far weaker iteration of the all-powerful hurt-bringer from the comics and movies.
While on one hand it's admirable that Telltale didn't simply follow the same rough arc as the MCU movies, it was still a huge disappointment for many who had been partially sold on the game by the heavy presence of Thanos in its marketing.
Subverting expectations can definitely be a good thing, but in this case they took a fan favourite villain and reduced him to a rent-a-goon who proved to be a mere inconvenience to the Guardians.
4. Doctor Eggman - Sonic The Hedgehog (2006)
Dr. Eggman aka Dr. Robotnik is without question one of the most iconic video game villains of all time, and while his design has undergone a number of variations over the years, they've largely clung to the maxim that Eggman is, well, bulbous and egg-shaped.
But the 2006 Sonic reboot - a game that really didn't need any help at all being critically reviled - was pilloried for drastically redesigning Eggman to be considerably thinner.
Furthermore, his trademark pink nose was nowhere to be seen, and his "realistic" sunglasses meant that we could also see something we've never seen before - his disconcertingly baby blue eyes.
Sega basically attempted to give Eggman's Sonic Adventure design a grounded update, but most fans were simply left horrified at what they'd done to a classic design that didn't remotely need tinkering with.
It's still less horrifying than Sonic making out with a human woman in the game, but only barely.
Thankfully the vitriol against Eggman's new design and the game as a whole was potent enough that he immediately returned to a more typically paunchy, cartoony look in the next Sonic game.
3. Vaas Montenegro - Far Cry 3
Far Cry 3 is the point at which the FPS franchise pivoted into card-carrying AAA blockbuster territory, in large part because Ubisoft decided to market each new game on the strength of its larger-than-life mascot-like antagonist.
In the third game this was charismatic pirate lord Vaas Montenegro, who was the focus of Far Cry 3's trailers above everything else, while the game's production team compared him to Darth Vader.
And in fairness, what we got of Vaas was pretty damn great for the most part - he was a dynamic, entertaining antagonist with an intriguing backstory as brilliantly performed by Michael Mando.
It's just a shame, then, that Vaas actually doesn't have much screen time throughout the game at all, amounting to about 20 minutes' worth of cutscenes.
Worse still, he's killed a mere two-thirds of the way through the game in a crushingly underwhelming encounter that culminates in control being wrestled away from the player in the pivotal moment. The overarching villain who takes his place, Hoyt Volker, can't hold a damn candle to him.
Seemingly realising they'd whiffed the opportunity to make the most of Vaas, Ubisoft resurrected him for one of Far Cry 6's DLC episodes which ultimately implies he could still be alive.
2. Shelob - Middle-Earth: Shadow Of War
Anyone who's seen The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King will surely remember Frodo's (Elijah Wood) traumatic encounter with the demonic Shelob, which takes the form of a giant spider.
Fans of both Peter Jackson's movies and J.R.R. Tokien's source material were excited to see how the character would be portrayed in Middle-earth: Shadow of War, only to be taken aback that developers Monolith Productions decided to depict her in the most cynical and pandering way possible.
In the game, Shelob is able to appear in the form of a sexy elven woman, which couldn't be much less transparent of an attempt to inject some added sex appeal into the game.
But why pick the one character supposed to look like a damn giant spider? The decision naturally raised a lot of eyebrows with the fanbase, who despite praising Shadow of War's gameplay found this character change to be basically sacrilegious.
1. Fat Officials - Demon's Souls
Bluepoint Games' remake of Demon's Souls is for the most part an excellent new-gen retooling of FromSoftware's classic predecessor to Dark Souls, save for some of its less-inspired redesigns of classic enemies.
And none got fans' goat more than the Fat Officials, the obese demons decked out in garish golden garb, which in the original game wore massively creepy grins across their mask-life faces.
For the remake, though, the Fat Officials were redesigned into a more generic, pustule-covered "fat guy" enemy, the spine-tingling smile replaced with a more neutral villainous facial expression, and their clothing made less-opulent.
If the original Fat Officials were grotesque caricatures of greed and inequality that only FromSoftware could come up with, the remake versions felt like garden variety enemies from any number of action-adventure games. The original character and personality has been almost entirely stripped away.