10 Video Games That Should Have Ditched Their Multiplayer Modes
Not everything is better with friends.
Multiplayer modes can be a great way for developers to prolong the lifecycle of their games, keeping players coming back time and time again. In recent years there seems to have been an effort to try and shoehorn in any kind of online interaction between players, in an attempt keep them engaged for months, years and even longer.
This has led to some out-of-place multiplayer modes being forced into series' that were predominantly a single-player experience.
That isn't to say that these multiplayer modes are inherently bad, however they were often not what fans of the series were looking for and you can't help but think that development resources could have been better spent elsewhere.
A small note then before we dive in:
Games are only considered for this list if they have a multiplayer mode separate from the core single-player experience. Therefore, titles that include cooperative or player vs. player modes embedded within the single-player campaign are excluded from this list.
So let’s take a look at the games that should have ditched their multiplayer modes altogether.
10. Bioshock 2
Similar to Far Cry 3, Bioshock 2 was released during a time when every First-Person Shooter had a multiplayer mode, so it should come as little surprise then that the second entry in the beloved Bioshock series also featured a competitive multiplayer mode.
A series best known for its twisting narrative and atmospheric worlds, it should be no surprise that the multiplayer mode was met with either a sceptical curiosity or flat-out indifference when it was first announced.
The series was also not exactly known for having tight gameplay mechanics and smooth gunplay making a multiplayer mode an odd choice considering Call Of Duty and Halo had recently redefined the expectations for Multiplayer shooters.
Despite this the mode turned out surprisingly well even featuring some nice story elements in the mode that would appeal to series fans, however it ultimately never took off as it wasn’t what fans wanted from a Bioshock game and it also unfortunately suffered from a number of bugs that hindered the experience.
The mode was even scrapped when the game was remastered for the Bioshock Remastered Collection in 2016.
9. Far Cry 3
A First-Person Shooter and a competitive multiplayer mode should go hand in hand, right?
That's clearly what Ubisoft Montreal thought when creating Far Cry 3. The game received excellent reviews for its vibrant world and addictive gameplay loop, not to mention its infamous antagonist, and is arguably the best in what has become a long running series.
Unfortunately the multiplayer mode, while good for a few hours of mindless fun, failed to recapture the magic seen in the solo campaign and therefore was a largely forgettable experience.
The multiplayer offered the standard competitive fare, as well as a co-operative mode that allowed players to work their way through specifically curated maps together. While neither of the modes were particularly bad they just became largely forgettable during a time where the offering of multiplayer shooters included the likes of Call of Duty: Black Ops 2, Battlefield 3 and Halo 4.
Therefore, in Multiplayer terms the game was little more than a generic FPS as the mode lacked what made the solo experience so great.
8. God Of War: Ascension
It may come as a surprise to some that the God of War series at one point actually included a multiplayer mode, especially for those only really familiar with 2018s exceptional reboot. That was the case though with the Playstation 3’s God of War Ascension, which featured a Spartans vs Trojans multiplayer mode in addition to its hack-and-slash single-player campaign.
The multiplayer had some unique ideas such as the ability to align with one of four Greek gods, which would determine the skills available and therefore the playstyle to go with. Players would then engage in combat against one another across a number of modes in a wide range of arenas. There was also a co-operative horde mode where players teamed up to fight off waves of enemies.
While it provided some entertainment for a short while, it wasn’t what fans of the series were clamouring for and served as little more than a nice distraction from brutally butchering Deities in the main campaign.
Many fans consider this the weakest entry in the series, so it begs the question of whether focusing entirely on the single-player could have helped this entry fare better in the eyes of fans?
7. Donkey Kong 64
This entry may result in some hate as there will likely be a large number of gamers who hold fond memories of playing the unlockable multiplayer mode in Donkey Kong 64 with soon-to-be former friends. The mode was fun for the time and provided some good fun in short bursts with up to four players, however it was vastly different to the single-player experience in Donkey Kong’s first 3D outing.
With two modes on offer, Monkey Smash and Battle Arena, the mode served as little more than a nice distraction when you had friends over. However, with games like Goldeneye, Mario Kart 64 and Mario Party already on Nintendo’s 3D system there were better games that could be played with friends.
The original manual for Rare’s Platformer even jokingly made reference to the fact that the game featured a multiplayer mode that was likely thrown in at the last minute and was likely average at best. Self-deprecating jokes aside, the multiplayer mode provided a nice distraction but was ultimately lacking compared to other games on offer at the time.
6. Assassin’s Creed: Brotherhood
Multiplayer in an Assassin’s Creed game seems like a weird dream but there was a time when it was there before the series’ transition to a sprawling open-world RPG.
In fairness to Ubisoft, the mode did work, and was a largely unique experience not offered anywhere else.
It’s a shame then that outside of small groups it never really took off in it’s own right and the series is still remembered only for its single-player experience.
The mode saw players trying to hunt another player or AI-controlled target while also being hunted by another player. Players would need to figure out ways to hunt their target while maintaining a low profile and blending into their surroundings.
The mode was good fun but unfortunately apart from a small dedicated group it never really served as much more than an icon on the main menu. The decision to hide some achievements and trophies behind the multiplayer mode also angered some fans who only enjoyed the series for its single-player experience.
5. Dead Space 2
It should be relatively clear by now that there is a common theme with a number of these entries in this list that are consistent with single-player experiences seemingly having a multiplayer mode shoe-horned in for whatever reason. The next victim of this procedure was Visceral Games’ sci-fi survival horror title Dead Space 2.
Featuring a multiplayer mode that played as little more than a Left 4 Dead clone, the game featured a team of four pliers as the human faction facing off against another four players playing as the Necromorphs.
The mode wasn’t inherently bad but it suffered from balancing issues that often meant higher-ranked players had a much easier time, making it much more difficult for new players to progress.
Couple the balancing issues with an experience that could be found better elsewhere and it should be little surprise why the competitive multiplayer mode was scrapped for the third entry in the survival horror series.
4. Spec Ops: The Line
Spec Ops: The Line was a nice surprise when the gritty Third-Person shooter released in 2012 largely due to its single-player campaign, which provided a refreshing take on the horrors and violence of warfare.
The game made players question their actions at a time when shooters were progressively becoming more like mindless action blockbusters.
However, in addition to the stellar solo campaign the game also featured a very out of place multiplayer mode that flew completely in the face of the message portrayed with the game's story.
Sadly, the multiplayer in Spec Ops was a rather generic class based Third-Person shooter that offered little in the way of anything new compared to other shooters on the market. More than anything though, the whole mode just felt painfully out of place in a game that was aiming to highlight the horror and morality of warfare.
So much so that developers Yager revealed in an interview with Polygon that they didn't want the game to have multiplayer but publisher 2K insisted on adding the mode, which was created by separate developer Dark Side Studios.
3. Tomb Raider
2013s reboot of Tomb Raider was an exceptional revival project that breathed life back into a long standing series in gaming. The game was very well received, as were its two sequels, however this was in large part to the core single-player experience rather than the inclusion of any multiplayer modes.
A somewhat puzzling decision at the time, the multiplayer featured some nice ideas, such as the option to set traps for enemies, however it never really drew in a consistent enough player base.
Sadly, the experience did contain its fair share of bugs and balancing issues that quickly killed off the community making it difficult to find enough players for a game. A number of Achievements and Trophies were hidden behind the multiplayer mode, which is often a big no-no when it comes to those looking to 100% their games, particularly when the game is predominantly a single-player experience.
It’s telling then that Crystal Dynamics made the decision to scrap the competitive multiplayer mode for the two sequels, choosing to focus instead on the single-player experience instead. It’s a choice that we are glad they took.
2. Batman: Arkham Origins
Hands up those who even knew Batman: Arkham Origins even had a multiplayer mode? Anybody?
What could possibly go wrong with creating a third-person competitive shooter to include with a game that had become synonymous with its fluid hand-to-hand combat? It turns out that pretty much everything could and did go wrong.
The Multiplayer mode, while a nice idea on paper, was clunky and unintuitive and therefore was a subpar experience that could be found executed better elsewhere.
The game pits two teams of mercenaries against each other in a Third-Person shooter. The twist here however is that at the beginning of each game two players are selected as Batman and Robin to help take on both teams of mercenaries. The concept was a genuinely entertaining take on the Cops and Robbers or Spies vs Mercenaries multiplayer mode that had featured elsewhere previously.
Unfortunately the novel idea was not enough to save the multiplayer mode and it was understandably dropped by the series for its next entry, Arkham Knight.
1. Dragon Age: Inquisition
The decision to add a multiplayer mode to a 100-hour plus single-player Role Playing Game is a strange one and is still puzzling to this day. However, for some reason Bioware saw it fit to add a multiplayer mode to the third entry in their sprawling fantasy RPG series.
Hardly the draw for those purchasing the game, the multiplayer mode featured four players together working cooperatively to dispatch enemies and complete a linear set of objectives completely separate from the main game.
The mode was capable of providing some fun in small parts, however it was not the reason that the majority of players were here and therefore, was quickly forgotten about. With complaints that even the solo campaign dragged on for longer than necessary due to a significant amount of filler content (looking at you Hinterlands) it’s no surprise then that players didn’t stick around for the multiplayer mode too.
Hopefully Bioware and EA see the light and forgo the Multiplayer mode in the upcoming Dragon Age 4 in favour of providing a more memorable single-player experience.