10 Video Games That Tried Too Hard

Sometime You Just Have to Sit Back, Relax, and Enjoy the Adventure.

video games tried too hard
thumb

The best games to grace our consoles or computers are often the ones filled with confidence in their features and mechanics. Unfortunately, all too often, that confidence can lead to developers adding so many gameplay features that it actually hinders the game's success. Likewise, developers oftentimes want to chase a trend in the gaming landscape, which can alter the overal tone of the game for the worse.

The following games in this list showcase titles that simply try too hard. Whether this comes from the all too familiar issue of feature creep to a game wanting to lift the ideas, concepts, and systems of another franchise in order to take a slice of the pie. While there is certainly nothing wrong with wanting to take inspiration from other games or wanting to pay homage to past exepriences, ultimately, when a game tries too hard to be the same, it leads to a less than stellar experience for the player. With that said, let's dive into 10 video games that tried too hard.

10. Lawbreakers - The Little Hero Shooter That Couldn't

lawbreakers game
Nexon

Lawbreakers was a free-to-play online hero shooter by Cliff Bleszinski and his now-shuttered studio, Boss Key Productions. Lawbreakers aimed to make a mark in an overly saturated market of online free-to-play games, specifically going up against the absolute juggernaut, Overwatch. It almost feels as if Lawbreakers was destined to fail because it was directly trying to compete in that market, and wasn't helped by the fact that it looked painfully generic and mundane. Lawbreakers looked to be the epitome of lackluster with a graphical style simply trying to mimic that of Destiny or Call of Duty, two series already enjoying their own successes.

For a game with this bumping a soundtrack, it felt like Cliff and his team themselves lacked the confidence and excitement for the title. Lawbreakers was shown off to be the next hit hero shooter installment with a massive character roster, frenetic and high-flying gameplay, and a long-term commitment to new features, heroes, and gameplay options.

While some games are able to break into an overly saturated market, such as Apex Legends and Warzone, most end up losing their player bases in a rapid manner due to the sheer factor of been there, done that. Unfortunately that was the case with Lawbreakers, with player numbers dwindling so quickly that the it had to be shut down. While there is a lot of speculation as to why the game ultimately failed, it seems to have come down to over promising and under delivering, Cliffy B's polarizing and divisive attitudes within the games industry, and an overall lack of direction and appeal for the new hero shooter.


9. Remothered: Broken Porcelain - The Game's Title Says It All; Broken...

Remothered Tormented Fathers
Stormind Games

Remothered: Broken Porcelain is the most recently released game on this list. As the title implies, it's a broken game, not just in part to the numerous issues it launched with, but because it truly doesn't know what it wants to be. Remothered: Broken Porcelain cherry picks ideas from many survival horror franchises such as Silent Hill, Outlast, and Amnesia, yet it all quickly falls apart like a wobbly Jenga tower. For fans of the first game, this second installment promised a more robust gameplay experience filled with a terrifying story, great stealth gameplay, and a fantastic location to explore. Unfortunately, these ideas never fully came to fruition. It's not often said how a game's premise and narrative direction come across as pretentious, but that's just what happens in the opening parts of this game.

Where the first game Remothered: Tormented Fathers stuck with a core concept of sneaking around a creepy old mansion and pushing the narrative forward, here, it just throws you in the deep end and tells you to just understand what's going on. If a game chooses to just throw the player into the deep end with little to no explanation as to what is going on, you better dang well sure setup the premise enough that your players will feel invested. Of course the opposite is done here and as you go through the opening hours of the game, a strong feeling of incoherence and frustration quickly set in. If the best part of your horror creation is the cathartic release of running towards the creeper just to meet your demise, then clearly that game was trying too hard.


8. Anthem - Probably Best To Not Sing This Song

anthem game
Bioware

I'm not sure what else can be said about Anthem at this point that hasn't already been said. In good faith, I don't see how a list about games that tried too hard can leave off Anthem. It's like this list was created just for Anthem. Most of us know the story by now but for those that don't, Anthem was created by the legendary game developer, Bioware, a development studio known for high quality RPGs such as Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic and the original Mass Effect Trilogy. We can leave out Mass Effect: Andromeda for this. Yet EA, in their business and money grubbing wisdom thought it best to have Bioware move away from their core development strengths into a live service space opera of sorts.

As you can already imagine, this didn't end well for Anthem. From terribly repetitive gameplay and mission loops to awful loot drops to a generic setting, Anthem tried as hard as it could, yet ultimately failed to impress at best, and at worst, lost almost of its players along the way. Anthem was and still is a part of the live service gaming boom. This market already had and has enough competition but EA were determined to get in on the action. Instead of making a truly unique and wholeheartedly enjoyable game, Anthem went the route of derivation, not innovation.

A major failure for Anthem came in no small part to the lack of long-term content that was promised for its loyal players. Anthem was seeking to have years of gameplay additions, story DLC, weapons, cosmetics, new areas to explore, and exciting new missions. In reality, Anthem ended up having to toss the roadmap out the window in hopes of rebuilding the core experience from the ground up to re-engage the player base.


7. Radical Heights - The Battle Royale That Failed To Take Off

Radical Heights
Boss Key Productions

Okay so it feels a bit unfair to have another Cliff Bleszinski/Boss Key Productions game on this list, I simply don't think it can be helped. Radical Heights was created out of pure desperation and necessity as a last-ditch effort, after the failed Lawbreakers, to keep the studio. While I absolutely admire the paradigm shift here as well as the courage it takes to make such a crazy change in direction, trying to take from the best of your competition will likely lead to a failed game. Such is the case with Radical Heights, an 80s inspired battle royale with some unique gameplay concepts, but ultimately a game that just looked too much like its competition, namely Fortnite, to garner any sort of critical success.

Pulling away players who have spent literally dozens upon hundreds of hours in their favorite battle royale of the time whether that be Fortnite or PUBG, was always going to be a major uphill battle. Yet, Radical Heights persisted, trying to lure players to their very early access game. While I admire the fact that the studio was upfront and honest about the game being in very early access, to the point of even using that as a marketing tactic, players weren't captivated by a game that looked janky and buggy and lacked overall content. Had Radical Heights released prior to Fortnite and PUBG, then perhaps it would have had a captive audience for the long haul, but as it stands it was simply another battle royale lost to the storm.


6. Resident Evil 6 - What's The Best Part Of A Horror Game? Not The Action.

resident evil 6
Capcom

Resident Evil 6 surely needs no introduction, yet I am going to try. What do you think is the absolute best part of any good and scary survival horror game? Did you answer, the bombastic and action heavy combat? Me neither. Despite that, Resident Evil 6 decided that the best direction to go was that of an action movie with some elements of horror thrown in for good measure. I'm not sure fans of the series were asking for this, yet Capcom decided it was best to double down on the action of Resident Evil 5 instead of the sublime horror components of the legendary Resident Evil 4. While Resident Evil 6 did have a couple of moments of tension and terror, specifically in Leon's campaign, it was thoroughly overshadowed by the rest of the action game set pieces.

I am starting to see a theme in this list, whereby, the games that try too hard seem to be the ones that pick and choose from the competition instead of truly innovating. It's quite clear in hindsight that Capcom were hoping to appeal to every type of player instead of focusing on the series' strengths; it's pure survival horror components. Resident Evil 6 allowed itself to fall into the trappings of more is better, but in this case the more being action, not scares. Fortunately Capcom learned from this and ultimately changed their direction with the frightening Resident Evil 7, but up until that time, their survival horror franchise was starting down the path of monotony. My friends, good survival horror thrives on the that less is more, a concept which would have truly benefited Resident Evil 6.


5. Sonic Boom - Gotta Go Fast? More Like Gotta Go Boring.

Sonic Boom
Sega

Sonic Boom is yet another one of the Sonic games to attempt to reinvent itself instead of doubling down on its strengths and previous successes. It's so strange that Sega continually tries to reinvent the wheel when it comes to the Sonic franchise. The original 2d games were some of the most loved games of the 90s, yet somewhere along the line, Sega decided to leave behind the success and arduously struggle to make Sonic into something that players never asked for. The majority of 3d iterations of Sonic have unfortunately failed, most likely due to the fact that competing with the likes of Mario, Spyro, and Crash seemed like an impossible task.

Sonic Boom wanted to try to compete with the likes of Super Mario Galaxy and New Super Mario Bros on the Wii, which in hindsight, is quite obvious that it failed in its attempt. Instead of keeping in theme with Sonic's successful games focusing on high-speed platforming gameplay, Sonic Boom decided to add in more traditional platforming systems as well as weapon combat. The Sonic games never needs those types of gameplay concepts but yet Sega thought it best to continue to strike gold instead of iterating on their previous gems.

Thank goodness the incredible Sonic Mania released to show the world that when the Sonic series is treated right, it can both pay homage to the classics while also adding in just enough new content to satiate new players to the world of Sonic and his pals. Had Sega adopted this strategy prior to releasing Sonic Boom, then perhaps it could have turned out differently.


4. Star Citizen - Just How Many Features Is Enough?

Star Citizen
Cloud Imperium Games

Star Citizen has been in development for the better part of nearly a decade. It's no surprise this game has become so notorious in games media due to the fact that it simply never releases, despite hundreds of millions of dollars of player-backed funding. Yes, this game has continued to this day to still receive millions upon millions of dollars to go towards its development. Yet Star Citizen has still not actually released. While there are probably numerous issues as to why this might be, a majority of this seems to come down to feature creep and over-promising. Remember Peter Molyneux and how he talked up the original Fable but simply failed to deliver on the majority of the touted features? Well, multiply that by about a thousand and you are left with Star Citizen.

Star Citizen was and still is promising its loyal players as well as newcomers with hundreds upon hundreds of hours of strategic and exciting space action set in a massive universe to explore. From massive space battles to navigating various planets and stars to customizing your own ship; these features are just a few of the aspects that Star Citizen is still working on properly releasing to its fanbase.

Robert Space Industries' head honcho Chris Roberts has even stated that the development time has been lengthened due to immense feature creep. What started out as one initial giant space epic with years of gameplay, eventually turned into a solo campaign separate from the massive multiplayer component. With funding still being accepted to this day and no release window insight, it's quite clear that enough is enough and the team needs to wrap this game up and release it in its entirety to its loyal community.


3. Call Of Duty: Infinite Warfare - We Are Always Chasing The Stars

Call of Duty Infinite Warfare
Activision

Oh, Call of Duty, how we love to hate on you, despite buying you each and every year. Yes, Call of Duty, the game series that truly needs no introduction. Every year our consoles and PCs are graced with a new Call of Duty entry. Call of Duty: Infinite Warfare is perhaps one of the most divisive in the entire series. Why? This is mostly due to the fact that people were completely ready to move away from the whole future tech space adventures of previous entries, instead of hoping for a more grounded experience that Battlefield 1 and Call of Duty: WWII eventually helped to provide. Call of Duty: Infinite Warfare decided to continue in the opposite direction, opting instead to push the game further into the reaches of the universe.

The outcome of this was one of the most disliked Call of Duty trailers in YouTube history. It was clear that the series was simply trying too hard to continue to cash in on people's fascinations with future, space adventures, not realizing we were all ready to move beyond this and get back to a boots-on-the-ground approach. While the core gameplay was still polished and the game had a surprisingly enjoyable campaign, it all felt too derivative of previous entries in the series. Add to this the egregious monetization practices and pay-to-win mechanics and it quickly became clear Infinite Warfare was doomed to be one of the most disliked in the series' history.


2. Mario Party 9 - One Party You Don't Want To Be Invited To

Super Mario Party Slaparazzi
Nintendo

Have you ever thought to yourself, the best way to make a new Mario Party game is to take the majority of great gameplay concepts in previous Mario Party entries and then throw them right out the window? Apparently, no one told that to Nintendo before they had Mario Party 9 be created by Nd Cube. Mario Party 9 made the fatal game development error of taking what people loved about the series and changing them simply for the sake of change. Mario Party has always been beloved for its board game-like gameplay, friendship ruining competition, fun mini-games, whimsical boards, and of course, the Mario series' characters. While the 9th entry in the series retains some of these aspects, it decided to change the core gameplay loop, to its detriment.

Traditional Mario Party games had you move about the board based on a dice roll and then compete in mini-games, all the while, earning coins and stars. Well, this entry decided to take away your individual movement and instead replace it will a vehicle mechanic where all characters travel together. This core change to player movement on the game boards made the strategic aspects the series has become known for, simply left feeling stale and lifeless. Coins and stars were also a thing of the past. While the mini-games themselves were still mostly enjoyable, those bigger gameplay concepts' removal made for a lackluster and mundane Mario Party experience. This is one party you are best to just avoid going to.


1. Metal Gear Survive - When A Name Can't Save The Game

Metal Gear Survive
Konami

Metal Gear Survive was created out of the toxic ashes of the fallout between the legendary game director, Hideo Kojima and Konami. Unfortunately, Metal Gear Survive was brought about as a quick cash grab by Konami to simply take the success of the Metal Gear name and try to spin it into a new entry that no one was asking for, thereby, tarnishing the famed series' namesake. Metal Gear Survive takes what Konami thought people would want; the Metal Gear name, zombie-like creatures, action combat, and survival aspects, but ultimately left us with one of the most divisive and uninspired games to date. Metal Gear Survive left players with a stale husk of a game. The love, care, and idiosyncrasies that Hideo Kojima and his team brought to the Metal Gear series were sorely missed in this title.

The lovely folks at Konami failed to realize why people actually loved the Metal Gear series to begin, much of this coming down to the fact that Hideo Kojima's vision is what made the series into the legendary series it has become. Instead of realizing that, Konami cobbled together a game filled with the core concepts and systems that had been utilized much better in other games. On top of that, in their infinite wisdom, Konami thought it would take the fantastic step of actually charging people real-world money for extra save slots, something that just comes standard in the majority of games everywhere. At the end of the day, Metal Gear Survive simply failed to make a proper step it the right direction.


Who Starred In These Iconic Video Games?

Donkey Kong Country 3 N64
Rare/Nintendo

1. Donkey Kong Country 2

 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Hello there! My name is Geoffrey Martin. Video games are delightful, and I write about them!