10 Video Games That Were Dead On Arrival
These games flatlined the moment they came out.
Video game development is one hell of a tough racket - developers can spend over half a decade working on their passion project, only to send it out into the world and have it be soundly rejected by critics and players alike.
This can obviously spell ruin for all but the most financially insulated of dev teams, and even if not, the moral blow of a years-in-the-making game being forgotten in short order must be absolutely crushing.
And that's absolutely what happened with each of these 10 video games, which despite having some serious pedigree or a recognisable brand name behind them, all landed on the marketplace with a colossal thud of indifference.
It won't surprise many to know upfront that this list is dominated by live service games, where developers evidently focused too much on how they could keep players engaged for the long haul rather than simply making a game that was fun to play in the moment.
Each of these game flatlined upon launch, failing to make a positive impression with the masses and basically falling off the face of the Earth within months, weeks, or perhaps even mere days...
10. Babylon's Fall
Let's kick things off with a game which, despite receiving its fair share of pre-release hype sank like a stone in near-record time.
Babylon's Fall marked PlatinumGames' attempt to break into the live service arena with this co-op multiplayer action-RPG, though even with the developer's acclaimed prior work (Bayonetta, Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance, Nier: Automata) and passionate fanbase, there was basically negative hype for this thing as release day approached.
The visuals looked dated, nothing about the gameplay seemed remarkable, and that's precisely what critics said when they finally got their hands on it.
The critical pannings only exacerbated the staggering indifference about the game, which peaked with less than 1,200 concurrent players on Steam, and in less than two months that figure permanently dropped below 100 players.
PlatinumGames stuck it out for six months before announcing that they were cancelling support for a game that nobody was actually playing, and the servers were ultimately shut down less than a year after launch.
And so, with this being an online-only experience, there's now no way for anybody to play Babylon's Fall - not that anyone actually was even when the servers were up.
9. Crash Team Rumble
Rather than have Crash Bandicoot 4 developer Toys for Bob hard at work on the next mainline Crash game, Activision instead made them develop a multiplayer party game spin-off nobody asked for - Crash Team Rumble.
This competitive 4v4 "strategic platformer" reeked of cynical live service slop from the moment it was revealed, all the more so as Activision was actually selling it for a retail price rather than releasing it free-to-play.
With so many quality free-to-play party games on the market, throwing down actual cash for one that looked this unremarkable was an unsurprisingly tough sell, and so Crash Team Rumble bombed at retail. Reviews weren't awful by any means, but they did criticise the lack of launch content and repetitive gameplay loop - both huge downers for a game that, again, isn't free-to-play.
Even Crash's loyal fans couldn't be compelled to part with their money, as Crash Team Rumble ended up with less PS5 players during release week than - wait for it - the PS Plus release of a Peppa Pig game. Ouch.
Less than nine months after launch, Toys for Bob ended support for the game, though to their credit the servers do still remain live at the time of press.
8. Brink
A bit of a deeper cut now with 2011's hugely-hyped, parkour-infused 8v8 multiplayer FPS Brink.
But the game, from Wolfenstein: Enemy Territory developers Splash Damage, launched to so-so reviews, with critics dinging its shallow gameplay while on release players grew frustrated with consistent connection issues.
Splash Damage attempted to pacify players by introducing a 4v4 multiplayer mode for those experiencing lag during 16-player matches, but the issues were only permanently remedied about three months later when the Agents Of Change DLC was released.
Despite significantly improving the game, the update was too little, too late, as players had lost their patience and abandoned Brink long before that point - an unsurprising outcome considering how competitive the multiplayer FPS space was in the early 2010s.
Brink's concurrent player count quickly settled down to around 100 and never recovered, though there are still a loyal 20 or 30 players who continue to play to this very day.
7. Onrush
The case of Onrush is actually pretty damn tragic, because despite the multiplayer racer having some serious genre pedigree behind it and actually being really good, it just never caught on with the general public.
Part of the problem might've been the game's unconventional hook - far from a typical racer, Onrush was a team-based, objective-led vehicular combat experience where not a single game mode revolved around crossing the finish line first.
And so, conceptually it would've immediately been unappealing to a decent swath of racing game fans - a genre with an already niche player-base.
Couple this with Codemasters' evident struggle to convey Onrush's unique gameplay in its marketing, and it wasn't terribly surprising that the game failed to make a dent when it launched.
Despite releasing to positive reviews and earning itself a small but passionate legion of fans, Onrush vanished into the ether within a matter of weeks, though Codemasters did at least keep the servers running for well over four years, so that's nice.
6. Predator: Hunting Grounds
On paper, Predator: Hunting Grounds actually seemed like a pretty great idea - an asymmetrical 4v1 multiplayer game in which players either control a soldier or the Predator.
Of all the multiplayer games based on horror IP released in recent years, this one had an especially strong chance of becoming a breakout hit, given the Predator's iconic appeal even outside of the horror realm, and the franchise's general popularity.
But reviews were wildly mixed right out of the gate, citing the janky, unbalanced gameplay, outdated visuals, and frustrating downtime between matches.
And though the Epic Games Store doesn't provide player data, the game's footprint on social media faded within a matter of weeks, leaving only the most die-hard of fans still playing.
And even when the game finally launched on Steam a year later, it rarely rose above 300 concurrent players, which says it all really.
There was so much potential here, but IllFonic - who previously developed Friday the 13th: The Game - basically whiffed it.
5. Godfall
Hands up if you remember Godfall. Anyone?
Quite possibly one of the most forgettable PlayStation launch titles of all time, Godfall was an always-online fantasy action-RPG with not a single thing in its visuals or gameplay to distinguish it from every other similarly themed video game.
We joke these days about generic-looking games being "what an AI would make," but in Godfall's case everything in its aesthetics and mechanics were so snoozily pedestrian that it actually felt true.
Reviews weren't quite disastrous but they were hardly glowing either, citing an abundance of bugs, grind-heavy gameplay, and general lack of long-term intrigue.
And the always-online requirement despite the game categorically not being a live service title didn't help it either.
Godfall evaporated from the collective gamer consciousness amid a sea of more appealing PS5 launch titles, proving so thunderously generic as to be almost entirely forgotten.
Despite developer Counterplay Games being among the many outfits hit with layoffs this year, Godfall's servers are surprisingly still up, even with the Steam player count rarely rising above a few-dozen.
4. Radical Heights
Careful not to cut yourself on the edge as we discuss the most boundary-pushing game of 2010... which was unceremoniously sloughed onto gaming platforms in 2018.
Radical Heights was Boss Key Productions' follow-up to the fun but commercially unsuccessful hero shooter Lawbreakers, and marked a clear attempt by founder Cliff Bleszinski to elbow his way into the lucrative battle royale marketplace.
Yet when the game was released in April 2018 in "X-Treme Early Access," it was painfully clear that Radical Heights had been curled out as fast as possible in an attempt to cash-in on the success of PUBG and Fortnite. The gameplay was extremely rough around the edges and, worst of all, it just wasn't fun to play, ensuring that it shed most of its already-diminutive player-base in barely a month.
The worst was yet to come, though - just 34 days after Radical Heights launched, Bleszinski announced that Boss Key Productions had shut down due to the commercial failure of Lawbreaker and Radical Heights back-to-back.
Tough and unforgiving though games development is, when a game whiffs as strongly of desperation as this one did, it never had a chance of turning around its company's fortunes.
3. Anthem
No game on this list was more aggressively hyped than Anthem - BioWare's always-online live service action-RPG which was widely touted as the game that could finally dethrone Destiny in the looter-shooter space.
Despite the obvious appeal of flying around in Iron Man-esque armoured suits with your pals and blowing up monsters, Anthem swiftly failed to deliver on its massive promise.
Even if you could forgive the nothingburger of a story and short campaign, Anthem screwed up the most important thing of all - the feeling of flight.
The game's tethering mechanic - which prevented players from flying too far away from their pals - proved infuriatingly restrictive, in turn preventing players from fully enjoying the thrill of flying around and kicking ass.
Add to this brutal loading times, grind-heavy gameplay, and a lackluster post-game, and it was clear why most players simply burned through the campaign in about 15 hours and then moved onto other games.
A year after launch - long after most had put Anthem to the back of their minds - BioWare announced they were hard at work on rebooting the game, though another year later, it was confirmed that all work on this had been scrapped.
Surprisingly though, Anthem's servers are still up, well over five years after it first launched.
2. The Culling 2
The prophetically-monikered The Culling 2 - a sequel to the well-received 2016 battle royale game - died a near-instantaneous death upon launch, with critics and players alike raking it over the coals for its god-awful gameplay and low player count, making it a struggle to populate a 50-person match.
IGN gave it a devastating 2/10 score and the player response was even more vitriolic, prompting developer Xaviant Games to pull the game from market and offer refunds to all players just eight days after it launched.
The developer issued a statement copping to the fact that The Culling 2 wasn't a worthy follow-up, but evidently they released it anyway to see if they could get away with it and turn a profit regardless.
Xaviant then returned to supporting the original game, which was itself delisted in 2019 amid falling revenues.
Today it lives on only as The Culling: Origins - a watered-down revamp where players are limited to 10 free games per day before being asked to open their wallets to keep playing. Yikes.
1. Concord
And finally, let's wrap this list up with a game that actually isn't even out yet - Sony's new first-person hero shooter Concord.
Though first announced last year, Concord got its true coming-out party in a recent PlayStation State of Play, which began with a quippy, Guardians of the Galaxy-esque cutscene only to reveal itself to be a 5v5 hero shooter - and a rather generic one at that.
Players were scathing in their criticism of the reveal, noting disappointment at Concord's boilerplate gameplay, the fact that it looks like an Overwatch clone, and that it's chasing the hero shooter trend more than a few years too late - while not being free-to-play, no less.
The Internet is rife with articles deeming the game dead on arrival ahead of its late-August launch, and given the lackluster nature of the reveal, it's tough to argue with the notion that Concord is indeed cooked.
Short of the planned July beta miraculously swaying public opinion, Concord is almost certainly getting tossed on the growing pyre of live service flops within a matter of months or even weeks.