10 Video Games The World Wasn't Ready For

Ninja Gaiden Z was a LOT more fun that people gave it credit for.

yaiba ninja gaiden z
Koei Tecmo

The famous painter Vincent Van Gogh was famously unappreciated in his time, but that didn't stop him from doing what he loved despite never really getting the attention he deserved.

It wasn't until years after his death that his work spread throughout the world and today he's one of the most beloved artists of all time. It's fair to say, the world was not ready for Van Gogh when he needed them to be.

The same thing can happen in all kinds of art.

Sometimes games that try new things often don't hit the mark. There are an infinite number of variables about there and even some of the most solid titles fail to find an audience to financially support them. When media tries new things, it opens itself up for glorious, game-changing success or abject failure.

Every game on this list was a success from a functional perspective, but the best laid plans of their developers didn't pan out when they came to store shelves. From under-purchased, overlooked and sometimes downright derided despite their promise; these games probably would've fared better if they had released at a different time or maybe a different place.

10. Resident Evil Outbreak

Resident Evil Outbreak
Capcom

When you think of survival horror, most likely you think of isolation. Tight corridors of a creepy location that gives you that fight or flight feeling when you encounter an enemy. You’ve only got yourself, and far too little ammo, to rely on.

In the scramble of the clearly oncoming wave that was online gaming, Capcom decided to take Resident Evil in a surprising direction with the Outbreak duology. By making use of the PlayStation 2 Network Adapter, the theory was surviving a Resi-style puzzle-box scenario online with other fans of the series.

With a dozen characters to choose from, as well as lots of interesting locations each with their own gimmicks and enemies; Outbreak wasn’t just an interesting twist on the classic Resi style, but it also built out the lore.

Unfortunately, a lack of voice chat functionality made it pretty difficult to work with your team, and that’s even if online functionality was even available in your country (hello from us long suffering PAL players).

It seems in retrospect that Outbreak had jumped the gun. Thankfully, dedicated fans have crafted PC servers that keep Outbreak’s online experience a possibility and thus we can all experience what exactly this could’ve felt like if it came at the right time.


9. Amplitude

Amplitude PS2
Harmonix

When Harmonix’s Guitar Hero was a huge success, the company probably breathed a huge sigh of relief. By their own admission, their previous output of Frequency and its sequel Amplitude had “sold peanuts”.

It wasn’t that the games weren't good, they just hadn’t managed to connect on a major level with audiences. The rhythm game genre was still in a blossoming state and the titles that had found success were those that were easy to understand. Dancing mats just made sense and even Samba Di’Amigo’s maracas, as unexpected as the peripheral was, were something fun to watch and made you curious to try them out.

Amplitude didn’t have any fancy unique controllers and its “boombox spaceship” concept was not something that connected at first glance. Without getting your hands on the game yourself you couldn’t understand what was fun about moving your cursor from lane to lane to match the rhythm and pitch of a song. The game developed a cult following and even got the “best game nobody played award” at the 2003 GameSpot awards which is the biggest backhanded compliment of all time.

After Harmonix had gone through the dizzying heights of success with Guitar Hero and Rock Band, they paid homage to the diehard fans of Amplitude that had stood by them the entire time by returning in 2016 with a remake.


8. Shenmue

Shenmue 1
Sega

These days, “open world” is essentially an expectation. It feels like about half of the AAA titles released in this era have large, sprawling locations to explore with lots to do and plenty of distractions. Whilst Shenmue didn’t invent such a concept, it was the game that really crafted the next level of what seemed to be a living, breathing world.

Not only did Shenmue beat Grand Theft Auto III to the punch of an open world city, it did so much that simply became standard practice in gaming moving forward. Quick time events, NPCs that seemed to have their own lives and endless mini-games and hobbies to partake in just to name a few. The graphics as well were leaps and bounds ahead of anything else at the time.

Trapped on the sinking ship that was the Dreamcast, many postulate that Shenmue’s lack of sales dragged the console down with it. It was the most expensive video game production at the time and it didn’t stand a chance of making back that money with the console’s low install base. The game and the console were intangibly linked to each other’s doom.

Shenmue’s impact is huge and Sega themselves have not completely shied away from what it did right. The Yakuza series and the Persona series, both owned by the company, have a direct throughline to Shenmue’s cutting-edge, open-world RPG style.


7. Eternal Darkness: Sanity’s Requiem

Eternal Darkness
Silicon Knights

Most gaming genres were flourishing during the huge steps of graphical fidelity through the 2000s and horror was certainly among them. As gamers got more and more realistic, horror got more powerful. Silicon Knights however decided that jump-scares and awkward tank controls were child’s play compared to what the medium presented.

Eternal Darkness really uses its identity as a video game to scare. Sporadically throughout the experience, the title will trick and disturb the player by teleporting their character around the map, pretending that the TV has lost connection to the console and, most infamously, appearing to delete the game’s save data. What a clever and wicked way to mess with gamers who thought that they had seen all that horror could do.

You’d think that this giant sidestep in what the genre could do would inspire loads of copycats and experiments but, for whatever reason, the world praised Eternal Darkness and moved on as if it hadn’t just shaken absolutely everything up. It wasn’t until the indie revolution of the last few years, with the likes of Doki Doki Literature Club and Imscared, that developers revisited the concept.

Perhaps most horrifying of all is that this revolutionary classic remains to this day exclusively available on the GameCube, having never been ported forwards or made available on the Nintendo eShop.


6. Yaiba: Ninja Gaiden Z

Yaiba Ninja Gaiden Z
Team Ninja

After three high fidelity and at least comparatively more serious entries, in 2014 Team Ninja wanted to do something different with the Ninja Gaiden franchise by giving it a well deserved and high energy spin-off.

In terms of the gameplay, Yaiba: Ninja Gaiden Z is just as good and as challenging as the core series, requiring focus and keen reaction time. Where it sings though, is also where it lost a lot of love from the franchise’s established audience. This time around your foes are largely zombies, and your adversary is mainstay protagonist Ryu Hayabusa.

Completely shifting gears, Ninja Gaiden Z has a far more comedic tone the main games, poking fun at tropes of the genre and the series itself and generally being bombastic and ridiculous.

In a post-Doom 2016 world, which celebrated the series by honouring it and playfully mocking it, you have to wonder if this cheeky side-game would’ve landed better with Western audiences than it did in 2014.

Western critics gave it some brutal reviews, which were in a strange juxtaposition to Japanese gaming magazine Famitsu’s strong score of 36/40. Detaching yourself from expectation of canon and tone, which is a much more Japanese approach to gaming, and you’ll find a beautifully cel-shaded, arcade-y, hack and slash romp. Think of it as the Far Cry 3: Blood Dragon of the series.


5. Manhunt 2

Manhunt 2
Rockstar

The controversy surrounding Manhunt 2 is almost certainly more well-known than the game itself. The 2007 sequel sold itself on outdoing the violence of the first and thus was banned outright in many places around the world. Other countries had alternate “cut” versions of the title to get past their local censors.

There was a lot of blurring in some versions of the finished product and executions that were outright removed, with Rockstar quite understandably miffed whilst comparing the game to the growing popularity of films’ like Saw and Hostel. Those films were fine, why not Manhunt?

As with many horror or gore-fests, it’s all about the context and whilst Manhunt 2 wasn’t pushing the graphical boundaries of the gaming industry in 2007 (if anything, it looked a little dated) it was as close to realism as we had known. 15 years later however, the game’s violence isn’t quite as visceral as you remember it.

Still, underneath it all is a quality experience with an interesting story. The gameplay is stronger than the initial shock-value of the original Manhunt but the focus on the savagery of the game’s executions overshadows an exciting thriller which adds some real darkness to the universe that people often forget it shares with GTA.


4. DmC: Devil May Cry

Dmc Devil May Cry
Capcom

The Devil May Cry series has had a tumultuous journey. Spinning off from a Resident Evil into its own highly rated original IP, the sequel was derided and the prequel was celebrated. Poor sales of the fourth entry caused Capcom to take drastic action and order Ninja Theory to work a total reboot.

When it finally came, DMC: Devil May Cry was critically acclaimed but fans couldn’t see past their own rage.

It’s a classic case of a game that probably needed a different title and set of character names. Most of the diehard Devil May Cry fan base were understandably turned off by the game not just doing away with a lot of what they liked about the franchise’s irreverent tone but actively making fun of it.

Who can forget the silver wig scene? What Capcom thought was a clever wink and nod felt to many like a kick in the pants.

If you ignore what they did to the character of Dante and just enjoy the title from a gameplay perspective, it’s an interesting take on the franchise’s style. At its core it’s clearly still a DMC game but it has all new finishing moves as well as essentially Angel Trigger to go with Dante’s usual Devil Trigger. Whilst the story may feel like a massive misstep, DMC did its best to provide an addictive combat experience.


3. Earthbound

Earthbound Nintendo
Nintendo

In Japan, Earthbound became one of the best-selling games of 1994. In North America, it made a fraction of those sales and Nintendo deemed the experiment a failure. To be fair, American gamers were far more focused on the action of Super Metroid, Sonic & Knuckles and the original Tekken.

Most American and European gamers’ first exposure to the character of Ness was most likely his appearance in Super Smash Brothers which made many curious to understand what made him so important to get this coveted position.

Where most RPGs tended to be high fantasy, Earthbound and its series broke the trend by setting its turn-based battle system in the real world. Making the mundane fantastical and interesting is at the game’s core, and it enraptured many imaginations across the world. It has influenced the likes of Yakuza as well as South Park: The Stick of Truth.

Toby Fox has made no qualms about the effect Earthbound had on him as a gamer and developer and this is reflected across his own modern cult hit Undertale, from the wacky boundary-pushing of the gameplay to the general warmth and themes within the story.

Earthbound's influence is felt today through indie RPGs like Undertale and the games that it, in turn, inspires.


2. System Shock

System Shock Original
EA

If you were to picture the FPS genre as a ladder it’s pretty obvious that the first rung of that ladder is the original Doom. The game absolutely changed everything and audiences were keen for more. Whilst many games were doing their best to emulate the style, when Doom II arrived, it overshadowed something that was already turning the genre on its head.

In 1994 LookingGlass released System Shock, a game that did away with Doom’s frenetic nature and instead crafted a slower, more deliberate pace and world. Exploring a derelict space station, the player pieces together what has happened through environmental storytelling and recorded logs. Combat is far less instantly gratifying, demanding more tactical consideration with its limited inventory and imperfect weapons.

Whilst the game reviewed well, it’s generally understood that its cost to make far exceeded the sale numbers. System Shock did manage to garner a sequel, and most importantly some of its greatest strengths went on to live again in BioShock when its creators worked under 2k Games. It was the success of this game that made many gamers aware of its spiritual predecessor and began a new cult status.

Without System Shock weaving narrative storytelling into its gameplay then we wouldn’t have games like Metroid Prime, Prey or even possibly the likes of Deus Ex and Resident Evil.


1. Star Wars Galaxies

Star Wars Galaxies
LucasArts

What upset many about 2006 MMORPG Star Wars Galaxies at the time was that out of the dozens of possible jobs and roles that players could assign to their characters, Jedi wasn’t one of them. This was deliberate for a few reasons. Chiefly among them, the developers were trying to steer away from combat-focused classes.

Star Wars Galaxies was more about roleplay than the standard MMO loop of hitting things and watching the numbers go up. Playing as merchants, chefs, doctors etcetera meant actually fulfilling your role and becoming part of an actual fictional community. When World of Warcraft launched though, players flocked to it looking for a game that fed their power-hungry needs.

A few years after Star Wars Galaxies' servers closed, life-sim games were all the rage.

Animal Crossing, Harvest Moon and Stardew Valley just to name a few are the kind of chill titles that are all about social simulation. Animal Crossing in particular thrives on growing and interacting with a community and New Horizons on Nintendo Switch has sold nearly 40 million copies alone.

More than that, the space for roleplaying in general has never been bigger. People watch Dungeons & Dragons groups online not to see who gets the highest damage rolls but for the stories, the characters and the roleplaying. This is something that gaming could do more to cater to, in the way that Star Wars Galaxies did years ago.


Watch Next


Contributor

Coming from a content creation background that now spans over two decades, Psy cut her teeth on personal video production and community radio. Originally joining the team as a writer and presenter, she added video editing duties to her responsibilities over time and became the longest-standing editor of the irreverent gaming show Tues Your Own Adventure. Psy has worked on many previews and reviews, long-form editorials (either her own, or supporting as an editor), as a frequent quizmaster and more. Praised for the two-pronged attack of her hard work ethic and light-hearted editing style, Psy is otherwise known as a font of retro video game knowledge which has caused her to rack up many gaming quiz wins. Outside of WhatCulture, Psy runs First Aid Spray Podcast - a long-running channel that focuses on Resident Evil in all of it's forms. You can follow her on BlueSky at http://psywhite.bsky.social and Instagram at http://instagram.com/therealpsywhite