10 Video Games With Bizarre Origin Stories
Smash Bros asked for forgiveness instead of permission.
Every story has a beginning. When players nestle in and select "new game", their story with a title starts... but the game itself may have already been through it's own sagas behind the scenes.
Comparing early concepts and ideas to the final product can often be a surprising and humbling thing, seeing how far that twinkle in the eye of a director had to come in order to find its true voice.
Many games flounder as they attempt to create a hook and sometimes have to take bold risks to find that missing piece of the puzzle. Others merely chance upon greatness by pure luck or perhaps a little bit of cheating.
After all, crafting artwork is not a straight forward process. There's no blueprint. It takes inspiration, experimentation and collaboration - sometimes all in surprising ways.
This list highlights some beloved video games that had some unexpected twists and turns in their development. Saving their company, shifting tone or starting out as merely a little self-experiment, these tales are all proof that anything can happen during the creative process.
10. Batman: Arkham Asylum Was Almost A Rhythm Game
The Caped Crusader has had lots of different video game appearances over the years but most of them stand in the great big shadow of the Arkham series. Starting in 2009 with Batman: Arkham Asylum, Rocksteady Studios told a satisfying set of stories that Batman fans could be proud of but the true star was the frankly addictive combat system.
More than a simple button-masher, Arkham Asylum’s hand-to-hand violence was all about flow and timing. Which makes sense, as it was originally devised as something far more akin to a rhythm game.
Not only would this have meant more obvious button prompts on-screen but that Batman pummelling waves of goons would’ve been set to a beat. A specific combat soundtrack was pitched that would’ve evolved throughout a fight, changing as new enemies joined the fray and altering depending on how many enemies surrounded the player.
The final version of the combat certainly feels rhythmic and discovering that that’s where it started makes a lot of sense. Still, if it had maintained the original concept in its purest form, we can only make educated guesses what the music for this would’ve been like.
After all, it wasn’t until 2022’s The Batman that we all found out that Bruce Wayne was a big Nirvana fan.
9. Resident Evil Saved Capcom
Whilst Resident Evil wasn’t the first horror video game ever made, it was certainly an attempt by one Capcom developer to prove that the genre was viable within the gaming space.
Tokuro Fujiwara had previously developed an NES tie-in to the horror movie Sweet Home. The game was a success but Fujiwara felt that the limitations of the console stilted his true vision. Convincing Capcom to work on a spiritual successor, Fujiwara acted as producer and handed-picked some fresh blood to work on his pet project in Shinji Mikami.
The game went through various different conceptual stages; starting life as an SNES game before hopping to the PlayStation, morphing from first person to the fixed camera angles and shifting away from the supernatural into zombies and mad science.
As it got close to release however, the game was nearly canned. Capcom had sailed along on the success of Street Fighter II in the early 90s but that well was drying up. The fighting game’s sequels had failed to sell and 3D games were far more expensive to produce. The company hired an American business advisor who suggested pulling the plug on Resident Evil but Fujiwara pleaded that his superiors see it through to the end.
Resident Evil, when it was released, became the best selling PlayStation game of all time and saved Capcom from financial ruin.
8. GTA’s Wanted System Was An Accident
It’s hard to imagine the video games industry without Grand Theft Auto at this point. One of the best selling franchises of all time but also a series that has had tremendous impact on both game development and design. GTA’s over-the-top adult style made waves in turning the hobby into more than something just for kids.
But when the first game went into production, it wasn’t called Grand Theft Auto. It was called Race‘n’Chase and was far less outlandish than the finished product.
Race’n’Chase was about head-to-head street races with the police in pursuit which made the name pretty apt. There was racing and there was chasing. However, a mistaken line of code suddenly changed the behaviour of the officers hot on your tail to be a lot more aggressive. Due to a glitch, the police would ram players off the road if they caught up, causing all kinds of mayhem.
For the future RockStar Games, it was a lightbulb moment if there ever was one.
With this mind, Race’n’Chase was significantly retooled with vehicular destruction and general criminal tomfoolery in mind. The “wanted” system, that has become a recognisable feature of the series, determines how hostile the police will act towards the player… and it all started as a glitch.
7. Conker Wasn’t Always An Adult Game
In 1997, Diddy Kong Racing released for the Nintendo 64 and included a variety of cute anthropomorphic characters, most of which had never been seen before. One of these, Conker the Squirrel, was set to make his debut in the coming months.
At E3 1997, Conker 64 was shown to industry insiders and whilst it seemed perfectly functional it was overshadowed by the charm of Banjo-Kazooie. Many even critiqued the game as being “too cute”, with the potential of reinforcing the negative stereotype that Nintendo was just for kids. Rare, who were developing the game, felt the game was missing something and it wasn’t coming together as hoped.
It was artist Chris Seavour who found the missing element for the project. Bad Fur Day, as he called it, would give the deceivingly cute title a harder edge with violence and raunchy comedy. The first redesigned quest-line featured wasps that stole a beehive, with Seavour adding in a punchline where the bee-hive fights back with automated weapons. The entire team loved it.
From here, development on the project was completely refreshed. Platforming gameplay took a backseat to film parodies, scatological humour and absolute absurdity.
Conker totally transformed, shocking those who had once called it “too cute” and became Nintendo’s second ever Mature rated title.
6. Geometry Wars Was Test Software
It’s a rare case when you can buy a title that’s two great video games for the price of one. Project Gotham Racing 2, the 2003 Xbox racing title, also happened to include one of the niftiest Easter Eggs known to man: an entirely different game.
Whilst in development on the original Project Gotham, Bizarre Creations’ developer Stephen Cakebread constructed a little test application. Apparently, the team were having troubles with the prototype Xbox controllers, in particular the right analogue stick, and Geometry Wars was put together as a means to explore their issues and test the controller out.
However, this little experiment was too good not to share with the world. In Project Gotham Racing 2, Geometry Wars can be found on an arcade cabinet sitting in the player’s garage.
Many Xbox gamers found themselves falling in love with it, so much so that the title got its own, broader independent release on the Xbox Live Arcade store and became one of the store’s best-sellers because of it.
It truly only needed to be simple to fit its purpose, which is why Geometry Wars’ art style is really just mathematical shapes and bright, beautiful colours. Through its simplicity players found something calming and addictive, and Bizarre Creations inadvertently created a new shooter/puzzler franchise.
5. Jean-Claude Van Damme Almost Killed Mortal Kombat
One thing that every good fighting game needs to succeed is a strong cast. Think of any of the big franchises within that genre and you’re immediately conjuring up a host of classic and iconic character designs. Mortal Kombat is absolutely no different, in fact it may well be one of the best in this regard, but it didn’t necessarily start off this way.
Mortal Kombat co-creators Ed Boon and John Tobias found themselves working with Midway Entertainment, who were extremely interested in their proposal for a fighting game using large, digitised characters. Actors would be filmed and then placed into the game’s world over sprites.
Midway turned down the original pitch for a ninja-themed fighting game and instead wanted to use digitised characters to create a tie-in for Jean Claude Van Damme’s Universal Soldier picture. A demonstration was prepared for the actor, but Van Damme was already in talks for another video game project (that ironically wound up falling through).
So, in light of this, Midway allowed Boon and Tobias to chase their original proposal.
In ode to this series of events that nearly derailed Mortal Kombat, the pair created Johnny Cage: a Hollywood actor whose split-legged punch to the groin was a nod to a moment in Van Damme’s Bloodsport.
4. Call Of Duty’s Zombie Mode Won Over Activision
Despite being a sturdy addition to the Call of Duty franchise, World at War is perhaps known best for being the game that introduced the series’ now long-time obsession with the undead... but that side-game almost didn’t happen.
After having developed Call of Duty 3, Treyarch were a little burnt out on the real world warfare and in order to keep themselves entertained they worked on a spin-off mode. Nazi Zombies allowed teams of four to squad up to take on waves of never-ending undead.
As much as they enjoyed it though, they didn’t see it ever becoming something publisher Activision would sign off on as it was too far removed from the gritty realism that Call of Duty fans had come to expect.
However, Treyarch’s colleagues in Activision caught wind of the mode and stopped by the office to try it for themselves. They were bowled over by how much fun it was but agreed that it would be a hard thing to market. So the story goes, Treyarch CEO Mark Lamis then simply suggested to not market it at all.
Nazi Zombies was tucked away as an unlockable Easter Egg in World at War. As expected, gamers adored it as much as the developers. As such, the zombies minigame would become a mainstay of the series.
3. Devil May Cry Started Off As Resident Evil 3
Veteran games director and Twitter block button master Hideki Kamiya’s first experience at the head of a project was the 1998 version of Resident Evil 2. With such success under his belt, Resident Evil figurehead Shinji Mikami tasked him with helming up the next game.
Set in a Spanish castle on a mysterious island, Kamiya’s intentions for Resi 3 starred a pair of twin brothers. Tony and Paul Redgrave - superhumans implanted with biotechnology - would discover they were the sons of Oswell Spencer, the mastermind behind a large part of the Umbrella Corporation’s evils.
It wasn’t just a departure for the story, but also on every other level. Mikami had told Kamiya that the next Resident Evil needn’t necessarily be a horror game.
Kamiya’s use of the words “stylish action” to describe his hopes for a new combat system would end up being a key phrase to define the new franchise that this idea germinated into. The concepts were worth exploring but perhaps were not fit for the Biohazard franchise.
Side-game Resident Evil 1.9 became RE3 to hold fans over as Kamiya pursued his fresh, exciting new world. Tony and Paul became Dante and Vergil as the game found its own identity as surprise success Devil May Cry, paving the way for Kamiya’s high-octane action style.
2. Super Smash Bros Didn’t Ask Permission
Masahiro Sakurai saw the Nintendo 64’s four controller ports and saw opportunity. Not only was he seeking to create a more casual style of fighting game, reportedly after whooping random Japanese citizens on arcade machines himself, but one that could be enjoyed by more than two players at a time. Thus begun development of Dragon King: The Fighting Game in earnest.
Whilst Sakurai was sure of his core gameplay concepts, he knew that fighting games don’t sell without a good roster of fighters. Rather than craft something original however, he mused upon the idea of using already established and recognisable faces through Nintendo’s catalogue.
Knowing that suggesting “what if we make a game where Link beats the piss out of Yoshi” would be a pointless endeavour, Sakurai crafted a demo without approval. It was better to ask forgiveness than seek permission.
Presenting an early build that starred Mario, Donkey Kong, Samus and Fox McCloud, Nintendo had no choice but to see the promise the project had.
Smash Bros was born.
If they hadn’t approved, it’s entirely likely that Sakurai’s Dragon King: The Fighting Game, as a novel as the core four-player party fighting system was, would never have matched the great heights that the Super Smash Bros series has soared to.
1. Yakuza: Like A Dragon Was An April Fools Joke
When April 1st rolls around, it’s time to be on your toes. There are plenty of social media managers out there who produce some amusing one-time gags, but occasionally companies will go too far with it.
After seven mainline Yakuza games highlighting the rises and falls of main man Kazuma Kiryu, Sega’s Ryu Ga Gotoku studio was making changes to the franchise with a new leading man. They hadn’t necessarily considered a huge departure from the fast-paced beat-em-up style gameplay of the previous titles but a video they produced for April Fools suddenly made that a possibility.
The fake reveal trailer was a good-humoured “what if” take on the series if it were a turn-based RPG. The thing was… it was awesome, featuring all the expected silly Yakuza sense of humour and badass environmental attacks.
The reaction to such a premise was so positive that the studio retooled the game they’d be working on, turning new hero Kasuga into a Dragon Quest fanboy who sees the world as a video game. Several moments from this April Fools gag feature in the finished product which, when it released in 2017, was so successful that Ryu Ga Gotoku are already at work on their next JRPG Yakuza title.
What started as a silly joke wound up completely revitalising a series.