10 Video Games You Constantly Have To Defend Loving

No, DmC: Devil May Cry isn't the dumpster fire that many fans claim.

DmC: Devil May Cry
Capcom

Opinions are like you know whats - we all have them, whether or not anybody else cares about them.

Playing a great video game that enriches your life and brings you joy is a wonderful thing, but that pleasure can turn to tired misery when you go online to read the absolute torrent of abuse being unjustly levelled against it.

It's no secret that the Internet thrives on negative hyperbole, and so fans of these 10 video games - almost all of them generally well-received by critics - will find themselves constantly qualifying their love of these titles.

The online debate surrounding the games is so contentious and explosive that it becomes genuinely exhausting constantly going to bat for them, defending their honour against wave after wave of impotent rage.

This isn't to say that these games are perfect by any means, but each is nevertheless great in its own way, even if some of their series' most die-hard fans really, really don't want to admit it.

If you're quick to drop a drive-by tweet ragging on these games, maybe think twice before doing so next time. Or don't - it's your call...

10. The Last Of Us Part II

The Last of Us Part 2 Ellie
Sony Interactive Entertainment

It's probably fair to call The Last of Us Part II the Star Wars: The Last Jedi of video games, in that the discourse surrounding the game has become so exhaustingly contentious and vitriolic that even those who love it might feel tired of it.

Naughty Dog's long-awaited survival horror sequel received predominantly rave reviews from critics and scooped more Game of the Year awards than any other title in 2020, but the player response was considerably more polarising.

Many fans took umbrage with the game's boldest creative decisions - namely, killing Joel in the first few hours and later switching control to his killer, Abby, for roughly half the game. And as we all know, haters are considerably more vocal than lovers.

For anyone who found The Last of Us Part II's story laudably envelope-pushing in tandem with its superbly tight gameplay, it remains an absolute chore to discuss and stick up for.

Passionate fans of basically any popular IP have a tendency to get a very specific idea in their heads of how a story should play out, and if it doesn't, they can't handle it.

That's not to say everyone who hated The Last of Us Part II "just didn't get it," but there are so many disingenuous, bad-faith takes about the game out there that its cheerleaders tend to keep quiet and avoid the tiresome dialogue altogether.


9. Resident Evil 6

Resident Evil 6
Capcom

Ask most Resident Evil fans what the worst mainline entry into the series is, and they'll tell you it's Resident Evil 6, a wildly overblown, overstuffed mess of a game that tried to cater to both fans of Resident Evil 5's gonzo action and those who favoured the series' survival horror roots.

But there are absolutely many passionate defenders of the game who admire its fearless, go-for-broke excess, offering up four mini-campaigns totalling a ridiculous 20+ hours in length.

There's certainly plenty of bang for your buck here, with the game approximating a comically bombastic Michael Bay movie in some of its greatest moments, even if it is unarguably an exhausting experience in its entirety.

Yet if you can look past the overall skittishness, the melee combat is remarkably advanced (despite the game explaining it terribly), and embraced as the schlocky B-movie it is, there's certainly a lot to enjoy.

But you can basically see most fans' temperament change the second you try to argue that Capcom knew exactly what they were doing with the sixth game, and that it's one of the best-selling entries in the series for a reason.


8. Mass Effect 3

Mass Effect 3
BioWare

The best argument you can make about Mass Effect 3 is that the journey is more important than the destination, for though fans were understandably upset by the game's flatly underwhelming pick-a-colour ending, does that entirely invalidate dozens, even hundreds of hours of play prior?

Put the trainwreck of an ending to the back of your mind and Mass Effect 3 touts a riveting story and top-tier combat, yet ultimately any discussion about the game's merits quickly loops back around to how terrible its finale turned out.

A big part of the problem in trying to defend the game is that fans aren't really talking about the third game in isolation - the ending tainted fans' perception of the entire series, and so they take it far more personally than a single game failing to stick the landing.

As much as BioWare undeniably screwed the pooch at the final hurdle, that shouldn't instantly erradicate hours and hours of fantastic time spent with the game and the series as a whole.


7. Final Fantasy X-2

Final Fantasy X-2
Square Enix

Final Fantasy X-2 is very much a Marmite type of game - some love it, some loathe it.

Following up the smash hit Final Fantasy X, many took umbrage with the fact that the spin-off was considerably more light-hearted in tone, and there are of course some predisposed to hate the game for simply daring to feature an all-female cast of protagonists.

Yet compared to the self-serious portent of most Final Fantasy games, X-2 is a major breath of fresh air - a silly, campy JRPG that begins with Yuna performing a devilishly catchy J-pop tune, centers its battle system around costume changes, and even features a totally deranged massage mini-game.

Expectations may have been part of the problem here - anyone hoping for a more serious-minded epilogue to Final Fantasy X likely had no idea what to do with such a supremely, unapologetically goofy game.

But as a daring riposte to the exhaustingly convoluted, navel-gazing nature of most entries in the series, X-2 is as close as Final Fantasy has ever gotten to outright self-parody.

Unsurprisingly, a lot of ride-or-die fans of the series don't much care to hear that opinion.


6. Days Gone

Days Gone
Sony

Days Gone is ultimately a game that went over far better with players than it did critics, but there's still far from unanimous player support for the critically maligned open-world zombie game.

Released with the expectation that it'd hit the same polished, impeccably crafted standard of most AAA Sony exclusives, Days Gone instead received mixed reviews for its "generic" open world gameplay, mediocre story, uninteresting protagonist, and bloated campaign.

And while most of the criticisms aren't without truth, Days Gone does nevertheless offer up a fun sandbox for players to cause chaos in, all while they pay cursory attention to the so-so plot and characters.

Because so many view Metacritic scores as an objective emblem of a game's quality and value, though, fans trying to argue its merits will be regularly rebuked that it fell far short of expectations.

The problem, really, is that Days Gone should've never been marketed as the next AAA Sony hotness. A studio of Bend's wildly mixed caliber was never going to turn in a refined masterpiece of a game, but that doesn't mean it's not a blast to play in the moment.

It does admittedly help that many of the bugs the game was rightfully dinged for at launch have since been fixed, but as the saying goes, first impressions count for a lot.


5. Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns Of The Patriots

Metal Gear Solid 4 Snake Big Boss
Konami

Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots was one of the most eagerly awaited games of the PS3's life cycle, touted as the swan song for franchise protagonist Solid Snake.

The result is a game that wowed critics but split fans right down the middle.

To some, Hideo Kojima's self-indulgent storytelling tendencies reached an unbearable peak - or nadir, even - due to both the game's parodically long cut-scenes and a truly unhinged, fan service-soaked story that never once exercised restraint.

Some fans also disliked the game's heavy reliance on using nanomachines to explain and demystify previously ambiguous elements of the series' lore, many comparing it to the midichlorians reveal in Star Wars: The Phantom Menace.

Yet Metal Gear Solid 4's gameplay was virtually peerless for its time, which combined with an array of creative boss battles and a story which brought Snake's arc to an emotional - if ridiculous - end, made it one of the most ambitious video games of its era.

While not everything it does is going to work for everyone, it delivers a thunderously entertaining collision of fan service and cutting-edge gameplay in a technically sublime, unapologetically messy package.

The thing is, when people point out the narrative inconsistencies, they're generally not wrong, but your overall opinion on Metal Gear Solid 4 likely depends on how much you care about that. The emotional heft of the game triumphs over its messy storytelling moments.


4. Dark Souls II

Dark Souls II
FromSoftware

Though Dark Souls II received rave reviews from most critics, fans were decidedly more divided, many feeling that the departure of prior series director Hidetaka Miyazaki, combined with a strained development amid a tight production schedule, caused the game to be compromised in many areas.

If it absolutely lacks the refinement of its direct predecessor, Dark Souls II is still a damn great piece of work by any conventional metric, packed with some of FromSoftware's most fiendishly difficult boss fights to date.

There's also the agreeable inclusion of a robust fast travel system, which compensates somewhat for the game's messier overall design.

Sure, it was developed by FromSoft's "B-team" - as the "A-team" were making Bloodborne at the same time - but any other franchise would be thrilled to have a game this good among its ranks.

Sometimes it's important to remind FromSoft fans that their expectations for the studio's games are sky-high, and the "awful" Dark Souls II is actually still great, believe it or not.


3. Grand Theft Auto IV

Grand Theft Auto Iv
Rockstar Games

Grand Theft Auto IV remains one the most eagerly awaited video games in history, and despite posting rave reviews and magnificent sales, its legacy is a bit of a complicated one.

For everyone who loves its gritty style and focus on "realism," there's someone who sorely misses the more cartoonish silliness of Vice City and San Andreas, not to mention that GTA IV's map size was considerably smaller than the latter's.

But GTA IV also marks the point at which the series transitioned into true "prestige gaming" territory, with a more serious-minded story and pointedly satirical overtone.

And yet, many fans still resent it both for not being San Andreas 2.0 and getting summarily outdone by the grandiose Grand Theft Auto V, dismissing it as an awkward lame duck entry in the franchise.

This is of course to totally devalue everything Rockstar put into GTA IV, a game that took bold risks when it could've just clung to franchise formula and likely been just as commercially successful.

Is it the best game in the series? Absolutely not, but it's tough not to get irked when folks call it "terrible" with a straight face.


2. DmC: Devil May Cry

DmC: Devil May Cry Dante
Ninja Theory

A lot of Devil May Cry fans would simply prefer not to even acknowledge the existence of 2013's reboot DmC, especially as the experimental retooling never got a sequel and Capcom eventually returned to the original iteration of Dante.

DmC is a game that scored surprisingly solid reviews from critics despite the avalanche of pre-release hate for its reworked "emo" rendition of Dante, and it's just as well.

Sure, the new Dante design pales in comparison to the classic version, and the game's "edgy" tone certainly won't work for everyone, but where it matters most - the gameplay - DmC is an absolute banger.

If not as challenging as its predecessors, DmC is a thrillingly breezy hack 'n' slash character action game best thought of as a fun adjunct to the mainline series, and one not nearly worthy of the petty vitriol it's still festooned with no matter that fans eventually got "their" Devil May Cry back.

Express even mild positivity towards DmC and you're apparently earmarking yourself as a filthy casual fan of the series.


1. Batman: Arkham Knight

Batman Arkham Knight
Rocksteady

Batman: Arkham Knight may have been kneecapped from the get-go with its disastrously botched PC launch, but if you take many fan comments at face value, it's as though the game personally came round to their house and pissed in their cereal.

Arkham Knight is certainly rougher around the edges than series-best entry Arkham City - the Batmobile isn't great, and the big narrative reveal is totally obvious - but the moment-to-moment wish fulfillment appeal of playing as the Dark Knight nevertheless remains.

Between the muscular combat, gorgeous visuals, and ultra-atmospheric depiction of Gotham, Arkham Knight is a great Batman game that was unlucky enough to come at the end of a quality run of Batman games released within a six-year period.

As superhero games go, it deserves to be discussed with the best, even if it's assuredly more of a flawed banger than either Arkham Asylum or Arkham City.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.