10 Video Games You Hated Before You Even Played Them

For better or worse, you pre-judged the hell out of these games.

legend of zelda wind waker
Nintendo

First impressions are so, so important where any form of entertainment media is concerned - hook potential customers quickly and you're guaranteed commercial success, but give them a reason to doubt you and you're going to struggle.

On the flip side, fans of any major IP are a fickle bunch, liable to outrage and tantrums on the turn of a dime, whether justified or based on only the most superficial information.

But we've all been there, pre-hating a game from an underwhelming teaser trailer or gameplay reveal that just didn't give us what we wanted.

Perhaps it felt like a lazy attempt to update a classic IP, a desperate effort to appeal to a wider audience, or simply made story decisions many fans didn't agree with.

Whatever the reason, these 10 video games all received more than their fair share of hate before they'd even hit stores.

In some cases the vitriol remains more-or-less justified, while in others the final release totally vindicated the developers and their boundary-pushing approach.

If there's anything to be learned here, it's that keeping an open mind is a good thing, though you also shouldn't trust video game publishers to do the right thing for art's sake alone...

10. Doom (2016)

Doom 2016
Bethesda

It can't be understated just how utterly underwhelmed Doom fans were by the initial reveal of Bethesda's 2016 Doom reboot.

As the first major entry into the FPS franchise in 12 years, what should've been a glorious revival was met with outright hostility by many, who felt that the extremely slick gameplay footage - especially the QTE-looking glory kills - suggested the IP was getting a cynical "reimagining."

It didn't help that the multiplayer beta was horribly received by the majority of fans, and when major outlets revealed they wouldn't be getting their review copies until release day, the writing seemed to be on the wall that a dud was on the cards.

But then, to the surprise of just about everybody, Doom 2016 received heaps of praise from critics for its fluid gameplay, brutal gore, and successful updating of the franchise while retaining its intense core.

Ultimately Doom was a major critical and commercial success, bringing the dormant series back to life and ensuring a sequel, the similarly well-received Doom Eternal, was given the greenlight.

As much as the skepticism was mostly understandable, we were all so, so wrong about this one.


9. The Legend Of Zelda: The Wind Waker

The Legend of zelda: The Wind Waker
Nintendo

As fanbases go, The Legend of Zelda's fans are relatively sane and sensible, though there's perhaps one major exception, when Nintendo first unveiled The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker and its cel-shaded art style left them totally lost for words.

There's no denying that The Wind Waker's aesthetic was a tectonic leap away from what players were used to, adopting a far more cartoon-y style than expected, especially as a tech demo released in 2000 touted a style far closer to Ocarina of Time.

To many, this suggested that Nintendo was trying to sheer the franchise towards younger players, and infamously led disgruntled fans to mockingly call it "The Legend of Celda."

Though the backlash was fervent enough to adversely affect sales - it sold barely half what Ocarina of Time did - the reception to The Wind Waker has warmed massively over time, such that it's now regarded as one of the series' best games, cutesy art style and all.


8. Call Of Duty: Infinite Warfare

Call Of Duty Infinite Warfare
Activision

With the release of Call of Duty: Black Ops II, the series began to ramp up its more out-there sci-fi aspirations, culminating in 2016's highly controversial Infinite Warfare.

Rather than meld the series' signature militaristic fetishism with light sci-fi hooey, Infinite Warfare went full-on nutso sci-fi, centering its story around a literal battle for the fate of the Solar System.

This only compounded many fans' existing complaints that the series was straying too far from its comparatively grounded roots.

The announcement trailer was met with such overwhelming disdain that it quickly became the second-most-disliked video on YouTube at the time. Yikes.

Add to this the fact that the announced remaster of Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare was available only to those who bought the more expensive special editions of Infinite Warfare, and it truly felt like publisher Activision had no respect at all for its own customers.

In the end Infinite Warfare was broadly praised by critics though certainly remains one of the lesser-regarded entries into the series, and amid soft sales Activision themselves even said the game "didn't resonate with fans."

Ultimately if you didn't like the aesthetic or gameplay presented in the trailers, the final game wasn't going to change your mind much.


7. Max Payne 3

Max Payne 3
Rockstar

It might seem like a mere distant memory nowadays, but when the long-awaited third entry into the Max Payne franchise was finally unveiled in 2011, the fan response was pretty damn ugly.

Rockstar made the bold decision to shift the action away from New York City to São Paulo, Brazil, in turn switching out the series' established film noir-esque art style for more colourful environments.

Oh, and Max was now bald, had a giant grizzly beard, and was wearing a Hawaiian shirt. In purely superficial terms, it felt like Rockstar made a decision to "lighten up" the franchise in the pursuit of greater commercial success after Max Payne 2's inexplicably mediocre sales.

But then Max Payne 3 came out, and in the eyes of many was quickly confirmed to be the best game in the series, or in the very least an extremely worthy follow-up.

Any worries about a sanitised sequel were quickly shot to bits in slow-mo: Max continued to be a trauma-riddled substance abuser and went through near-literal hell before game's end.

Better yet, the gunplay was arguably even better than in the first two games, courtesy of the refined physics engine.


6. Metal Gear Survive

Metal Gear Survive
Konami

Unlike every other game on this list, fans had their pitchforks out for Metal Gear Solid spin-off Metal Gear Survive from the second it was announced due to what it represented.

Survive was the first Metal Gear game put into production following Hideo Kojima's departure from Konami amid the combative development of Metal Gear Solid V, and also the first Metal Gear game created without Kojima's involvement in almost 30 years.

That alone was enough to have fans up in arms, though perhaps the tide might've been stemmed if Survive actually seemed like a quality entry into the franchise.

Instead, the first trailer made it clear that the game would be pasting the series' distinctive aesthetic over the top of a painfully soulless, generic multiplayer survival shooter.

It was about the most unimaginative thing Konami could've done with the IP after Kojima's departure, and fans sure as hell let them know it.

Unlike many of the games on this list, though, the furore was largely justified, as Survive was indeed as blandly cynical as it seemed. In a refreshing bout of comeuppance, though, it also bombed at retail.


5. Star Wars Battlefront II

Star wars battlefront 2 theed
EA

The development and release of Star Wars Battlefront II was nothing short of a rollercoaster for fans.

After the previous game was criticised for its lack of launch content, EA promised that the sequel would rectify this issue by including a cinematic single-player campaign and releasing all downloadable content through free updates.

Pre-release, it really seemed like EA was determined to shake off their prior stink as the "Worst Company in America," that they had learned a lesson in humility and, you know, actually giving players an experience worth their hard-earned cash.

But that all came crumbling down shortly before Battlefront II's release, when players who took part in the game's beta test criticised its aggressive loot box monetisation, which heavily incentivised them to spend real money to unlock items and special characters which could otherwise take up to 40 hours a pop.

Though EA promised to remedy this before release, press reviews noted that little had changed since the beta, sparking the embers of global outrage from fans who felt they were being utterly disrespected by the publisher.

The backlash was so intense that EA ended up temporarily disabling microtransactions a day before the game's release in the hope of stemming the tide of righteous indignation, but for many the damage had very much been done.

Though Battlefront II still sold incredibly well, EA's share price dipped by 2.5% on its release date, and the company lost an eye-watering $3 billion in stock value within two weeks of its launch, while numerous authorities around the world investigated its predatory "gambling" practises.

Ultimately Battlefront II is in much better shape today, but the dark pall cast over its release was so intense that many never even bothered trying it.


4. Resident Evil 4

Dr. Salvador - Resident Evil 4
Capcom

Resident Evil 4 represented a major, major shake-up for the hit survival horror series, and tough though it might be to imagine today, the initial fan response was borderline vitriolic.

The game was finally revealed after years of laboured development, with persistent rumours suggesting Resident Evil 4 was a troubled, even doomed project.

The last numbered game in the series, Resident Evil 3: Nemesis, was released a whole six years earlier, and the skepticism was massively furthered by drastic changes Resident Evil 4 made to the signature gameplay.

Ditching the signature fixed camera angles and slower pace for an over-the-shoulder camera, refined tank controls, a new inventory system, laser-targeted weapons, and a more frantic, urgent tempo, Resident Evil 4 felt like the sort of game that gets made when a publisher is desperate to keep a franchise relevant.

Additions like QTE sequences and a recurring merchant character were met with particular disdain from players, who felt they betrayed the more stark purity of the earlier games.

And yet, when Resident Evil 4 was finally released, Capcom was entirely vindicated, because it earned by far the best reviews of the entire series and is still generally accepted to be the best game in the franchise.

The unfortunate by-product, though, was that Capcom doubled down on this approach with the next two sequels, amping the action up to unbearably silly levels at the cost of most all suspense.


3. Mario + Rabbids: Kingdom Battle

Mario rabbids kingdom battle
Ubisoft/Nintendo

If you've ever wondered why publishers and developers hate leaks so much, it's because of situations like Mario + Rabbids: Kingdom Battle.

Prior to its unveiling at E3 2017, the game's existence was leaked online free of any wider context, and an image of Mario and Rabbid Peach posing together was widely mocked by Mario fans, who felt the game would be a lame cash-in spin-off.

This context-free leak adversely affected morale at developer Ubisoft Milan, enough that when the game was revealed in earnest at E3 to a rapturous response, director Davide Soliani could be seen crying with relief in the audience.

Though there was still plenty of justified skepticism leading up to its release - namely that it would be a shallow XCOM rip-off and little more - in the end Mario + Rabbids: Kingdom Battle was widely lauded by critics, won Best Strategy Game at The Game Awards, and sold incredibly well.

Needless to say, there's not much doubt that the impending sequel, Mario + Rabbids Sparks of Hope, will be a ton of fun.


2. DmC: Devil May Cry

Devil May Cry DMC Dante
Capcom

After fans spent almost three years waiting for a fifth Devil May Cry game to be announced, they were left utterly fuming when Capcom confirmed the next game in the series would be a reboot.

The new game, DmC, saw Capcom give protagonist Dante a drastic design overhaul, causing many to mockingly call the new dark-haired, mopey Dante "Emo Dante" while suggesting Capcom was trying to appeal to the angsty teen demographic.

Even the series' original creator, Hideki Kamiya, expressed disappointment at the redesign, while others expressed doubt that newly appointed developers Ninja Theory could match the high gameplay standard set by Capcom on the previous games.

In the end, DmC received solidly positive reviews from critics for its gorgeous art style and slick combat, while many fans were left to begrudgingly admit they were wrong about it. Mostly, anyway.

The new Dante didn't win everyone over of course, and there are still many who refuse to admit the game is good, but they were finally sated when a direct sequel to Devil May Cry 4, Devil May Cry V, was released in 2019.


1. The Last Of Us Part II

The Last Of Us Part II Abby
Sony Interactive Entertainment

Surely no game this past decade has had its narrative more ferociously argued over than that of The Last of Us Part II.

After the blistering success of the original game, expectations were extremely high for the sequel, but when videos spoiling major aspects of the story were leaked roughly two months before release, much of that hype changed to anger.

These leaks spoiled not only the premature death of Joel but also the fact that much of the game would actually see players control a new character, Abby.

While many fans did their best to steer clear of the leaks, others couldn't resist the temptation and, upon learning what was up, began loudly disparaging the game on social media, with some even vowing to boycott it.

Not all fans were foaming idiots about it, though - some were genuinely disappointed at what they learned from the leaks, and were unsure if they wanted to throw down cash for such a potentially disappointing experience.

The pre-release discourse was so heated that even those genuinely excited about the game may have been somewhat soured on the experience, because as we all know, the worst part of any sufficiently popular IP is the damn fans.

But ultimately, no leak can do justice to how those spoiled elements play out in the full context of the game, and while its big surprises were never going to work for everyone, The Last of Us Part II was an ambitious, masterfully crafted piece of work.

It seems that many simply wanted Naughty Dog to play the hits and give them more of the same, but they decided to do something bolder and more imaginative, as they surely knew would be massively divisive.

The toxic discourse impressively didn't prevent the game from becoming the fastest-selling PS4 exclusive of all time, though.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.