10 Video Games You Only Like Because Everyone Else Does

Admit it, after 2015's E3 you had to Google "What's Shenmue?" too.

Gordon Freeman Half Life 2
Valve

No matter what kind of media you're into, there'll no doubt be an established body of material that's considered the absolute peak of the respective field. And although they've only been around for a relatively short period of time when compared to the likes of music or cinema, video games are no exception.

Amassing a wealth of examples that have been chosen as the very best of the best, certain video games have been mythologised as untouchable pieces of art - on par with the likes of The Godfather or Citizen Kanes of the film world.

But just because certain titles have been awarded this legendary status, doesn't mean that everyone's going to love them, and yet, there's a curious feeling in the gaming community that you have to like certain releases if you want to be considered a "true gamer".

And, hell, even if you have reservations about some releases, if everyone's saying these titles are great, then they have to be, right?

Well no, and there's no shame in following the pack. Being passionate about something makes you feel great, and nobody wants to be left out of the conversation, but after all these years I think it's time to finally be truthful to ourselves: we only like these games because everyone else does.

10. Metal Gear Solid 4

Metal gear solid 4 solid snake big boss ending
Konami

One of the highest-rated games to ever grace the PS3, Metal Gear Solid 4 acted as the culmination of the Solid Snake saga, bringing back adored characters and stories for one final hurrah.

And while it was amazing to see the finale of this epic series, the game itself was one of the most muddled and inconsistent in the entire franchise. Completely skewing the gameplay-to-cutscene ratio massively in favour of the cinematics, you spent more time watching MGS 4, than actually playing it.

Which would be fine, but the exposition-heavy scenes were difficult to grasp for even the most diehard of fans already heavily invested in the series' lore.

So, while the game received almost perfect scores across the board, this acclaim definitely had more to do with the respect the series had built up until then, and was 100% thanks to the resonance of the story, rather than the gameplay itself.


9. The Sims

The Sims 4 Pregnant
EA

Everyone always talks about how much they love being able to mess around causing havoc in The Sims, but actually playing through the game without any cheats over a long period of time is one of the most frustrating things you can ever do.

I see the appeal of the series: being a God in control of your own imagined community of people made in your own image is a great concept - it's just a shame that the gameplay itself is so boring.

Working the daily grind, observing from afar and just trying to get your family to go a whole day without wetting themselves is an arduous chore. Likewise, it's telling that the best Sims stories come from people purposefully trying to break the game by creating ridiculous situations, rather than actually adhering to the rules.

The appeal of the series and the fandom it's amassed is definitely down to what you can do in The Sims in theory - yet I'd argue the vast amount of its fans haven't put more than a couple of hours into any of the games in the series.


8. Shadow Of The Colossus

shadow of the colossus final boss malus
Team ICO

Shadow of the Colossus is one of the games you simply must play if you want to consider yourself a serious fan of the medium. At least, that's what people involved in the industry would have you believe. Treated like the pinnacle of artistry, calling Shadow of The Colossus bad and doubting its importance would be like a film fan saying same thing about The Godfather.

And yet, while Shadow of the Colossus is clearly an important milestone and represented a major shift from the norm at the time, the gameplay itself is actually spotty as hell. It's not even the best experience created by the developers behind it, either, with Ico being a much tighter and more accomplished title overall.

There are elements of Shadow of The Colossus that really shine, but the repetitive structure, mechanically-limited gameplay and frustrating controls don't make for a perfect title.

It's just another example of a release whose reputation precedes it - you have to love Shadow of the Colossus, or you're just a CoD-obssessed casual.


7. Half-Life 2

Half Life 2
Valve

Half-Life 2 was a trend-setter, a technical marvel when it first released, and the perfectly-paced second game in the historic series was a giant step above the first in terms of quality. Introducing revolutionary physics-based gameplay and a set-piece heavy structure, Valve's title broke the mould of first-person shooters at the time.

But it definitely presented a very specific idea of what a first-person shooter should be. With a mute protagonist fighting off standard aliens through realistic settings, Half-Life 2 lacked the arcade charm of previous releases in the genre, taking a more grounded and linear approach.

And if we're being honest, the shooting itself wasn't the tightest, and without the physics-based gimmicks to distract you, it quickly becomes apparent that playing through the game is actually kinda... boring. The combat in Half-Life 2 isn't very fun, and there isn't much depth beyond pointing and clicking on bad guys until they die.

This is especially the case if you're playing it for the first time years later, as Valve's title hasn't stood the test of time. Sadly, its combat has been ripped off so many times, and the narrative itself has only felt more contrived and wooden as the years have drawn on, meaning that sadly, Half-Life 2 just isn't all that relevant anymore.


6. GoldenEye 007

goldeneye 007 proximity mines
Rare

GoldenEye 007 is one of the best licensed games ever made. Faithfully adapting the James Bond universe, the title made waves when it released almost 20 years ago, ushering in a new era of split-screen multiplayer.

But look, nobody playing GoldenEye for the first time now - or even revisiting it all these years later - is going to say it's still as much fun as back in 1997. Unless you were there at the time, it's hard to appreciate what the game did for the industry as a whole, and while it's still one of the greatest James Bond tie-ins ever, it's not an untouchable classic.

It's just one of those games you have to love if you don't want to be called out for being a contrarian. GoldenEye has amassed a huge reverence over the years, and while it did push the medium forward, it passed on the torch far too long ago.


5. Shenmue

Shenmue II
Sega

When Shenmue III (or rather, its Kickstarter page) was announced at E3 last year, the internet went into meltdown. From the reaction you'd have thought that Half-Life III or something had been announced, not a moderately successful RPG revival that hasn't been relevant for over a decade.

But you can see why everyone wanted to get involved in the hype: Shenmue is a genuine cult classic, with a rabid fanbase that's desperate for any kind of new release. But there's no denying that the franchise is a very niche product, with slow (and kinda boring) gameplay that's definitely an acquired taste.

It's just not an accessible series, and the massive hype surrounding the latest announcement seems incongruous with the minimal impact the first two titles had fifteen years ago.

The games aren't for everyone (I could never get into them myself, despite multiple attempts), so it's not crazy to expect to see plenty of these new fans being disappointed by the return of this niche series once the third title finally drops.


4. Castlevania: Symphony Of The Night

Castlevania Symphony Of The Night
Konami

Like Shenmue III, when Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night (the spiritual successor to Castlevania: Symphony of the Night) was successfully Kickstarted everyone lost their minds. Euphoria swept the forums because finally, after all this time (and conveniently forgetting all of those other great Castlevania sequels) there'd finally be a faithful follow up to Capcom's under-appreciated series.

A genre-defining release, Symphony of the Night is revered today for partly pioneering the "Metroidvania" type of gameplay - a retro style of game design that's become legendary in recent years.

But while this revered entry in the franchise is a pretty tight experience in its own right, the game is remembered fondly today more for what it stood for than the reality of its quality.

It's only talked about so much because "Metroidvania" gameplay is considered to be some kind of holy grail lost art form in the industry today, and Symphony of the Night just so happened to be the grandaddy of this particularly popular buzzword.


3. Final Fantasy VII

Cloud final fantasy VII 7
Square

Final Fantasy VII is the crown jewel in the legendary franchise, considered to be the one game in the series that even non-fans adore - yet it doesn't really deserve its position in history.

The franchise is a pretty impenetrable series to just pick up, and its repetitive and frustrating turn-based gameplay often causes more harm than good when it comes to its mass appeal. This is especially relevant to VII, which has a weak combat system when compared to some of the follow-ups to this "seminal" title.

So while the narrative and world design is particularly strong, I'm not entirely sure why the seventh main entry in the series has gained such a mythical status over some of its equally impressive - and in many ways even better - sequels.

But once again it's probably because VII's reputation has gown larger than the game ever was, allowing the title to take a place in pop culture history as one of the greatest RPGs of all time. And while it's definitely a strong entry in the series overall, there's a good chance that you only like Final Fantasy VII because you've been told how much of a masterpiece it is


2. The Legend Of Zelda: Ocarina Of Time

Ocarina of Time
Nintendo

Considered the pinnacle of the series and everyone's favourite childhood game, The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time has gone down in history as one of the very best releases for the Nintendo 64. And with the franchise still going strong all these years later and the fandom still well and truly alive, Ocarina of Time remains inescapable whenever the greatest video games ever are brought up.

Yet the title itself only has the reverence it has today because of how it blew everyone away when they were kids.

Equally good games in the franchise have came and went that haven't received the same legendary status - probably because their players were too old to feel the same childhood whimsy they did when they fired up Ocarina on their 64.

If you weren't the right age when the title dropped (or just didn't care for Zelda's particular style of dungeon crawling), then you were probably left wondering just what all the fuss was about.


1. Grand Theft Auto III

GTA III
Rockstar

GTA III is one of the most important video games in the history of the medium. Completely revitalising the open world genre by introducing gamers to a fully realised 3D city, the game pushed technological boundaries at the time while cementing the gangster series as one of gaming's biggest franchises.

But just because the game is important doesn't mean that it's any good, and the clunky combat and forgettable characters didn't do the title any favours. It's important, sure, but it's clearly a stepping stone onto something much bigger. As a result GTA III is more of a promise - a promise that Rockstar was finally able to fulfil with Vice City and San Andreas.

And that was back then - enjoying the game now is almost impossible. This third release was a brilliant way to spend a few hours messing around, flying cars over jumps and seeing how many pedestrians you could kill before being wasted by the cops - but the actual campaign missions (you know, the entire point of the title) were entirely forgettable.

--

Which games do you just not get the hype for? Let us know in the comments!


In this post: 
Half Life 2
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Josh has over 11 years of experience as a published writer, having worked nine of those years as a full-time content producer at WhatCulture. In that period he has created hundreds of articles, videos and podcast episodes for multiple WhatCulture channels, specialising in gaming, horror and film & TV. He now primarily works as a senior content producer and presenter on WhatCulture Gaming where he co-hosts the WhatCulture Gaming Podcast, a top 3 UK most listened to gaming podcast that he co-created in 2018. Over the years he has reviewed several high-profile gaming releases, covered industry events with on-site reporting, opined on breaking news, and even kicked off his interviewing career by chatting to childhood hero, Tommy Wiseau.