10 Worst Areas In Dark Souls
Which areas in the Souls series left you banging your head against the wall and wanting out?
Throughout the series, Dark Souls has provided players with some of the most spectacular locations and boss arenas to loot, fight and die in.
From the wonder and amazement that we felt finally arriving in Anor Londo for the first time to seeing Drangleic Castle and the visual spectacle of The Ringed City, it has never been a game that held back when it came to flexing its level designing abilities.
But no one bats a thousand. Not every second of every game can be a world beater and a triumph. Some of the more boring or basic areas are relatively forgettable, but there have been some real howlers that the whole community almost universally hated.
Whether the gameplay and mechanics didn't work well, the enemies were unfair or even just the visuals left a lot to be desired, what are the areas in the series that left us counting the minutes until we could leave?
Choosing only from Dark Souls 1, 2 and 3, here are the blemishes that dragged down otherwise excellent games, and the reasons they annoyed people so much.
10. Smouldering Lake
In Dark Souls 3, at the end of the Catacombs of Carthus and before High Lord Wolnir, you crossed a suspiciously rickety bridge.
When hit, this bridge collapsed downwards, usually dropping skeletons to their doom at the same time. Once this animation had finished, you could interact with it, and climb down it like a ladder to enter the Smouldering Lake.
The first thing you'll notice is the strange sound from somewhere off in the distance. The second thing will be three shots from a ballista that send you sprawling in the water amongst the massive crab enemies.
While there is decent loot to be had here, trying to kill the crabs, avoid the ballista and not get demolished by the Carthus Sandworm that spawns near the boss fog takes any fun out of it.
Your best bet is to run past everything (crouching behind a wall and let the ballista bolts kill the sandworm for you first), through the Demon Ruins, disable the hazard and explore at your leisure. Not offensively bad in any real way, but loot, a decent optional boss and an NPC fight are squandered in an area that feels "meh" at best, and frustrating at worst.
9. Irithyll Dungeon
Another area from the third game, the main issue with this level is the enemies. The jailers can be considered borderline unfair for their life-drain attack and being found in either places with long line of sight opportunities, or in groups. There are also the horrible looking cage-spiders, rats (both giant and normal sized), an actual giant, mimics, wretches and basilisks to contend with.
Add to this the fact that the level is a long, looping mess where you need keys to open shortcuts and doors back to the bonfire at various points and the whole thing becomes a slog to grind through.
It isn't optional, either. If you want to slay Yhorm the Giant or access Archdragon Peak, then you will need to pass through this area.
Anyone interested in dark pyromancies or spells will need to rescue Karla here, not to mention that the Prisoner Chief's ashes are located in a cell in this area, and Siegward of Catarina is seen locked up here as well.
Basically, no matter how much you dislike the atmosphere, the level design and the enemies, there is no getting around doing this level on every playthrough.
8. The Gutter
Not for the last time in this list, we come across a common complaint with some levels in the series. Darkness.
There is a difference between having a dingy aesthetic or creating a mood and having a lack of light that hinders gameplay and ruins enjoyment.
The Gutter in Dark Souls 2 is one of the worst offenders. Unless you already know the layout off by heart, taking a torch is a requirement. Even if you are relatively confident, it is still advisable due to awkward enemy locations, many places where you can drop to your death and a very confusing layout.
The torch mechanic was specific to the second game and you could (theoretically) find yourself in this area with no "torch time" left and have to go through blind. Having it in your off-hand meant that any players that were used to two-handing weapons or fought with something in each were additionally hamstrung.
The bonfire locations aren't the most obvious either and it was very possible to miss that all-important check point that saved you from starting again from scratch. While there is no denying that they created an atmosphere here, pure frustration is probably not what they were going for.
7. Iron Passage
Iron Passage in The Crown of The Iron King DLC for Dark Souls 2 has become infamous for all the wrong reasons. For people who criticise DS2, it was everything that there was to dislike about the second game in one place and at its most frustrating.
Mobs of high damaging enemies in tight corridors attacked aggressively, while range-based attacks flew in at the same time from Possessed Armours and Mages, who were located in areas that couldn't be accessed from the lower portions.
You could have spells cast on you that made you over-encumbered, making evasion and rolling far more difficult, and your reward for beating three rooms of these enemies was a chance to go up against the Blue Smelter Demon, a boss that was no joke.
There were two NPC summons available at the start, and while they each increased the defences of the Demon by 100%, it could be worthwhile to have the support through the first portions. Best advice? Short of killing all enemies twelve times so they stop re-spawning, just run through to the boss and take your chances.
Hardly peak Dark Souls gameplay, which might explain why it was so disliked.
6. Shrine Of Amana
Similar complaints come up when you talk about the Shrine of Amana in Dark Souls 2. This time, the enemies casting spells do it from even further away and they home in on you. Not only are there large and hard-hitting melee enemies, there are also Aberrations that lurk under the water, appearing only to leap out at you when you're nearby.
Going slow and using a bow to snipe and lure enemies one at a time is time-consuming and tedious. Especially when you consider that the water you are forced to walk in for most of the level has steep drops hidden within it that will result in instant death.
This is another place where using a torch is helpful, if only to give you a slightly better idea of when you're about to plunge out of existence, but using a torch means you can't use a bow. Better stock up on flame butterflies to relight every time you put it away.
As well as all this, there is a red NPC invasion towards the end, Poison Brumers that break your gear, and if you want to collect the soul and armour of King Vendrick, you'll need to come back here again later.
5. Tomb Of The Giants
Take everything you thought you knew about darkness being an unfair obstacle to overcome and apply it here.
The Tomb of the Giants in the original Dark Souls is pitch black, and bringing a light source of some sort is almost mandatory unless you are supremely confident in where you're going. There are prism stones placed on the ground at some key points, but it is still a very slow task to edge your way through the level, never knowing when your next step will drop you to your death.
This lack of light doesn't seem to affect the many enemies down here however. The archers will snipe your face off from half a mile away, the Skeleton Dogs will leap out of nothingness to attack you, and the Bone Towers will distract you long enough for the fake Pinwheels to pepper you with spells.
This is also where you can be kicked down a pit by Trusty Patches to battle two hollow NPCs in an effort to save a third. Do yourself a favour and either bring the Skull Lantern, or wear the Sunlight Maggot, and this area should just be irritating instead of impossible.
4. Lost Izalith
Despite the praise that the original Dark Souls received, there were some signs that parts of it had been rushed and suffered in the crunch time of development.
The worst offender by far was Lost Izalith. This lava-strewn nightmare was filled with odd, overly-bright textures that were painful on the eyes and the whole area lacked the polish that the rest of the game had. There have been some very vocal complaints about the Remaster and this area reflects the back-and-forth nature of community reaction pretty well - although the lava was made a little less painful to look at, it was still garish and many were disappointed.
The area is full of old enemies being re-used. In particular, the Capra and Taurus Demons that served as stand-alone bosses in the early game are here as mob enemies.
Once you have the Orange Charred Ring from the Centipede Demon, you can run on lava, but the constant sound effect is distracting.
Add into this that the boss of the area is the infamous Bed of Chaos, notorious for its unfairness especially when compared to the rest of the game, and you have an area that few enjoy or look forward to.
3. Farron Keep
Dark Souls 3 was obliged to contain the mandatory area that limits movement and damages the player. Their answer was in the Farron Keep area.
Combine slow walking, poison build-up, and basilisks with a confusing layout and the need to extinguish three lights in an area where everything sort of looks the same, and you have all the necessary components to frustrate and annoy the player.
There is loot here that is important to grab, so the player is forced to endure everything above as well as the Ghrus enemies, who do impressive damage, jump at you and exist almost entirely in groups.
For good measure, there is a second tree where the Giant can fire his arrows at you if you aren't on good terms with him. Dark Wraiths and the massive Elder Ghrus round off the painful list of problems waiting for you.
The Watchdogs of Farron Covenant is found here by the Old Wolf bonfire, as well as the Dreamchaser's Ashes, and the Abyss Walkers boss that blocks access into the Catacombs of Carthus. There is no avoiding this area in order to progress through the game, so the best advice is to equip poison resistant gear, grit your teeth, and go.
2. Blighttown
If you combine all the pain that the swamp area in Farron inflicted on you but up the ante even further, then you would come up with Blighttown.
In the lower areas, the swamp builds up poison and is full of Leeches, Mosquitoes and Barbarians that throw boulders at you all while you forcibly slow-walk through the mire.
If that doesn't seem like fun, then there are Barbarians with clubs, Blowdart Snipers that inflict toxic and flaming Dogs available in the upper levels. Most enemies here try to poison you, and due to the point in the playthrough when you are meant to get here, you will have to walk back through it all again to escape since you can't warp.
In addition to issues with enemies and mechanics, this area was infamous for causing the framerate to plummet and render it nearly unplayable. There was also strange killbox placement, where falls that should be easily survivable would result in your death, and earlier patches allowed for some frankly insane drops that didn't.
If you want to ring the Bell of Awakening, then you're going to have to come through here and kill Quelaag, unless you want to use cheats and glitches.
1. Frigid Outskirts
Arriving in the Crown of the Ivory King DLC for Dark Souls 2, this was an area that led to the optional bosses Lud and Zallen.
It's probably just as well it was optional because regardless of how difficult players found the boss, it was the run to them and the enemies before the arena that were the real issues. You're started off in an area with stones and three NPC summon signs, which should be the first warning that something was wrong.
You can see a building in the distance in between flurries of snow that reduce visibility to zero, and if you time it right you can just make it before the snow blows in. The next building is visible, but when you try to repeat the same trick, there are some nasty surprises waiting. The game will spawn these Reindeer right next to you, no matter what route you take and they can do heavy damage.
The same happens after this second building, and after the third AND there can be multiple spawns at once. Then there is an invading NPC on the bridge before the boss.
Everything is unfair and nothing is fun. Don't give up, skeleton.
Watch Next
How Well Do You Remember Dark Souls?