10 WORST Things About Popular Video Game Genres
Spikes of volume isn't horror.
Popularity is not always indicative of quality.
What's popular today may not stand the test of time, and though it's reasonable to say that video games are more than just a fleeting curiosity at this point, there's a handful of genres under the wider umbrella of virtual entertainment that have maintained their lofty status since their humble beginnings.
Text-based RPGs have evolved into fully-realised, open world offerings and racing games have developed from janky, top-down, affairs to downright simulation. There's something for everyone to enjoy within the realm of video games, with people across the globe discovering a handful of games that they hold dear.
However, the refining of each respective category of games hasn't been void of errors and annoyances. Medium-defining titles are so rare in number. Pitfalls of modern gaming are still present in abundance, and it seems that every popular genre of game has one or two recurring frustrations.
There are games that innovate, and games that follow, but many of the trailblazing developers and their projects have blemishes that are replicated by others attempting to create something themselves.
Video games are amazing, but there's always room for improvement.
10. Realism Over Fun - First-Person Shooters
Perhaps above all else, games are supposed to be fun. That's not to say they can't be hard-hitting or educational, though, as much of our world's history comes from warfare. As such, realism is placed on a pedestal, bringing players as close to the fight as possible.
Heavy storylines, malfunctioning guns and realistic bullet flight are all in line with real combat, but this philosophy when implemented in games often comes at the cost of fun. For as great as games like Metro Exodus, S.T.A.L.K.E.R and Far Cry 2 can be, the addition of such realistic elements only hinders the overall enjoyment.
Fairness and competition (be it online or in PvE) are surely far more important to a first person shooter's core design, which is often ousted in favour of a 'realistic' experience.
Plonking a AAA release in the trenches of World War I or the intricate warzones of modern conflicts can offer significant emotional weight that's grounded in reality. The issue is when the gameplay tries to mimic the real-world scenario, and in turn it becomes a chore to play.
Gameplay is the vessel for which most enjoyment from a game can be extracted, so it's crucial to design the fundamentals of the game in a way that retains a sense of realism while never losing its fun.
9. Cheap Jump-Scares - Horror Games
Jump-scares, if used infrequently and correctly, can be a great way to garner a quick scare in a sea of otherwise building tension. They're lazy, but effective.
However, when the backbone of a game becomes anticipating when the next will occur, it rather ruins the fun. Games like Outlast use them so often that the player becomes numb to their effects, meaning the back half of an otherwise terrifying horror title quickly becomes a meta-game of 'guess where the next cheap fright is'.
The majesty of titles like Bioshock lie in their ability to generate genuine fear without the need to lean into tacky tactics. When Irrational Games' masterpiece does use them, however, they're always memorable as a result.
Presentation, art style and sound design are all essential breadcrumbs on the trail towards genuine terror, and all serve to leave a long-standing sense of fear in the player rather than a period of boredom followed by a cheap jump out of their chair.
There are so many components needed for a good horror game, and there is no one secret formula to achieve the heights that Silent Hill 2, PT and Dead Space do. Jump-scares are an entirely valid piece of the horror puzzle, but it's also one that's far too relied upon.
8. Brainless A.I. - Stealth Games
The stealth genre can wield some of the most rewarding experiences in all of gaming.
Sneaking through the middle-eastern desert in The Phantom Pain or successfully avoiding the nightmarish creature in Alien: Isolation always conjures immense satisfaction. Each successful sneak often provokes more of a sense of achievement than blasting your way through corridors of baddies.
The potential for exciting moments is endless, it seems, but it dampens the fun somewhat when you realise that the enemy AI is totally oblivious to anything that isn't a machine gun rattling at point blank range.
Memory-deficient soldiers in Metal Gear Solid and Ellie-oblivious zombies in The Last Of Us detract (slightly) from the overall experience, and in some cases, it's the only significant blemish on a game's otherwise perfect resume.
Stealth should be a viable --even preferable-- gameplay technique in such titles, so knowing you could have reached the end of a level by waltzing through without the enemies really suspecting a thing is a real shame.
In truth, suppressors, silent footsteps and stealthy takedowns are far less impactful when the same result can be achieved with big bullets, bulky boots and bashing the attack button.
7. Unstable Servers/Rage Quitting - Sports Games
Legendary NFL head coach Vince Lombardi once said that winners never quit, and quitters never win.
Apparently the swath of FIFA faithful's didn't get the memo, as the temptation of bowing out of an online game a little too early is present in abundance in the series.
The same applies to most any sports game, in fact, as a glut of sore losers would rather leave a game half-way through than be gracious in defeat. It's positively infuriating to those of us who spend our precious time refining our skills in the crucible of FIFA, Madden or NBA 2K.
The puzzling thing, however, is that sport games so rarely have stable servers, so it's hard to know when they've quit or the game has decided to stop working.
We're looking at you, every FIFA ever made.
In fact, sometimes the game itself isn't sure, so any experience or reward you would have received is in doubt, as there is no guarantee that the game doesn't think you were the one to quit.
Throw in frequent maintenance updates, and you'll spend more of your time scheduling the safest times to play the game you paid so very much for.
6. Truly Obtuse Puzzle Solutions - Adventure Games
If woven together well, an adventure game can provide the perfect platform for a truly great narrative to unfold.
From The Walking Dead to Pillars Of The Earth, the mechanic of pointing and clicking is as simple as it gets, and allows for the narrative to take centre stage with the somewhat limited gameplay serving to move the story forward. It's a design philosophy that simply works wonders, and fans of the genre love it, but that great story squeals to a halt when an infuriatingly complex puzzle presents itself.
Titles like Broken Sword or, if we're honest, the entirety of 2021's Twelve Minutes, are significant blemishes on games that wield thoroughly entertaining and engrossing stories elsewhere.
In extreme cases -- like Broken Sword -- the tales presented are hindered by the game's insistence on making you angry. The inquisitive romp through Paris, Ireland and the like in Revolution Software's crowning achievement has distinct phases through its ~10 hour adventure: The charming first act, the infuriatingly annoying goat puzzle that makes you tear your hair out, and the concluding chapters that you don't remember as you were still calming down.
In any great adventure game, the mechanics should serve the story first and foremost.
5. "Over-Innovation" - Fighting Games
The formula of the fighting game genre is simple: two competitors on a 2D plane tussle to see who's life bar drains first.
It's a gameplay philosophy that has been forged, developed and perfected, so it's always a nervous time when a developer tries to drastically alter what has been so perfect for so long.
From the mediocrity of Naruto: Ultimate Ninja Storm's bland 'open world' and janky 3D combat to the scores of uninteresting modes in Smash Bros, anything that deviates too far from what makes the core gameplay great is so often so poorly executed.
The best fighting games are simple in design, easy to learn and hard to master. Tekken 3, Super Street Fighter II, SoulCalibur and Mortal Kombat 9 are all enjoyable to both hardcore veterans and newcomers alike. Combos are king, and they don't overcomplicate things to a degree that takes away from the fun. Side activities aside, fighting is always at the centre of their design, and they're all the better for it.
However, innovation is never a bad thing, and opting to stay stale is no better than over-innovating. Creating something new that best accompanies the tried-and-tested formula is where the true magic happens, and working within those parameters is pivotal to a game's overall quality.
4. Expensive Controllers For The "Best" Experience - Racing Games
As real-world racing returns to our screens, the simulation bug has infected many of us who were left waiting for the Formula 1 season to resume.
Video games, as was evident this past year, are a perfectly viable way for non-racers to feel like they're blasting through the streets of Monaco or tearing through the Styrian pines at the Austrian Grand Prix.
Anyone can be a Schumacher with the advancements of racing games, but with the distance in quality between regular gamepad and plug-and-play steering wheel, it's hard to enjoy games like Project Cars, Forza Motorsport and F1 2021 knowing that there is a far more comfortable --and expensive-- way to play.
A dedicated racing wheel is just the tip of the iceberg, as the need for an eye-wateringly expensive set-up to achieve truly great scores meant that most who only had a Dualshock were immediately on the back foot. Before you know it, that £50 game has now cost you over £700, 12ft of space in your living room and your marriage.
It's an over-exaggeration, sure, but there's no denying Racing games of today are prioritising simulation over frantic action, which is a price few of us can afford.
3. Menu Management - RPGs
Role Playing as a wanderer in Fallout 4 or Geralt of Rivia in Witcher 3 is designed to wrap you in a world unlike any other medium is capable of.
They often succeed in doing so, but only in the times you aren't meticulously organising your inventory or draping your party members in the finest armour. In titles like the aforementioned Witcher III and even quasi-RPG's like Mass Effect, more time is spent listening to the menu theme than the game's immersive soundtrack, which is the one thing that stops you from enjoying the role-playing adventure.
Weapon modding, armour equipping and party selecting are all core elements of the genre. No galactic commander or monster slayer would leave home without micro-managing to boost their survival odds, yet the often lack of an efficient, speedy means to do so results in an overall experience that's more akin to Football Manager rather than a high fantasy epic.
A simple button to select the best available gear set (like in Final Fantasy XIV, for example) is all it takes to streamline the process. At no point is a player going to select a far weaker, dumber looking item over a dashing, over-levelled piece.
2. Other Players - MMOs
Despite the valiant efforts of many to desperately restore the reputation of MMO players, there's an overwhelming consensus that the genre is plagued by somewhat disagreeable fanbases.
Letting a smorgasbord of colourful characters loose in a gigantic open world is a recipe for disaster. Much like social media, MMO servers are occupied by dozens upon dozens of people across the globe, and from all walks of life. A little bit of everything, all of the time wields predictable results: that there'll be more than a few bad or annoying eggs among the bunch.
Fruity language in party play is a common occurrence, so many of us navigate to the mute button to get away from the madness.
The Massive Multiplayer Online genre often finds comfort in fantasy settings or within worlds thick with lore, so tinny mic inputs, unpunctual party members and half-witted healers causing the dungeon to be restarted all detract from the colossal potential for escapism that the genre holds.
Make no mistake, player interaction is an essential component of the genre, without it any MMORPG would simply by an RPG. The drawback is that online games aren't exempt from the flaws of humanity.
Predictable, if disappointing.
1. Boring Tutorials - Collectible Card Games
Despite sometimes wielding similar items and mechanics, no card game is alike.
From the simplicity of Triple Triad to the intimidating waters of Magic: The Gathering, there's often so many unique quirks that need to be learned to get the best out of the game's often complex systems. Unless you have the freedom of Breath of the Wild to create a learning stage that mimics the wider game, tutorials have to be thorough, and as such are rarely ever enjoyable.
At the risk of sounding like your Year 5 Science teacher, learning is fun, but learning something in order to enjoy something else just feels like you're being held back from the main event.
Ants infest your pants, which is a dangerous (and probably uncomfortable) situation to be in, as the more restless you become, the more likely you are to skip through the boring, hand-holding segment.
Trudging though the banal tutorial to emerge from the other side means many players feel the need to stick to one game in the genre for fear of repeating the same mind-numbing affair elsewhere. What began as a curiosity into the card-game genre has now rendered you a prisoner to a single game.
You'll be good at Hearthstone, though, which is something, I guess.