10 Worst Weapons In Horror Video Games
Don't mess with a man and his weaponised sausages.
Generally, horror games opt for one of two extremes.
Many will cast the player as a defenceless, desperate, woefully-inept-in-a-fight protagonist relying on stealth to survive. Just as many will instead arm the player with a huge, absurd array of weaponry, unleashing all manner of grisly enemies from the depths of Hades’ u-bend upon them.
The Resident Evil series has done both several times. All of this makes weapons wielded by the player in horror titles a real mixed bag. Some of them are pitiful melee tools that are only to be used in dire emergencies, while others will effortlessly eviscerate hordes of oncoming foes.
Often, it just depends whether a game is putting the survival in survival horror or the grim, grisly, gory rampage in… horror.
At the same time, though, it would be easy to deem a weak weapon a bad one, but there’s much more to the equation than that. Here are some of the most impractical, feeble and silliest weapons players of horror games have ever had the misfortune to wield.
10. Resident Evil 4 - Eggs
Leon S. Kennedy can become a true one-man army in Resident Evil 4, getting his hands on everything from a rocket launcher to the wacky timed explosives of the Mine Thrower.
His humble handgun and knife can also be devastating, thanks to the melee attack prompts that were introduced here. Eggs, however, do precious little good at all from an attacking standpoint.
The primary function of eggs is to serve as a backup form of healing. The Chicken Egg, Brown Chicken Egg and Gold Chicken Egg restore different amounts of health to Leon, with the latter offering a valuable full heal. As well as eating them, though, the player can also equip them, then proceed to throw them at enemies.
It’s a funny novelty move, but it’s a terrible idea for a number of reasons. Not only can this be an awful waste of resources, but they’re a huge pain to aim with. Even if you do hit, you’ll only get a brief stun on a single foe for your troubles.
9. Silent Hill 4: The Room - The Paper-Cutting Knife
By contrast, Silent Hill has never been a franchise to focus on all-out action (generally). The horror here is of a more insidious, psychological kind.
The monsters protagonists battle here tend to be of a symbolic sort, grotesque manifestations of their guilt, sadness, desire and more.
Regardless, they are no less real from a gameplay standpoint, and can be warded off the old-fashioned way (at least, some of them can): with a selection of melee and projectile weapons. One of these is the classic knife, a standard starter weapon in titles from across the gaming spectrum.
Silent Hill 4: The Room features perhaps the worst take on this weapon in the series. The Paper-Cutting Knife is located very early on in the Hospital World, super weak and already obsolete.
Its speedy attacks allow it to get the better of the occasional lone enemy, but try to engage a group with this and you’ll be torn apart.
8. The Evil Within - Matches
The Evil Within is a survival horror franchise that strives to blend grim and gory confrontational horror with more thoughtful, complicated, mind-bending unease.
From a gameplay standpoint, however, The Evil Within offers the Agony Crossbow and some very standard fare in terms of weapons. Castellanos’ matches, both weapon and tool, can take down standard enemies immediately, but are frustratingly difficult to use effectively.
Essentially, they’re the player’s way to ensure that foes are actually dead.
As per Resident Evil’s remake, enemy bodies can be burnt to eradicate them for good. Castellanos’ matches perform this function here, but can only be use on grounded, struggling foes or those preparing a sneaky ambush.
They’re capable of tremendous damage, but foes must be lured to bodies to take advantage of the fire. It can be a real pain, opportunities to do it are rare, and matches themselves even rarer.
7. Dead Island - The Paddle
Most games featuring combat of any kind offer a gentle tutorial for said combat. Usually it’ll be accompanied by some weaker enemies to cut your teeth against, and a weapon that’s just about worthy of the name to see them off with.
Dead Island is a horror title that features more action than many, and it’s no exception to this. The first melee tool the player will find here isn’t the familiar knife, but the iconic-in-its-own-way Dead Island paddle.
It’s available as soon as that tutorial mission is complete, and very easily found on the beach. It has reasonable range and isn’t too punishing on your stamina, but it quickly degrades and will be automatically discarded (a la Link in The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild). This isn’t too much of a hardship, though, as you’ll be discarding it soon enough in favor of absolutely anything else.
It’s designed to quickly become obsolete, and that’s a mission accomplished for Deep Silver.
6. Eternal Darkness - Sanity’s Requiem: The Flash Pan
Eternal Darkness: Sanity’s Requiem tells the tale of a small band of people from across the ages, battling to foil the plans of the mysterious Ancients (separately, in their own time). Silicon Knights’ GameCube classic takes place across a series of chapters, each starring a different person from across history who finds themselves swept up in these events.
It’s a clunky original Resident Evil-esque affair, all set camera angles and inventory-wrangling. Along the way, there are various lumpen monstrosities from the depths of H.P. Lovecraft’s subconscious to battle, with the current chapter’s protagonist armed with time- and character-appropriate gear.
Chapter 9 of the game, A War To End All Wars, is set during World War I and stars Peter, a journalist. Among his starting equipment is a Flash Pan, such as photographers would have used at the time.
From a gameplay standpoint, its only use is to briefly stun foes with the bright light it emits. It does no damage at all and Peter has very limited uses of it. He’d be better served forgetting it exists at all.
5. Little Nightmares II - The Pipe (And Other Melee Weapons)
Tarsier
Studio’s Little Nightmares offered something unique and compelling on its
release in 2017. It was a brief, budget, indie title with a horrifically
beautiful aesthetic and bags of creepy charm. Not to mention a grim story to
tell in an entirely visual manner.
The unfortunate Six, a small girl in her characteristic yellow raincoat, was hunted across a dark and dingy cruise ship by its horrifying denizens. Little Nightmares II brought all of these essential frachise elements back, in a journey across larger and more varied environments that starred a new protagonist (aided by the returning Six), Mono.
The sequel added a wrinkle that the original game didn’t explore at all: combat. Mono can pick up a wield a variety of melee weapons in certain sections, and this could be the weakest element of the game. They are awkward and heavy to wield (to reflect Mono’s fragility and inexperience with such things), and while some players find it satisfying to be able to fight back, perhaps it’s a little too contrary to Little Nightmares’ core concepts to be able to do so.
4. Dead Rising - The Sausage Rack
Unlike the majority of survival horror titles, Dead Rising has never really been known for its seriousness. For its water-pistol-wielding, golf-club-swinging zaniness, certainly, but absolutely never for seriousness.
The first outing in Capcom’s beloved franchise arrived in 2006, introducing the unfortunate Frank West. West finds himself trapped in Willamete Parkview Mall, beset on all sides by the ravenous undead. He’s no combat-hardened soldier, and he has nothing but what he can find in the mall with which to defend himself.
Luckily for him, he is indeed in a vast mall, and the developers of the game had a wicked sense of humor. The result, as franchise fans will know, is a huge range of hilarious makeshift weapons to experiment with.
The aforementioned water pistol can be modified to be far deadlier than it may have been at first, so it really isn’t that bad a weapon at all. Everyone will have their favorite picks from Dead Rising’s absurd arsenal, but there’s nothing quite like dispatching a foe or two via a well-timed heave of a rack of sausages in the Meat Processing Area.
It’s completely impractical as it’s destroyed after being used once, making it awkward to use and easy to waste. Funny, though.
3. Bendy And The Ink Machine - The Plunger
Bendy and the Ink Machine is one of the most visually striking horror titles in recent gaming memory. With its cutesy cartoon visuals and adorably horrifying antagonist in Bendy, this episodic adventure oozes just as much style as it does ink.
In gameplay terms, though, it’s rather conventional. First-person horror titles offering light puzzling and some combat on the side are hardly a rarity. The selection of ink-addled opponent at least look unique, though, even if Henry’s selection of weaponry leaves something to be desired.
In the game’s third chapter, he finds a humble bathroom plunger. It’s more a tool than a weapon, but it can be wielded as one.
It’s much weaker than the other melee weapons (to the extent that the Achievement “Unlikely Victory” is offered for completing Chapter 4 using it), as its comical appearance would suggest.
2. Dead By Daylight - The Bear Trap
Needless to say, in a title that revolves around hunting down and disposing of survivors as a vicious horror movie-esque killer, bear traps can be hideously effective.
Nevertheless, The Trapper is often regarded as one of the game’s weakest killers, and it’s easy to see why that is.
Bear Trap is The Trapper’s Power, and with canny use, it can definitely be a game-winner. Survivors who stumble into it can be easy pickings, after all. The Trapper’s problem is that they are able to hold only one Bear Trap at once, which can severely hamper the performance of even an expert player.
Time is always of the essence in Dead By Daylight, and thanks to the Bear Trap, this Killer spends much of their time fighting their own limitations.
Combine this with the fact that Survivors can escape from the trap (and careless Trappers can even ensnare themselves) or free each other, and this weapon is just too ineffective and counter-intuitive compared to the tools some of the rest of the murderous cast bring to the table.
1. Castlevania: Dawn Of Sorrow - Terror Bear
The venerable Castlevania franchise isn’t really known for its silliness. Cheesy dialogue about miserable little piles of secrets, yes, but the Dracula-busting franchise tends to keep things distinctly po-faced.
After all, gothic horror is no place for whimsy.
Nevertheless, there’s always room for a joke weapon or two. Terror Bear, which appears in Castlevania: Dawn of Sorrow and Castlevania: Harmony of Despair, is one example. The in-game description of it from the latter title says it all: “insidious stuffed toy filled with iron and sand.”
Players, then, are treated to the sight of Soma Cruz swinging this cuddly toy over his head at foes. It gives a very meager attack bonus and is only notable for its hit speed and quantity. A novelty that Soma doesn’t need in his life.