10 Wrestlers P*ssed At Their WWE 2K23 Rating

Some wrestlers were so baffled by their WWE 2K23 ratings that 2K changed them?!

WWE 2K23 Ratings
2K Games/WWE

Undisputed Champ and all-round megastar Roman Reigns looks down on the rest of the pack in this year's WWE video game. The 'Tribal Chief' has an eye-watering 99 overall, which means he's two points better off than nearest challenger Brock Lesnar and a full three points better than top-ranked female Becky Lynch.

All of those names will be content, but how about those who won't be happy?

Of course, 2K's own 'Ratings Reveal' special on YouTube was a mix of kayfabe aggression and lighthearted banter between hosts and wrestlers about the scores dished out. Look beyond the worked elements though, and you'd maybe spot those who weren't exactly thrilled by what they were hearing.

Does getting a better score in WWE 2K23 mean everything? Well, no, but it is representative of the year these men and women have had on company TV. That's why there were some miffed glances when the ratings came out - some might've even had a quiet word behind the scenes, and fans definitely shouted loud enough to get one worker's score changed.

Here are all the WWE stars with a serious grumble ahead of 2K23's release.

10. Shotzi

Shotzi WWE
WWE.com

Rating: 75

Shotzi was a 77 overall last year, but she's tumbled two full points to 75. Why? Well, she's hardly had a banner year on SmackDown, and even managed to lock herself in the dressing room on an episode last year. That came after WWE 2K22's release, and it might go some way to explaining why she's fallen.

It's pretty rare for 2K to drop a wrestler's score by more than one point, so Shotzi should maybe take this as a sign that things aren't exactly clicking for her on Fridays. In fairness, she took the news in stride during the 'Ratings Reveal' piece, but she was clearly unhappy.

Things could get worse come 2K24 if WWE creative doesn't give Shotzi more to do - she's only really on the roster to act as a temp tag-team partner for bigger stars the writers have nothing else for solo, which is a real shame.


9. Braun Strowman

Braun Strowman
WWE.com

Rating: 89

If you fancy some unintentional comedy, then just check out Braun Strowman's speech during the 'Ratings Reveal' shindig. The 'Monster' started giving it the big one about being "better, stronger, faster" like he was Bianca Belair, and pointed out that he's in tremendous physical shape compared to his character in 2K22.

Then, the host announced that 2K didn't agree with any of that, and dropped the bombshell that Braun had actually fallen from a 90 to 89 overall. Ouch. Strowman's wide-eyed response said it all - he was a wee bit confused as to why that could be.

Braun wasn't even on the WWE roster when he collected one of those royalty payments for 2K22, but he must've even expected bigger things for the newest game. Nope, his character is actually a worse version in 2K23, and he kinda didn't know how to take that revelation.

Oh well, at least he's better than his tag partner Ricochet (82).


8. The Miz

The Miz
WWE.com

Rating: 85

Time for a strange moment.

2K's very own reveal claimed that The Miz's 2011 model would get a 90 overall score. However, whilst that suggests that Miz is one of John Cena's opponents in Showcase, he isn't listed on the official match lineup. Maybe he'll feature in some kind of bonus bout (WrestleMania XXVII, probably)?

Anyway, Mr. Miz was a bit baffled by what happened next. He found out that his modern-day character has shed a point to come in at 85 this year. That's lower than his 86 overall in WWE 2K22, which...definitely had the heel scrambling to rant and rave about how this is a disaster and everyone responsible should be fired.

Nobody's claiming that Miz is the most vital cog in the machine these days, but it does seem rather harsh to lower his rating in 2K23. Surely keeping him at 86 wouldn't have been too much to ask.


7. Bret Hart

Bret Hart
WWE

Rating: 91

Yes, this is just a little bit of fun. Bret Hart is hardly going to realistically lose much sleep over his character's rating in WWE 2K23, but maybe someone close to him who plays the game should keep a few things quiet. Firstly, Bret's 91 score means he's two points behind Triple H.

Y'know, the dude Hart has effectively called a terrible pro wrestler in the past. That sounds like the kind of thing that'd tick Bret off on a bad day. Hey, there's a positive though; the 'Hitman' is rated two points above regular bitch victim Bill Goldberg. That'd still irk Bret ('Only two stinking points?!').

On top of all that, Hart is three points lower than Hulk Hogan's 2002 model, and even one point beneath Seth Rollins. That's another guy the legend has been critical of during interviews in the past. Let's just say Bret should probably be kept in the dark about this year's ratings!

It's that damn Goldberg's fault.


6. Austin Theory

WWE Survivor Series 2022 WarGames Austin Theory
WWE.com

Rating: 82

Austin Theory heeled it up during the 'Ratings Reveal' and said he'd "talk to somebody" about his character's rating. He bagged an 82, which is actually fairly decent and puts Theory on par with the likes of Omos, Solo Sikoa and The Hurricane.

Wait, no wonder he's p*ssed.

Zero offence intended to those guys, but this was a wrestler handpicked by none other than Vince McMahon to become a breakout star. Things have calmed down after a sizeable dip under Triple H, but Austin probs predicted a bigger jump from last year's 80 score.

Not to worry, because his coming WrestleMania 39 bout vs. John Cena, and the improvements Theory is making every single time he works, should lead to bigger things in next year's game. He has every right to be a bit annoyed that he's beneath Baron Corbin and Ezekiel (who isn't even on TV anymore) though.


5. Dana Brooke

Dana Brooke
WWE

Rating: 73

Right, you'd be forgiven for wondering why Dana Brooke is even here. She's a peripheral figure in the women's division at best, and has next-to-no chance of ever becoming a top name who battles for the bigger singles belts. Regardless, her 73 score merits a moan.

She's three full points below Aliyah, which doesn't seem right. Again, no offence intended to anybody here, but Aliyah totally failed to grab attention when jumping up from NXT, and it's safe to say that Dana has done better during her run. It's slightly harsh that Brooke ranks as the second-worst female in the entire game.

Tamina (71) is the only one with a worse rating.

This is indicative of where Dana is in WWE at the moment. She's a supporter player who tries her able best, but she's never going to be taken all that seriously by the stat men and women hyper-analysing WWE's product over at 2K.


4. Chad Gable

Chad Gable Otis Alpha Academy
WWE.com

Rating: 77

Chad Gable has admittedly gone up a point since 2K22, but he's still mired in the glut of workers occupying the lowly 72-77 range. If Gable has anything to be p*ssed about, it's that he's rated beneath scrubs like Elias and Drew Gulak. Yep, Drew f'n Gulak scored a 79 in WWE 2K23. How is that even possible?!

Meh, he must've impressed 2K's top brass with his performance as trainer for last year's handy tutorial section. That's the only explanation one can think of to rationalise why Gulak's character is two points better than the head of Alpha Academy. Chad might have to tell someone to "SHOOOOOOOSH!" around these parts.

Finally, Gable is also two points behind NXT's Axiom. That's a bold decision, especially when Chad has consistently shown he's one of the best technical wrestlers on the entire roster. Apparently, that doesn't count for much in 2K's world.

How very dare they.


3. Jimmy Uso

Paul Heyman Jimmy Uso
WWE

Rating: 89

Perhaps Paul Heyman can use these WWE 2K23 ratings as fuel during promos later this year. Maybe, when trying to fire The Usos up, Heyman can sneakily mention that Jey got a better score than his brother Jimmy despite them being twins. Why not? It'd be a real show of sh*thousery from Paul E.

Both Usos got the same 85 rating last year, but 2K decided to switch things up a bit in 2K23. This time, Jey is a 90 overall and Jimmy is 89. That must be deliberate - there's no way this wasn't given some thought behind the scenes. During the reveal, Jimmy (jokingly) walked off set as Jey grinned.

Oooh, the tension.

Jimmy likely thought both he and Jey would get exactly the same ratings. In fact, most fans buying 2K23 probably believed they'd be borderline identical characters with a few minor appearance differences. Not quite. Jey is a stronger pick than his bro.


2. Rhea Ripley

WWE Elimination Chamber 2023 Rhea Ripley
WWE.com

Rating: 87 (increased to 90)

Fans online were shocked when the host of 2K's 'Ratings Reveal' told Rhea Ripley and Dominik Mysterio the entire Judgment Day faction's overall scores. No-one was stunned that Dom came in as the lowest-ranked of the members, but everyone raised an eyebrow when Rhea's number popped up.

2K handed the Royal Rumble winner and surefire future SmackDown Women's Champ a measly 87 rating initially. That wasn't going to fly with the gamer base, and people let the developers know it. The backlash was so severe that 2K eventually decided to increase Ripley's rating to 90.

Someone got a tap on the shoulder at 2K HQ about that one. You couldn't have Rhea ranking below a lot of the women she's going to be joining atop the women's division very soon. Besides, she's been the standout member of JD, and deserved to be rewarded for that with the best score of the lot.

At least they fixed it once people (including Ripley) got annoyed.


1. Zelina Vega

Zelina Vega WWE
WWE.com

Rating: 74

Zelina Vega will still be under her Queen Zelina gimmick in WWE 2K23. She's not angry about that, but the pint-sized mouthpiece for Legado del Fantasma is aggrieved at her overall rating in the new game. Zelina couldn't resist posting her thoughts on Twitter after seeing that she'd been rated 74.

During her rant, Vega pointed out that she'd become WWE's first ever "Queen Of The Ring" (by winning the Queen's Crown tourney in 2021, and had enjoyed a 132-day reign as Women's Tag-Team Champions alongside partner Carmella. Unfortunately, that history didn't really matter to 2K.

Zelina's 74, unlike Rhea's score, wasn't going to improve.

It's pretty rubbish that Vega is still "Queen" in 2K23 and doesn't appear to be aligned with Santos Escobar and the rest of Legado. That dates her character, and the 74 score means she's also one of the worst wrestlers in the game.

Which other WWE stars must be miffed by their 2K23 rating? For more wrestling, check out 10 Most Embarrassing Product Placements In Wrestling History and WWE 2K23: 10 Things To Know Before You Buy!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.