10/10 Video Games The Public REJECTED
Critics said yes, the public said hell no.
Much like that old adage about thumbs and fingers, all critics are people but not all people are critics and inevitably the two groups will disagree from time to time.
Whether illustrated by a commercial flop, a wild disparity in review scores granted by critics versus those submitted by the public, or a genuinely great game that came off a little too niche or was poorly marketed, these games may have taken home some stellar scores from certain critics, but weren’t taken home by the public. Mostly. Because they didn’t buy it.
Some of these games are very good and it just so happens that nobody picked them up while some were critically praised but gamers were like, no, this is kind of bad and elected not to trade their dollars for the experience. In either case, the fact of the matter remains, the general masses didn’t take to these ones.
9. Octopath Traveler II
Sporting a 10/10 on Steam and a sea of perfect and near perfect scores, you’d be forgiven for assuming that 2023 JRPG Octopath Traveler II was a slam dunk commercially given the game was even bigger critical success than its predecessor.
Not only that, Octopath Traveler II is one of the entries on this list that gamers loved as well, which begs the question why not that many people went out and bought it.
In its release week, the game only shifted 78,000 units, getting absolutely stomped by Kirby’s Return to Dream Land Deluxe which launched on the same day and sold 190,000 copies. Though Team Asano would go on to announce that in just under four months on sale, the game had sold one million units across all platforms and including both digital and physical sales, Octopath Traveler the first sold the same amount of units after less than a month on shelves, and at that point the game was only available on Switch. Exactly why more fans didn’t return to the sequel despite stellar review scores is hard to say. It’s possible that the second game launched in a far busier release window as opposed to the first game which landed in the middle of July in 2018, only seriously competing with the beefed up version of Sonic Mania and the Xbox release of Nier: Automata.
To be fair, there’s likely not a lot of audience overlap between Octopath and Sonic Mania fans, and there was no pulling Nier diehards out of that hundred hour experience just to throw them into another one, anyway.
There was also an attractive shiny new aesthetic and quirkiness to what Octopath Traveler offered back in 2018 that has since become well-trodden ground, likely resulting in the sequel pulling in fewer new fans.
8. Tearaway Unfolded
Remember Tearaway? I played this whole game and its sequel and completely forgot about it until I started researching for this list. Though I also have no idea where my PlayStation Vita is.
The 2013 platformer with a bevy of papery graphics and Vita-specific gimmicks that actually worked really well was a hit with critics and players. It won a pile of awards and spawned sequel Tearaway Unfolded which arrived just two years later. The follow up scored pretty much the same level of critical acclaim that was levied upon the first game except this time around, nobody bought it. While loads of us who invested in a Vita and had played enough of Gravity Rush for one lifetime decided to at least give Tearaway a go, because good games for the platform were getting pretty thin and our giant-screened handheld console was starting to look like a $350 paperweight, Tearaway Unfolded was a whole other story.
The sequel launched in September which isn’t a terrible time to come out, especially when there’s not a lot of games quite like it and you’d assume the original’s fanbase would mosey on over to check this one out on the PlayStation 4, gamers were a little preoccupied in the back end of 2015.
Charming, though Unfolded was, it absolutely fell apart commercially. It tanked so very hard that it didn’t even chart on the vast majority of top sales lists in the West or in Japan. Some speculated that Sony sent their first-party kid out to die but having a look at the release calendar I’d say that even with the greatest marketing budget known to man, very few gamers would have been electing to tuck into the Tearaway sequel when just one week prior Mad Max and Metal Gear Solid 5: The Phantom Pain had come out. If that blow wasn’t already fatal, Super Mario Maker landing three days later quickly followed by Forza 6 and indie darling Undertale would have handily scooped up any remaining idle gamers.
The writing was on the wall and unsurprisingly we never did get a Tearaway 3.
7. Deathloop
Crafted from Arkane Studios, the same minds who made Dishonored and whose Austin Studio would later make Redfall which was admittedly not good but then Microsoft went and shut it down which is frankly appalling because studios should be able to release a dud without being shuttered and this is exactly the problem when the big guys acquire the little guys–I feel I’ve fallen off my point, but in summary Arkane: good, many fans, 2021’s Deathloop: presumed to be slam dunk.
For many critics Deathloop did deliver on everything they hoped for. It got a swath of high scores including a bunch of 10/10s from outlets praising the game for its art style, writing, invasion mechanic, and world-building. Deathloop also received loads of accolades, including Game of the Year nominations from pretty much everybody who dispenses such a thing. In contrast, fans were not feeling this one. Though it may have fallen victim to the sort of overhype that skewered games like No Man’s Sky and Fallout 76 before it, gamers at large found Deathloop wanting for a bunch of reasons. Plenty of people reported picking it up only to bounce off it with disappointment over the game’s AI, the multiplayer, and the narrative, among other things.
That said, there were still a bunch of people who loved Deathloop, it likely just fell victim to a lot of reviewers saying it was perfect so expectations were through the roof before anybody even got their hands on it.
In reality, some people may have been perfectly enjoyable if they went in expecting a solid 7/10 game instead of what equated to the second coming of Dishonored. Of course, games are subjective and like any of the games that didn’t make this list, the games that did will have their diehard fans and their naysayers, but the fact that almost every critic gave Deathloop a stellar score while the public was deeply divided over its quality makes the action shooter well and truly list-worthy.
6. The Legend Of Zelda: Skyward Sword
I use this joke a lot but I’ve said ‘divisive’ so now by law I need to mention The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword, a game that has an incredible 93/100 on Metacritic but is memed by the internet for being, well, a bit shit.
Whether it is actually a bit shit or not will vary from person to person. In fact, if we take away the user score averages on Google and Metacritic they’re an overwhelming positive 96% thumbs up and 8.1 respectively suggesting the vast majority of people really liked it. But boy, you wouldn’t know it from the infamous derision this game earned as, for a time, the internet’s most hated Zelda game.
Slammed for its incessant hand-holding via the means of Fi, art style, control scheme which at certain points made entire segments agonising, needless padding, and antagonist Ghirahim who is either a cult favourite tongue-wagging camp icon giving gay in all the right ways, or borderline offensive. Your call. Reception for Skyward Sword was probably also impacted negatively given it came out just one week after Skyrim which didn’t have the same padding or control issues.
Also, not even making the cut as the best Sky game that came out that month is a tough break. Much like Deathloop, Skyward Sword was probably another victim of its own success in that fans might not have been so critical of it if it hadn't been praised almost unanimously by critics. Or maybe it’s just crap. Like I said, that one is entirely up to you.
There’s a good chance that public opinion on this one changed dramatically when the HD version landed in 2021. Even though that's an entire decade after the original hit shelves, the Switch version benefited enormously from dropping the inconsistent Wiimote and Nunchuk controls, alongside fine-tuning the performance and letting players decide on their control scheme of choice. Always a good thing.
5. Rule Of Rose
Rule of Rose is one of the games on this list that wasn’t rejected because the internet hated it, it was mostly a victim of its own controversy, coming out at a time where the general public just wasn’t ready to accept a game that dealt with such heavy subject matter.
Punchline’s 2006 survival horror would eventually rise to cult classic status, but outside of those circles it remains largely unknown. Back when moral panic and video games went hand in hand way more often than they do now, Rule of Rose became page six level gossip for supposedly featuring extreme sexual themes, violence, and pretty much every item in the book that would lead someone who had never played a video game to find some pearls to clutch.By and large, these claims weren’t even accurate and by today's standards its themes are hardly outlandish or unheard of in the medium.
Getting to the reality of the title and not its exaggerated perception, Rule of Rose has fairly rudimentary gameplay mechanics but its story is well worth the price of admission. Protagonist Jennifer has a little dog that gets hurt which is honestly one of the worst parts, and the narrative does feature kidnapping, torture, suicide, violence involving children, and loads of inarguably dark elements.
All that said, the general public including critics really turned on this one, calling it exploitative and unpleasant, and as a result sales were skewered before it even hit the market. Those who did vibe with it praised its representation of deep psychological horror and compelling narrative that successfully seesawed between the disturbing and emotional. It’s certainly an uncomfortable play but only in the way in which brutal horror movies are an uncomfortable watch.
Go in expecting a fun time and it’s no wonder many found it distasteful, but as an emotional and rich dark horror tale, it's deeply successful.
4. Dark Souls II
Dark Souls II, or as it is now known ‘the bad Souls game’ by the fanbase, actually has stellar review scores. Believe it or not the most polarising game in the series for FromSoft fans has a better Metacritic rating than Dark Souls, Dark Souls III, and Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice.
It sparked controversy among those who weren’t a fan of the Souls threequel for pacing issues, random spikes in difficulty coupled with breezy encounters, irritating ambushes, and an overload of bosses, while some also took issue with the game’s comparatively shallow narrative and more linear map design.
This is a tricky one, because while the majority of fans statistically seemed to come away feeling favourable about the game, the group who were more critical were certainly a lot more vocal. In this case, one man’s pleasing complex systems, improved spell integration, and exceptional bosses were another’s gripes over the combat and health mechanics. There’s a little suspicion over whether professional critics might have been influenced by the groundswell of public belief that Souls games could do no wrong.
Similar to Dragon Age II, while the review scores backed both sequels as true to form entries from the heavy hitter studios, enough people took to Reddit to express their frustrations, cementing both in the realm of infamously divisive.
3. Planescape: Torment
Following on from games that people love to hate or hate to love, Planescape: Torment is almost universally agreed upon to be one of the greatest games ever made, and in this case both critics and fans seemed to agree.
It was just unfortunate then that nobody bought it.
Despite iterating on digital RPG systems in a fascinating way and enabling player freedom of interaction in a way not many games of this scope and size had done so at the time, Planescape: Torment presented as perhaps a little too niche for its own good. While its grand and delightfully complex narrative and witty dialogue is a joy to immerse yourself in, it was a trickier thing to sell to gamers.
With a 91/100 on Metacritic and a final product that lived up to its 10/10s the game should have been too critically acclaimed to fail even without a successful marketing campaign, but it only sold 73,000 in its first four months on shelves.
The sales numbers improved somewhat over time but at the time Planescape sunk under the weight of bigger RPGs like Ultima IX that released just a month prior.
2. Overwatch 2
I’ve saved the two top spots on this list for games that critics loved but gamers said “absolutely not” in droves. And not because said games were too niche, marketed poorly, or had competitive release windows, they were just a big let down.
I’ll parrot my subjective statement again just to cover the inevitability that you or someone you may know actually likes one or both of these games but chances are you probably don’t. Knowing how much everybody absolutely dunked on Overwatch 2 you might have forgotten that Blizzard’s team shooter cleaned up in the impressive review score department at launch.
Most of the major outlets pinned it with 8s if not 9s but players were not having it. Despite gathering more than double the players of its predecessor in its launch month, that really just meant even more players were primed for frustration.
It’s not quite accurate to judge this one on user reviews since there were not one but three reasons the game was a target for review bombing.
The first was Activision Blizzard’s harassment allegations, the second being Blizzard ditching their partnership with Chinese company NetEase that meant players in the region couldn’t use local servers, and finally the game itself dropped its intended PvE content and swapped out loot boxes for a battle pass.
There were also complaints about the game’s poor matchmaking, and everything in the game being nickel and dimed to oblivion. The first game being universally beloved was always going to be tricky to live up to but the missteps here were next level.
1. Starfield
If you didn’t see it coming before you’d probably be none too surprised to see this one in the top slot. Starfield certainly has its fans but much like Overwatch 2, this was expected to nail it since it came from a studio who proved they had the capacity to produce a truly masterful video game.
Unfortunately, Starfield was not a masterful video game, in fact most fans found it to be deeply average, which is odd since its review scores are actually great. Seriously, it got a bunch of 10/10s and its Metacritic score is somehow 85/100. I know.
While the game is, by most reports, in better shape now than it was at launch almost a year ago, there’s a massive gulf between the critical reviews that praised the game world, graphics, joy of exploration, and score as opposed to the reception from the public. Some players took to online forums to say they found the experience to be mediocre but not fantastic, while others criticised the narrative for being largely soulless, in addition to the game’s one note characters, disappointing systems and writing, and reliance on procedural generation that stripped the game of that rich Bethesda goodness.
Maybe you liked this one more than others or maybe you hated it more, but the disparity between the critical reception and that of the public at large is one of the bigger divides in recent video game memory. If you’ve got any more ideas you know where to put them.