11 Creepiest Urban Legends In Video Games
Did you hear the one about the dead developers making a video game?
Whether you believe them or not, it's hard not to get suckered into an urban legend. Because tall tales such as these are so appealing, it's no surprise that the world of video games have their fair share of myths.
But we're not talking about the Tomb Raider nude code or fighting Street Fighter's Sheng Long. We're looking at the lore that have a flair for the macabre.
Because you can learn if there is any truth to these myths online, you'd assume stories such as these would be quashed quickly. However, because gossip can circulate online at an astonishing rate, it's allowed these horrifying urban legends to linger for years. Even after they have been irrefutably disproven, some tales are just too interesting to die.
What's more bizarre is that some of these legends go beyond the game itself, and spill into the real world. There are rumblings of games that have been connected with murders. Some also entrenched in so much mystery, we're not sure if they ever existed.
If you don't mind not sleeping for a while, here's a look at some of the freakiest urban legends plaguing the virtual world.
11. The Shadows In Shiverburn Galaxy - Super Mario Galaxy 2
When you reach the Shiverburn Galaxy in Super Mario Galaxy 2, there is a peculiar detail you may notice the instant you enter the terrain. If you go into first-person mode and look towards the glacier cliffs, you should notice three shadowy figures watching you.
Thinking rationally, you may assume these "creatures" are an incomplete texture.
But the more you learn about these dark entities, the scarier they become.
Firstly, the file name for these shadows is "HellValleySkyTree". Weirder still, the area these figures reside in is titled "Beyond Hell Valley." Although you can't tell by looking at them, these entities are enormous. (The tallest one is a hundred times larger than Mario.) It's also worth mentioning these enigmatic critters resemble kodamas - Japanese spirits who hide in trees, waiting to curse anyone foolish enough to cut them down.
But what's worse is Nintendo has never explained what these things are. If they were an enemy in the beta removed from the final cut, why don't the developers just come out and say it?
As there's no explanation on what these beings are, gamers have speculated they are some sort of hidden enemy, forever unclassified.
10. Sparky And The Secret Code - Five Nights At Freddy's
Because the very nature of Five Night at Freddy's is cryptic, it would've been less surprising if Scott Cawthon's survival horror franchise didn't include an urban legend or two.
Sure enough, there were murmurs of a secret animatronic called Sparky the Dog hidden in FNAF, shortly after the point-and-click adventure debuted. Unlike his sinister companions, this one-armed robot, who supposedly appeared Backstage, never attacks the player.
Sadly, Sparky was proven to be a hoax, (which is a shame since he was pretty terrifying).
After this fabrication was exposed, you would think gamers would be more cautious about what to believe in the future. Instead, fans of Five Nights fell for the rumour mill yet again. Although the Kitchen camera is deactivated, it was suggested it could be turned on in Custom Night mode by inputting "666" on the keyboard while this room was selected.
However, after dataminers failed to find any image file for the Kitchen, this rumour was quashed. (They could've also disproven this tall tale by pressing "666" while selecting the Kitchen to see if anything happened. That... would've been way faster.)
9. Yummer - SpongeBob Saves The Day
SpongeBob Saves the Day is an online Flash game released in 2019. Throughout your adventure, you need to help our titular sponge prepare for holiday by helping his friends. It may be a simple game, but it's clear the developers put a lot of care into the project, since it perfectly captures the look and feel of the beloved animated series.
But over time, there were stories that SpongeBob Saves the Day had a hidden character called Yummer, which left players utterly terrified.
When images of this bald, humanoid entity started popping up online, many assumed it was a hoax. Not only did it seem nonsensical for such an unsettling character to appear in a kids game, Yummer's hyperrealistic aesthetic didn't match the cutesy design of SpongeBob.
When this legend refused to die, players investigated the inner workings of the game, only to discover Yummer... was real. While accessing the offscreen section of the Krusty Krab, the grinning figure can be spotted peeking from the side.
Once Yummer's' existence came to light, the developers explained he was used as a modelling test. Although they put Yummer in the game as a placeholder, they forgot to remove him, allowing him to scare the crap out of anyone who came across him.
8. Piggsy And Ratman - Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas
Anyone who's played Grand Theft Auto should be well-acquainted with the myth that Bigfoot is hidden in GTA: San Andreas.
However, you may not be familiar with a far more disturbing legend circulating this game. By waiting around a specific destination, you should encounter Piggsy - the serial killer from Manhunt.
As ludicrous as this report sounded, it's theoretically possible since both franchises were made by the same company. The rumours gained further traction when YouTuber, DarthDementous uploaded a video in 2008, depicting footage of the pig-masked psychopath in Mount Child and Shady Creeks.
But when dataminers found nothing to back up these claims, interest in the Piggsy rumours dissolved.
Or maybe the myth died down because gamers were obsessing over another GTA urban legend.
The same year the Piggsy video was uploaded, GTA IV was released. Not long after its launch, an image circulated online of a human-rat hybrid lurking in the subway tunnels in the game's Easton Service Station. This overgrown rodent was said to kill the player instantly if they had the misfortune of running into it.
Even though many dismissed the picture as a fake, there were some who saw enough clues to warrant the Ratman's existence. Several NPCs mention large rat-like critters near the station. One comedian at the Split Sides Comedy Club says he saw a homeless man run by him at astounding speed, which some believe is another reference to the furry cryptid.
7. Brutus The Bulldog - Animal Crossing
It's always the cutest games that spawn the most disturbing urban legends. Sonic.EXE and Pokemon's Lavender Town legend have freaked out more gamers than Silent Hill.
Which brings us to Animal Crossing. Although it's arguably Nintendo's most adorable franchise, that doesn't mean its immune to a few spooky myths.
All the way back in the original Animal Crossing for the GameCube, there were speculation that the player could make contact with an evil bulldog called Brutus. This purple pup supposedly moved into the village during the night, and would be gone the following morning, giving the player little chance of encountering him. Allegedly, Brutus would send the player binary letters, delete your village if you saw him, or crash the game if you entered his house.
This legend got so out of hand, it dictated how certain people played the game. Some turned Animal Crossing off at night to avoid running into Brutus, and incurring his wrath.
Despite there being no evidence of this character's existence, there are rumours that he's been sighted in nearly every Animal Crossing entry since, even after twenty years.
6. The Letter - Twisted Metal: Extra Twisted
Twisted Metal: Extra Twisted was a PS2 port of the PSP instalment, Twisted Metal: Head-On. Rather than being a straight port, the game included an additional mode called Twisted Metal: Lost, which contained four levels from the cancelled sequel, Twisted Metal: Harbour City.
Although Twisted Metal: Lost was a nice bonus, the origins of how it came to be are really weird. Apparently, the level Harbour City was cancelled after six of the developers died in a plane crash.
Two years later, a letter supposedly signed by these developers found its way to Sony, imploring them to show their work to the world.
Even though the note is regarded as a hoax, the fanbase was split on whether the sextet of developers existed in the first place. During an interview, lead developer, David Jaffe, seemingly confirmed the story behind the developers' demise was legit.
But while speaking on his now-defunct blog to a journalist from 1UP.com, Jaffe made a conflicting account, stating "the developers dying in the plane crash" was "totally fake", and "was never used to promote the game", instead saying "it was our take on a Blair Witch set up" for the game's story, and that none of this had been clarified before launch.
With no definitive answer for years though, the Twisted Metal community more than went along for the ride.
5. The Killer Game - Taboo: The Sixth Sense
Taboo is a tarot simulator released for the NES in 1989. (Weirdly, it was developed by Rare - the same guys behind Donkey Kong Country and GoldenEye 007.)
Even though fortune-telling is intriguing, Taboo does absolutely nothing with the concept.
In the game, you must give your name, birthday, and gender. After that, you are handed several cards that propagate a possible future for you and... that's it. Without a shred of exaggeration, it takes longer to complete Taboo's instruction manual than the game itself. Since there are no puzzles, enemies, obstacles or skills required, some question whether it can be classified as a game to begin with.
With little to offer, Taboo vanished into obscurity almost immediately after it was released.
However, many years later, Taboo came back into the spotlight, when it was rumoured the tarot simulator accurately predicted the deaths of several young players. Because it's difficult to find any details on this report other than standard write-ups though, it's safe to assume the event is bogus.
4. Herobrine - Minecraft
It took less than a decade for Minecraft to become the most successful video game of all time. Mojang's blocky sandbox title has managed to stay on top, due to its accessibility and addictive gameplay.
But there's no way Minecraft could've been popular for this long without generating at least one creepy story.
Speaking of which, let's look at the game's scariest character. Not enderman. Not creeper. Minecraft's true boogeyman is Herobrine.
To hardcore fans, Herobrine is the stuff of legends since there've been hints of his existence since the game's pre-release, when images of him circulated on gaming forums. In these pictures, Herobrine resembles the default Steve character with fully whitened eyes.
It was rumoured that if you see random objects manifest into being in a single-player world, you know Herobrine is near. The few who allegedly spotted him said they only saw the mysterious spectre for a second before he vanished.
However, all the gamers who claimed to have encountered Herobrine are more commonly known as "liars", since the character never existed.
Even though this legend should've died down by now, there's always some Minecraft gamer with an overactive imagination who swears they bumped into Herobrine upon their last playthrough.
3. The Insanity Mod - The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind
When Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind took the world by storm, it wasn't long before die-hard gamers started crafting their own mods of the RPG. Although there are hundreds of versions of Morrowind, there is no question the jvk1166z.esp. mod is the most infamous.
At first, many suspected jvk wasn't a game, but a virus since it corrupted save files when activated. To get it to work, jvk had to be played in DOSbox.
Immediately after this incarnation of Morrowind boots up, crazy things start happening. All the main characters are dead. NPCs keep telling you to "Watch the sky." When your health hits zero, you encounter a spider-creature called The Assassin.
If you enter a nearby dungeon, you'll come across a locked door. Even though there's no known way to open this door, it hasn't stopped people trying. According to some reports, players spent days without sleep, obsessing over accessing this area. Gamers became so fixated on this door, they suffered from night terrors or hallucinations revolving around The Assassin.
Although it's debated if these reports are real or if the mod itself actually existed, jvk1166z.esp. has been recreated many times by fanatical modders, ensuring this urban legend won't be going away any time soon.
2. The Co-Ordinates - Pale Luna
In recent years, there have been reports of a creepy text-based adventure title called Pale Luna. In this game, you must choose which part of the forest to walk towards, while carrying gold, a shovel, and a rope. Because most players couldn't make heads or tails of it, Pale Luna was dismissed as a broken game.
However, there was one guy called Michael Nevins who managed to beat it. After Nevins tried every possible combination of movements, the screen flashed with the text, "PALE LUNA SMILES WIDE. There are no paths. PALE LUNA SMILES WIDE. The ground is soft. PALE LUNA SMILES WIDE. Here. Command?".
Nevins dug a hole, threw in the gold, and filled it up. He then received a message, which read, "Congratulations, 40.24248 -121.4434."
Out of curiosity, Nevins reportedly looked up these numbers, only to learn they were coordinates in Lassen Volcanic Park in California. After locating this exact spot, Nevins dug up the dirt with a shovel, and discovered... the body of a girl who went missing the previous year.
If that story made the hairs on the back of your neck stand on end, don't get too excited. As entertaining as this tale is, it is one of the most infamous Creepypastas that took on a life of its own, not an actual video game.
1. The Game That Never Was - Killswitch
Much like Polybius or Pale Luna, the urban legend that surrounds Killswitch is not the game itself, but whether it existed in the first place.
Supposedly, a Czechoslovakian company called Karvina Corporation made 5,000 copies of this alleged title during the late 1980s or early 1990s. In this mystery horror game, you could choose to play as an invisible fire-breathing demon called Ghast or a girl called Porto.
What made Killswitch unique is how it could only be played one time. If the player died or reached the goal, the game would automatically erase itself, leaving no record it was there in the first place.
Because it's difficult to prove a video game was never real, you'd imagine this Creepypasta would linger forever.
However, it's surprisingly easy to disprove Killswitch's existence, since its origins can be traced to Catherynne M. Valente's short story, Melancholy of Mechagirl, which was published in 2013. Since we can pinpoint where this tale originated from, you'd think that would put this myth to bed.
But because so many people have uploaded their own mods of Killswitch online over the years, the gaming community has managed to keep this legend alive.