11 Times Video Games Did Horror Better Than Movies

What about when you're the one who has to open that creaky old door into the unknown?

Horror is something that comes in a whole bunch of different flavours; from volume-spiking jump-scares to grotesque imagery that will haunt you deep into the night, or just an over-reliance on gore to turn your stomach by default. All of them transfer over to gaming perfectly, as although the medium of film challenges you to watch the events unfold on screen, gaming puts you directly in the shoes of that innocent person exploring a dilapidated old mansion, or the one who has to delve deeper into the depths of somewhere you'd otherwise stay away from just to retrieve an object to forward the story. For many the first experience of having their horror-cherries popped would have been with either the first Silent Hill or Resident Evil games. Both operating in a manner that's become known as 'tank controls' where your characters could only rotate before heading forward or back, this limited movement actually increased the horror element thanks to restricting how well you could get away from what surrounded you. However, recently we've seen a huge amount of first-person horror titles emerge, from the latest entry in the Amnesia series to the meme-based cult-hit Slender: The Eight Pages, featuring everyone's favourite elongated stalker. All the games above are very enjoyable for a number of cross-medium reasons, but the unique thing gaming has offered horror fans is that feeling of not wanting to press on, but knowing that only you are able to. In itself it's a terrifying concept, and one that's personified in some of the best titles in the genre.

11. Slender: The Eight Pages - Realising Someone Is Watching

Birthed by creator Eric Knudson for an online competition where photos had to be altered to look like they featured spooky activity, his images were accompanied by seemingly real-world accounts of people who had come into contact with the "Slender Man". The creations and photos went viral, with Knudson supplementing the hype with an origin story and more faked documents to propagate the idea that Slender was actually a real demon who abducted children with his "persistent silence and outstretched arms" striking a chord with thousands. The Eight Pages was the first incarnation of the mythos, kickstarting the entire first-person horror revolution we're now in the middle of. Putting you in the shoes of somebody lost in the woods and tasking you with recovering the titular eight pages that were scattered around, the game is a masterclass in sound design, topped off by the slow burn that at any moment you could turn around and see Slender right behind you. Even M. Night Shyamalan's much-derided Signs features the highly-effective method of showing a static silhouette watching from afar, in a great scene where the figure of a man stands ominously on a rooftop, glaring at Mel Gibson's character. A reliance on the unknown - or in this case, the unknown intentions of a character - is one of the best tools any horror-connoisseur has in their repertoire, and it's a delicate balancing act revealing the creature in the shadows in a manner that keeps pulses sky-high, yet also delivers on the idea of a threat. Luckily for us, Slender succeeded so well in digging his claws in that he's now a cultural phenomenon, the very mentioning of which chills some people to the bone from being stuck out in the woods for too long.

10. Outlast - Using The Camcorder As A Torch

2004's Saw might have gone on to be one of the most drawn-out laboriously-produced 'horror' franchises of all time, but in that first instalment director/writer-combo James Wan and Leigh Whannel's hearts were in the right place. A particular scene that got away from the plight of the characters and was genuinely quite original and innovative was the flashback where Whannel's character Adam has to explore his power-drained apartment using a camera's flash as the only light-source. In a brilliant move this meant the audience only saw what was right in front of him for a split-second, before being plunged back into darkness as he continued to creep around. Needless to say when the Jigsaw killer did finally emerge from a cupboard, it was one of many things that contributed to that first film's high reception.
Over to this year's Outlast and the game is putting you in charge of a similarly sporadic light source, except this time around it's a camcorder. Set in an abandoned (yeah, right) asylum, you'll have to explore a plethora of incredibly dark, dank rooms and basements, holding the camcorder up to use night-vision as the only way to properly scout ahead. Being that this is a PS4 game the graphics are superb, and also due to the fact that you're using this mode the pupils of enemy characters' eyes are illuminated the same way as whenever ghost hunters go off into the night on TV shows or movies. If you were one of the people in the audience who were just thankful that you weren't the one who had to explore the apartment like Adam, this is the title that flips that on its head perfectly.

9. Resident Evil - The Perfect Jump-Scare

Jump-scares are the go-to scare-tactic of choice when a creator has run out of ideas. They definitely have their place, and can be one of the most effective - and affecting - moments in any given film or game if used appropriately. The most common criticism levied at the overuse of these to garner quick thrills is that you're reacting more to the sudden increase in volume, rather than anything more meaningful. How many times have you been watching a teen slasher-flick and they pull out the standard volume-swell reaction shot - only to reveal it's one of the protagonist's friends or colleagues? These days you can telegraph the vast majority of jump-scares based purely off which camera angles are being used - but that's where the genius of Resident Evil's dog-jump comes in. Not only had we already travelled down the corridor in question and had nothing happen - thereby instilling the idea that it's a safe zone upon return - but the camera angle is more of an establishing shot of the entire area, meaning that when the dogs do come crashing through the window they're right in the forefront of your vision. Being a great mix of sound and the unexpected, it's only through gaming that this worked so effectively, prompting us to check every window in every corridor for the rest of the game.

8. Metal Gear Solid - Feeling The Power Of What You're Up Against

Definitely not a horror game, but as we'll see later in this list (and over here) creator Hideo Kojima knows how to create an macabrely directed scene and fill it with an force we immediately felt we'd never be able to beat. Coming at a point in the game where you're still exploring the warehouse facility Solid Snake finds himself in, you're suddenly greeted by an entire corridor of butchered guards, all slain by "some type of blade." Keep in mind so far in the game it'd been a menagerie of fantastically epic dialogue and hiding in cardboard boxes to avoid guards, and this scene was horrifyingly brutal. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I2VxvJH5A6A#t=321 With a sound cue that appears to be a mix of down-tuned voices all cobbled together like some demonic whispering crowd, you slowly advance down the hall until the very Silent Hill-esque image of another hapless guard being held upright by your foe is revealed. Grey Fox is a total sadistic nutcake whilst you fight him too, and even afterwards he shouts and proclaims he's been 'waiting for this pain' to fight you once again. Story-beats aside, back in 1998 this moment was a slightly-surreal foray into the many different themes and genres Metal Gear would walk between on its journey into gamers' hearts.

7. Siren: Blood Curse - Being Stalked Through Enemy Eyes

Released in many parts on the Playstation Store back in 2008, the Siren series is one of those hidden gems that those who have dabbled in its world of Japanese horror and characterful story are screaming to the rafters for the rest to try out. The main gameplay hook - and something that's never been done better - is called 'Sight Jacking'; the ability to 'tune into' other character's fields of vision as you attempt to sneak through the various broken homes and shanty towns throughout. Because you can't sight jack and move at the same time, it gets really interesting as you very meticulously switch between any number of foes to ensure you'll be able to make a break for the next opening - only to find one of the Shibito zombies staring straight at you from behind. One particular highlight is when you're trapped in a hospital as young girl Miyako, and must navigate the many tight corridors and interlocking rooms with a whole group of them ambling around above, below and around you. Jacking between is a nightmare to keep track of, and at no point do you feel remotely comfortable. It's a callback to the many horror films who'll show the killer stalking a character from afar, except here it was all given extra tension thanks to some suitably twisted character designs and environment aesthetics.

6. Silent Hill - Perfect Edge-Of-Your-Seat Audio Cues

Like the Jaws theme doing an excellent job of making you feel on-edge before the reveal of the shark himself topped it off, one of Silent Hill's defining attributes is the use of the radio static that gradually increases in volume to hint at the presence of monsters nearby. It goes hand-in-hand with another signature trait that came completely by accident - that of the fog blanketing the city - although it was actually a technical limitation of the time rather than an artistic decision. The HD re-releases would then 'fix' this, but it removed all sense of dread we felt when trying to make out any shapes of monsters and demons in the distance as the radio crackled away underneath. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JdLrooeI3wU From the nightmarish Pyramid Head who appears as a rapist in part two thanks to main character James Sutherland's twisted mind, to the size and scope of the towns themselves which take you everywhere from hospitals to hotels and even theme parks; they were all made to be as hauntingly disturbing as possible. Playing on the level of immersion you feel when acting out the part of the intrepid hero exploring ahead, it's these accompanying sounds that kick in just when you think you're safe that drive home the feeling you're not alone.

5. Heavy Rain - Sheer Finger-Severing Desperation

Thanks to the success of the Saw and Hostel films a few years ago, it proved that many audiences will treat the sheer suffering of others as a form of horror in itself. After all, being forced into committing a violent act to another human being - or yourself - is easily quite a disturbing thought, and that's before you're put behind the controller. Heavy Rain is a very divisive game, doing some things very right and others hilariously bad. However if you're on board with the plight of father Ethan as he attempts to save his son you felt every bit of the agony he went through when the Origami Killer demanded he cut a portion of his finger off to show his devotion. In a move that'll please armchair-sadists worldwide, you were actually given a choice of which implement to use, adding a sense of weight and realism to what was about to happen and letting you ask the question of what you would do in the situation. With time ticking away, running is always an option, but from a selection of knives, scissors and even a pliers if you want to survive the ordeal and continue the story you'll have to take part in this extremely brutal scene.

4. Fatal Frame - Seeing The Horror Up-Close

Something that many games, movies and TV shows do wrong over the course of their runtimes is showing the enemy force too soon. As is the case with The Walking Dead it's very hard now that we're four seasons in for the zombies to maintain any sense of threat - especially when characters like Michonne are samurai sword-wielding badasses who can take on huge numbers of them with ease. The Fatal Frame series on the other hand actually has enough confidence in its designs that the core mechanic is waiting until the last possible second before dealing damage. Armed with a camera that can dole out punishment the closer an enemy is to you before pressing the shutter, Fatal Frame actively encourages you to get stuck into its world of sunken-eyed ghouls and torn-dress demons, before goading them out of hiding and finishing them off. Outside of the older Evil Dead movies or action movies in general it's very rare that a protagonist will actually face the unseen threat head-on, and as the manner in which you deal with enemies here is so specific to how the entire experience controls, it's one of few that could only be done by putting you in an active role.

3. Amnesia: The Dark Descent - Knowing There's Something In The Room

Although development would switch hands and last year's A Machine for Pigs didn't have an enemy that could do the series justice again, previous title The Dark Descent introduced one of those "so obvious it hurts" gameplay mechanics that expertly forced you to avoid looking directly at your opposition. Thanks to the implementation of a 'Sanity Meter' characters Daniel and Justine will gradually get worse just through the very act of seeing the various set-pieces and demons that populate the world you're exploring, as well as being overcome with fear if you spend too much time cowering in the shadows. In short it's a shockingly effective tactic that forces you to press on almost as much as it does to take your time and prepare for what's ahead. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b5uoZh_uatQ One scene that tends to get mentioned a lot online is when you find yourself in a pretty expansive chamber that's been partially flooded. Many characters in horror films will utter that immortal phrase surrounding the idea that "there's something in here with us", and in Amnesia it's the surrounding water that gives the creature away. Connoting the childhood game many of us have played where 'the floor is lava' and you have to try and stay on 'high ground' (or a couch), the only way to escape from this invisible horror is to clamber up on a set of boxes across the room - leading to many instances of bracing for impact whilst screaming if you happen to fall back in.

2. Resident Evil 3: Nemesis - Running For Your Life

We've all had one of those nightmares where we're being pursued by some unseen lumbering horror, the one dominant force that in the dream-world we know we have to get away from at all costs, regardless of the reason why. In Nemesis that creature is given a name and a face - and it's not pretty. We've already covered what it's like to have an unexpected jump scare your britches off, but when you're aware of exactly what hunts you through the night - as well as the knowledge that you have no hope of taking it on - it's an altogether different experience. Resi's third main entry in the series proved that showing the horror you've heard so much about and are prepping yourself to take on can work wonders, especially when he's introduced in one of the most memorable ways possible - slaughtering a fellow teammate like they was nothing. The titanic lumbering mound of death himself appeared as if at random in certain levels, and it was then up to you to sprint in the opposite direction as you would be pursued across multiple screens and interiors, sometimes ending in having to make a split-second decision that could go gruesomely wrong.

1. P.T. (Silent Hills) - The Horrifically Tense Atmosphere

First off, it doesn't matter that this is 'just a teaser' or a demo, what Metal Gear's Hideo Kojima and filmmaker Guillermo del Toro have created is easily the best all-round horror experiences there's been in years, thanks to a combination of all the above elements and so much more. Set in what appears to be some form of purgatory comprised of an L-shaped corridor and a bathroom, the genius in the design is in how the smallest elements within change every time. Say you get to the door at the end of the corridor you'll reappear at the start, although some things will have been altered. It starts out as a knocking on a closed door, building into another one slowly closing as you approach, to which you'll spin around and realise a third is now ajar. It's very subtle (at the start anyway), but it's indescribable how these little touches really get under your skin like nothing else. That's only the beginning though. The sound design underneath is a mix of a radio report detailing a horrific family tragedy, as well as awful moans and muffled screams that routinely get louder as you see things like a disfigured baby in the bathroom, or a figure standing in the hallway that disappears into the shadows. This teaser is just that for now, but it's already spawned a devout following online and has become something of a viral sensation, with many filming reaction videos to themselves or subjected family members. What elevates the whole thing even more though, is that some of these most affecting elements - such as the ghosts appearing, or an attack from behind - are seemingly random, meaning that even on repeated playthroughs as you're beginning to think you know where to go and what to look for, you'll still be surprised by a zombified woman appearing at the window. Which titles do you think have horror experiences that could only work in games? Let us know in the comments!

Watch Next


In this post: 
Silent Hills
 
Posted On: 
Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.