11 Video Games Where You're The Bad Guy - Commenter Edition
Nice job, hero.
If the title of this list looks familiar, it should!
Jules covered a bunch of these guys earlier this year, but I guess what they say is true, everybody loves a bad boy so you guys suggested heaps of entries that should also have been on this list.
Spoilers abound, of course, so please be careful. Here are 10 video games where you’re the bad guy - commenter edition.
11. Hitman
I’m starting with the most controversial of your suggestions as there’s some disagreement over whether our friendly neighborhood Hitman is an anti-hero or a straight up bad guy. Okay, he does do a lot of killing.
As you guys pointed out it’s right there in the name, but he does mostly kill bad people. Though he does do it for money. But he tries not to kill any innocent bystanders. Then again, that’s up to you, and you do have the option to cement someone to death. Yeah, look, I think Agent 47’s earned his spot here.
10. Carrion
There are a bunch of horror games that let you play as the thing that goes bump in the night, but fewer horror games that let you play as a gory, amorphous blob that brutally consumes everything in its path.
That’s the M.O. of Carrion’s protagonist, the aforementioned blob, which makes its way through the game flinging around the bodies of the scientists who imprisoned it and generally wreaking a whole bunch of gruesome tentacley havok. Your blobby self will continue to grow and evolve as you play turning into a blood red mass filled with snarling mouths. Lovely.
9. Plague Inc.
The disturbingly relevant Plague Inc. takes the third spot on this list as the game calls on you to create and evolve a virus with the end goal of taking out the human race. Some of you guys did bring up that pathogens aren’t necessarily bad given they aren’t aware of the evil they’re doing--a parallel worth drawing to Alex Mercer in Prototype, but look, it’s still not great.
You have to hand it to Ndemic Creations, though, as they did add a new game mode that lets players stop an outbreak. They also donated a quarter of a million bucks to COVID relief efforts so that’s pretty cool, you know, off the back of their game that has a higher body count than any on this list.
8. Tyranny
As the name implies, Paradox’s 2016 RPG Tyranny puts you in the stylish yet affordable boots of a lawmaker in a world ravaged by war and under the rule of an evil tyrant. An evil tyrant that you work for. As such you have an awful lot of power and a tonne of tricky decisions to make to maintain it.
The game focuses heavily on these choices but they are significantly more nuanced than the binaries you’d have come to expect from other choice-driven games. Tyranny thrives in the shades of grey between kinda evil and super evil and lets you run with it.
7. Dragon Age Origins: The Darkspawn Chronicles
Some may say DLC doesn’t count, but hey, this is your list and a lot of you wanted this one mentioned so let’s do it. The Darkspawn Chronicles DLC lets you play not as the valiant Warden, but as darkspawn. Specifically, a Hurlock vanguard who is champion to the Archdemon and capable of commanding Darkspawn thralls.
The DLC takes us back to before the Joining ceremony and proceeds along the Origins timeline as if the Warden had died, so you’ll be up against Alistair and his forces. In the final battle you’ll need to straight up take on and kill off the heroes that make up the party of the main game. If that’s not enough to whet your appetite, the dog in the DLC is called Barkspawn. A+.
6. The Last of Us: Part I & II
Spoilers for The Last of Us are ahead so I’m giving you a couple of seconds to nope out if you haven’t gotten to it yet. Still here? Great. Now the obvious bad guy here is Abby, the sequel’s new addition. In The Last of Us: Part II she takes out the beloved Joel toward the start of the narrative, kicking off Ellie’s revenge story to avenge him. Except that the game puts you in Abby’s shoes around halfway through, a move a lot of gamers weren’t stoked about given she’d murdered Joel.
Then again, maybe you’re on Abby’s side and think Joel should have handed Ellie over and not killed all those people including Abby’s dad at the end of the first game. It’s really up to you who the bad guy is in these two games but chances are you agree it’s at least one of them.
5. InFamous 2
Another contentious one that really depends on how you play the game is Infamous 2. Of course, there are a lot of games that let you be a paragon or renegade but y’all wanted this one so you got it. Evil Cole MacGrath becomes the villain if you make a tonne of bad karma choices like scaring civilians, choosing violence, and doing murders.
There are actually three kinds of naughty Cole, referred to as Evil Cole in inFamous, Beast Cole in inFamous 2 and Vampire Cole in Festival of Blood. Beast Cole is interested in power and killing off The Beast who almost took him out at the start of the game. In the final mission, he rampages through New Marias getting steadily stronger and eventually realising he’s become the very thing he set out to destroy. Damn.
4. Payday 2
Well that all got really heavy so let’s talk about a game where your only goal is to do crimes and rob banks. Nice one. Cooperative action-heavy mischief is rife in Payday 2 where you’ll take on contracts of varying stakes and rewards. You’ll build up your guns and gear as you go, as well as investing in any of five skill trees designed to get you in and out with as little or as much chaos as you prefer. There are also more mask options than its predecessor so at least it’s both stylish and COVID-safe.
3. Shadow Of The Colossus
Big, big spoiler warning for this one, but Shadow of the Colossus has a final act about turn that’ll chill you to your core and make you feel like human garbage because it turns out you’re the bad guy. Somehow, our heroic steed-riding Wander taking on foes 100 times his size was actually not doing the right thing after all as we had been acting on behalf of an evil entity called Dormin in an attempt to resurrect a pretty girl.
Oops.
For hours we were tricked into thinking we were doing the right thing by killing towering, beautiful Colossi to save our girlfriend. Well, I guess we learned a hard lesson here: never assume.
2. Fallout 3 - The Pitt DLC
Another popular suggestion was The Pitt DLC for Fallout 3. There’s a lot to contend with here, an industrial raider town suffering through a plague that calls on you to make some damn tricky choices in a conflict between slaves and raider masters. You’re tasked with uncovering a cure for the mutations plaguing the town that the raider boss is hiding away. Turns out that cure is his daughter, a baby girl. Yeah.
You can either rescue the baby, leaving the population diseased and enslaved, or hand it over to make a cure out of. Yucky. Whichever faction you don’t end up supporting will hate you, obviously. But what’s far yuckier is a third option, which will make everyone hate you. That’s by using the cannibal mod to eat the baby. As Fallout itself would say, ‘Everyone Disliked That’.
1. Spec Ops: The Line
I’m sounding my spoiler bell again, mainly because I really want you to play this and see the twist for yourself because Spec Ops: The Line is an absolute classic in the genre of games where you play as the bad guy. The game introduces you as Captain Martin Walker, a soldier sent into war torn Dubai with the goal of rescuing survivors and uncovering what happened to Colonel John Konrad who appears to have entered the battlezone and gone rogue.
Atrocities abound through the story and at the end it turns out the real Konrad took his own life some time earlier, and the version you’ve been talking to is a traumatic hallucination of Walker himself. It all gets very Heart of Darkness and there are multiple ways for the ending to play out depending on your choices. Perhaps what makes the game extra disturbing is you wouldn’t expect it to be anything out of the ordinary for a military shooter from the outset. An early clue is the loading screens, some of which just come up with the text, “Do you feel like a hero yet?” Nope, I super did not.